Bakemonogatari - Episode 10 Discussion / Poll

[Woland]

Originally Posted by Shiroth

I don't see why it won't be fixed, i mean it's been said many times about the few episodes of Moon Phase that ended up like this, along with a few episodes from the first season of Hidamari Sketch.

The difference is Hidamari Sketch episode 10 (which probably was in even worse condition than this one) was fixed in just a week for TV broadcasting, that's why some of us are still hoping to see a better version in the next days

[Shiroth]

Originally Posted by Woland

The difference is Hidamari Sketch episode 10 (which probably was in even worse condition than this one) was fixed in just a week for TV broadcasting, that's why some of us are still hoping to see a better version in the next days

Like it's been said, then that would mess up the schedule for episode 11. I say best leaving it for DVD.

[sirn]

Don't know if this is appropriate to post in this topic, but anyway: here's a comparison pic for episode 10 of Hidamari Sketch for those who never watched it (could only find the low-quality one, sorry.).



Note that all images are exact-second comparison between two stations...
The DVD contains even more, ugh, corrections than this.

[Lummie]

How people are able to rate this episode a 10 or a 9 is still a mystery to me........

[Zetsubo]

Originally Posted by Lummie

How people are able to rate this episode a 10 or a 9 is still a mystery to me........

I agree.....

[guanin]

I want subs! I want subs nao!

Why was Araragi apologizing to Kanbaru in one of the last scenes? And why did Kanbaru push Araragi? And what the hell happened to the snake? Did it escape?

[Woland]

Originally Posted by Shiroth

Like it's been said, then that would mess up the schedule for episode 11. I say best leaving it for DVD.

Why? It's not that the same peoples of 10 are doing episode 11... it would be catastrophic! Different group are assigned on each episode, and usually an episode is (almost) finished 1 week before airing (well they do the composing for 10 the same day of airing Shaft is amazing... in some way). And they have to start working on web episode and the new season of Natsu no Arashi, it's not that they can stop at some point only to fix what is messed up (it's probably obvious that they are taking too much works).

To be clear it's not that (at this point) I would complain if they will only fix the episode on DVD.

[zetsumei]

Originally Posted by guanin

I want subs! I want subs nao!

Why was Araragi apologizing to Kanbaru in one of the last scenes? And why did Kanbaru push Araragi? And what the hell happened to the snake? Did it escape?

Spoiler for Answer:

Araragi was poisoned by snake. If he get excited the poison will spread. Kanbaru wanted to convey that to Araragi.

Araragi was trying to prevent the snake from going back to the boy that put the curse on Nadeko (there were 2 curses on Nadeko, one from the girl that like the boy that confessed to nadeko and one by the boy himself (Nadeko rejected him)). The snake was going to cause the boy harm. Kanbaru reminded Araragi that, "don't mistaken the person you should be saving". Araragi gave up on chasing after the snake after hearing that.

I'm not very good at explaining things so I hope this is sufficient.

It was still a fun episode to watch, in spite of the animation. I enjoyed it...

[Voitan]

I wonder if we should request a seperate thread for the finished version?

It'd be sorta convenient for me to know when the finished episode will be released, I don't want to watch this botched one and ruin my enjoyment of Bakemonogatari.

[omimon]

Originally Posted by Zetsubo

I agree.....

We are all forgiving.

[Vexx]

Originally Posted by Lummie

How people are able to rate this episode a 10 or a 9 is still a mystery to me........

Well, there's no way to bifurcate a rating.... so you end up either rating it for the story content (great) or the animation execution (omg, a slideshowz!). I'm still stewing but will probably average it out with the idea that much will be fixed later - and people viewing the poll will likely be scratching their heads.

[aulzon]

I dunno whether to wait for a rebroadcast version or DVD version to actually rate this.

Feels like rating a beta version of an episode.

[apr]

Are you people under the mistaken impression that your vote on an anime forum will change the course of history?

Just rate the experience for what it is when you see it.

[Shiroth]

Originally Posted by apr

Just rate the experience for what it is when you see it.

Exactly. I'm giving this episode a 9 because i enjoyed it quite a lot.

Also that OP is outstanding.

[wb121]

The OP is so catchy (been looping it for a while now).

Really fits the character.

[tarajis]

Wow!! Someone voted a 1... this person gotta be very disappointed with this episode... well can't blame him/her...

I myself will rate it a 5... +1 for the new OP... and +3 for seeing Senjougahara with only an apron... well like she said that it's every man's dream to see this...

AHHH... SENJOUGAHARA FASCINATION...

[qwertyman]

Originally Posted by Shiroth

Exactly. I'm giving this episode a 9 because i enjoyed it quite a lot.

Also that OP is outstanding.

I'm tempted to rate it likewise, even though I think Nadeko is easily the weakest female thus far.

That OP though... SHAFT must've figured out how to develop visual digital crack or something.

[Shiroth]

Originally Posted by qwertyman

I'm tempted to rate it likewise, even though I think Nadeko is easily the weakest female thus far.

She has the chances of being my favorite female out of the show, though there really isn't much from her at all, which is a huge shame. I'm just going to love her for what we got in these two episodes.

[qwertyman]

Maybe if she's lucky, she'll appear a bit in the next arc?

Kanbaru got decent exposure this arc, which was a nice surprise for me.

[zato_1one]

Yes, I think that what surprised me the most was the fact that no Senjougahara. And Kanbaru got full screentime in this arc.