2009-03-13, 19:56 | Link #3881 | |
Banned
|
Quote:
come on, Ishida is the sexy calm power. |DD; |
|
2009-03-13, 20:10 | Link #3882 | |||
Shameless Fangirl
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Germany
Age: 33
|
Quote:
Did the average Roman mind slavery? Did people protest when most countries made themselves out to be "chosen by God" and/or inherently superior to others at one point or another? I don't think so. A heavily flawed system can only exist because people in general are easily corrupted - that's how I see it. And I got the impression that Code Geass agrees with me on that, even though it gives us some notable exceptions. Quote:
Then I really don't see the point in the "making Suzaku smile" line. Oh well... R2. xD Quote:
After Zero Requiem, he has the chance to do better... and I imagine he's going to use it. He will not become a second Euphie, but I don't think he'll go and hunt some "Elevens" for fun.
__________________
|
|||
2009-03-13, 20:11 | Link #3883 | ||
~Hi -mi- tsu des~
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Canada
Age: 39
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
||
2009-03-13, 20:36 | Link #3884 | |
No Eyes
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Dirac Sea
|
Quote:
|
|
2009-03-13, 20:43 | Link #3885 | |
Shameless Fangirl
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Germany
Age: 33
|
Quote:
Romans didn't mind enslaving their enemies. Britannia doesn't mind killing them. So either the system is "evil", or people in general are. Or both, because they are so closely connected... or neither. And that's exactly why I don't see any characters in Code Geass as "evil", including Gino. He's far from being moral, but it's not like he is a lost cause - just corrupted by false ideals. Britannia as a whole seems to have this problem. There are some exceptions, like Lloyd, who's just... well, Lloyd; or Clovis, who just didn't seem to care much about anything anymore - except maintaining his status, but even that seemed more like desperation to me than anything else. I'm not saying that either of them is "better" or more moral than the other, but neither do I view them as "evil". But Lelouch had also killed Charles and not been very... modest about it. Anyway, that's the blind loyalty again, and it's definitely not a good thing. But I think he might very well be able to cut those ties now.
__________________
|
|
2009-03-13, 20:53 | Link #3886 | |
~Hi -mi- tsu des~
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Canada
Age: 39
|
Quote:
|
|
2009-03-13, 20:58 | Link #3887 | |
Shameless Fangirl
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Germany
Age: 33
|
Quote:
Not to mention that there were slaves who were used for pleasure. The Romans may have thought that was all right. But if they can have their own moral standards, so can Britannia.
__________________
|
|
2009-03-13, 21:10 | Link #3888 |
zzzzzzzz
Join Date: Oct 2008
|
You should try Sparta. They had a hunting season where young Spartans proved how manly they were by finding the fittest Helot they could, hunting him down, and killing him unarmed. Naturally, they could rape them whenever they wanted to as well. If a girl accidently came of one of those unions, they were just left out to starve and die because they wouldn't be as useful for work.
|
2009-03-13, 21:16 | Link #3889 |
No Eyes
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Dirac Sea
|
I find that hard to fathom and see it as nothing more than hopefulness when he didn't even allow his best friend to explain his actions and opposed him, despite being loved by everyone, for not agreeing with his view. As Gino said, he doesn't accept their Britannia.
|
2009-03-13, 22:00 | Link #3890 |
~Hi -mi- tsu des~
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Canada
Age: 39
|
Well obviously... are you suggesting that punishment for breaking laws is amoral? Obviously there have also been revolts and such (Sparticus and his slave rebellion for one) but facts are that one of the strengths of the Romans was their ability to tie conquered people to them through citizenship and the granting of rights which permeated to their treatment of the slaves of conquered people. As I said that is not always the case but in general the way they view slaves especially after the republican period is not exactly how you made it out to be. (I am deliberately not touching the subject of the "pleasure slaves" as on the whole women in antiquity is... complicated...)
|
2009-03-13, 22:34 | Link #3891 |
No Eyes
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Dirac Sea
|
Nogi, your comparison of cultures and acceptance is also a rather poor one. You are saying that people get born into cultures and that they accept them because that is all that they know, which is true. But your argument runsaground when you realize that you are comparing a common citizen, someone who is not involved in the inner workings and likely quite oblvious to most things, to someone like Gino who is fully engrossed in the inner workings of the system.
