Rate That Signature!

[Hs Vi Germania]

fallschirmjager: 9/10

[Katocchi]

fallschirmjager - 7.5/10

[ganbaru]

fallschirmjager 8,4/10 the art is good

-fate- , it's from the 3th volume of the ''Bungaku Shoujo'' serie

[KimmyChan]

ayu-smepai - 9/10
fallschirmjager - 9/10
Hs Vi Germania - 10/10

[Rikimtasu]

Ok...kind of fixed the hair part,don't really notice it when i render it.
Change it into a 1pcx black border,too.
@fallschirmjager 9.4/10

[Kana Futayo]

KimmyChan - nice looking sig, but I hate Kaede. 8.5/10
Rikimtasu - render quality is not good, and also the white parts are visible. 7/10

---

Also rate this one:

[KimmyChan]

Moonie - 9.5/10 for both

[Katocchi]

Moonie (posted one) -9/10 Cute ! I Love brush on the Left side

[KimmyChan]

Katocchi - 10/10

[Hs Vi Germania]

KimmyChan: 8/10
Moonie: The posted one: I don't like these strange forms at the bg. 8/10
The standard one: Here I do not like the form of the whole sig. 8/10

[KimmyChan]

Hs Vi Germania - 10/10

[Lord Uiruu]

Germania-san: 8/10
and about your avatar... lulu? why? (rhetorical question)

[KimmyChan]

Lord Uiruu - 8.5/10

[ganbaru]

Rikimtasu 8,4/10 the hair issue is not yet fixed
Moonie ( posted) 8,7/10 I like it
KimmyChan 8,5/10 not a bad text. ( I used longer text than that before )

[Katocchi]

KimmyChan - 7.5/10

[Endrance]

Kimmychan-very cute-9/10

[escimo]

ayu-smepai - 0/10 - Doesn't comply with the forum rules. (Lose the text and shave the 2269 bytes it is over the size limit and it'll be at least a 9.5. I really like it.)
-Fate- - 7.5/10 - OK
fallschirmjager - 8/10 - It has a very dynamic feel to it. A real sense of motion.
Rikimtasu - 6.5/10 - While the idea is quite good the render is just awfully bad quality.
Moonie - 9.5/10 - I like it very much. Great sig.
Hs Vi Germania - 9/10 - Very nice.
KimmyChan - 6/10 - A bit too simplified. Just a wall of text and a few faces.
Lord Uiruu - 7/10 - Rather plain.
ganbaru - 7/10 - Don't really care for the colors. And still a novelfull of text.
Katocchi - 8.5/10 - While I'm not a huge fan of the colors, the design works. Good use of brushes and the green eyes are a nice touch.
Endrance - 8.5/10 - If I'm not mistaken that sig is older than time itself. Works. Very effective while being very simple.

[Hs Vi Germania]

Endrance: that girl again 9/10
escimo: it's just great 9/10

[Endrance]

escimo-you always have the most awesome texts....must learn your secret..-10/10.Hahha yeh this is version 2 of that ancient one of mine this time instead of the croud passing around her i went for rain and puddles

[ganbaru]

Endrance 8,4/10 look like she have a aura, no ?
Escimo 9,3/10 I love your background

BTW Escimo, sorry than you don't like my text.

For this new sig, I am not really sure which version is the best, this one ot the one than I use.