|
View Poll Results: To Aru Kagaku no Railgun - Episode 2 Rating | |||
Perfect 10 | 16 | 15.24% | |
9 out of 10 : Excellent | 15 | 14.29% | |
8 out of 10 : Very Good | 22 | 20.95% | |
7 out of 10 : Good | 27 | 25.71% | |
6 out of 10 : Average | 6 | 5.71% | |
5 out of 10 : Below Average | 4 | 3.81% | |
4 out of 10 : Poor | 8 | 7.62% | |
3 out of 10 : Bad | 1 | 0.95% | |
2 out of 10 : Very Bad | 1 | 0.95% | |
1 out of 10 : Painful | 5 | 4.76% | |
Voters: 105. You may not vote on this poll |
|
Thread Tools |
2009-10-10, 20:51 | Link #102 | |
そのおっぱいで13才
Join Date: Dec 2006
|
Quote:
You say they didn't give you railgun when they say they would, but, uh... Mikoto=Railgun, and she clearly appeared... ...? Beh, don't mind them. It isn't worth the time if those people are judging the entire anime from one episode... ...? I didn't say she was the only reason the manga is popular. Who knows... You can ask that about a lot of anime. Use the same setting and characters, but move in a different direction...? I guess you can find out if you join one of those animation teams...
__________________
|
|
2009-10-10, 21:01 | Link #103 |
~ Your Smile ~
Author
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: 346Pro
Age: 38
|
I rofl at how this Railgun discussion thread has turned sour in the opposite direction of a typical Index episode thread. As we learnt before 1 anime season ago, there's no pleasing you guys...
__________________
|
2009-10-10, 21:26 | Link #104 | ||
Administrator
Join Date: Dec 2003
Age: 41
|
Quote:
My entire argument is simple: open your mind. Stop trying to force this show into the narrow box of your preconceptions on what it's "supposed to be", and allow the show a chance to demonstrate the director's vision for what he feels the show is all about. It might not be what you think it's supposed to be, and maybe that's okay! Understanding and appreciating a story is about a lot more than digesting and appreciating each and every one of the contextless bite-sized parts. You don't even know where they're going with all this yet, you only think you know. Quote:
Please rejoin the realm of us mortals here on the ground floor. I'm quite certain that the team of writers, artists, planners, producers, and directors working on this show have spent a lot more time considering "what Toaru Kagaku no Railgun is" than you or I have. I think we can cut them a bit of slack at these early stages of the game, and wait to see what they're trying to tell us through this story. And if it turns out that what they think "it is" is different than what you thought it was, who says that they're wrong and that you're right? It's not that I think this show is so great, or by any means that I think it's above criticism. There are certainly points that can be criticized, and it's reasonable that people's expectations may change based on the evidence going into a show. But, at the same time, you need to apply a bit of perspective, and it doesn't solve things when you try to brush off your over-stated assertions by "keep in mind I gave it a 7!". You're looking at a small piece of a large puzzle and using that to extrapolate the entire picture and pass judgement. Right now, no matter how well you think you know the manga, you can't see the forest for the trees for this anime. None of us can. Give it time, see where the story leads us, contemplate, reflect, and then decide if the net result, on the whole, does a good job of conveying the themes and messages it set out to convey. Because -- more profound non-logic -- this anime only is whatever they make it to be, and none of us know what that will look like yet. This is exactly why I hate episode threads... context is everything, and a single episode is not context! Sigh... |
||
2009-10-10, 22:28 | Link #105 | ||||||||||
Crazy Devout Fanboy
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: 1st Ra Cailum-class battleship Ra Cailum, port-side officer's bunks
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
And um, no, if you think Toaru Kagaku no Railgun is simply about Mikoto appearing......then you really aren't seeing much here..... Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
That said, in this particular area I digress; As I said (and I guess you missed the several times I said this), I'm perfectly fine with them making anime-original material, plot-related or not, manga-accurate or not, as long as it's good. Watching a bunch of random Kuroko crazing over Mikoto with absolutely nothing happening is not what I consider good. At least it was a good laugh though. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Last time: I DON'T MIND AT ALL IF IT'S NOT WORD-FOR-WORD WHAT THE MANGA IS, OR IF IT TAKES A NEW DIRECTION. NOR DO I SEE THIS ONE, SINGLE EPISODE AS A CONTEXT FOR THE ENTIRE SERIES. I'M PERFECTLY WILLING TO WAIT AND SEE HOW IT TURNS OUT BEFORE CALLING JUDGEMENT ON AN ENTIRE SERIES. Stop putting words in my mouth, and stop treating me like those narrow-minded "MANGA RULEZ ALL ELSE SUCKS" guys that I'm always debating against. It's getting quite frustrating. I do, however, care whether or not it's GOOD. And when nothing happens, whether it be plot, character development, or whatever, I don't consider that "good." Quote:
*finishes ripping apart a poor pillow* *sharp breath*
__________________
Last edited by Shinji103; 2009-10-10 at 22:40. |
||||||||||
2009-10-10, 22:51 | Link #107 | |
Clockwork
Join Date: Oct 2006
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2009-10-10, 23:18 | Link #108 |
house music addict
Join Date: Mar 2009
|
My, this series is a lot of fun so far! I decided on a whim to start this one even after I couldn't manage to enjoy Index enough to watch past the fifth episode. Seems like indeed there is no need to have watched/read Index to jump right into this storyline. They are taking their time with the pacing to allow for proper character development, which is quite the welcome change. Poor ecchi Kuroko; it looks like her love will always be unrequited :'(
__________________
|
2009-10-10, 23:25 | Link #109 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2009
|
Quote:
Having rarely posted outside the Umineko forums has now made me appreciate what a really good mod Klashikari is.
