AnimeSuki Forums

TheHaruhiIncarnate · 2011-07-16, 09:36

Guh. I don't like that DVD cover. -_- I could have done a better job.

Heminga13 · 2011-07-16, 11:22

Yeah I was a little disappointed when I saw the cover, too. It wasn't so bad for the poster but it's not very exciting to look at. On the FB page I believe it said that they aren't finalized so it could change, but I doubt it.

Gamer_2k4 · 2011-07-16, 12:39

The only thing I don't like about the cover is that it tells you absolutely nothing about the movie except (for the observant) that it takes place in winter. If I didn't know a thing about the series and saw this in a video store, I would pass it without a second thought.

GMT · 2011-07-16, 17:50

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gamer_2k4

The only thing I don't like about the cover is that it tells you absolutely nothing about the movie except (for the observant) that it takes place in winter. If I didn't know a thing about the series and saw this in a video store, I would pass it without a second thought.

What is there in this movie for someone that knows nothing about the franchise anyway? Without having seen the rest of the series, someone would have no way of knowing that Haruhi has any redeeming characteristics that would make Kyon want to seek her out (as the pre alt!Yuki-verse scenes just have her being bossy and cos-raping Mikuru.) Nor would they understand why Yuki executes an illegal operation in module emotion.exe and remakes the universe.

I'm just fine with the cover as it is. Though if you want to draw in the uninitiated person (who will just spend the whole movie confused anyway,) you could put a picture of Asakura (with her knife) on the cover and fool them into thinking it's a murder mystery.

Jonbob0008 · 2011-07-17, 00:03

Quote:

Originally Posted by Takamura Mamoru

Look at the way they are leaning against the wall.

Mikuru is on her toes, Haruhi is actually leaning against the wall, taking away height because her legs are bent.

Same goes for Kyon and Koizumi where I think Koizumi's leg is just slightly more bent, as well as Kyons posture (from body to head) being completely straight whereas Koizumi is slightly bent. Hell, even Kyons head is looking up while Koizumis is looking down.

The only thing I could agree with is Yuki being a little too short.

I'll grant you your point about Mikuru, but I still think Kyon's a little too tall. *shrugs*

ijuinkun · 2011-07-17, 00:29

Yuki does look tiny. Kyon should normally be about 20 cm taller than Yuki and Mikuru, and 15 cm taller than Haruhi.

Gamer_2k4 · 2011-07-17, 10:21

Spoiler for comparison images:

Happily, with the exception of Yuki, the characters are all in the same order. And, accounting for perspective, this looks about right. Yuki comes up to Itsuki's shoulder and is just past Kyon's shoulder. Haruhi goes up to Kyon's ear. Mikuru is about an inch and a half shorter than Haruhi, and if you figure she's just a touch closer to the viewer, it's pretty much dead on.

The picture may not look quite right, but it IS accurate.

TheHaruhiIncarnate · 2011-07-17, 12:23

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gamer_2k4

Spoiler for comparison images:

Happily, with the exception of Yuki, the characters are all in the same order. And, accounting for perspective, this looks about right. Yuki comes up to Itsuki's shoulder and is just past Kyon's shoulder. Haruhi goes up to Kyon's ear. Mikuru is about an inch and a half shorter than Haruhi, and if you figure she's just a touch closer to the viewer, it's pretty much dead on.

The picture may not look quite right, but it IS accurate.

I really like the picture with them leaning on the wall, but now I cant unsee the Yuki-is-wrong-height problem. Also, Haruhi is tall. I mean, taller than the other 2 girls. Also Tsuruya's height is perfect.

Jonbob0008 · 2011-07-17, 23:40

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheHaruhiIncarnate

I really like the picture with them leaning on the wall, but now I cant unsee the Yuki-is-wrong-height problem. Also, Haruhi is tall. I mean, taller than the other 2 girls. Also Tsuruya's height is perfect.

Maybe Yuki's height is meant to be metaphoric or something...although I'm probably talking out of my ass on that one.

