AnimeSuki Forums

ID555 · 2010-07-18, 04:53

Quote:

Originally Posted by ShiroiRyu

They can be perverts ... Like B Gata H Kei ...
But to a "normal" level ... XD
But i don't dislike this show, no, no ... It's just i compare it to B Gata H kei.

Me too. I'm still hoping for some sort of story or 'progression' from this show >_<

margafred · 2010-07-18, 05:21

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kaoru Chujo

I enjoyed ep3 just as much as the other two, myself. Really nice pace and mood and humor. Maybe not exactly the same humor as the other two, but actually solidified my liking for the show. High-class direction -- mood, timing, and pace -- for me.

^ Exactly

Amakusa Shino is another girl on my "girls that i love" for this season. She totally spices up this show with her pervertic jokes, and she makes a best duo with Aria when it comes to that. Though it feels weird to have a "perfect traits" kaichou but with twisted and perverted thinking, coz it juz doesn't make any sense at all. But i don't mind all of that.

This show feels completely opposite from the previous Seitokai show (Seitokai no Ichizon)...instead of having a completely pervertic enthusiast male lead, here we have the same too, except its a female, and a kaichou. Its a good thing to have a kaichou that tries to understand males from a different point of view, and on top of it, have no delicacy at all when it comes to it. At least the jokes are way better than the jokes of pervertic male lead that thinks of nothing but building harem within the student council.

As for episode 3....have to say, Shino really made my day with her warped view of the historical places in Kyoto. Just love every moment of Shino and Aria. Though i prefer the moment between Tsuda and Shino more, but episode 3 wasn't that bad. Great story direction and the flows between Shino-Aria and Tsuda-Suzu.

Next week will have all 4 of them again together inside the SC room. Looking forward to more pervert jokes from Shino.

8/10

passin'gass · 2010-07-18, 07:26

Was that flag-raising scene with the Vice and Accountant, just before they fell down, part of the manga?

I'm not shipping those two...

Seiryuu · 2010-07-18, 07:30

This show really surprised me. The jokes are sometimes very crude, but still I can't help but laugh. And surprisingly, while I often go for the "main" characters, and the show seems to support that angle, in this case it currently feels like the best pairing is Tsuda and Suzu, and I'd really like to see that pairing work. Can't really see much happening between Tsuda and Shino so far. Every time they're together all that happens is that she says stupid things that show how shameless she is and he tries to deal with it. With Suzu, though, there's some really touching moments as they're together. I imagine there will be some moments with the other two once they're back, but right now it's looking like love could bloom between the two freshmen, and that's fine by me.
Anyway, Shino's already in a relationship, with a Nara doe. That was a doe, wasn't it? Don't all the bucks have antlers??

passin'gass · 2010-07-18, 08:05

And another thing, is the Prez and Sec in second or third year? Same with the Accountant, freshman or junior? Strange disconnect from source...

Mizuno · 2010-07-18, 08:10

The cursing was definitely the best part. lol.

quigonkenny · 2010-07-18, 09:46

Quote:

Originally Posted by passin'gass

And another thing, is the Prez and Sec in second or third year? Same with the Accountant, freshman or junior? Strange disconnect from source...

Shino and Aria -- second year
Tsuda and Suzu -- first year

technomo12 · 2010-07-18, 10:45

i realy lauigh a lot after watching the

CHASTITY BELT part hahaha

that was the KEY the KEY to a great HIDDEN treasure hahahaha

also the freaking photographer is AWESOME!

Vexx · 2010-07-18, 11:54

Quote:

Originally Posted by ID555

Me too. I'm still hoping for some sort of story or 'progression' from this show >_<

Its a 4-koma comic adaptation .... "progression" usually takes a back seat to "daily life" humor. Not that it doesn't happen (e.g. Azumanga Daioh, Working!!, etc) - its just fairly slow in comparison.

ID555 · 2010-07-18, 12:35

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vexx

Its a 4-koma comic adaptation .... "progression" usually takes a back seat to "daily life" humor. Not that it doesn't happen (e.g. Azumanga Daioh, Working!!, etc) - its just fairly slow in comparison.

I know! I'd be very happy with the kind in Working, there's so little here it's imperceptible.

