Rate That Signature!

[ganbaru]

delorean2200 8,4/10 old school

[Krytonis]

ganbaru: nice quote and character, also my favourite colour combination (black and white) 9/10

[Dist]

matty : Excellent one.. but then again, as expected from the master of signatures . My only complaint would be the render itself, I don't like it very much. So 7/10.

So a new signature finally for me, this time done by rikikai. I had hard time on deciding what kind of text I want.. Perhaps any of you could offer some feedback as to which version you like the most?

Spoiler for 8 versions and I still can't pick between them :x:

[delorean2200]

@Dist: The one you have or the forth one, except of course for the first one the rest kind of conflict font style wise imho. 9/10 btw i like the overall look.

[ganbaru]

Koominator 8,3/10 not too hot for this background
Dist 8,9/10 look great

[Rethice]

@ganbaru - Amazing once again, the diagonal perspective is refreshing and makes it stand out front the crowd. 9/10

@dist - Really vibrant colours, and the text blends well. Love it 9/10

@koominator - I like the originality of it, the background looks like it took a lot of effort. Needs a border though, and something more to blend it all together. 8/10

@matty543 - Beautiful colours with effective use of space in such a small signature 8.5/10

[delorean2200]

Rethice: 8,7/10 a bit to blurred and quality is also a bit low, otherwise love it, what is it from ?

[Haladflire65]

Dist: Great! 8.9/10
Koominator: It needs more focus and the text can be worked on (also not feeling for the stripes there) 8/10
Rethice: Agreeing with delorean, 8.4/10
delorean: Not bad, 8.6/10

[ganbaru]

Rethice 8,4/10 quality issue.

[HasuMasu]

Rethice: Blurry me thinks. - 7/10
Dist: I personally like the one your using. - 9/10

[Rethice]

@Detective-san - Fukkireta, lol, smooth animation. 8/10

@Halad - Nice effect - 8/10

-

By the way, the blur on my the image in my signature is intentional - the depth of focus is set on the 3 characters on the left. Notice how they're not blurry at all, and I cropped them so they extend out of the rectangle to make them stand out even more?

Is it really that hard to tell? Might have to redo it if it's not obvious...

[grylsyjaeger]

Rethice: I like how you've the characters protruding outside the border but the image seems awfully low quality. Particularly the face on the right. 7/10

[Rethice]

@fallschirmjager - The comic effect is good while still making use of such a small space. 8.5/10

How'd I do this time guys? Went for a completely new angle due to size constraints.

Spoiler for for cleanliness:

[HasuMasu]

Rethice: 7/10 I think your previous one was better, with the charcaters standing outside the border and all.

[delorean2200]

Rethice: 7.5/10 needs a border and the whole image seems to be suffering from low quality, my only guess is that it has something to do with your export/save settings, cause you probably made that bg from scratch right ? I agree with the previous one being better and like i said the blur wouldn't have been a problem if the previous one wouldn't also have had a blurred character and would have resumed just to a some bg objects like the three and wall.

[Rethice]

@delorean2200 - Tuxedo mask can NEVER look bad. 8.5/10

Alright so I combined the two concepts together, and I'm pretty happy with the results this time

[ganbaru]

Rethice 8,5/10 it's a improvement

[delorean2200]

Rethice: 8.8/10 now that is an improvement, good work, my only advice would be to have the border include the lower part of the image/main render (characters), but just the lower zone, most easy way would be just to draw an extra line there, this way you get a better feeling of introducing sort of blending them in the image without loosing the nice effect of them standing out of the image.

[Haladflire65]

Rethice: I also don't think the renders need the drop shadow behind them. Also agreeing about the lower border~ 8.5/10
ganbaru: Nice one. The render seems a bit jagged in places though... and is the text slanted? I can't really tell but if so I don't really feel it's necessary 8.7/10

[delorean2200]

Ganbaru: 8.4/10 agreeing with halad, plus i'd like to add that it feels a bit to saturated.