This is why I compared him and the KoR to the Schutzstaffel, because neither are just common citizens born into a nation and people who simply go with the flow of the nation, they are people who know and understand all the inner workings of the nation and willingly perpetuate them. Most Nazis and German citizens did not know about the camps, or the mass slaughterings of Jews, they were told A while the Schutzstaffel did B. How many Germans do you think heard about the various reason-less murderings of Jews on the streets by disgruntled Schutzstaffel soldiers or by orders from the top to "cut back on a ghetto's population and to redistribute the cloth for new incomers". How many Britannians do you think would have been told that Gino led a bunch of Knightmares to slaughter people seeking freedom? How many Britannians do you think know that Cornelia annihilated a ghetto of innocent people, and not just a "hive of terrorists that threatened everyone". The common Britannian likely did not know about any of the horrors that were done, that is what media is for, and we even see it in season 1 that the media is active in spinning the stories. These people do not have to accept the evil of their nation because they have no clue it exists, they are oblivious, much as most of the Germany's National Socialist German's Working Party were. This is where the comparison between the Schutzstaffel and KoR comes in, you can throw in Cornelia and even Clovis into the mix if you want, because they fully understood how the system worked, mass killings, racial oppression, and so on, and perpetuated it with no signs of regret or morality. To them, the people that they oppressed were simply targets waiting to be shot in the case of a revolt. The Schutzstaffel were butchers that killed to keep disidents, jews, and every other group that the Nazi's disagreed with, in check and under its heel. Utterly no different from what the KoR do regularly, what Gino is shown doing and suggesting, and what Cornelia is shown doing. The Schutzstaffel are by all standards considered an abomination of a group and many people consider them downright evil people, to the very core, because they accepted the job of slaughterers of people who simply did not want to live under someone's heel. It is these people that were, at the end of WWII, tried for various warcrimes, crimes against humanity, and most who were detained (and that did not flee) were executed. The KoR are no different, and there is nothing to distinguish Gino from the group, he is a slaughterer just like the rest of them. A man who willingly kills and tramples people to perpetuate his own idealogy, and he does it while smiling. There is no "being born into the system" for these people because they had at every oppurtunity the chance to realize (even if its just morally) that what they were doing may have been wrong, but it never crossed any of their minds. You don't see any of them ever contemplating the blood on their hands nor do they even give more than a seconds thought to slaughtering civilians if it quells an uprising. People who do not even get the sense of "this might be wrong", enjoy doing it, and willingly do it, are generally called psychopaths. People aren't conditioned into this, unless they go through rigerous desensitization training (which I highly doubt Gino ever did), they are born like this and they are generally called genuinely evil people, or at the very least completely amoral. Did you ever wonder why Gino, Luciano, Bismark, Anya, and so on, were in the same unit? Because they are all psychopaths or completely emotionless people, and fanatically loyal. People you work with generally tend to be a reflection on your own character, Gino works with people like Luciano and Bismark, they show us that he is not that different from them, even if he may not be as bad as them. When Suzaku was with them, he was also a lunatic who did not, despite all that his character stood for, give second chances. He killed mercilessly and he managed to earn the title of Shinigami, a title not easily earned in only one year. These are not people who are just born into the system, these are people who fully understand and support said system and are as corrupt and vile as the system itself. Gino may not be a demonite like Luciano, but he is an amoral man within an evil organization, that has the sole purpose of controlling the world and keeping nations under-heel. And he is fully aware and accepting of that fact. And like I said, in any realistic conclusion, Gino would have been tried for countless warcrimes and executed. You cannot brush away who the man is, and there is nothing in the show that even shows that he has left that behind (which would be nigh impossible given how fanatically loyal he was to begin with). |
2009-03-14, 02:12 | Link #3893 |
Spinning Lotus
Join Date: Jul 2008
|
He did nothing of the sort. You don't gain a name like "White Death" for being lovey dovey to everyone you meet. All Suzaku did was say "give up and I won't kill you," then rampaged once the opponent inevitably said "no." As shown in the picture drama he was complicit in the conquering of what must be quite a few countries, and saving that little girl to make him feel better doesn't change that fact. For all his claims of non-violence, Suzaku did nothing but perpetuate Britannia's violent expansionism during his stint as a KoR. Even before that he went along with the violence, though to his credit he's simply too ignorant to realize what he's doing then.
__________________
|
2009-03-14, 08:48 | Link #3895 | |
今宵の虎徹は血に飢えている
Join Date: Jan 2009
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2009-03-14, 08:53 | Link #3896 | ||||||||||
Shameless Fangirl
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Germany
Age: 33
|
Quote:
So... yeah, I have hope. xD Quote:
Quote:
Roman slavery may not have been the most awful of all in the history of mankind, but I sure as hell wouldn't want to switch places with one of those slaves, either. Quote:
Quote:
Which is why I don't think that the average Britannian would have minded innocent "Elevens" dying for their nation all that much. Charles' speeches said it all. Quote:
He may not have cared about innocent people dying anymore after three years in Area Eleven, but I also doubt he supported the system. Before he came to Japan, he had other plans than Cornelia, who told him to "leave his feelings out of this" and just bring to heel whoever resists. He also didn't seem very prejudiced against "Numbers" in the Sound Drama (except maybe that they "let Lelouch die", but he seemed to have been past that already), and simply underestimated the system when he made his plans. He became quite the bastard, but not because he thought Britannia was awesome, but because he abandoned all his morals and "kindness" along the way and became indifferent to almost everything. Quote:
To me, the ending means that all the characters left alive were capable of change, and even if you don't think that's very believable, I don't have a problem with it except that it came out of nowhere in many case due to a lack of screentime. Quote:
That's what the ending was about, after all. And really, Kallen being ready to kill her friends if they found out about her connection to the Black Knights isn't exactly "normal", either. It's a result of what happened to her and what she believed in. Of course she's still a much "better" person than Gino, but we don't know enough about what went on inside his head to say if there was a time when he had trouble taking lives. Quote:
Quote:
Again, this might not work very well in real life, but I didn't mind it at all in Code Geass, except for the fact that it was much too rushed.