AmyElizzabeth · 2011-07-19, 12:43

I always thought she was shorter than everyone..I don't have a problem with the DVD cover

Mion S. · 2011-07-20, 23:24

I like that picture, but it does not seem well fit on a DVD, a poster is perfect for it.

speedyexpress48 · 2011-07-26, 19:15

That picture is nice, but for a DVD cover it looks...really bland. On a poster it works fine, but for a DVD cover...meh.

Hope they come up with something better.

DL546 · 2011-08-26, 03:02

Speaking of the DVD/Blu-Ray coming out on the 20th of September, will it have the Japanese dub with English subs on it? Because, I went to a site where you can pre-order it, and it said that it would. Thanks in advance.

Ithekro · 2011-08-26, 05:40

In today's market, why would it not have the Japanese dub? The english subs might not be the extact subs (they might be the closed captioning subs instead), but I've not seen many recent English dubbed anime that don't leave the Japanese dub intact anymore. Unless it is a show that is localized (and editted) for American television, and those aren't all that common anymore.

DL546 · 2011-08-27, 04:00

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ithekro

In today's market, why would it not have the Japanese dub? The english subs might not be the extact subs (they might be the closed captioning subs instead), but I've not seen many recent English dubbed anime that don't leave the Japanese dub intact anymore. Unless it is a show that is localized (and editted) for American television, and those aren't all that common anymore.

Just wondering. Thanks.

TakariCritic · 2011-09-02, 18:52

Okay, I finished my preordered Disappearance.

Gotta say, the english cast did a superb job. Crispin Freeman was astounding, and even though Sugita did a marvelous job in the movie, Freeman certainly delivered as well.

That being said, I think Michelle Ruff's alt-Yuki was a little lacking, but overall everyone performed in a way that kept me immersed, even after countless views of the original cast.

One thing that I feel conflicted about is the re-write of Koizumi's comment as the train passes. I won't spoil it, but its clearly heard and.... controversial. Personally, its exactly the type of thing I think the alt-version would say, and matches exactly how I perceive his true feelings, but others may be less inclined to agree. I'm sure it will come up later in discussion/debate.

AbZeroNow · 2011-09-03, 02:23

I also watched my pre-ordered copy of Disappearance and went back to check that scene that Takari mentioned. I felt Johnny Yong Bosch's reading of that line as the train is going by after they've left the restaurant was spot-on. That line is also apparently present in the original Japanese too since Daisuke Ono(Itsuki's seiyuu) mentions that particular line at a screening. The movie changing it from the book was a good change, it made it more clear that alt. Itsuki clearly has feelings for alt. Haruhi.

I was slightly disappointed that Michelle Ruff didn't try to play up the moe of alt. Yuki. Then again, I am sure there would be been blooper takes where Bridget Hoffman would say that she wants to take Yuki home with her(and really Ryoko sounding like Rena would probably induce nightmares.) if Michelle went in that direction.

Crispin deserves a lot of praise for his portrayal of Kyon in this movie. He really nails those emotional moments. The rooftop scene has a couple of great examples of Crispin giving a great performance as Kyon. There were many great examples in the movie though.

Takamura Mamoru · 2011-09-03, 20:04

Good to know Crispin Freeman could deliver. I was blown away by Sugitas performance in the movie and since I'm a fan of Freeman's Kyon, I wondered if he could keep up with that amazing voice acting.

ijuinkun · 2011-09-04, 03:31

I agree. Watching Kyon's big internal soliloquy trying to decide what he really wanted was one of the character's best moments.

