AnimeSuki Forums

ClockWorkAngel · 2008-10-19, 18:58

Ack, worst time to go out and come back. I think you got the thing down pat, now we can only wait.

Nadeor · 2008-10-19, 20:14

Kinzo in EPX is not as addicted to Beatrice as he was in the official ep's
Natsuhi's plan doesn't involve epitaphs
Rosa was with the servants all night in the guest hotel, if anyone had left, either through the door or the window, they will definitely saw by either Genji, Kanon or Shannon
Battler is not addicted to drugs, neither is George, and Battler is not an accomplice
Kinzo does not wish to fight with Krauss, but Krauss wished to fight with Kinzo
Genji saw the whole second twilight happening
Rosa and the servants did not believe the Witch even to their last minute
At least one of the servants resisted the twilight he/she was in
George and Battler never got a chance to visit the forest

ROSA NEVER CLAIMED HERSELF TO BE THE WITCH, NEITHER DID ANYBODY ELSE

There, I think I just destroyed your theory, Exilon =D
No hard feelings, right?
Now you can eliminate a few more possibilities, so good luck guys
this is the last day, so I will make it all count for you guys

Nadeor · 2008-10-19, 20:26

One more:

The Seating of the Ushiromiya family was the same as in the original work

Some extra's:

The Ashes which Nanjo had discovered in his room around 8 or so the second morning, was NOT left there when the gang went out for the search. Nanjo did have a glance at his ash tray before he left at sometime because of some reason (Like you and me always do before we left a room, checking and making sure our bed's done and floor's clean and so), and it was completely clean before they left for the search.
Rosa doesn't smoke.
Rudolf smokes.
Kinzo smokes.
Beatrice smokes (But not relating to EPX)
Krauss smokes.
George smokes.
Battler...no, he doesn't smoke.

oh, and

The ash tray which contained the ashes found by Nanjo was not in his room last night(The definition of Last Night: October 4th, 1986, from 10:00 PM 'till October 5th, 6:00 AM)

How's that?
Remember, the rules of resigning is:

If you resigned and the witch had won, the resigned one's wins as well because they stood on the witch's side. And once the game has concluded, their positions as a human will be redeemed immediately. But the choice of resigning ends 3 hours before the game concludes (deadline: West Coast time 9:00 PM, October 20th)

jonnysalaris · 2008-10-19, 20:41

Quote:

At least one of the servants resisted the twilight he/she was in

Spoiler for kihihihihi:

Goose Boy · 2008-10-19, 21:58

Wow... hard one.....

Spoiler for Last thoughts:

Nadeor · 2008-10-19, 22:12

Kyrie did not seduce anyone with the tie/breast or in any form

Alright Goose Boy, welcome to the witch's side~

ClockWorkAngel · 2008-10-19, 23:26

We can't simply let the game end, no that just won't do. Come and get me Witch-sama, but know this I'll never come to you.

Spoiler for Come, Let It Flow:

Nadeor · 2008-10-19, 23:56

Well I did say it had nothing to do, but only to point out a fact that it's on the island and acting as a place for the people to go into
But trust me, there's nothing much about the forest which relates to how the people got killed
I will go to sleep now, and recite those requests prior to 24:00

Natsuhi is not addicted to drugs
Genji did not resist his twilight

...
Here's something from the solution arc which was not hinted in the question arc
The witch did it on purpose, and now I've been told to reveal it to you guys

For the last twilights, Gumasawa and Gohda's wounds which described on the epitaph was not enough to kill them, so some other ways were used. After all, the two of them carries more than one wound on their corpses.

jonnysalaris · 2008-10-20, 00:43

recite in red

Spoiler for red text...:

are there any syringes in rokkenjima?

Nadeor · 2008-10-20, 08:40

Some of the servants have at least two wounds
The Victims of the 1st twilight don't have any wounds

Looks like the game has concluded...
The winner of this round is the witch's side
The result will be posted soon~!

