Rate That Signature!

[i0td]

Originally Posted by Cyz

her name is millia rage from guilty gear series (game)

Thanks Cyz. She is very pretty and your sig just makes her even more so 9.97/10

lavielove, Nice signature. The only thing that bothers me a bit is how the text up front stands out too much relative to the overall style. Good choice of coloring. 9.8/10

[Black Death]

10td

Sig-8/10
i love Chiyo-chan from Azumanga Daioh.

Can someone rate my sig?

[i0td]

Black Death, Nice grunge effects on your sig. The contrasting colors works really well overall. And doesn't that kanji character mean the opposite of death :P Your quote is funny.

[Riker]

@lavielove:

Originally Posted by lavielove

...the background is a photo >_>

No, it's not!
It's from the next episode preview.

Spoiler:

As for your sig, I like the simplicity, but somehow I don't feel the black border suits it tho. 8/10

@i0td: Haha, cute! 8/10

@Black Death: As i0td has mentioned, the kanji doesn't really fit, but the rest of the sig is pretty good. 7.5/10

[KiNA]

@ i0td .. Chiyo ... LOL ... sorry I just cant forget her cuteness =3 .. Nice work on the sig overall... If I have to comment tho, it would be that your name spill out of the speech bubble... You have a speech bubble, you have a text on top of it, but why make it goes out of boundary :/ . Secondly, the squares pattern is very visible, try lowering the pattern to a lower opac to make it effect more... subtle. 88%

@ Black Death.. Very nice, the BG are smooth and match her.. The kanji look a bit out of place, and the placement could be a bit centered... Nice choice of font. 88%

@ Riker.. You've already read my comment last nite. Yey! Much much better ^^ .. Gladly giving out 95%

[D3athScythe]

Riker: Very busy sig =P the animation is awesome tho, must've been hard to do, i have no idea how to do those (some idea, but its to hard =P) 8/10

Kira_Naruto: Rider =P nice lil abstract, I like the purple added to it =P the ring around her head is somehow appealing =P The text is also cool! 9/10

[SweetHoney]

Ichy: O-O Anju again yay! 10/10

Riker: Nice as always 10/10

KiNa: Rider is nice in any sig 9.5/10

As for mine I was almost killing myself to get the size down

[Riker]

@D3athScythe: Ilya! Good stock and I like the cloud background, tho it feels a bit empty. 8.5/10

@SweetHoney:

Originally Posted by SweetHoney

As for mine I was almost killing myself to get the size down

Welcome to the headache of animated sig makers. ^___^
It's Anju, and it's animated, so it gets bonus points. Bias rating 9/10

Btw, I noticed that your background isn't consistent.
You can probably reduce the file size considerably if you make it static.

Refer to my tutorial for details. http://forums.animesuki.com/showthre...570#post521570
(No, it's not a shameless self promotion. :x)


Please rate the sigs in the spoiler instead of the one I'm using.

Spoiler:

Version 1: Normal Archer


Version 2: Ghostly Archer


It helps if you tell me which version you prefer and why.

[Cyz]

yes yes, i'll rate it.

riker: the first sig looks much better than the second one. the transparent look on the second one kinda makes distracts the attention away from archer. if you ask me, i'll prefer version 1. version 1 gets a 9/10 and version 2 gets 8/10

deathscythe: ooh! a cool ilya sig! very nice. love that bg and love ilya's posing there. 9/10

[Wavie]

dammit why did you all have to post such awesome sigs - this is the best page of sigs i have ever seen on animesuki - come on check em out they are all perfect... just had to reply after seeing these

I am really happy with the work done on every sig in this page. if you lot get any better than this i wont know what to do

cyz yours is awesome love your colors and image. - favourite img of a character on this page for me - what anime is she from? design of character so cool and colors again as i said before are sweet.

lol riker yours makes me dizzy but i love it.

sweethoney i like the atmosphere in your sig... sorta shows lonleyness

D3athScythe - amazing image background text, lines, it all fits together well.

KINA might be one of your best sigs - love it

iotd its nice sig but im not fan of orange - could carry a lot of weight with a different background - that anime set in school right ? maybe set the character in a room with school background ? apart from that its sweet

blackdeath - your sig gave me the wow factor... i really like that one - saved it to my pictures along with others on this page for inspiration.


id rate every sig on this page from 8-10 - most being 10 and i normally have critical things to say... good job people.