cbfox99 · 2011-09-04, 20:37

Crispin Freeman=Tomokazu Sugita

Johnny Yong Bosch=Daisuke Ono

Michelle Ruff DOES NOT=Minori Chihara

Well not the alt. Yuki anyway. I have to agree with AbZeroNow. She just couldn't do it. She sounded like a cross between
too timid, too scared and very annoying. Michelle played the original Yuki spot on, of course, but with alt. Yuki it was like nails on a chalkboard, you just did not want to listen to her. I almost covered my ears when she's talking to Kyon about the library incident at her apt. I have to say that at times she was more annoying to listen to than Mikuru!
The problem was she just didn't sound like Yuki at all.
When Minori Chihara played both versions of Yuki she still sounded like Yuki! However, Michelle played alt. Yuki so bad that I honestly thought she was another voice actor. This shows her versatility as a voice actor yes, but it's not so good when she's trying to portray the same character.
I saw the dub at Otakon so when Kyon and adult Mikuru went to the Yuki from 3 years ago I nearly jumped out of the chair and said "Yes, now THAT sounds like Yuki!" I was so happy to hear the voice I've loved all these years.
So IMO the cast did an awesome job except for Michelle's alt. Yuki but since her part was so small anyway I bit my lip and sucked it up. By the end of the movie I was so happy to have seen the dub and was so thankful that it didn't change all that much from the original that I didn't care anymore about moe Yuki or lack there of.

2011-07-16, 09:36	Link #581
TheHaruhiIncarnate Goddess Join Date: Mar 2010 Location: On Earth	Guh. I don't like that DVD cover. -_- I could have done a better job. __________________ F**k Moe Embrace Tsundere

2011-07-16, 11:22	Link #582
Heminga13 Wannabe Sleuth Join Date: Apr 2009 Age: 35	Yeah I was a little disappointed when I saw the cover, too. It wasn't so bad for the poster but it's not very exciting to look at. On the FB page I believe it said that they aren't finalized so it could change, but I doubt it. __________________ If you're interested in what I'm watching, click here. Heminga13: Speculating and anticipating 'The Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya' movie since August 3, 2009.

2011-07-16, 12:39	Link #583
Gamer_2k4 Anime Cynic Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: USA Age: 35	The only thing I don't like about the cover is that it tells you absolutely nothing about the movie except (for the observant) that it takes place in winter. If I didn't know a thing about the series and saw this in a video store, I would pass it without a second thought. __________________

2011-07-17, 10:21	Link #587
Gamer_2k4 Anime Cynic Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: USA Age: 35	Spoiler for comparison images: Happily, with the exception of Yuki, the characters are all in the same order. And, accounting for perspective, this looks about right. Yuki comes up to Itsuki's shoulder and is just past Kyon's shoulder. Haruhi goes up to Kyon's ear. Mikuru is about an inch and a half shorter than Haruhi, and if you figure she's just a touch closer to the viewer, it's pretty much dead on. The picture may not look quite right, but it IS accurate. __________________

2011-08-26, 05:40	Link #594
Ithekro Gamilas Falls Join Date: Feb 2008 Location: Republic of California Age: 46	In today's market, why would it not have the Japanese dub? The english subs might not be the extact subs (they might be the closed captioning subs instead), but I've not seen many recent English dubbed anime that don't leave the Japanese dub intact anymore. Unless it is a show that is localized (and editted) for American television, and those aren't all that common anymore. __________________

2011-07-17, 00:29	Link #586
ijuinkun Senior Member Join Date: Feb 2007	Yuki does look tiny. Kyon should normally be about 20 cm taller than Yuki and Mikuru, and 15 cm taller than Haruhi.

2011-07-19, 12:43	Link #590
AmyElizzabeth Moo Join Date: Aug 2009 Location: Iowa Age: 28	I always thought she was shorter than everyone..I don't have a problem with the DVD cover

2011-07-20, 23:24	Link #591
Mion S. Junior Member Join Date: Jul 2011 Location: Washington	I like that picture, but it does not seem well fit on a DVD, a poster is perfect for it.

2011-07-26, 19:15	Link #592
speedyexpress48 Boo, you whore Join Date: Jul 2011 Location: Smokin that CO bong	That picture is nice, but for a DVD cover it looks...really bland. On a poster it works fine, but for a DVD cover...meh. Hope they come up with something better.

2011-08-26, 03:02	Link #593
DL546 Junior Member Join Date: Aug 2011 Location: Vancouver, BC Age: 27	Speaking of the DVD/Blu-Ray coming out on the 20th of September, will it have the Japanese dub with English subs on it? Because, I went to a site where you can pre-order it, and it said that it would. Thanks in advance.

