Rate That Signature!

[leofish]

skyfall: oooo.. very pretty :3 colors and perspective are great, only critique would be the text, the harsh black border against the solid white doesn't mesh very well with the smooth, tranquil background. 9/10


Cyz: the subtle color on the visor is a great little addition, I didnt notice it at first, but especially the red comes off as a color reflection of the saturated yoko on the left.. very nice. like KiNa said though, the white leftovers from the cut job are visible, especially on the tuft behind her neck. 8/10

[Spectacular_Insanity]

cyz: Cool! 10/10

KiNa: *Chotto* ecchi, ne? 10/10

leofish: lol. 8/10

[bigdave]

Cyz>> Ur gettin better at making the sigs Cyz! ^^
Ur yoko looks nice. I think u have the arrangment of ur renders down good and the subtle addition of details in the monochrome Yoko is nice. the only thing u need to work on is what the others said. 7/10

KiNa>> hehehe Very nice ecchi their KinA! XD I must say ur quite good at that. The only gripe I have is ur Name animation is kinda hard to see but It does blend in with the back so its Ok. 7.8/10

Sky>> ^______^ im still learning how to do those kinda effects T,T
Very Kakoi sig. 8.4/10

Leo>> O man I hate may colds and other sicknesses >,<;
Nice sig, the only thing I see, or at least what I think needs work on is the BG its hard to make out those designs and the color should kinda go with the other colors in the sig. ^^ 6.8/10

AE>> hahaha same sig huh! ^__^
still very nice. I have to get better at changing the shape of my sigs 8/10

BD>> and as for me this one is one of the sigs I made and My very first attempt at making an "ecchi" sig

[Kaioshin Sama]

I spun my new Signature out of Straw. WHOA that's kind of freaky that the guy above me has the same character only in adult form. I chose this avatar for the sheer audacity that Evangeline shows in this panel. Actually it's not that creative, but the whole idea behind it caught me so off guard as I was reading the chapter that I just had to use it as a sig for a while and give the Zeta Gundam a bit of a rest.

I myself give it a 5/10 since I only made it in like 15 minutes.

I give DeathKillz sig a 9/10. It's quite the eyecatcher.

The guy above me get's an 8.5/10

Cyz get's a 9/10, although its missing the best part(s) of Yoko.

[Cyz]

Originally Posted by Kaioshin_Sama

Cyz get's a 9/10, although its missing the best part(s) of Yoko.

Patience no? I'm thinking of making me a sexy Yoko sig

@ leofish: The grayish BG doesn't suit her though but it does suit the mood 8/10

@ bigdave: a little blurry and her last name is a little hard to see. 7/10

@ Kaoshin Sama: looks scary no? 6/10

[Wandy]

Kaoshi - 5/10 I understand it's from a comic/manga but why is it overstretched T_T

Cyz - I see white stuff from the image :P you tried rendering it?
and improvement is seen the text colour seems out of place

I need to make sigs small...and stop abusing kb/bytes

Spoiler:

[bigdave]

Cyz>> hehehe I tried Fixing the things u mentioned.

Azami>> I Like ur sig it gives this like celestial or angely feeling ^__^ and I like when the sig has nice smooth corners! XD 8.22/10

O and the Chii sig is good as well, it seems to give the same "Vibe" as ur current sig. 8/10 =)

[Aoie_Emesai]

bigdave - Hehehe, true your image is sorta blurry. Seems like you resized it up. Usually I try to find an image at least 1024x768 with good resolutions, if the image is bad quality to begin with, I try not to use it. But there's this image I have that I can seem to find a better quality of. I bet everyone has the same copy or less. (ahh can't find it) (But it's that artwork by Aoi Nanase, with the girl holding her straw hat in a watery blue background, in a white one piece.)

Azami - The Chii sig is very nice. Though I find it rather bright. I think if you messed with the curves a bit and darken the image a bit, it would look quite good. 9/10 (10/10 if it was a bit darker ^^)

Skyfall - Nice lighting effects for those glowing orb thingy. Her expression don't quite seem to fit into the effects you made for the background. She seems quite frightened but the background conveys a different feeling.(But she's still cute ^^) 8/10

[Furuno]

Aoie_Emesai - 9/10. Nice work! And good combination with the avatar too...

Kaioshin_Sama - 5/10. Try not to strech it too far...

bigdave - 7/10. So-so.

leofish - 7.5/10. Maybe if you change the color composition...

[CrowKenobi]

Cyz: I like it! The subtle glow effect on the goggles works wonders! To fix the name problem (I don't think there's anything wrong with it), try reducing the image transparency to soften the color. 9/10

bigdave: Very ecchi! Like what you did with it, the softness improves the image greatly! 9/10

leofish: Simple and direct and Konata = 10/10

KiNA: Giving JoJo a run for his money, eh? 9.5/10

How does this sig look? I got the idea of making an "old" picture with the gang in their yukatas... Does it work? Would it look better without the text?

