|
View Poll Results: To Aru Kagaku no Railgun - Episode 10 Rating | |||
Perfect 10 | 13 | 17.81% | |
9 out of 10 : Excellent | 26 | 35.62% | |
8 out of 10 : Very Good | 17 | 23.29% | |
7 out of 10 : Good | 10 | 13.70% | |
6 out of 10 : Average | 4 | 5.48% | |
5 out of 10 : Below Average | 2 | 2.74% | |
4 out of 10 : Poor | 0 | 0% | |
3 out of 10 : Bad | 0 | 0% | |
2 out of 10 : Very Bad | 0 | 0% | |
1 out of 10 : Painful | 1 | 1.37% | |
Voters: 73. You may not vote on this poll |
|
Thread Tools |
2009-12-08, 16:11 | Link #121 | ||||||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2009
|
Haha I'm glad someone actually agrees with me on something here
Indeed but his point of view is still valid and I believe other people in AC share his view (or not...who knows) well if you say so.... And I din't just call her plain stupid but stupid enough. There's difference between the two but I don't think I should bother explaining. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
The question is the one of what a reasoble perosn migh expect in this situation. And I like how every time you ignore the tamepring with the brain part just before that. [QUOTE=Ansalem;2809614] For the love of god, you say she deserves to be in a coma! How can you say that a girl Saten's age deserves that from what she did? Obviously she must be horrible to deserve that fate. You have called her stupid, ignorant, inconsiderate, dangerous, deserves no sympathy, and deserves to be in a coma. You can paint a picture without naming it. I actually said the got what was coming for her and it happened to be a coma. Not my idea of the best consequence but what can you do? I never said she was horrbile nor stupid in the sense you are implying. Also I called her selfish which you missed but you skipped the "for her actions" part of deserves no sypathy and added deserves to be in a coma which I never actually said (even if I said something very similar). And when I said her actions were ignorant I meant "lacking knowledge or information" about what she's doing. Oh and lets not forget I said I sypathize with her character in general which you sort of skipped here. Quote:
I can't really help you "see" something you don't want. I'm sure you're well aware of that. Quote:
So again using something you know next to nothing about that tampers with your brain to give you super powers and alter god knows what else in your brain is very normal for a young person? Oh and she even shared it with her friends because that way if something goes wrong they'll all go down. And if the 3 girls she gave it to ended up dead because of her actions you would still feel sympathy towars her and say it's normal? Quote:
The "I never said that" part was in response to you saying "we should all learn our life lessons from anime, so it should portray all people as model citizens." which I really didn't say nor meant. Quote:
And the "hurt her friends" part here wasn't adressing the 3 girls she gave the LU to but towards Uiharu, Misaka, Kurko and her mother. I believe I don't need to tell you the reasons why they would be emotionally hurt especially her mother and Uiharu. (but if you want I can add them) And I never said it was deliberate - I said if she carefully though about everything and talked with her closest frinds about it (optional) she shouldn't have done it because it's quite clear it has potential risks that are not worth the pros gained. Quote:
I believe that's not really a strech if you consider only these 3 things and ignore all the coma info and the it depends on the people using the LU part. Sure some might see it as far fetched thus I base more of the things I say on the potetila health dangers of messing with your brain and this only adds up to the reasons not to use it. Quote:
And yes her sample might be biased even though the people have no connection with each other, come from different areas, are differen age but they all commited crimes after using the LU. Even if they are limited samples there are no evidence of other people using the LU at that point. Also having nothing in common except using the LU and commiting crimes makes this a higly probable theory at the time. Last edited by Joe_fh; 2009-12-08 at 16:27. |
||||||||||
2009-12-08, 17:37 | Link #123 | |||||||||
Speaker
Join Date: Sep 2009
|
Quote:
Quote:
It is not logical to think that because something is unique is dangerous. That there is nothing similar to it doesn't mean that it has a high risk of being dangerous. You mention that it's a unique thing that messes with your head, which you imply is dangerous, but the psychic training from school also affects the brain, and it is (as far as we know) not dangerous. I don't think that either of those implicitly show danger. As to calling me dumb, I exaggerate. You implied either I cannot understand or do not want to understand what you are saying. I understand what you are saying, but I disagree. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
A: the anime isn't promoting "acting like an idiot," and B: that even if it were, fiction is not required to give a moral compass. Quote:
Quote:
I'll restate my core beliefs on the matter here, because we seem to be getting very jumbled: 1. I don't think Saten made a wise choice; I think it was a mistake. 2. I don't think it was blatantly obvious from Saten's information that something would occur as drastic as it turned out. That in turn, does not change what I am saying in point one. 3. I think the criticism of Saten was harsh on the first few pages of the thread, considering her age and circumstances, to the extent that she was portrayed in a very negative light. 4. I think she is a sympathetic character. That is to say, I find Saten's actions to be completely understandable for a girl in her situation. I am not saying that she was justified (that her actions were right), but that I can understand why she acted as she did, and that make me sympathize with her. Joe_fh, this'll probably be my last post on it, since we have fundamental disagreements on the subject, don't agree with each others interpretations of what we're saying, and aren't really progressing anywhere with our discussion. Hopefully we'll see more eye-to-eye on future happenings in the world of Railgun.
