Hayate no Gotoku manga (raw discussion only)

[leoblack9]

So do you guys think Shiranui was, at one point, some hero saving people in need? Crazy theory, but in world of Hayate no Gotoku nothing is ever crazy.

Father Linn, he's a tough cookie, I percieved that he and Hayate's brother must've been colleages at one point since at that time they must've been at the same age and could've met at some point in time. They must have been involved with something and they ended up with scars on their foreheads.

[Lisemer]

Sorry guys, but I don't think Hata is lying with the characters'sheets, and anyway, if all of you forget it, the X scar of the father was from the arrow that kill him...
Anyway, if any of you remember it, Shiranui seems to has something similar to CC's geass of love, because any girl that see the cat, fall in a curse or something that does the girl doesn't want to be apart from him (at least, that I feel, seeing the response of Ayumu, Hina and Nagi at the sight of the cat...).
And maybe, Hayate's aniki fall for another curse that tranform him into a cat...

[zodanhko]

I thought the father said he existed for 400 years in spirit form.

[Edge Meltdown]

Originally Posted by Lisemer

And maybe, Hayate's aniki fall for another curse that tranform him into a cat...

i thought somehow he managed to get a ability to shapeshift since his scar is eerily similar to shiranui's and also this is HnG we're talking about, so anything's possible... (but not all i guess...)

[zodanhko]

You guys are thinking to deep toward the subject. I can see Hata pointing and laughing at the moment thinking "just as planned."

[fukarming]

Originally Posted by zodanhko

You guys are thinking to deep toward the subject. I can see Hata pointing and laughing at the moment thinking "just as planned."

But it is fun thinking deep, isn't it? I think plenty of discussion in the HnG manga thread results from us thinking deep. Hata probably never expected us to go from pages to discuss what Athena/ Hina/ Nagi/ Hayate thinking deeply inside or what that one conversation/ screen really means....etc

[zodanhko]

It's working, it's working. Lol

[Used Can]

inb4 Hayate is his own father, tang, happy birthday, it was all a dream, the butler was the culprit, and "The Heart"

[Koroshiya_Kame_13]

Instead of trying to find a resemblance for Hayate's brother to a character that has already appeared, can't it also be assumed that the scar was just there to dramatize the revelation of his face and a special feature for Athena to remember and Hayate to identify.

[frivolity]

Nah, I'm pretty sure it's Col. Mustard in the kitchen using the candlestick.

[GlassesLady]

I thought Hayate and Nagi were clones of Nii-chan's parents.... o3o

[Led_Zeppelin]

Originally Posted by Used Can

inb4 Hayate is his own father, tang, happy birthday, it was all a dream, the butler was the culprit, and "The Heart"

hahaha, you forgot "pie end"...

[GlassesLady]

Originally Posted by fukarming

and btw, where is the continual argument between "should Athena be praised?" I think used can make the perfect analogy but no one wants to talk about it anymore?

Oh, go ahead and post it. This is a spoiler thread; we're obviously supposed to be having a serious-business argument about some fool fictional character's morality, not, I don't know, discussing spoilers or anything (:

Seriously, though, go ahead and post it.

[Used Can]

Originally Posted by Led_Zeppelin

hahaha, you forgot "pie end"...

I actually thought about that and "nice boat," but I wanted to avoid it.

[Game8910]

so this has been posted around...I am not sure the origin of this page but if someone here knows what it is (and what are they saying?) please explain >_<

Spoiler for Did Hata make this?:

It has the same art as his early chapters...so im guessing this could be some kind of pre-HnG prototype?

[musouka]

Originally Posted by Game8910

It has the same art as his early chapters...so im guessing this could be some kind of pre-HnG prototype?

No, it's from "Umi no Yuusha Lifesavers", one of Hata's previous works.

[Game8910]

Originally Posted by musouka

No, it's from "Umi no Yuusha Lifesavers", one of Hata's previous works.

well damn...but seriously its almost like he based a character from everyone on that page lol...I saw a Nagi-like, Saki-like, Hina-like...and now even Hayate's brother which look 90% the same...

[Used Can]

I don't think that's really odd, since many mangakas tend to recycle characters. Umi no Yūsha Lifesavers was never that popular; so, he's able to easily recycle those characters.

I remember I read Umi no Yūsha Lifesavers quite some time ago, when I was looking for Hata's manga about Hina and Yukiji's life (which I've never found). I don't think it was particularly interesting, but I wouldn't be surprised if some people were to like it.

[Arabesque]

^
In addition to that, it's not unusual for an illustrator to create character that resemble each other through out their career (wither its in the same story or not) After all, they all came from the same person.

Spoiler for As for spoiler:

I just hope that the scar is just a way to have Hayate know it was his brother that saved Athena, and not Hata trying to introduce a ''X-shaped scar on forehead=Secret Legacy '' plot line.

[GlassesLady]

Spoiler for 'Bout dat scar:

I'm hoping there's at least a little reason to it beyond easy identification, like the story of how he got it at least, but yeah, a 'secret legacy' storyline would be a bit much.