Exilon · 2008-10-20, 08:59

aww too bad I wasn't here but sleeping. In my clock, it's still the 20th of October.
Congrats on that xD

Spoiler:

Well, that was fun while it lasted. We should make more of these, it's a good way to kill *lots* of time~

jonnysalaris · 2008-10-20, 10:12

hey, when will the solution arc be posted?

Golden Witch Drugs · 2008-10-20, 14:16

I... Lost..? Nooooo!!! I will die?! OwO Damn it <v< Next time I wont lose Ò_Ó Will there be a next time... Kana, kana?

Nadeor · 2008-10-20, 20:44

It was indeed nice work to you all
Your efforts were admired by the Witch of Despair
However, those are still not enough to defeat us

The solution arc will come in about a week or two, and the truth will be revealed

ClockWorkAngel · 2008-10-20, 21:04

The only problem was half way through we lost our only way to get real answers XD

It was very fun and helps us prepare for the bigger game ahead of us.

All praise the Witch-sama!

Nadeor · 2008-10-20, 23:03

The Chinese players had the same conditions, and they had more resigns than you guys did
So in a way, congratulations on beating the chinese side ^_^

Exilon · 2008-10-21, 02:33

I'd be happy if I knew that we got close than they did, but I guess we tried different theories. :P

A week or two? aww >< That will take lots of time xD Oh well... we'll just have to wait, I guess..

Asashio123 · 2008-10-21, 21:08

Aww~ I had to be away for the last day of the battle. What a shame

Oh well, great theories everyone. That was really fun. It'd be awesome if someone could think of something this ingenious again.

Well then, time to wait for the translations of the solution arc!

Nadeor · 2008-10-21, 23:43

Actually, one of the things you guys need here, to solve this mystery, is what you guys had in the beginning:

-Wild imagination

After all, whoever came up with that tie/breast seduction thing was probably just his/her fetish
but something like that has to go with the mystery

Exilon · 2008-10-22, 02:17

wild imagination, lol xD

I'll take it as long as the solution is logical... that's what I was actually trying to do xD
Oh well xD

2008-10-19, 18:58	Link #161
ClockWorkAngel Aspiring Aspirer Join Date: Oct 2007 Location: Somewhere Over The Rainbow, Canada Age: 32	Ack, worst time to go out and come back. I think you got the thing down pat, now we can only wait. __________________ Credit To Risa-chan!

2008-10-19, 21:58	Link #165
Goose Boy Happiness witch´s followe Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: Venezuela Age: 30	Wow... hard one..... Spoiler for Last thoughts: If no servant leaved the guest house, and shannon/george thing is related to that, then HIDEYOSHI DID IT...... anyone thought that eva could have done it.... but hideyoshi is also able to do that... but i dont find no explanation to that.... KYRIE DID IT WITH THE TIE/BREAST THING.... resign.

2008-10-19, 23:26	Link #167
ClockWorkAngel Aspiring Aspirer Join Date: Oct 2007 Location: Somewhere Over The Rainbow, Canada Age: 32	We can't simply let the game end, no that just won't do. Come and get me Witch-sama, but know this I'll never come to you. Spoiler for Come, Let It Flow: Alright, time to try my best on this; Krauss, Eva, Hideyoshi, Rudolf, Kyrie, George and Battler in the main room, Jessica and Natsuhi are in the house. Genji, Gumasawa, Gohda, Shannon and Kanon, Rosa, Maria, and Nanjo are in the guest house. Kinzo is in his study. Natsuhi, Jessica, Battler, Kyrie, George and Hideyoshi were killed. Krauss, Eva and Rudolf were kept alive. I have a feeling Natushi is addicted to drugs XD. Her prolonged use might be a cause of her state. Since it's been said that only Jessecia and Natushi were the only ones murdered But then how do we deal with the others, they were not murdered. Would that mean it was by accident? Ugh the only problem is that the gray might have actually been true. Sigh. I'm still going with my Eva-crazy theory . Also thanks for the tidbit on "No one wrote down the whole accident on a paper, put it in a bottle, and put it in the sea, the only way that we knew how this all happened was through the tales of those who survived." This means that someone had saw George's proposal. Interesting; I wonder who? Genji is working with Rosa it's entirely logical. The second twilight was most likely planned to begin with, forcing Kinzo's killing of Krauss. The person who resisted was Genji, a stab to the foot isn't lethal at all. Nadeor, you said that the forest had nothing to do with the story at first... What was with that contradiction right now? Ugh not much time, I don't expect to win however. This is all I can give for the challengers recite please! Natsuhi is addicted to drugs. Genji resisted his twilight. There's alot of shoddy wording, so not much to do, let's wait for the solution arc. __________________ Credit To Risa-chan!

