Rate That Signature!

[ganbaru]

SOGESNAKE 8,5/10 actualy there's a discret border on my signature

[Haladflire65]

MC: ... interesting 8.6/10
ganbaru: Ooooh, I see it! 8.7/10

[delirium]

Originally Posted by Haladflire65

MC: ... interesting 8.6/10
ganbaru: Ooooh, I see it! 8.7/10

Haladflire65: 1/10 I'm not sure how much work has gone into it. It's the same as all the others you put out too.

[kkcrow]

delirium: 4/10. All the elements seem a bit "cut-and-pasted". The layout and positioning of the elements look nice, though.

[Haladflire65]

Originally Posted by delirium

Haladflire65: 1/10 I'm not sure how much work has gone into it. It's the same as all the others you put out too.

The funny thing is, I only remember switching sigs maybe twice at the most since you've started posting in this thread. *shrugs* maybe since I don't switch subjects for every new sig I do, they all look the same to you, but some people like ganbaru who have seen dozens of my sigs with the same guy saw that I tried some new stuff with the bg, blending a C4D into the stock image which I usually don't do, and that took quite a bit longer than usual. But I suppose you didn't notice. And maybe you didn't consider that maybe I might have a style of sigmaking by now, 1 year into graphic designing?

Anyways, I don't really feel like giving your signature a proper rating at the moment but I'll just say that it's too small, and the render is also too small. It could use some blending.

And yes, I'm a little bit insulted.

[delirium]

Originally Posted by Haladflire65

The funny thing is, I only remember switching sigs maybe twice at the most since you've started posting in this thread. *shrugs* maybe since I don't switch subjects for every new sig I do, they all look the same to you, but some people like ganbaru who have seen dozens of my sigs with the same guy saw that I tried some new stuff with the bg, blending a C4D into the stock image which I usually don't do, and that took quite a bit longer than usual. But I suppose you didn't notice. And maybe you didn't consider that maybe I might have a style of sigmaking by now, 1 year into graphic designing?

Anyways, I don't really feel like giving your signature a proper rating at the moment but I'll just say that it's too small, and the render is also too small. It could use some blending.

And yes, I'm a little bit insulted.

I'm okay with you being insulted, Haladflire65. Feel free to tear my signature to pieces if it pleases you. This thread's entire purpose is to have your signature rated by your peers and rate theirs, correct? It's not as though I gave yours a low rating to screw with you. So I have to ask, what's the problem here? I wasn't aware this thread was a circle jerk. The first post to this thread states the thread isn't for personal chats, so keep that in mind, okay?

kkcrow: 8/10: Your signature is unique and the peanut lass is awesome.

[Kagayaki]

SOGESNAKE: Star-shades never get old. 8.5/10
ganbaru: Your style is consistently good 8.8/10
kkcrow: I'm allergic to peanuts, but I still love this. 8.7/10

[ganbaru]

kkcrow 8,5/10 not bad
kagayaki 9/10 looking great

[delorean2200]

Halad: 9.5/10 nice blends.
Kagayaki: 9/10 nice.
Ganbaru: 8.5/10.

[Rennir]

Kagayaki-8.8/10 Nice smudging. That bright star takes away from the focal though.
Ganbaru-8.6/10 A little too dark for my tastes. Can't really make out the render very well...

[ganbaru]

delorean2200 8,2/10 not a bad idea...

[Haladflire65]

Kagayaki: cool stuff, why the only top-and-bottom border though? I also agree with Renn-kun on the star. But still, awesome! 8.9/10
ganbaru: A bit dark, 8.5/10

[philhalo66]

5/10 kinda lame

[ganbaru]

philhalo66 8,5/10 the limit is 48,8kb

[philhalo66]

Originally Posted by ganbaru

philhalo66 8,5/10 the limit is 48,8kb

its 20KB now

[Mr.Raw]

philhalo66: 5/10...Text isn't readable, can't see a border, render is too bright (around the face) and it looks stretched.
Rennir: 9/10...awesome I already gave you a full review
ganbaru: 8/10...I like the overall signature, but the renders are a little bit too dark for me.
Haladflire65: 9/10...Great effects Halad!
Kagayaki 8,5/10...Nice effects o_o

[SOGESNAKE]

Godlike1889: 9.5/10 - It's just so.... colorful~

[delirium]

Godlike1889: 10/10 It's really gorgeous, there is no way to deny it is awesome.
philhalo66: 8/10 for a good attempt. The flaws are obvious, but it's not as though we should expect better from you, therefore you get the rating that you did. I hope you keep working on your signatures and such and improving them with each iteration. I can see what that signature will look like when you improve and I've gotta tell you it will be pretty!

[Mr.Raw]

delirium: 7/10...The overall signature is nice. The left side does look a little bit empty. Her left hand (for us: Right hand ) is too bright. To be honest: I don't like the text, you should change that IMO.

[ganbaru]

delirium 8.5/10 as Godlike1889 said, it a bit empty and the text could use some work