__________________
|
|
2009-10-10, 23:29 | Link #110 | |||
Administrator
Join Date: Dec 2003
Age: 41
|
Quote:
I'm sorry that I resorted to such direct language to try to convey my message. Tone can be a difficult thing to convey in text, and clearly you took things more personally than I intended for them to be. I never intended this as some sort of personal attack, and I apologize that it came across that way. However, although I know you're really trying to stay open-minded here, I still find the juxtaposition of "I'm open-minded as long as it's good" very hard to grapple with. Quote:
Quote:
I certainly know that you're no manga purist. I was never trying to claim or imply that. But at the same time, most of the people I do see as manga purists would all vehemently deny that they are; they always say that they'd be okay with changes, as long as those changes are good. The flipside is that, in an almost-overwhelming amount of changes, they think virtually any change the anime makes is bad. This isn't generally because they dogmatically think that manga is better than anime on some sort of principle, but it's because of the expectations that have accumulated based on their prior exposure, and whatever the idea they have in their head of what it could have been like. In other words, I don't believe that people are manga purists by "choice". They're manga purists as a result of the continual disappointment of unmet expectations. I believe, based on your posts, that you have certain expectations (relatively high ones, I think?) on what this show can and should deliver. I think that's great, and I'm not trying to rob you of those expectations. But I did feel that you were coming across rather strongly in your claims that this episode fails to fit the definition of what this show should be, according to your reading of the manga. My caution is simply that the show could go off in its own direction that's different than the manga, and other people (not necessarily you) may like it this way. While I certainly would by no means expect you to be pleased if that were the case, please also don't rob others of the privilege of loving something you may end up considering abominable. And to that end, I would encourage extended manga/anime comparisons to be kept out of episode threads, because what this show is and what the manga was/is aren't necessarily one and the same. I hope that makes sense without being too presumptuous or over-bearing. There's a lot more that I could say, but I'd rather not open the door to even more misunderstandings. I only claim to be a fallible human being like everyone else. I sometimes state things more directly than I should, and I make my share of mistakes. I try to apologize when I've wronged people. But, mod title aside, I'll always be unapologetically the same "me" that I was before I got this title. And sometimes that will cause more misunderstandings because people will only see the "title" and won't see me. But that's just how it is. Last edited by relentlessflame; 2009-10-10 at 23:42. |
|||
2009-10-10, 23:41 | Link #111 |
Human
Join Date: Aug 2004
Age: 37
|
Plenty of people who aren't manga readers don't like this direction though, as we've seen in this thread. Certainly some potential viewers are going to abandon this series, under the assumption that it's all going to be like this. And maybe it is, who knows? But if it isn't, and instead intends to eventually get to the parts that made manga readers call it great, then we just lost a bunch of viewers entirely from poor planning. And I'd call that a failure on the part of the producers.
|
2009-10-10, 23:55 | Link #112 | |
Administrator
Join Date: Dec 2003
Age: 41
|
Quote:
|
|
2009-10-11, 00:02 | Link #113 | ||||||||||
Crazy Devout Fanboy
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: 1st Ra Cailum-class battleship Ra Cailum, port-side officer's bunks
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
1) Too much Kuroko crazing over Mikoto 2) Nothing else happening at all 3) What's the point of the episode? Unless you think I'm flawed in thinking there should be a point to the episode. Quote:
Quote:
Not to mention which I don't know where you get that last part about possibly considering the series abominable, simply from me not liking one episode of a 12-24 episode series. You're the one saying not to jump to conclusions; you just made half a jump yourself. And I'm hoping that last line wasn't you mixing things up again, but to be safe: I'm NOT saying the episode was below par because it failed to compare to the manga.
__________________
Last edited by Shinji103; 2009-10-11 at 00:28. |
||||||||||
2009-10-11, 00:05 | Link #114 | ||
Knowledge is the solution
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: St. Louis, MO
Age: 39
|
[QUOTE=Shinji103;2697186]What "character interaction development?" At the end of the episode, and all the way through it, nothing has changed; Mikoto is still rejective of Kuroko's advances, Kuroko is still Oneesama-obsessed, Uiharu still looks up to Mikoto, and Saten still gets along with them. There's no development on any level or in any form.
