AnimeSuki Forums

DaBackpack · 2010-07-09, 11:16

Quote:

Originally Posted by Almazluverdis3

I know.I'm just saying it's sorta the same idea. The truth is, I needed to make some theory that actually makes sense to my simple fried brain. Anyway, moving on, who thinks Shannon is more evil then we think she is?

I think most of us do

Almazluverdis3 · 2010-07-09, 11:19

Quote:

Originally Posted by DaBackpack

I think most of us do

Spoiler for Almaz text dump:

My Almaz text is awesome.

Smeckledorf · 2010-07-09, 11:20

Quote:

Originally Posted by DaBackpack

I think most of us do

If Dine is in the next episode, we won't.

DaBackpack · 2010-07-09, 11:43

Quote:

Originally Posted by Smeckledorf

If Dine is in the next episode, we won't.

Well, Shannon is a rather popular suspect, but if Van Dine is in the next Episode then she at least cannot be the culprit because the servants cannot be the murderers.

Does it say anything about accomplices, though?

Smeckledorf · 2010-07-09, 11:46

Quote:

Originally Posted by DaBackpack

Well, Shannon is a rather popular suspect, but if Van Dine is in the next Episode then she at least cannot be the culprit because the servants cannot be the murderers.

Does it say anything about accomplices, though?

He refers to accomplices as 'co-culprits' so I am not certain.

DaBackpack · 2010-07-09, 11:54

Quote:

Originally Posted by Smeckledorf

He refers to accomplices as 'co-culprits' so I am not certain.

Well, I'm pretty sure Nanjo HAS to be in on some of the crimes. Not by actually killing anyone, but lying about the diagnosis. Or else Nanjo is dangerously incompetent and should not be a doctor.

Even though he is only a general practitioner, he did have to go through medical school and I'm sure he learned how to take a heartbeat there.

If Nanjo is completely innocent, then Kanon can't be EP1's culprit and Jessica certainly cannot be EP2's culprit.

Almazluverdis3 · 2010-07-09, 11:57

Quote:

Originally Posted by dabackpack

well, i'm pretty sure nanjo has to be in on some of the crimes. Not by actually killing anyone, but lying about the diagnosis. Or else nanjo is dangerously incompetent and should not be a doctor.

even though he is only a general practitioner, he did have to go through medical school and i'm sure he learned how to take a heartbeat there.

If nanjo is completely innocent, then kanon can't be ep1's culprit and jessica certainly cannot be ep2's culprit.

doctors are evil

Smeckledorf · 2010-07-09, 12:02

Quote:

Originally Posted by DaBackpack

Well, I'm pretty sure Nanjo HAS to be in on some of the crimes. Not by actually killing anyone, but lying about the diagnosis. Or else Nanjo is dangerously incompetent and should not be a doctor.

Even though he is only a general practitioner, he did have to go through medical school and I'm sure he learned how to take a heartbeat there.

If Nanjo is completely innocent, then Kanon can't be EP1's culprit and Jessica certainly cannot be EP2's culprit.

Nanjo is not a servant, though. Nanjo is more of a guest.

Jan-Poo · 2010-07-09, 12:04

What Dine has to say about culprits cleverly disguising as servants while they actually aren't?

Almazluverdis3 · 2010-07-09, 12:04

Quote:

Originally Posted by Smeckledorf

Nanjo is not a servant, though. Nanjo is more of a guest.

I think inverted. HE KILLED KANON IN EP1

AND JESSICA IN EP2

Smeckledorf · 2010-07-09, 12:08

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jan-Poo

What Dine has to say about culprits cleverly disguising as servants while they actually aren't?

I don't think Dine has anything to say about disguises, at all.

Almazluverdis3 · 2010-07-09, 12:18

Quote:

Originally Posted by Smeckledorf

I don't think Dine has anything to say about disguises, at all.

Knox rules, I think, don't allow them.

DaBackpack · 2010-07-09, 12:22

Quote:

Originally Posted by Almazluverdis3

Knox rules, I think, don't allow them.