Kaoru Chujo · 2010-07-18, 13:04

Quote:

Originally Posted by ID555

I know! I'd be very happy with the kind in Working, there's so little here it's imperceptible.

I think the progression between Suzu and Tsuda over three episodes is greater than that between Takanashi and Mahiru over that space of time. Whether it will continue, or is romantic at all, are open questions. I expect Tsuda's relationships with Suzu and Shino to both evolve in some way. Or at least I hope so, and think it's possible.

margafred · 2010-07-18, 13:18

Judging from the current amount of volumes (3 volumes only so far) for SYD, its highly unlikely that we will see any development (romance relationship to be precise) between the characters. Not like you can expect anything from a near-realistic guy to have a relationship with 2 perverts and a loli-like SC members.

But i might be wrong at this anyway... since i haven't read any of the manga yet.

ID555 · 2010-07-18, 13:33

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kaoru Chujo

I think the progression between Suzu and Tsuda over three episodes is greater than that between Takanashi and Mahiru over that space of time. Whether it will continue, or is romantic at all, are open questions. I expect Tsuda's relationships with Suzu and Shino to both evolve in some way. Or at least I hope so, and think it's possible.

Yep, so far it's just Suzu and Tsuda getting EVER so slightly closer to each other.

Shiroth · 2010-07-18, 16:11

I was a little worried with how the humor would be handled when taking Tsuda, so i'm glad to say this episode did a great job of that. Heck, they even made a joke about him not being there.

Liked that little scene where Tsuda helped Suzu with the chair. I hope we see more of that sort in this series.

ZeKeR · 2010-07-18, 23:08

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shiroth

I was a little worried with how the humor would be handled when taking Tsuda, so i'm glad to say this episode did a great job of that. Heck, they even made a joke about him not being there.

Liked that little scene where Tsuda helped Suzu with the chair. I hope we see more of that sort in this series.

still.... those girls are epic......

margafred · 2010-07-19, 02:48

Just read the whole volumes of the manga, and this is what i feel about it.

Spoiler for mild spoilers ahead...:

ID555 · 2010-07-19, 03:45

@margafred

That sound promising, thanks.

Silverwyrm · 2010-07-19, 04:05

Once again, I liked this ep more than the previous, due to both better timing of jokes and because it wasn't 100% pervy humor (which while funny, gets predictable/old when its the only kind of joke). Didn't see that stupid teacher either >.>

I loved how all the deer *sweatdrop* after her comment about the licking XD

Also, when started falling and it cut to the deer suddenly jumping in same manner I was like "wtf O.o"

~~mangatron~~ · 2010-07-19, 04:15

Quote:

Originally Posted by Polarpew

English Man: "Thank you"
Hagimura: "Yeah"
English Man: "Little Girl"
Hagimura: "F* You!"
Hagimura: "Mother F*er!"
ROFL

Haha easily my favorite scene, even though I saw it coming (as well as the deer assault), it still gave me a big laugh. Probably helped by the english guy not even being fazed

Got a laugh out of Hata the newspaper girl's antics too, kinda feel bad for her and her deleted pics

but yeah, they sure went a little easy on the perverted jokes this time around, though I'm not placing a bet on it staying this way.

ID555 · 2010-07-19, 04:21

Quote:

Originally Posted by mangatron

Got a laugh out of Hata the newspaper girl's antics too, kinda feel bad for her and her deleted pics

but yeah, they sure went a little easy on the perverted jokes this time around, though I'm not placing a bet on it staying this way.

Looks like the VA is being typecast as a pervert character

2010-07-18, 16:11	Link #254
Shiroth Beautiful fighter. Join Date: Dec 2005 Location: England, UK Age: 37	I was a little worried with how the humor would be handled when taking Tsuda, so i'm glad to say this episode did a great job of that. Heck, they even made a joke about him not being there. Liked that little scene where Tsuda helped Suzu with the chair. I hope we see more of that sort in this series. __________________ MyAnimeList Twitter