__________________
|
||||||||||
2009-03-14, 08:56 | Link #3897 | ||||||||||
Shameless Fangirl
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Germany
Age: 33
|
Quote:
So... yeah, I have hope. xD Quote:
Quote:
Roman slavery may not have been the most awful of all in the history of mankind, but I sure as hell wouldn't want to switch places with one of those slaves, either. Quote:
Quote:
Which is why I don't think that the average Britannian would have minded innocent "Elevens" dying for their nation all that much. Charles' speeches said it all. Quote:
He may not have cared about innocent people dying anymore after three years in Area Eleven, but I also doubt he supported the system. Before he came to Japan, he had other plans than Cornelia, who told him to "leave his feelings out of this" and just bring to heel whoever resists. He also didn't seem very prejudiced against "Numbers" in the Sound Drama (except maybe that they "let Lelouch die", but he seemed to have been past that already), and simply underestimated the system when he made his plans. He became quite the bastard, but not because he thought Britannia was awesome, but because he abandoned all his morals and "kindness" along the way. Quote:
To me, the ending means that all the characters left alive were capable of changing, and even if you don't think that's very believable, I don't have a problem with it except that it came out of nowhere in many case due to a lack of screentime. Quote:
That's what the ending was about, after all. And really, Kallen being ready to kill her friends if they found out about her connection to the Black Knights isn't exactly "normal", either. It's a result of what happened to her and what she believed in. Of course she's still a much "better" person than Gino, but we don't know enough about what went on inside his head to say if there was a time when he had trouble taking lives. Quote:
Quote:
Again, this might not work very well in real life, but I didn't mind it at all in Code Geass, except for the fact that it was all much too rushed.
__________________
|
||||||||||
2009-03-14, 12:26 | Link #3898 | ||||||||
No Eyes
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Dirac Sea
|
Quote:
Quote:
Further the means we may consider morally questionable for Romans, are anything but questionable for Gino and the KoR, they are downright abominable. And the system cannot exist without people perpetuating it, Gino and the KoR are those responsible for the growth and strength of the system. You do not just blame the system, ever, you also blame the people supporting and pushing forward that system. Same as with the Nazi's, people don't just blame Hitler, they blame all the lunatics who supported him and his genocide. Quote:
Quote:
So yes, Clovis is incomparable to the KoR, but you served in making my point. Clovis is driven out of a sense of failure and a vendetta, the KoR and Cornelia are driven by pure fascism and amoral mentality. Quote:
It is just putting far to much faith and optimism in the writers when these characters never showed change. They are extreme fascists. This is what I chock up to a completely assenine epilogue where the staff didn't even know what to do but give you a stupidly happy, unrealistic ending. Quote:
The ending was also completely unrealistic and gave people idiotic blank slates. You can't say the retardation that is the epilogue, with all its nonsense, as a support to something. No sane world would make Ougi a prime-minister, or have three loli's in charge. Kallen is shown explicitly regretting killing people. Gino is shown smiling and waiting for a "wonderful pretext" to purge people. The comparison would poke out a person's eyes. You are being far to arbitrarily forgiving of Gino. You are making arguments that are based on nothing but baseless optimism. If that is how it will be then I want you to tell me why Bismark had to die, or why the other KoR had to die, other than Luciano. Bismark said he hated wars, that sounds like a plus compared to Gino's shown desire to fight people. The blonde KoR-girl was outraged by the Emperor's lack of caring and questioned him on it. All these characters were killed right where Gino mostlikely should have been killed because, even for all their lack of characterization, they are at worst his equals. I understand you arguing for Clovis because you have something to go on, but your arguments for Gino have utterly nothing to go by other than "I think". Quote:
Quote:
There is simply nothing to distinguish Gino from the other KoR (excluding Luciano) and there is everything to distinguish (and I am surprised I am saying this) him from Viletta, who actually shows a change in character and can be some what believed in the ending. Can't we just agree that the only reason he survived is because of his fanservice cash cow? Because that is the only way you are going to explain how he survived things that killed everyone else. Blatant plot armor to keep him around without reason. |
||||||||
2009-03-14, 16:06 | Link #3900 |
Um-Shmum
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: at GNR, bringing you the truth, no matter how bad it hurts
Age: 39
|
he wanted to become KoO so he can rule japan
and that takes achivements and since he got INTO the KoR by selling out his best friend to the emperor who cares about other countries
__________________
|
|
|