Watashi-tachi no Tamura-kun (manga discussion)

[HayashiTakara]

I've read up to ch.6 and wow... I didn't know what to expect and kept reading, and damn... this really really hit home in the heart. I want more damnit!!!

[LeaD36]

chapter 7 is out, and the plot is just starting to get interesting ^-^

[HayashiTakara]

Lordy, gimme chapter 8, I demand you!...

I really wanna see this series animated. If they do it right, it can be a real tear jerker... and why is comedy listed in it? Theres no comedy >_>..

[LeaD36]

hopefully there will be xd, there are quite a few mangas i´d like to see animated, eventhough i could be hella disappointed by the outcome, and the worst is Shina(or Shiner?) Dark is animated aswell, but no1 is making translations for it :S

[serenade_beta]

Originally Posted by HayashiTakara

and why is comedy listed in it? Theres no comedy >_>..

Because there is?

[HayashiTakara]

Perhaps whatever comedy is in there is completely overshadowed by the drama, at least to me.

[KickHopper]

Wah! After reading chapter 8, I find Hiroka so cute. Tsunderes ftw!

[TrueKnight]

After chapter 8, I have to say that Hiroka is what Tsundere is all about..... Though I have to say that maybe Hiroka's aim is Yukisada's older bro......

[Yaoi_Daisuki]

oh mine this is interesting, i bet there is some trick going on with hiroka

[mako1138]

It ends with volume 4? Then I must read this more slowly.

[Izayoi]

So I see too much drama, somehow this appeals to me with nothing but moe. BUT OmG SO MOE IA M OGONNA DIE<

Tomoya: "Those who take girls to a arcade on their date is some serious loser."

[Irenicus]

Now that I've gone and spoilered myself on the ending, I lost motivation.

Spoiler for ending spoiler:

Spoiler for second line of defense:

What was that!? This is ridiculous. Anyone with any bit of sense and sensibility would recognize that tsundere > moeblob ALL THE WAY.

I'm currently dreading the same issue in To Aru whatsitsname no Index. Boys can't resist sad girls and girls in trouble, eh. Well, I shouldn't say it myself but, aaaah. *frustrated*

[serenade_beta]

Originally Posted by Irenicus

Spoiler for ending spoiler:

Spoiler for second line of defense:

What was that!? This is ridiculous. Anyone with any bit of sense and sensibility would recognize that tsundere > moeblob ALL THE WAY.

I'm currently dreading the same issue in To Aru whatsitsname no Index. Boys can't resist sad girls and girls in trouble, eh. Well, I shouldn't say it myself but, aaaah. *frustrated*

Wait, what?

Spoiler:

Are you trying to say Yukisada should have chosen Hiroka over Komaki just because Hiroka is a tsundere?

It really isn't ridiculous at all. Throughout the series, both girls "had" a chance to win, and Yukisada was the one to fall in love with Komaki first, before Hiroka came along and ended up liking him.
In fact, this "boys can't resist sad girls and girls in trouble" fits Hiroka a lot more than Komaki. Yukisada went "love/crush at first sight" with Komaki, but he started interacting/getting closer to Hiroka over her trauma.

Perhaps you are just angry that Hiroka lost and is snapping at the author/Yukisada over this?


By the way, when did Komaki become a moeblob character?...

[Darknemo2000]

serenade, she always was moeblob you are just too big fan of her to recognize it.

Anyways, I personally thought the ending was just as boring as the whole manga. And incredibly predictable too. it was clear who will win from the very beginning and the second girl never really had a chance as the main guys interests never really wavered (even during the second volume). Boring novels/manga with atrocious characters tahts what impresion I had with this, its a good thing I never became really interested in the series to begin with.

Can't say that Toradora is much better but at least the main male character is not unrealistic idiot as in here.

[Izayoi]

So I finally finished volume 4 last night.

Spoiler for Impression:

I am not really going to fall for Tsundere moe, the only times I fall for Tsundere moe is when they are also blonde and loli. Compare to a lot of drama series I seen this one is rated probably pretty low, it is really just a typical plain drama; but Komaki's moe caught on and appealed me just about so much. So in the end I would call it pretty good, HOORAY FOR KOMAKI'S WIN!!!!!

[LeaD36]

Originally Posted by Setsilya~

So I finally finished volume 4 last night.

Spoiler for Impression:

I am not really going to fall for Tsundere moe, the only times I fall for Tsundere moe is when they are also blonde and loli. Compare to a lot of drama series I seen this one is rated probably pretty low, it is really just a typical plain drama; but Komaki's moe caught on and appealed me just about so much. So in the end I would call it pretty good, HOORAY FOR KOMAKI'S WIN!!!!!

go with hayate no gotoku then punk

[Izayoi]

Originally Posted by LeaD36

go with hayate no gotoku then punk

LoL I finished both manga and anime, just hasn't read the light novel yet.

[DanielSong39]

I don't consider this a true love triangle as there is no question as to who the lead male prefers; the issue over whether he'll ever get the opportunity to make the choice. If Yukisada and Komaki are separated for good, then he'll move on with Hiroka. But if not, Yukisada and Komaki will get together.

An alternate approach to teenage romance, which I appreciate.

[tzia_n]

Originally Posted by Darknemo2000

it was clear who will win from the very beginning and the second girl...

please keep the spoiler at a minimum, not everyone thinks that it's clear who will win, especially just on the material that's been translated

[Darknemo2000]

Did I say who will win? Not really, unless you count 'girl' as a spoiler, maybe you think taht some boy will win? If so then indeed my sentence is a spoiler but I didn't really tell which of the girl wins (thats why I didn't put the spoiler on).