2008-10-20, 00:43	Link #169
jonnysalaris Oblivious Nerd Join Date: Sep 2008	recite in red Spoiler for red text...: -each servant has at least two wounds -the victims of the 1st twilight don't have any wounds are there any syringes in rokkenjima?

2008-10-20, 08:59	Link #171
Exilon Philosopher of theories Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: Portugal Age: 32	aww too bad I wasn't here but sleeping. In my clock, it's still the 20th of October. Congrats on that xD Spoiler: I still believe Rosa left the guest building. She was seen by either one of the three but since Genji is working with Rosa, he didn't care. I'm also thinking that one of the "victims" of the first twilight was drugged so they could fake their death and wake up some time later, carrying out the final twilights. Finnaly, there is one little thing I just got reminded of. If Krauss was an accomplice and he's also taking part of it, he could have pretended he saw Jessica so everyone could get out of the palce they were. When he found out things weren't going according to his plan, he talked with Genji, which took him to Kinzo. but well, it's too late to be making any more possibilities now. Well, that was fun while it lasted. We should make more of these, it's a good way to kill lots of time~

2008-10-19, 20:14	Link #162
Nadeor Asmodeus Saigo (>v<)/ Join Date: Feb 2008	Kinzo in EPX is not as addicted to Beatrice as he was in the official ep's Natsuhi's plan doesn't involve epitaphs Rosa was with the servants all night in the guest hotel, if anyone had left, either through the door or the window, they will definitely saw by either Genji, Kanon or Shannon Battler is not addicted to drugs, neither is George, and Battler is not an accomplice Kinzo does not wish to fight with Krauss, but Krauss wished to fight with Kinzo Genji saw the whole second twilight happening Rosa and the servants did not believe the Witch even to their last minute At least one of the servants resisted the twilight he/she was in George and Battler never got a chance to visit the forest ROSA NEVER CLAIMED HERSELF TO BE THE WITCH, NEITHER DID ANYBODY ELSE There, I think I just destroyed your theory, Exilon =D No hard feelings, right? Now you can eliminate a few more possibilities, so good luck guys this is the last day, so I will make it all count for you guys

2008-10-19, 20:26	Link #163
Nadeor Asmodeus Saigo (>v<)/ Join Date: Feb 2008	One more: The Seating of the Ushiromiya family was the same as in the original work Some extra's: The Ashes which Nanjo had discovered in his room around 8 or so the second morning, was NOT left there when the gang went out for the search. Nanjo did have a glance at his ash tray before he left at sometime because of some reason (Like you and me always do before we left a room, checking and making sure our bed's done and floor's clean and so), and it was completely clean before they left for the search. Rosa doesn't smoke. Rudolf smokes. Kinzo smokes. Beatrice smokes (But not relating to EPX) Krauss smokes. George smokes. Battler...no, he doesn't smoke. oh, and The ash tray which contained the ashes found by Nanjo was not in his room last night(The definition of Last Night: October 4th, 1986, from 10:00 PM 'till October 5th, 6:00 AM) How's that? Remember, the rules of resigning is: If you resigned and the witch had won, the resigned one's wins as well because they stood on the witch's side. And once the game has concluded, their positions as a human will be redeemed immediately. But the choice of resigning ends 3 hours before the game concludes (deadline: West Coast time 9:00 PM, October 20th)

