Rate That Signature!

[Wandy]

wing - 8/10

skyfall - 8.5/10 hurray for ....uhm...what was this anime again...ah! Kanon2006 lol

Tsukuyomi~ yeay you post here as well as in AR...(well from time to time?) 8.5/10 for the sigs in the spoiler tags (nice lighting,theme & the text is good...lol personally I think the text is fine..I don't know why you guys say it's too dark :x)

yes it isn't anime but >_> I have made the ones I wanted already T_T <3 SnB

v1

Spoiler:

v2

Spoiler:

[MoMo ^.^]

^^ Aoie Emesai: very cute, lots of color and i like the rounded edges gives it alittle more sparkle 8/10
Tatsumiko: love it, shes very cute and happy, i like that, oh such cute big bloo anime eyes , wonderful 9/10
Azami: very sparklie, lots of shinny colors, very nice 7/10

[~Tsukuyomi]

Originally Posted by Azami

Tsukuyomi~ yeay you post here as well as in AR...(well from time to time?) 8.5/10 for the sigs in the spoiler tags (nice lighting,theme & the text is good...lol personally I think the text is fine..I don't know why you guys say it's too dark :x)

I need views from other types of people... Best way to know your trend that way...

As for spoiler tag siggy, well I can't a lot about it... The glossy-ness on the render is too much eye catching and takes away from the main image... Its a bit messy and the text doesn't seem too grand (though I know that font is somewhat your logo)... Depth, lighting, and maybe a little bit more color could be used... 6/10

[Takeru]

~Azami: Wow, the colors on that are insane. 8/10
~Tsukuyomi: Needs more character IMHO 7/10
~MoMo ^.^: I would have used a different image format for a better quality. 8/10
~Skyfall: text over borders in my book = nono 8/10

[KaWaitress]

MoMo: cute, but i can't see the border well desu~ 8/10 :3
~Tsukuyomi: Nice contrast, cold feel to it 8.5/10
Raiju32: Short n Sweet ^_^ 8/10

[MoMo ^.^]

huh i didnt even know it had a border o.0 ... Photobucket, where all your dreams come true ^^

i rate KaWaitress: oohhhh a perfect 10/10 lovin the color, its so clear and shinny and u can see every detail, very nice, oohhh pretty ^.^

[darkjester]

Tatsumiko: Overall, very nice 9.2/10
MoMo ^.^: those eyes are hypnotizing 8/10

k thxs

[Cyz]

@ MoMo ^.^: her eyes really are charming no? BG is really good too and it's shiny . 8/10

@ Tsukuyomi: I like how the lighting was focused underneath her face, though the overall img seems a little dark and could use a little lighting. 6/10

[~Tsukuyomi]

@KaWaitress
Hmmm... Isn't that my render from Animerender.com??? Well, I don't find it as to remotely interesting since its a bit too boring for my tastes... 6/10

@MoMo^.^
Need a bit of control with your brush there... I usually recommend not having any brushes over the main image since it destroys the depth value of any work... 5/10

@darkjester
For collage type work, its more best if every image you get is at the same quality or art style... A person looking at usually feels weird when looking at something that doesn't feel like it belongs... 4/10

Spoiler for My siggy in here...:

"I am the bone of Photoshop.
Colors is my body, and effects is my blood.
I have created over a thousand sigs.
Unknown to trends.
Nor known to traditions.
Have withstood pain to create many siggys.
Yet, those hands will never hold mouse. (stupid laptop)
So as I pray, "WTF is this Work?!?"

[Aoie_Emesai]

MoMo ^.^ - very nice with the starry effect, but a border will do it good ^_^. 8.5/10

~Tsukuyomi - amazing, it's only 22.5kb? Did those 2 saber have little amount of frames or something?

ps: Here go mine from a weird nanoha dojin, non H ^_^.

[Tatsumiko]

@ Momo : You changed your sig already?...hmm this one's cute too..just like the last one...cant make up my mind..Ill give em both the same score 9.5/10

@ Darkjester: I like the blue color with the apple she's holding 7/10

@ Cyz :....already forgotten...he he >)...8/10

@ Aoie Emesai : Waaaaa....WTH....XD....They arent really that much of a couple..at all....7.9/10

[rogueblade]

7/10

I like the image; dead cute. But the border seems poorly executed, and adds too much clutter IMO. The text could also do witha re-think as well - it's rather plain, isn't it?
Overall, though, it works!

[saphyre]

Originally Posted by Aoie_Emesai

~Tsukuyomi - amazing, it's only 22.5kb? Did those 2 saber have little amount of frames or something?

If you right click one of the animated Saber's and go to properties you'd notice that the actual animated bit is 294.06 KB. :P

KaWaitress - I like that image source, looks really nice - 8/10
MoMo ^.^ - Same image source as me lol - 7/10
Tatsumiko - 7/10
rogueblade - 8/10

[Ichy]

@ saphyre: 7/10
@ rogueblade: 6/10
@ tatsumiko: 9/10
@ Aoie_Emesai 10/10
@ ~Tsukuyomi: 7/10

Again I fooled around with Photoshop... > new sig

[Pellissier]

Ichy: Feels a bit empty on the right, or alternatively, slightly big. But the subject is not bad, and the background interesting either. Just.. there's something missing 7,5/10

New signature, featuring Shihou Matsuri from sola, and it's not a static (on the contrary, there are 29 frames ^^). Just give her the time to wake up ^^

[Riker]

@Pellissier: Yay, animated! Smooth and cute. Bias rating 9.5/10,

[KiNA]

@ Pelli .. Excellent, would be better if the glow on your name used the colors from the sig itself ... right now, its kinda stand out too much ..

@ Ichy .. The red glow is kinda

[kaito-kid]

@~Tsukuyomi


7.5/10


7.5/10

I like these two the most but I think you should have played a little more with the color balance, levels and brightness.

anyway, I like your work so far, but I think you should try out a new style.
and don't forget, the most important thing is to keep your work unique and original.

good luck!

[Cyz]

Ichy: I like the pic. 7/10

Pellissier: Brighten it up a little since it's too dark. Animated 8/10

-> Hmm, maybe I should change my sig now........nah, I'll stick with Ayu for a little while longer

[Pellissier]

KiNA: One of the most beautiful sign of you in the last period. Certainly, having such a subject as Ayako does help. My only qualm, a bit more of imagination would have helped, instead of repeating the same figure three times . But a very nice one nonetheless, excellent text animation. 9/10