(L) Fairy Tail Manga Discussion Thread

[B214]

Well it's not on the chapter that's for sure.

[Krono]

Originally Posted by B214

Well it's not on the chapter that's for sure.

He wasn't talking about the chapter that just came out. He was talking about the chapter he was starting to work on. Which assuming it's not a bonus chapter, could be anywhere from 3-7 chapters from now.

[G147]

Hopefully so.

[Edge Meltdown]

Spoiler for 393:

Silver...

[MAX_COLA_POWER!]

*points to Edge's post* times a ton

[_Misfit]

Damn... Well, Juvia has to do what needs to be done...

[Pinwheel10]

Is Fairy Tail Zero out yet? I think it is.

That chapter. Why did Silver have to die? He doesn't seem evil enough to warrant a death penalty. I think he's overreacting. Couldn't he just have chosen to live with Gray? Makes me feel this chapter was trying too hard to be dramatic/sad. Glad Juvia's involved, though.

[XFire]

GODDAMMIT FAIRY TAIL YOU'RE SUPPOSED TO BE STANDARD SHONEN STOP MAKING MY SOUL LEAK THROUGH MY EYES!!!!


*Ahem*

[_Misfit]

Originally Posted by Pinwheel10

Is Fairy Tail Zero out yet? I think it is.

That chapter. Why did Silver have to die? He doesn't seem evil enough to warrant a death penalty. I think he's overreacting. Couldn't he just have chosen to live with Gray? Makes me feel this chapter was trying too hard to be dramatic/sad. Glad Juvia's involved, though.

Of course he's not evil enough to die (even though he's kinda already dead), that's what I think makes this chapter pretty impactful. There's really no other choice here: if Keith remains unharmed then, yeah, Silver will live but the Face plan goes through and everyone is screwed. Juvia's only choice, as much as it might hurt Gray, is to go in on Keith and finish him off. I mean, I would love if Mashima decided to somehow keep Silver alive, but that's just how the cookie crumbles sometimes. I never got the sense that Mashina was playing this up for Maxium Feels, I looked at it as the only logical conclusion given what we now know about Silver.

[B214]

This week's chapter was just.....T-T

[Pinwheel10]

Originally Posted by _Misfit

I never got the sense that Mashina was playing this up for Maxium Feels, I looked at it as the only logical conclusion given what we now know about Silver.

I get the part where Silver will die once Keith dies for the sake of saving the world. Sad, yes, yada yada, but necessary.

But my point here is he WANTED to die in the first place... by Gray's hands even. It's just that it wasn't fully explained why he suddenly felt like "his hands were too stained" that he felt unworthy and wanted to die, when he saw Gray in the GMG. That made it feel to me like he was overreacting.

He could have chosen instead to be like the members of Crime Sorciere, who can't die because they have to atone for their sins. He was on that track, anyway, as he said he was already slaying demons and and aiming to destroy Tartaros. He could have used the life he had gained from necromancy by being a father to Gray, even if that will never happen since Keith must die.

I think it would have been more sad if all Silver wanted was to be reuntied with Gray, but finds it can never happen due to how Keith must die. It just seems illogical to me why he wanted to die and had to take that fatal blow from Gray, when he could have done something.... y'know, more positive to his relationship with Gray.

So yeah, TL;DR, I think Silver was severely overreacting.

[ImperialFlameGod8190]

This is a chapter naturally for feels as people have said. Other then that its utter bullox

[HayashiTakara]

Why can't he just be evil? an evil zombie... this "turn of events" is like the norm for this series, "hey! I'm a badguy! no not really, I'm just pretending or being brain washed, forgive me?"

[Krono]

Originally Posted by Pinwheel10

Is Fairy Tail Zero out yet? I think it is.

That chapter. Why did Silver have to die? He doesn't seem evil enough to warrant a death penalty. I think he's overreacting. Couldn't he just have chosen to live with Gray? Makes me feel this chapter was trying too hard to be dramatic/sad. Glad Juvia's involved, though.

Presumably he did plenty of dirty work for Tartarus well working for them. Sure he was working to kill demons when he got the chance, in hopes of eventually getting the chance to bring Tartarus down, but he's likely killed plenty of innocent people along the way in the service of Tartarus.

As he's already dead, the normal arguments as to why he should live on don't really apply. As long as he's still moving, Keith likely has the option of exerting control over him, and if Keith dies, he stops moving. So the best thing that can be done is for him to be put out of his misery.

[Kafriel]

It was a standard chapter imo - predictable, emotional and character-centered. The only thing I found rather out of place was Silver's behavior...

S: Kill me Gray, do it nao! I WANNA DIIIIEEEEE....ehm, END!
G: I-I can't do it, dad!
S: Oh, you can't? Well, it's okay, my body won't last long anyways.
(G: WTF!?)

[Eragon]

So.....Itachi of Fairy Tail ? Showing your luuurve through tormenting the one you love ?

At least, Grey didn't have his mind fucked 18 ways over...literally.

[ranchan13]

Originally Posted by XFire

GODDAMMIT FAIRY TAIL YOU'RE SUPPOSED TO BE STANDARD SHONEN STOP MAKING MY SOUL LEAK THROUGH MY EYES!!!!


*Ahem*

So much this!!!!

And Silver gives Juvia starmode at the end as well.
This is for Grey's sake? We've seen what she will do for Grey's sake.

[immblueversion]

Originally Posted by Pinwheel10

I get the part where Silver will die once Keith dies for the sake of saving the world. Sad, yes, yada yada, but necessary.

But my point here is he WANTED to die in the first place... by Gray's hands even. It's just that it wasn't fully explained why he suddenly felt like "his hands were too stained" that he felt unworthy and wanted to die, when he saw Gray in the GMG. That made it feel to me like he was overreacting.

He could have chosen instead to be like the members of Crime Sorciere, who can't die because they have to atone for their sins. He was on that track, anyway, as he said he was already slaying demons and and aiming to destroy Tartaros. He could have used the life he had gained from necromancy by being a father to Gray, even if that will never happen since Keith must die.

I think it would have been more sad if all Silver wanted was to be reuntied with Gray, but finds it can never happen due to how Keith must die. It just seems illogical to me why he wanted to die and had to take that fatal blow from Gray, when he could have done something.... y'know, more positive to his relationship with Gray.

So yeah, TL;DR, I think Silver was severely overreacting.

Hehe... Keith...

[Wandering Soul]

Originally Posted by XFire

GODDAMMIT FAIRY TAIL YOU'RE SUPPOSED TO BE STANDARD SHONEN STOP MAKING MY SOUL LEAK THROUGH MY EYES!!!!


*Ahem*

This x1000

Juvia will do just about anything for Gray's sake so Kieth is screwed but she will be indirectly taking away his father.

[Casshern]

Gray spin-off is out and I love it