2013-04-16, 10:55 | Link #482 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
Quote:
Devil Survivor 2 shows none of this because demons form the greatest danger and they can be wiped out in seemingly endless numbers by a super white tiger. Oh, and the protagonists have decided to join up with the government so they can have grand adventures. They have resources, security, and power - the very opposite of a survival story. If this show was based on the first game where the main cast have to rely on their own wits, then the story would be more about surviving, but that's not the case here. Quote:
...Wait, maybe that came out wrong.
__________________
|
|||
2013-04-16, 11:19 | Link #483 | |
Kamen Rider Muppeteer
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Unknown
Age: 39
|
Quote:
I'm going to admit I'm having a bit of a hard time here when people are so adamant about how their assumptions can't possibly be wrong when it's pretty much impossible for me to even attempt to provide an argument to the contrary for obvious reasons. Although I'll accept that this might be some indication of the impression that people get from just the beginning two episodes. Should I just stay away from the discussion entirely until the whole thing's over? That sounds kinda boring. |
|
2013-04-16, 15:56 | Link #484 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2010
|
*sigh*
I'll just throw my final two cents out there before this turns into another source material circlejerk. Most likely any arguments or complaints I will make in the future will be centered around these two points anyway. 1)Don't assume you know the game's plot with just knowledge from the first game or from this anime. There are enough differences even early at this point that the only way you'll know the story accurately enough is to play the game itself. 2)An adaptation that captures only the skeleton of the source material's narrative is not necessarily a good adaptation, even if the animation itself is high quality. For example, take the Fate/Stay Night adaptations, which are generally regarded as poor adaptations of Type-Moon's works. Both the TV series and the Unlimited Blade Works movie followed the basic narrative closely enough - they fight the same people, and the ending is ultimately the same as the visual novel, so it's nothing near as poor as other anime adaptations like Yumekui Merry, Tsukihime, or Chaos;Head where it diverges from the source material completely to present a poorly written filler plot. So then why were the Fate/Stay Night anime poorly received? Believe it or not, the minor details do matter. Changes in character dynamics can cause anime-only viewers to judge characters completely differently from how they normally are in the source material. Changes to major events like fights can change a viewer's judgement of a character from strong or clever to being a weakling who only wins through plot convenience or just a character who is useless in general. There is a very real possibility that small differences in individual episodes can accumulate into a largely different experience by the time one cour passes. |
2013-04-17, 04:34 | Link #485 | |
→ Wandering Bard
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Grancel City, Liberl Kingdom
|
Quote:
Still I am enjoying this adaptation. They kept the various details like the game transitions.
__________________
|
|
2013-04-17, 10:27 | Link #486 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2010
|
Quote:
Perhaps this is where our expectations differ; You seem to want a faithful adaptation in a well-directed anime that you would call good, but I want to see a work that can potentially improve on the bloated original story, even if it means bringing about some major changes in adapting from the source material. Quote:
Quote:
My case in point: Giving Hibiki a proper, distinct personality to play off the other characters instead of him being the passive avatar he was in the game. I cannot take anyone who wanted him to be autistic bunny-chan or Yu Narukami seriously, because that very characterization risk the severity of the story. I still personally feel Kishi's decision with this was the best one we could've gotten, even if a little generic. Last edited by com_gwp; 2013-04-17 at 10:38. |
|||
2013-04-17, 11:40 | Link #487 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2010
|
Quote:
I mean, I agree that the game or its narrative isn't that spectacular as far as Shin Megami Tensei games go, but I wouldn't call one step forward, one step back an improvement either. Quote:
Adaptations that end up better than the source material are even more rare than faithful ones that remain the same quality. I do agree improvements can be made to the game, like better characterizations overall to Ronaldo, Jungo, and Keita as well as tying certain character developments to the main plot better (won't say how or why since this is the anime thread), but if the anime creates problems in areas where the game was already good, can't we just get a faithful adaptation instead? Quote:
As mentioned before, an improvement would have been if Kishi designed Hibiki to have only slightly more powerful demons than Daichi or Io at the beginning, and had him use his wits to coordinate team attacks with Daichi and Io participating. In the church scene, Hibiki could have directed one of them to find the haywire phone while the rest work with him to get rid of the Itsumade and protect the citizens. What I do think is an improvement is how Daichi was presented before the train crash, because the anime actually shows how he has been buddies with Hibiki. I also think Io rescuing Daichi before the truck crash was better than what happened in the game. However, with all the other changes I mentioned before, I can't say the anime's narrative is overall better than the game so far. Last edited by Shadow5YA; 2013-04-17 at 11:58. |
|||
2013-04-17, 13:12 | Link #488 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2010
|
Quote:
Because personally I'm liking the fact that show is striking out on its own the way it is, and for better or for worse, I'm really anticipating to see how the changes will play out over the course of the show. |
|
2013-04-18, 14:15 | Link #491 |
綺羅星★!
Join Date: Jan 2004
Age: 42
|
Definitely very surprised by the turn of events in ep3. I felt this was the best episode yet, since it didn't drag and they handled the major battle here pretty well. As a fan of the game, the direction the anime is going suddenly has me much more interested now.
Spoiler:
Still no Airi though, and no Airi next week either. I think next week should be pretty exciting, but... Airi.... where.... are.... you... T_T |
2013-04-18, 14:57 | Link #492 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2010
|
Quote:
you can save him or let him die in game (failed to save him) It look like they don't plan to save all character to have more time slot for others |
|
2013-04-18, 16:47 | Link #498 |
Alive
Join Date: Jan 2013
Location: in my really nice house
|
for someone that haven't play the game I was suprise that they fail to save Keita.
the demon that they were fighting look way too powerful this episode was really good and it look like the next will be better
__________________
|
2013-04-18, 16:51 | Link #499 | |
Kamen Rider Muppeteer
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Unknown
Age: 39
|
Quote:
So... I'd recommend -against- reading the manga. Because it will spoil everything. |
|
2013-04-18, 17:04 | Link #500 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2004
|
Rather than Keita's death, I'm actually more interested in the fact that the Osaka team has pretty much lost right at the start of the story. System ruined, barriers down, summoners dead except for one (and the three from Tokyo), the enemy is invading... Nice, nice.
|
Tags |
atlus, devil_survivor, index, persona |
Thread Tools | |
|
|