__________________
Last edited by Ansalem; 2009-12-08 at 19:07. |
|||||||||
2009-12-08, 21:28 | Link #124 | ||
Guns Galore!
|
Yeah, I flipped through the rambling pages of discussion against Satan, and all I can say is mehhh. Oh and I agree with the below.
Quote:
?? Also. Quote:
Lastly, how old are the girls suppose to be again? Because they're all so thin. Or am I just looking at them in a lolicon way. owo
__________________
|
||
2009-12-08, 21:41 | Link #126 |
Guns Galore!
|
So what's that? 12?
EDIT: Ok nevermind, my friend google got me some references. My memory of my "middle school" is very jaded. =( If there's anything I'd have to nitpick at, is why is it middle school girls of all the people in the city that's seemly investigating and doing anything about this? Where's the government or secret agents? I just have a hard time relating to 11 year old girls saving the world; doing this crap than say manly Touma and the epic forces of magic! So much for academy city's ultra security that tour bus girl was rambling on about in episode 1, if they rely on loli's for protection. Sidenote ramble: This is why i'm put off by RPGs nowadays, it's all about 9 year olds who happen to be master warriors they clearly can't be for their age bullcrap, streamrolling monsters the size of godzilla that's acid blood itself disintergates the floor in seconds! (coughstaroceancough) *Sigh* There's only SO much crap for storyline that you can go along with right. Is anyone else like this or am I on my lonesome? ;-; At least the team is gonna get backed up next episode by the super awesome Anti-skills and win. (Sarcasm) Someone before said (I think) they're made up of school teacher volunteers and they don't have an actual police force or military or anything more appropiate for this stuff? I can't believe the city isn't burning already.
__________________
Last edited by Jin Kizuite; 2009-12-08 at 22:03. |
2009-12-09, 04:59 | Link #130 | ||||||||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2009
|
Well ok I'll cover most points for the sake of it. Just to have a proper response after all.
Quote:
Quote:
And since the psychic training from school is official and has been tested prior to being applied to the milions of students it can't be compared to the LU which is an unkown unique substance. At lest I see it like that. Quote:
And that was a real exaggeration because to call someone you don't know dumb based on actually almost nothing is wrong. Quote:
Quote:
You're saying the dangers I see are not obvious to a young girl like her but since I consider her to be a reasonable person I think she should have thought about them more since they are there. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
So yes I mean both things. I didn't mean the anime but the character. And yes it doesn't promote "acting like an idiot" as a moral to follow - it shows someone acting like an idiot ang getting away with almost nothing in general. This is not Saten's case thus me saying "She got what was coming for her". It doesn't have anything do with morals - it just annoys me and with a more extreme outcome the characters that acted "like an idiot" will understand better how stupid their action was. And yes fiction is not required to give a moral compass but I didn't have this in mind when I said that. I'm jsut annoyed by these sort of characters in general since in most cases they don't understand what they really did. And actually morals and fiction almost never go hand in hand and they never will. Or so I believe. Quote:
Quote:
And again the side effects that are "potetnionally dangerous" to the health come from tampering with the brain part and can also be reinforced by what Kuroko said (not by much but when you add these up I believe they become quite obvious). Also I always use potentionally in front of dangerous. That doesn't mean they are there for sure, however she didn't consider them as even a remote possibility which I am actually trying to say. Quote:
2. I think it was obviou from Saten's information that using the LU might be potentionally very dangerous and she ignored all that. She also didn't consider what kind of emotional impact that would inflict on her friends. 3. I never meant to portray her in a "very negative light" but say that her actions were selfsih, potentionally really dangerous and inconsiderate thus they (her actions) are something that I can't sympathize with nor do I justify them at all. 4. I think she is a sympathetic character as well but to a lesser extent. That is to say, I could sypathize with her as a fellow human due to the hardships in her life but that doesn't go against with what I'm saying in point 3 Quote:
Either way it was nice talking to you on those points^^ And our opinions are that different on some points so I'm sure we'll agree on future things |
||||||||||||
2009-12-09, 06:45 | Link #131 | |
Impostor Cutie
Join Date: Oct 2009
|
Quote:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suspension_of_disbelief ********* Totally forgot about all the nice quotes from this episode. Here: Third place goes to unnamed level upper girl: You're ten years too young to take me... Mikoto is on the second place: Let me participate in the investigation. And of course the first is Kiyama Harumi: How about I strip for the preview...
