AnimeSuki Forums

Revolutionist · 2012-09-06, 12:53

Clearly that's really why I have an issue with it >_>

Has nothing to do with wanting a coherent narrative in which characters behave somewhat realistically...

The fact that you find no issues with text msg traitor girl and Girard just shows you either live in a bubble or you are just taking the opposite stance as me every time for the sake of arguing. Military personnel and their dependents have access to good healthcare, so to have a pilot become a spy to pay for healthcare is dumb and makes no sense.

Znozzy · 2012-09-06, 14:09

The feds are corrupt and wont pay out health insurance, hurrdurr subplot

Dr. Casey · 2012-09-06, 14:20

Quote:

Originally Posted by Revolutionist

Clearly that's really why I have an issue with it >_>

Has nothing to do with wanting a coherent narrative in which characters behave somewhat realistically...

The fact that you find no issues with text msg traitor girl and Girard just shows you either live in a bubble or you are just taking the opposite stance as me every time for the sake of arguing. Military personnel and their dependents have access to good healthcare, so to have a pilot become a spy to pay for healthcare is dumb and makes no sense.

What's wrong with Girard? Crazy waifu wanting to get revenge in the name of her dead husband sounds plausible to me.

Revolutionist · 2012-09-06, 16:09

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dr. Casey

What's wrong with Girard? Crazy waifu wanting to get revenge in the name of her dead husband sounds plausible to me.

She took the worst possible course of action which resulted in many deaths, including her own. That was very dumb and irrational when all she needed to do was go up the chain of command with the recording. She would eventually get up to the big shots, and even if they said the same thing as the base commander, which I seriously doubt Algreus would do, then she could always leak it to the media. Once they got involved, there would have to be a formal investigation, Simmons would get caught, the base commander and others would lose their jobs, perhaps even go to jail, and she'd get real justice for Girard.

Raysoul · 2012-09-07, 02:42

Quote:

Originally Posted by Revolutionist

She took the worst possible course of action which resulted in many deaths, including her own. That was very dumb and irrational when all she needed to do was go up the chain of command with the recording. She would eventually get up to the big shots, and even if they said the same thing as the base commander, which I seriously doubt Algreus would do, then she could always leak it to the media. Once they got involved, there would have to be a formal investigation, Simmons would get caught, the base commander and others would lose their jobs, perhaps even go to jail, and she'd get real justice for Girard.

She reported it to that commander, not knowing that she will be bribed/promoted just to be silent about the incident. And taking action might cause her more trouble, hence a corrupted federation. Remember what happened to Grodek when he tries to give some leak to Flit? That could also happen to Girard.

Sides · 2012-09-07, 03:51

Quote:

Originally Posted by j0x

lol i have to stop reading about Gundam AGE hate.... its true most of the hate about age is due to poor character development as all hated anime shows...

to me from what i observe on viewers reaction and my liking for AGE is that

Gundam AGE is more Plot-Driven Story since it tackles 3 generations and a lot of story elements from previous gundam shows since it has more sub-plots that made most character development somewhat lacking and not likable by many take for example Wendy remember her? Kio's girlfriend or Girard Spriggan that only lasted at least 2 episodes? so ye...

Gundam 00, Seed, etc in the other hand has more of Character-Driven Story their are longer and enough character development and character interactions that most viewers can relate too and dream of and made characters more memorable

to me im more of a Plot-Driven Story viewer so i like Gundam AGE

Same here. Personally I think AGE is the only other series with potential for good side stories, that aren't too spaced. We already have Asemu's tale with SID indicated the anime and featured in the manga side story. We also have a lot of gap year for each character that can be exploited and of course the various MS that were shown only briefly in the show.
Overall the concept for AGE has a much better layout than recent gundam-takes, in my opinion. A lot of the other AU series and their side stories feel like patch work and doesn't really feel being part of it.

SoldierOfDarkness · 2012-09-07, 09:14

Quote:

Originally Posted by Raysoul

She reported it to that commander, not knowing that she will be bribed/promoted just to be silent about the incident. And taking action might cause her more trouble, hence a corrupted federation. Remember what happened to Grodek when he tries to give some leak to Flit? That could also happen to Girard.

For the record Grodeck was assassinated because he was getting to close to the truth behind the mars colony cover-up. Flit eventually located the culprit and had them executed as traitors.

In Renai's case it doesn't matter what the base commander would've done since she was being manipulated by that turncoat coward.

Quote:

Gundam AGE is more Plot-Driven Story since it tackles 3 generations and a lot of story elements from previous gundam shows since it has more sub-plots that made most character development somewhat lacking and not likable by many take for example Wendy remember her? Kio's girlfriend or Girard Spriggan that only lasted at least 2 episodes? so ye...

