Mahouka Koukou no Rettousei LN - Archived Discussion

[bietchie11]

Originally Posted by Flere821

Dude, remove those ASAP before the mods come down with their banhammer >.> I'm pretty sure posting links to those are against forum rules.

Did you click in the second picture?
Yes? Ok i will remove it now.

[hakazee]

Originally Posted by whsie

If you're talking about the summary translation of the Mayumi SS, then it might not even come out in volume 11. In the Web releases, it was originally tagged alongside Web 4 (i.e. volume 8). If it comes out, it'll probably with another group of SS compilation like Volume 5.

If people want to verify the accuracy of the translation, someone can go ahead and get the original text (which I no longer have) and try to translate it better than me. With that said, I'm pretty confident about that SS in question. If the area that you guys are arguing about was of minor importance, I would just translate it so that you guys can get the meaning (e.g. the beginning of Web 4). In those areas, people can go ahead and question the exact translation.

However, when I hit key points of the story, I really, really slow down and work it sentence by sentence/word by word. For all intents and purposes, these areas are translations and I'm relatively confident in its accuracy. One of the ways to tell that I believe an area is worth slowing down is that I add in notes and commentary. For example, in Web 4, areas that I slowed down include the Miya and Miyuki discussion of the procedures done to Tatsuya, Mayumi SS Koichi sections, and Maya vs Tatsuya. Later, when volume 8 was first released, I basically released a brief summary translation of Maya's Meteor Line and brief commentary of the magic.

i mean Web Arc 6 Summary.

actually i believe the summary content and Hayama opinion about miyuki identity. I think he would not give an opinion without any convincing proof ( he is Maya's Butler after all ).

[Seitsuki]

Nooo! You perverts! Get away from my pure Miyuki chwaaannn!

[bietchie11]

Originally Posted by Seitsuki

Nooo! You perverts! Get away from my pure Miyuki chwaaannn!

KeKeKeKeKe

[rickiminato]

How imagine the final of mahouka?
i like a happy end with tatsuya recovering his feelings and free from yotsuba family

[hakazee]

Originally Posted by rickiminato

How imagine the final of mahouka?
i like a happy end with tatsuya recovering his feelings and free from yotsuba family

i hope tatsuya die alone

[bietchie11]

Originally Posted by hakazee

i hope tatsuya die alone

Why do you want that?

[hakazee]

Originally Posted by bietchie11

Why do you want that?

he is way too Hax and disrupt the balance.

if his secret to be exposed.

he will never be able to live in peace and freedom.

every day at any time can be targeted by enemies or other countries.



different story if his secret was never exposed, but I doubt it will happen.

[Quol]

I think this novel will end up with tatsuya's name still unknown to the world but he did major things that changed the world. He is still in the Yotsuba Family, but he grew to accept it. And the series ends with him graduating from the high school and going into the world as a researcher. (Though the people who read the web chapters could tell us how it really ends.)

Spoiler for Volume 5 - Summer Break:

"...You know, Honoka, I'm actually a human missing part of his soul."

"...eh?"

"When I was a child, I was involved in a magic accident of sorts... some of my mental functions were erased."

Honoka's face paled visibly. Her pallor was evident even in the dark night.

Her eyes were open wide, and only a 'no way...' leaked out as she covered her mouth with her hands.

"At that time, I guess, I lost all of what you could call feelings of love. They weren't sealed, so they can't be released. They weren't broken, so they can't be fixed. That which is lost, cannot be recovered."

Tatsuya spoke casually as if it were someone else's affair.

"I can't feel love. I can like someone, but I could never fall in love with them. In a way, only the knowledge remains. Searching my mind, I can tell a part is missing."

I've been curious for a while now, why do people think his feelings can come back. Just because this series revolves around magic doesnt mean his feelings will magically come back.

[blackwhite67]

Originally Posted by Quol

I think this novel will end up with tatsuya's name still unknown to the world but he did major things that changed the world. He is still in the Yotsuba Family, but he grew to accept it. And the series ends with him graduating from the high school and going into the world as a researcher. (Though the people who read the web chapters could tell us how it really ends.)

Spoiler for Volume 5 - Summer Break:

"...You know, Honoka, I'm actually a human missing part of his soul."

"...eh?"

"When I was a child, I was involved in a magic accident of sorts... some of my mental functions were erased."

Honoka's face paled visibly. Her pallor was evident even in the dark night.

Her eyes were open wide, and only a 'no way...' leaked out as she covered her mouth with her hands.