As with the Knox Rules, disguises cannot be used without sufficient foreshadowing or hints given beforehand.

Jan-Poo · 2010-07-09, 12:22

Unless they are hinted, and Shannon/kanon are definitely suspicious. Since they have been called "furniture" several times, and since it's been revealed that "furnitures" are fake imaginary characters, that could work as a hint that the "servant Shannon" or the "servant Kanon" are just cover up.

Almazluverdis3 · 2010-07-09, 12:32

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jan-Poo

Unless they are hinted, and Shannon/kanon are definitely suspicious. Since they have been called "furniture" several times, and since it's been revealed that "furnitures" are fake imaginary characters, that could work as a hint that the "servant Shannon" or the "servant Kanon" are just cover up.

Then Kinzo is a pedo?

m0h · 2010-07-09, 12:36

Quote:

Originally Posted by Smeckledorf

Nanjo is not a servant, though. Nanjo is more of a guest.

Infact Gaap in not the standard servant of the witch.. Goldmith made a contract with her, just like Nanjo with Kinzo.

If Nanjo = Gaap is true, the relationship are quite close. And it would be at least an accomplice, even if not a direct servant like Shanon and Kanon.

In this case we do assume that:

- Ronove e Virgilia have been summoned under Beatrice contract.
- Gaap have been summoned under Goldsmith contract.

So, we have 2 types of contract... so 2 MASTERS that controls the demons... Only one in reality , since Kinzo/Goldsmith is dead.

Almazluverdis3 · 2010-07-09, 13:08

Quote:

Originally Posted by m0h

Infact Gaap in not the standard servant of the witch.. Goldmith made a contract with her, just like Nanjo with Kinzo.

If Nanjo = Gaap is true, the relationship are quite close. And it would be at least an accomplice, even if not a direct servant like Shanon and Kanon.

In this case we do assume that:

- Ronove e Virgilia have been summoned under Beatrice contract.
- Gaap have been summoned under Goldsmith contract.

So, we have 2 types of contract... so 2 MASTERS that controls the demons... Only one in reality , since Kinzo/Goldsmith is dead.

And how? I really don't get the 'Nanjo Gaap' thing. To me, Gaap is Maria's Rose.

Auria · 2010-07-09, 13:09

When Nanjo represents a magical character close to Kinzo, .... uhm... NANJOTRICE

Almazluverdis3 · 2010-07-09, 13:10

Quote:

Originally Posted by auria

when nanjo represents a magical character close to kinzo, .... Uhm... Nanjotrice

nanjo-itrice lives

the crowd goes wild

Smeckledorf · 2010-07-09, 13:10

Gaap could be a Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle for all I care. I think she is the least relevant thing in Umineko. The scorpion charm is more relevant than Gaap. The boat that brought Battler to Rokkenjima is more important than Gaap. The cloud in the background when Battler was boarding that one plane is in fact more relevant than Gaap.

2010-07-09, 12:04	Link #13529
Jan-Poo 別にいいけど Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: forever lost inside a logic error	What Dine has to say about culprits cleverly disguising as servants while they actually aren't? __________________

2010-07-09, 12:22	Link #13534
Jan-Poo 別にいいけど Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: forever lost inside a logic error	Unless they are hinted, and Shannon/kanon are definitely suspicious. Since they have been called "furniture" several times, and since it's been revealed that "furnitures" are fake imaginary characters, that could work as a hint that the "servant Shannon" or the "servant Kanon" are just cover up. __________________

2010-07-09, 13:10	Link #13540
Smeckledorf Intellectual Rapist Join Date: Nov 2009 Location: 3 12151805142615	Gaap could be a Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle for all I care. I think she is the least relevant thing in Umineko. The scorpion charm is more relevant than Gaap. The boat that brought Battler to Rokkenjima is more important than Gaap. The cloud in the background when Battler was boarding that one plane is in fact more relevant than Gaap. __________________ My interpretation of 07151129

2010-07-09, 13:09	Link #13538
Auria ... Join Date: Jan 2009	When Nanjo represents a magical character close to Kinzo, .... uhm... NANJOTRICE