The problem with AGE is that there are characters and plots that occur and the viewer has to ask, "what was the point?"

They don't have a lot of time and they waste it with characters that had little to contribute or even if they do they aren't.

In Flit's case, everything was paced okay no problem (Loss of colony and Yurin pushed Flit over the edge).

In Asemu's case......I dunno but it was somewhat okay.

By Kio's case.....it seems to have gotten worse. We got Arisa's kid who I thought would've been co-piloting the AGE 3 with Kio. Shanuala was forgotten after she died and it felt like her words didn't go with Kio.

I mean in cases like Renai, it would've made more sense to me if Kio could've used his x-rounder powers to get to her and see why she was so mad. Instead Zeheart got that scene and to top it off it was the base commander who scammed her so it kinda washed the Federations' hands clean in that part.

Meltyred · 2012-09-07, 11:24

There was no point to Largan (well in the manga or novel I think he died so it's fine to treat him as non existent I guess)

Kio's arc.... We get Wootbit, who at first disliked Kio, magic happened they became friends and he suddenly vanishes. Wonderful. Then we have people like that random Yes boy of Zehearts. What is the point of him when you have Fram....
Oh and Zera Gins, the so called GREATEST VEIGAN PILOT EVER.
I mean Zeheart could have filled out any role played by him, and Ezelcant basically says in the show that he screwed up and Zera Gins isn't really that important....
And they recycled so many characters for future generations, because they realised they introduced them in a earlier arc for no reason. (I'm looking at you Dique and Yunoa)

Revolutionist · 2012-09-08, 14:22

That yes boy is Leil Leight, valuable subordinate #2, and he is probably going to kill Cedric with his hand-me-down Girargha...

Znozzy · 2012-09-08, 15:53

Quote:

Originally Posted by Meltyred

There was no point to Largan (well in the manga or novel I think he died so it's fine to treat him as non existent I guess)

Kio's arc.... We get Wootbit, who at first disliked Kio, magic happened they became friends and he suddenly vanishes. Wonderful. Then we have people like that random Yes boy of Zehearts. What is the point of him when you have Fram....
Oh and Zera Gins, the so called GREATEST VEIGAN PILOT EVER.
I mean Zeheart could have filled out any role played by him, and Ezelcant basically says in the show that he screwed up and Zera Gins isn't really that important....
And they recycled so many characters for future generations, because they realised they introduced them in a earlier arc for no reason. (I'm looking at you Dique and Yunoa)

they didnt really recycle alot of characters, just the Asuno's that made cameos, and yeah, Dique, Woolf, Millias.

What i don't understand is why they didnt keep the bloody bridge crew for atleast 2 generations, that would make sense, you know, develop them a bit.

Largan would've made a perfect Obright if they kept him in the show

solidvanz · 2012-09-09, 05:00

Meltyred · 2012-09-09, 05:12

Quote:

Originally Posted by Znozzy

they didnt really recycle alot of characters, just the Asuno's that made cameos, and yeah, Dique, Woolf, Millias.

What i don't understand is why they didnt keep the bloody bridge crew for atleast 2 generations, that would make sense, you know, develop them a bit.

Largan would've made a perfect Obright if they kept him in the show

Largan appeared in memories of Sid, for awhile, then vanished once Asemu hijacked the manga.
How great = =
And yeah changing the bridge crew was unnecessary = =.
At least tell us what happened to them sheesh.

GN0010 Nosferatu · 2012-09-09, 05:37

A black Zeydra and a ball with arms, not too impressive.

Znozzy · 2012-09-09, 06:20

the Zeydra/Khronos is a awesome design tho, but the ball is just .. what? there is no point too it, lol

overloard · 2012-09-09, 07:58

Yeah, the ball is by far the ugliest vehicle in the whole series, even worse than the shovel-wielding Desperado from the Fardain arc.

Znozzy · 2012-09-09, 08:15

Well, the Desperado actually had a purpose, being a civilian mobile suit and all.

The Gurdolin though, it serves no purpose at all. Then again, AGE has a habit of introducing things that serves no purpose.

overloard · 2012-09-09, 08:23

Well, what purpose do you think it should serve? However ridiculous it's looking, it still custom made MS for supposedly ace pilot, so defeating it gives Seric some meaningful achievement.