__________________
|
|
2009-12-09, 09:01 | Link #132 | |
Human
Join Date: Aug 2004
Age: 37
|
Quote:
|
|
2009-12-09, 10:09 | Link #133 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Manila, Philippines
Age: 34
|
Lol, skipping all whatever debate that happened here, episode 10 was well... I wouldn't say amazing neither too... horrible, when it isn't. In fact, it presented all the things I wanted to see... plus I can feel with Mikoto... and even Saten and Uiharu. Yes, those emotions, I see J.C.STAFF is drawing through this... well if they added Kuroko's obsessiveness over Mikoto, it might have ruined the moment, good thing they didn't... XD
Lmao @ Harumi wanting to strip for the preview, lolz, it'd be amusing if she actually did it... XD (pics for ep 11 are already out in Project Railgun in case anyone wants to see them?) |
2009-12-09, 11:06 | Link #134 |
Impostor Cutie
Join Date: Oct 2009
|
I think something important haven't been addressed in this thread so far, maybe because people were too entranced in the Saten argument, - namely introduction of a new cute face in this episode!!!11
Here: It's Konori Mii from Judgement. Well she's already appeared in some of the previous episodes, but never has she been shown so close. Now she's got a little more attention at last, and it turned out that she's beautiful! (And she has charming voice too!) I'm totally in love with Mii-chan after this episode And I demand more Mii from now on!
__________________
|
2009-12-09, 13:46 | Link #136 | |
Me, An Intellectual
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: UK
Age: 33
|
Quote:
Plus girls tend to internalize their problems ,ie, self hate, whilst guys tend to externalize it ,ie, open anger or aggression.
__________________
|
|
2009-12-09, 21:05 | Link #137 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Manila, Philippines
Age: 34
|
Konori Mii... yes, she's that kinky sempai of Kuroko with the glasses that makes her hotter... 8D I agree with your post Cyrus17! >D /don't mind me I'm obsessed with girls wearing glasses.
The fact that the anime gave her a name and that she was switched with the Judgment girl Mikoto meets in the manga gives her that attention indeed... *bricked* And that conversation with Mikoto and Kuroko... whoops, I totally forgot to mention that in my last post... |
2009-12-11, 05:23 | Link #138 |
Human
Join Date: Aug 2004
Age: 37
|
I haven't exactly followed this thread since it got taken over by the whole Saten argument, so forgive me if this has been said before.
I think I realized why they added all those random filler enemies in previous episodes (eyebrow girl, asphalt girl replacing Touma, etc). It's to Spoiler for pretty obvious, but not technically revealed yet:
|
2009-12-11, 09:20 | Link #139 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Manila, Philippines
Age: 34
|
Quote:
Spoiler for hmm, good point:
|
|
2009-12-11, 14:37 | Link #140 |
Me, An Intellectual
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: UK
Age: 33
|
^ I'd hate to rain on your parade but someone already figured out the invisibility girl a long time ago
http://forums.animesuki.com/showthre...89#post2738389
__________________
|
|
|