2010-07-19, 02:48	Link #256
margafred ლ(́◉◞౪◟ ◉ ლ ) Join Date: Jul 2007	Just read the whole volumes of the manga, and this is what i feel about it. Spoiler for mild spoilers ahead...: Surprisingly GoHands follows the manga flow accurately, but if i have to say, they adapt the materials at a pretty slow pace. I thought with the recent episode, it should cover at least half of volume 1 of the manga, but i was wrong. Episode 1 only covered chapter 1-3 of vol 1, while episode 2 from chapter 4-6 of vol 1. The recent episode 3 was entirely a filler episode (on the Kyoto trip part), while the scenes between Suzu and Tsuda were taken from other half of chapter 6. At the rate this goes, i can predict that the first 5 episodes will cover the whole chapters from vol 1 (vol 1 only contains 15 chapters only, and each chapter has about 14 strips). The next 5 episodes will probably cover the whole vol 2 (vol 2 contains 30 chapters, with each chapter contains 7 strips...so if say each episode takes 42 strips as materials, then i can safely assume that for vol 2, each episode will need 6 chapters), while the final 3 (plus the bonus episode on the DVD, if any) will cover the the final volume. As for the story, well its not likely going to be a complete gag and pure humor only between the SC members. I spotted few development / story / progression in each vol, with Tsuda on the center of it. Might look like a romance development but i think its juz becoz the girls are being naive, or Tsuda being dull, which leads to such development. Not worth for any kind of shipping anyway if you ask me. But this isn't like Working imo....where it shows a clear relationship between Inami and Takanashi. I hardly spot any clear evidence of Tsuda having a relationship with either one of the SC members or with other girls in the school. The above is just my impression about the manga anyway...but who knows GoHands might change that into something more interesting and worth shipping?

2010-07-18, 07:26	Link #243
passin'gass Cropduster Join Date: Dec 2005 Location: Nomadic Existence	Was that flag-raising scene with the Vice and Accountant, just before they fell down, part of the manga? I'm not shipping those two...

2010-07-18, 07:30	Link #244
Seiryuu Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2003	This show really surprised me. The jokes are sometimes very crude, but still I can't help but laugh. And surprisingly, while I often go for the "main" characters, and the show seems to support that angle, in this case it currently feels like the best pairing is Tsuda and Suzu, and I'd really like to see that pairing work. Can't really see much happening between Tsuda and Shino so far. Every time they're together all that happens is that she says stupid things that show how shameless she is and he tries to deal with it. With Suzu, though, there's some really touching moments as they're together. I imagine there will be some moments with the other two once they're back, but right now it's looking like love could bloom between the two freshmen, and that's fine by me. Anyway, Shino's already in a relationship, with a Nara doe. That was a doe, wasn't it? Don't all the bucks have antlers??

2010-07-18, 08:05	Link #245
passin'gass Cropduster Join Date: Dec 2005 Location: Nomadic Existence	And another thing, is the Prez and Sec in second or third year? Same with the Accountant, freshman or junior? Strange disconnect from source...

2010-07-18, 08:10	Link #246
Mizuno Undefined Join Date: May 2004 Location: With the gods Age: 40	The cursing was definitely the best part. lol.

2010-07-18, 10:45	Link #248
technomo12 Wise Otaku Seeker Join Date: Feb 2008 Location: Philippines Age: 34	i realy lauigh a lot after watching the CHASTITY BELT part hahaha that was the KEY the KEY to a great HIDDEN treasure hahahaha also the freaking photographer is AWESOME!

2010-07-18, 13:18	Link #252
margafred ლ(́◉◞౪◟ ◉ ლ ) Join Date: Jul 2007	Judging from the current amount of volumes (3 volumes only so far) for SYD, its highly unlikely that we will see any development (romance relationship to be precise) between the characters. Not like you can expect anything from a near-realistic guy to have a relationship with 2 perverts and a loli-like SC members. But i might be wrong at this anyway... since i haven't read any of the manga yet.

2010-07-19, 03:45	Link #257
ID555 Kamaboko smash & grab Join Date: Nov 2009	@margafred That sound promising, thanks.

2010-07-19, 04:05	Link #258
Silverwyrm Senior Member Join Date: Jan 2008 Location: Folsom, CA, USA Age: 37	Once again, I liked this ep more than the previous, due to both better timing of jokes and because it wasn't 100% pervy humor (which while funny, gets predictable/old when its the only kind of joke). Didn't see that stupid teacher either >.> I loved how all the deer sweatdrop after her comment about the licking XD Also, when started falling and it cut to the deer suddenly jumping in same manner I was like "wtf O.o"