2011-09-02, 18:52	Link #596
TakariCritic Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2009	Okay, I finished my preordered Disappearance. Gotta say, the english cast did a superb job. Crispin Freeman was astounding, and even though Sugita did a marvelous job in the movie, Freeman certainly delivered as well. That being said, I think Michelle Ruff's alt-Yuki was a little lacking, but overall everyone performed in a way that kept me immersed, even after countless views of the original cast. One thing that I feel conflicted about is the re-write of Koizumi's comment as the train passes. I won't spoil it, but its clearly heard and.... controversial. Personally, its exactly the type of thing I think the alt-version would say, and matches exactly how I perceive his true feelings, but others may be less inclined to agree. I'm sure it will come up later in discussion/debate.

2011-09-03, 02:23	Link #597
AbZeroNow North American Haruhiist Join Date: Oct 2010 Age: 43	I also watched my pre-ordered copy of Disappearance and went back to check that scene that Takari mentioned. I felt Johnny Yong Bosch's reading of that line as the train is going by after they've left the restaurant was spot-on. That line is also apparently present in the original Japanese too since Daisuke Ono(Itsuki's seiyuu) mentions that particular line at a screening. The movie changing it from the book was a good change, it made it more clear that alt. Itsuki clearly has feelings for alt. Haruhi. I was slightly disappointed that Michelle Ruff didn't try to play up the moe of alt. Yuki. Then again, I am sure there would be been blooper takes where Bridget Hoffman would say that she wants to take Yuki home with her(and really Ryoko sounding like Rena would probably induce nightmares.) if Michelle went in that direction. Crispin deserves a lot of praise for his portrayal of Kyon in this movie. He really nails those emotional moments. The rooftop scene has a couple of great examples of Crispin giving a great performance as Kyon. There were many great examples in the movie though.

2011-09-03, 20:04	Link #598
Takamura Mamoru The Hawk Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Berlin, Fatherland	Good to know Crispin Freeman could deliver. I was blown away by Sugitas performance in the movie and since I'm a fan of Freeman's Kyon, I wondered if he could keep up with that amazing voice acting.

2011-09-04, 03:31	Link #599
ijuinkun Senior Member Join Date: Feb 2007	I agree. Watching Kyon's big internal soliloquy trying to decide what he really wanted was one of the character's best moments.

2011-09-04, 20:37	Link #600
cbfox99 Scrumy! Join Date: Mar 2010 Location: I can see you	Crispin Freeman=Tomokazu Sugita Johnny Yong Bosch=Daisuke Ono Michelle Ruff DOES NOT=Minori Chihara Well not the alt. Yuki anyway. I have to agree with AbZeroNow. She just couldn't do it. She sounded like a cross between too timid, too scared and very annoying. Michelle played the original Yuki spot on, of course, but with alt. Yuki it was like nails on a chalkboard, you just did not want to listen to her. I almost covered my ears when she's talking to Kyon about the library incident at her apt. I have to say that at times she was more annoying to listen to than Mikuru! The problem was she just didn't sound like Yuki at all. When Minori Chihara played both versions of Yuki she still sounded like Yuki! However, Michelle played alt. Yuki so bad that I honestly thought she was another voice actor. This shows her versatility as a voice actor yes, but it's not so good when she's trying to portray the same character. I saw the dub at Otakon so when Kyon and adult Mikuru went to the Yuki from 3 years ago I nearly jumped out of the chair and said "Yes, now THAT sounds like Yuki!" I was so happy to hear the voice I've loved all these years. So IMO the cast did an awesome job except for Michelle's alt. Yuki but since her part was so small anyway I bit my lip and sucked it up. By the end of the movie I was so happy to have seen the dub and was so thankful that it didn't change all that much from the original that I didn't care anymore about moe Yuki or lack there of. Last edited by cbfox99; 2011-09-05 at 09:16.