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
||
2009-10-11, 00:06 | Link #115 | |||
そのおっぱいで13才
Join Date: Dec 2006
|
Quote:
Exaggeration aside, to put it simply, it is the viewer's fault for having such a short patience and judging the series by one simply episode. Random Example: OMG, Pokemon just had an episode full of Seiyuu jokes! The future episodes must all be going in this direction. Time to leave... Quote:
Quote:
Is how I figured it out. Of course, you could be talking about how the first episode fitted your definition of "Toaru Kagaku no Railgun" and how the second did not, but who knows. It is simply about focusing on Mikoto. The whole point is to give Mikoto more screen time. It isn't directly following the novel. If there is no Mikoto, this manga doesn't exist.
__________________
|
|||
2009-10-11, 00:50 | Link #117 | |||||||
Crazy Devout Fanboy
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: 1st Ra Cailum-class battleship Ra Cailum, port-side officer's bunks
|
Quote:
Quote:
But as I said in above posts, the staff at JC....Staff, said they were making an adaptation of the Railgun manga, which is hardly anything at all like Someday Dreamers, so it's only stands to reason that people would expect Railgun's plot and action over Someday Dreamer's slice-of-life. And nothing against you at all, but I just don't see how anybody could expect this show to be like Someday Dreamers, at least not before episode 2. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Needless to say, I don't think this is the case.
__________________
|
|||||||
2009-10-11, 00:57 | Link #118 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2007
|
Quote:
a) Geneon is promoting this series - not the creative team and not the production studio (the series producers aren't from J.C.Staff either, but I digress). b) If the director mentioned that the series centers on friendship, doesn't it mean that someone already suggested a potential change in focus? The pre-release seiyuu interviews also promised a large helping of Kuroko's obsessive advances, so this didn't come without warning. c) Regardless of what anyone says, some people will moan and bitch anyway. In this market, expectations are set once an adaptation is announced. |
|
2009-10-11, 01:08 | Link #119 | |
Crazy Devout Fanboy
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: 1st Ra Cailum-class battleship Ra Cailum, port-side officer's bunks
|
Quote:
b) No it doesn't actually. The manga was centered on the friendship between the characters too, while still having its plot. There were entire chapters devoted to how some of the characters got to be friends and stuff (just no chapters on how Mikoto and Kuroko met, at least not yet). so that doesn't mean anything to the effect of the anime being different. And the manga had a large helping of Kuroko obsessiveness too; that doesn't mean they'll fill whole episodes of the anime with it. But as I said, that wasn't the real problem with episode 2 for me; it's that it was filled with Kuroko obsessiveness and nothing else. c) Well, yeah. But giving the manga lovers a real heads-up could only have helped. At least the shock of "HEY! This isn't like the manga!" wouldn't be so hard for them. After all, it was things like the anime going different from the manga that got Rurouni Kenshin cancelled before they could actually finish it.
__________________
|
|
2009-10-11, 01:20 | Link #120 | ||
Administrator
Join Date: Dec 2003
Age: 41
|
Quote:
The way you state your opinions may imply arrogance and judgement that you may not intend. Yeah, I know. Like I said, irony. I've never once been trying to discredit your opinion, the basis for it, or anything else. All I was trying to point out is "you say you're open-minded, but some of your statements seem quick to judge; this appears contradictory". That's really all I was trying to say! This is why when you kept pointing out "you're missing my point, you're missing my point!", our points were completely missing each other. I wasn't trying to talk about your opinion, I was trying to point to the way you stated your opinion. When you assert that the anime isn't giving us "Railgun". When you assert that part of the content isn't good. When you assert that the producers would be idiots for not delivering something that resembles the manga (and/or telling us ahead of time of this fact). You might say "well, it's obvious that's just my opinion", but you state it as if it's "objectively true fact". (And I hope that you'll please excuse if I've taken more shortcuts in summarizing the arguments; I'm trying to point to the tone of the arguments.) These sorts of assertions, stated in this manner, seem arrogant and assuming to me, and seem like an indirect put-down of people who might like things the way they are. Not that you were necessarily intending this, but that's how it sounds to me (and possibly some others). That's why I was poking at those kinds of statements in particular. I was never trying to attack your opinion or the basis for it, only trying to demonstrate that the way you stated those opinions doesn't demonstrate the open-mindedness you actually subscribe to. All of my analogies and illustrations were trying to lead to this point, but you took it literally as if I was trying to tie the analogies back to what you "mean" rather than what you "said". I was literally focused on the words, not the thoughts. I'll give one more example that I really hope will make sense... Quote:
I hope to hell that this makes a bit of sense, because otherwise I really don't know how else to explain it. I'm totally supportive of your right to dislike or like some or all of the show for whatever reason you choose. But, to me, you came across a bit too strong in your criticism of the sections you didn't like, as if it was "totally obvious" they had no value at all. Hence my emphasis on "let's keep an open mind", which got converted down to "my opinion isn't welcome". What a mess... I'm really crossing my fingers here, because really, I'm not trying to attack, demean or anything. If this still didn't work, then I just sincerely apologize, and hope that you'll forgive me. |
||
|
|