[Areguzanda]

Cyz: ooh nice!! I love it! 10/10 nice coloring.
Aoie_Emesai: Pretty! 9/10
Kira_Naruto: Oy! Ecchi ne? 9/10
Skyfall: Lovely. love the colors. 9/10
leofish: May sickness. funny 9/10
bigdave: Little ecchiness but pretty. 8.5/10
Kaioshin_Sama: don't know the story it's from. and it's a little plain.. 6/10
Azami: one word: Pretty! 9/10 Chi-sigg - repeat of word: pretty! 9.5/10
furuno: Ayu!<3 8.5/10
CrowKenobi: Lucky Star sigg - nice. looks "old-style" 8.5/10. Yoko sigg - not much to say. I like it 9/10

off-topic: what show is this Yoko from? I see more and more of her in Avatars and siggs...but don't know what Anime she's from :S

[Kaioshin Sama]

Originally Posted by Areguzanda

Kaioshin_Sama: don't know the story it's from. and it's a little plain.. 6/10

It's actually a screencap I took of a panel from a Negima chapter, that's why it looks so plain. It's one of those take it and run with it things. Believe it or not it's actually been reduced in size, not stretched. It just looks a bit weird because of his style and the quality of the scanlation. Does the new one look any better people. It's hard to compress an image down to 120 vertical pixels and still make it look good, but I'm trying to strike a balance between height and width to get the best out of it.

Areguzanda, I'd give yours a 7/10. I kind of see that expression of Matsuri's an awful, lot, but the pictures nice overall.

[CrowKenobi]

Originally Posted by Areguzanda

off-topic: what show is this Yoko from? I see more and more of her in Avatars and siggs...but don't know what Anime she's from :S

Yoko is from the anime: Tengen Toppa Gurren-Lagann which has it's own forum here: Gurren-Lagann (be sure to check out the image thread where there is an abundance of Yoko pics)

It also looks like Matsuri rules too, and Klash's sig is awesome! 10/10

Kaioshin: You're getting better, but fix those pesky dimensions so there's no stretch effect and we can see Evangeline's (stinky) feet more clearly. 6/10

[Cyz]

@ CrowKenobi: The Yoko pics are nice but they seem to be a little mismatch IMO. The BG matches her btw. 7/10

[KiNA]

Cyz.. you always get the 1st post isn' it

@ Cyz .. better then the previous version ... Now learn to make some BG or make the white gradient glow much bigger ^^

[felix]

Cyz I really like the character expression and details on the right. They really appeal to me, tho' the one on the left not so much. In any case this sig really growed on my ^^ so.. 11 - 11

[Deathkillz]

cyz ~ id say you are trying very hard nice contrast between the two but the yoko on the left needs a bit of blending ~ 8/10

kiNa ~ now youve gone and done it T_T *feels urge to challange your kanu* awesome ecchi sig and the animation is a stroke of genius! 9/10

cats ~ MMM momo ^__^ i feel sleepy now ~ 8/10

[Sephi]

@cyz Mmm 7,5/10 for yoko sig. Simple but nice. After seeing so many sigs of her i really feel the urge to pick up Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann and see what makes yoko so loved.

@Kira *whipes off the blood form a nosebleed* yes a 8/10. What anime is it from btw?

@cats. Really cute. 8/10

@deathkillz. fate pantsu shot!!! Bonus points ! 9/10! Goes cleaning up the blood again...

[felix]

Mmm.. Se - phi.. it says you just registered but you style and name sound vaguly familiar.

----------------------------------
Oh gosh now I gotta rate.. U_U *cries*

I like the quality.. ^_^ I like the blur.. ^__^ I like how the mecha is blended into the bg, ^___^ I don't like that thin chaotic border.. T_T what were you thinking. ..and soldier boy looking like that gives me the creeps. x_X 11 - 9

[Klashikari]

^ well... that's sousuke anyway, he is rather a quite "normal" like this

Cyz : good improvement for the cut, but you still need more work on it, especially if you want to use screencap stock for future signatures.
as for the balance, i would suggest some tweek with the pictures size : i feel the signature getting splitting in 2 because of the 2 signatures size.
8/10

KiNa : very nice cut for left kanu. however, i think you should do something more fancy with the right picture alone. (i don't know how to express it, but the left one is kinda hindering the impression of attraction)
8.5/10

Sephi : i think the signature is really flaring too much (Kaname white seifuku is almost burning my eyes >_<). did you use color dodge blending? if so, you should tone it down a lot, i think it is conflicting quite a bit with the smoother blue hue of the BG.
I think the Arbalest should be sharp instead of blurry, with a slightly higher opacity.
Good signature, but i lacks of something, i can't say what ~~
8.5/10