Znozzy · 2012-09-09, 09:52

uh? no it isnt? he was on the way to a purple dorado when the mechanic said it wasnt ready yet, so he took the useless ball instead and went out

overloard · 2012-09-09, 10:37

My mistake. The ball wasn't specifically made for him, but still, it some sort of prototype machine and seeing how he slaughtered grunts left and right it's obviously quite powerful. The thing served its purpose after being defeated by Seric and making him look cool, so i fail to see what's so useless about it.

kk2extreme · 2012-09-09, 12:22

Ball

2012-09-06, 12:53	Link #3001
Revolutionist Puppet Master Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: Behind You	Clearly that's really why I have an issue with it >_> Has nothing to do with wanting a coherent narrative in which characters behave somewhat realistically... The fact that you find no issues with text msg traitor girl and Girard just shows you either live in a bubble or you are just taking the opposite stance as me every time for the sake of arguing. Military personnel and their dependents have access to good healthcare, so to have a pilot become a spy to pay for healthcare is dumb and makes no sense. __________________ I cannot give you back your homes, or restore your dead to life, but perhaps I can give you justice, in the name of our King. ~ Ned Stark

2012-09-08, 14:22	Link #3009
Revolutionist Puppet Master Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: Behind You	That yes boy is Leil Leight, valuable subordinate #2, and he is probably going to kill Cedric with his hand-me-down Girargha... __________________ I cannot give you back your homes, or restore your dead to life, but perhaps I can give you justice, in the name of our King. ~ Ned Stark

2012-09-09, 05:00	Link #3011
solidvanz Special Operative Join Date: Aug 2009 Location: East Malaysia Age: 39	__________________ Minus - Imgur - Last.fm - MAL - MU - PSN

2012-09-06, 14:09	Link #3002
Znozzy Praise the sun! Join Date: Aug 2004 Location: Sweden Age: 34	The feds are corrupt and wont pay out health insurance, hurrdurr subplot

2012-09-07, 11:24	Link #3008
Meltyred Senior Member Join Date: Jun 2011	There was no point to Largan (well in the manga or novel I think he died so it's fine to treat him as non existent I guess) Kio's arc.... We get Wootbit, who at first disliked Kio, magic happened they became friends and he suddenly vanishes. Wonderful. Then we have people like that random Yes boy of Zehearts. What is the point of him when you have Fram.... Oh and Zera Gins, the so called GREATEST VEIGAN PILOT EVER. I mean Zeheart could have filled out any role played by him, and Ezelcant basically says in the show that he screwed up and Zera Gins isn't really that important.... And they recycled so many characters for future generations, because they realised they introduced them in a earlier arc for no reason. (I'm looking at you Dique and Yunoa)

2012-09-09, 05:37	Link #3013
GN0010 Nosferatu Where's the monoeye? Join Date: Dec 2008 Location: Hargenteen Age: 35	A black Zeydra and a ball with arms, not too impressive.

2012-09-09, 06:20	Link #3014
Znozzy Praise the sun! Join Date: Aug 2004 Location: Sweden Age: 34	the Zeydra/Khronos is a awesome design tho, but the ball is just .. what? there is no point too it, lol

2012-09-09, 07:58	Link #3015
overloard Member Join Date: Dec 2010 Location: Russia	Yeah, the ball is by far the ugliest vehicle in the whole series, even worse than the shovel-wielding Desperado from the Fardain arc.

2012-09-09, 08:15	Link #3016
Znozzy Praise the sun! Join Date: Aug 2004 Location: Sweden Age: 34	Well, the Desperado actually had a purpose, being a civilian mobile suit and all. The Gurdolin though, it serves no purpose at all. Then again, AGE has a habit of introducing things that serves no purpose.

2012-09-09, 08:23	Link #3017
overloard Member Join Date: Dec 2010 Location: Russia	Well, what purpose do you think it should serve? However ridiculous it's looking, it still custom made MS for supposedly ace pilot, so defeating it gives Seric some meaningful achievement.

2012-09-09, 09:52	Link #3018
Znozzy Praise the sun! Join Date: Aug 2004 Location: Sweden Age: 34	uh? no it isnt? he was on the way to a purple dorado when the mechanic said it wasnt ready yet, so he took the useless ball instead and went out

2012-09-09, 10:37	Link #3019
overloard Member Join Date: Dec 2010 Location: Russia	My mistake. The ball wasn't specifically made for him, but still, it some sort of prototype machine and seeing how he slaughtered grunts left and right it's obviously quite powerful. The thing served its purpose after being defeated by Seric and making him look cool, so i fail to see what's so useless about it.

2012-09-09, 12:22	Link #3020
kk2extreme Your wife is hot... Join Date: May 2008 Location: At your house fixing A/C	Ball