2008-10-19, 22:12	Link #166
Nadeor Asmodeus Saigo (>v<)/ Join Date: Feb 2008	Kyrie did not seduce anyone with the tie/breast or in any form Alright Goose Boy, welcome to the witch's side~

2008-10-19, 23:56	Link #168
Nadeor Asmodeus Saigo (>v<)/ Join Date: Feb 2008	Well I did say it had nothing to do, but only to point out a fact that it's on the island and acting as a place for the people to go into But trust me, there's nothing much about the forest which relates to how the people got killed I will go to sleep now, and recite those requests prior to 24:00 Natsuhi is not addicted to drugs Genji did not resist his twilight ... Here's something from the solution arc which was not hinted in the question arc The witch did it on purpose, and now I've been told to reveal it to you guys For the last twilights, Gumasawa and Gohda's wounds which described on the epitaph was not enough to kill them, so some other ways were used. After all, the two of them carries more than one wound on their corpses.

2008-10-20, 08:40	Link #170
Nadeor Asmodeus Saigo (>v<)/ Join Date: Feb 2008	Some of the servants have at least two wounds The Victims of the 1st twilight don't have any wounds Looks like the game has concluded... The winner of this round is the witch's side The result will be posted soon~!

2008-10-20, 10:12	Link #172
jonnysalaris Oblivious Nerd Join Date: Sep 2008	hey, when will the solution arc be posted?

2008-10-20, 14:16	Link #173
Golden Witch Drugs しゆあげいん。 Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: Rokkenjima stage	I... Lost..? Nooooo!!! I will die?! OwO Damn it <v< Next time I wont lose Ò_Ó Will there be a next time... Kana, kana?

2008-10-20, 20:44	Link #174
Nadeor Asmodeus Saigo (>v<)/ Join Date: Feb 2008	It was indeed nice work to you all Your efforts were admired by the Witch of Despair However, those are still not enough to defeat us The solution arc will come in about a week or two, and the truth will be revealed

2008-10-20, 21:04	Link #175
ClockWorkAngel Aspiring Aspirer Join Date: Oct 2007 Location: Somewhere Over The Rainbow, Canada Age: 32	The only problem was half way through we lost our only way to get real answers XD It was very fun and helps us prepare for the bigger game ahead of us. All praise the Witch-sama! __________________ Credit To Risa-chan!

2008-10-20, 23:03	Link #176
Nadeor Asmodeus Saigo (>v<)/ Join Date: Feb 2008	The Chinese players had the same conditions, and they had more resigns than you guys did So in a way, congratulations on beating the chinese side ^_^

2008-10-21, 02:33	Link #177
Exilon Philosopher of theories Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: Portugal Age: 32	I'd be happy if I knew that we got close than they did, but I guess we tried different theories. :P A week or two? aww >< That will take lots of time xD Oh well... we'll just have to wait, I guess..

2008-10-21, 21:08	Link #178
Asashio123 The Human in the Big Red Artist Join Date: Jul 2008 Location: Up north where everyone is happy, jolly, and kind.	Aww~ I had to be away for the last day of the battle. What a shame Oh well, great theories everyone. That was really fun. It'd be awesome if someone could think of something this ingenious again. Well then, time to wait for the translations of the solution arc!

2008-10-21, 23:43	Link #179
Nadeor Asmodeus Saigo (>v<)/ Join Date: Feb 2008	Actually, one of the things you guys need here, to solve this mystery, is what you guys had in the beginning: -Wild imagination After all, whoever came up with that tie/breast seduction thing was probably just his/her fetish but something like that has to go with the mystery

2008-10-22, 02:17	Link #180
Exilon Philosopher of theories Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: Portugal Age: 32	wild imagination, lol xD I'll take it as long as the solution is logical... that's what I was actually trying to do xD Oh well xD