"At that time, I guess, I lost all of what you could call feelings of love. They weren't sealed, so they can't be released. They weren't broken, so they can't be fixed. That which is lost, cannot be recovered."

Tatsuya spoke casually as if it were someone else's affair.

"I can't feel love. I can like someone, but I could never fall in love with them. In a way, only the knowledge remains. Searching my mind, I can tell a part is missing."

I've been curious for a while now, why do people think his feelings can come back. Just because this series revolves around magic doesnt mean his feelings will magically come back.

Tatsuya is making that statement from his point of view. We, as the omniscient audience, believe otherwise. There was also the scene in the web arc 5 summary where Tatsuya stopped Miyuki and Lina's battle due to feelings of guilt which theoretically shouldn't be possible. I guess that we went a little overboard interpreting that as a sign that his emotions are returning.

[Quol]

Originally Posted by blackwhite67

Tatsuya is making that statement from his point of view. We, as the omniscient audience, believe otherwise. There was also the scene in the web arc 5 summary where Tatsuya stopped Miyuki and Lina's battle due to feelings of guilt which theoretically shouldn't be possible. I guess that we went a little overboard interpreting that as a sign that his emotions are returning.

But according to him, he can feel emotions that are of a lesser degree in intsensity. For example he can feel guilt but he cannot feel remorse. (Or am i missing something )

Also can someone please tell me what happened in this battle between Lina and Miyuki, i am only caught up to what is posted in Bakatsuki.

[blackwhite67]

Originally Posted by Quol

But according to him, he can feel emotions that are of a lesser degree in intsensity. For example he can feel guilt but he cannot feel remorse. (Or am i missing something )

Also can someone please tell me what happened in this battle between Lina and Miyuki, i am only caught up to what is posted in Bakatsuki.

Basically, Miyuki got pissed at Lina for trying to ambush Tatsuya with her USNA hit team. She challenged Lina under the condition that the loser would tell the winner everything they know. Obviously, killing is prohibited. Tatsuya realized midway that Lina was going to lose since she was already tired and Miyuki held the advantage in terms of magical compatibility. Anyhow, he cancelled out both their magic midbattle and ended it even though it wasn't getting serious. He later told Miyuki that he felt guilty about Leo getting hurt, which wouldn't have happened if he had taken the opportunity to get answers from Lina when she attacked him during patrols. This level of guilt should not have been possible. It affected his judgement and made him take illogical actions.

[iheartz]

Originally Posted by Quol

I've been curious for a while now, why do people think his feelings can come back. Just because this series revolves around magic doesnt mean his feelings will magically come back.

His feelings of love may be lost, but it may be possible for new buds of love to grow. Also, I don't think Tatsuya is an expert at mind-manipulation magic so who knows?

Note: I'm neutral on this topic, I'm just throwing some ideas out.

[Seitsuki]

What are you people talking about? He's perfectly capable of love. To exactly the right person.

[alviam099]

Originally Posted by Voceane

It's easy to understand why Koichi is upset, look at this
And if Kichijouji know, it means that the scion of the Ichi family know too so the ten.


101 is by the side of the Yotsuba.
Yotsuba stay in the shadows.
Tatsuya use an hability who is only known by someone who isn't really seen as an ally.


Conclusion
The Yotsuba are link with William Sirius. Thus, spys have infiltrate the Yotsuba and maybe take control of them.

Here buddy, it was only George's misunderstanding regarding Molecular Divider, if you read the story after your quote, you'd know that Tatsuya used Decomposition.

[setsuna86]

Originally Posted by Seitsuki

What are you people talking about? He's perfectly capable of love. To exactly the right person.

I don't think he's capable to "love" someone (except Miyuki as little sister), but I think he is capable to "like"

[Ultragunner]

that's who he is refering to

[bietchie11]

Originally Posted by Seitsuki

What are you people talking about? He's perfectly capable of love. To exactly the right person.

Exactly Mr.zerg-rushed.
It's perfectly normal for a faithfull husband to not have any feeling for any women beside his wife. Even more for someone from a different generation, younger generation.
Same goes for Tatsuya.

[Hiyono]

Any content (e.g. images, text, video, etc.) that is of a pornographic, extremely violent, repulsive or disturbing nature, or otherwise unsuitable for minors, is expressly forbidden.

What's with the sudden fascination with posting pornographic content?

[fujin of shadows]

Originally Posted by Nandesuto

What's with the sudden fascination with posting pornographic content?

Just curious, going to erase it now