[Yotsuba]

@Wavie - The image quality is a bit low, but I guess that can't be helped. The girl is cute, though! 8/10

[SweetHoney]

Yotsuba: Lol that's funny 9/10

Wavie: Nice image 8/10 and yeah my sig is like lonleyness since Anju got seperated from Karin

[wingdarkness]

@SweetHoney - Awwwww....That so ~ Kawaii~, little girl and her swing-set...

n_n cute, kinda happy-face outta 10...

[Mr.Hawq]

Black death- I like the sig, nice backround, and sig, overall has a good feel to it. 8.7/10

yotsuba- This sig is much better than your other one, very well done 8.8/10

Riker- I like the first one better, the ghost one just does not go, first one gets a 8.6/10 and the second one gets 7.7/10

IOTD- good sig, nice. and gives you a happy feeling 8.3/10

Sweethoney- It's nice that it animated, but quality kind of crappy, but I know the reason why, otherwise it just looks like a avatar, that is a sig, 8.2/10

pellesier- same as sweethoney, but quality is smoothe, and better, 8.4/10

[lavielove]

@i0td did Chiyo say your name ??(^_^)?? lol that's cute.like the black border on her hair + font design.a good sig 8.1/10

@Black Death KOS-MOS from Xenosaga ? the top-notch character design that I was rooted.It would be better if you use mecha style font for your name.8/10

@SweetHoney,a girl on the swing-set always move me as well as a girl sitting on a bench and swing their legs.A good thought to capture that moment and made it as an signature 7.9/10 coz still some works are needed to be done in the sig.

@Mr.Hawq thumbs up.I have the same brush like you have,but I still cannot use it effectively.Just take 9/10 from me if you made that logo design,it's rock.
I have no life,so I will nag even though I like,there is something overlapped on the sword.^_^

edited:
thanks for your rating from *you* Kira =P

what toko and rinko shouted together was the line from Akumaizar 3.
ゆくみちひとつ オ ` ただひとつこれがわれらの いきるみち. that's pretty prodigy and I liked it so I put inside my sig =D

[KiNA]

@ Hawq.. very nice.. which anime is that? what brush is that? where can I get it? hmm.. I dunno know, maybe I'm sleepy already, but your name make it a bit heavy on the left side ..89%

@ LL .. I'm sleepy, and to see a head got cut out.. and dont understand the whole sig feel.. I present you your worst rating from me =x 70%

[Mr.Hawq]

Originally Posted by Kira_Naruto

@ Hawq.. very nice.. which anime is that? what brush is that? where can I get it? hmm.. I dunno know, maybe I'm sleepy already, but your name make it a bit heavy on the left side ..89%

@ LL .. I'm sleepy, and to see a head got cut out.. and dont understand the whole sig feel.. I present you your worst rating from me =x 70%

ahham, the anime is Peacemaker kurogane, one of my favourite anime's of all time, with blue gender, and gungrave.

The brush, is just the default maple leaf brush from adobe photoshop cs, which I used at school, so yah, I can't get any downloadble brushes from school.

The logo, was just a screencap from the show, I wish I could make something like that.

If you want to see a sneek peak of the peacemaker, refer to my link under my signature, that was the fourth ever music video I made, which was during the summer break. Check it out, also check out my other videos if you got the time.

Lavie love- I like your sig alot, don't know why, I am always so fond of that white lighting you use for some of your sig, which makes you sig stand out very nicely. 9.1/10

[Cyz]

@wavie: she's millia rage from guilty gear.

mr. hawq: a little dark but i like it coz it gives a samurai appeal. you know, like those scenes under the moon 8/10

lavielove: nicely made. cool designs and i love the colors. there were some bright spots but it's not that bright. 9/10

[Yotsuba]

@Cyz - I like the image. The colours feel restful, and the animation and simple brush techniques are nice. I don't really like the text, but it does. 8/10

[D3athScythe]

Cyz: Love it, colors and the render =P 9/10
Riker: For the archer one, the first one is better... =P just cause it is