AnimeSuki Forums

epyon96 · 2007-09-03, 22:06

This is one of those exploratory topics so any out-there explanation that can be rationalized by manga will be very welcome.

Now this is a big IF.

If Tobi does turn out to be Obito, whether it is via body sharing, or some other "voodoo deus ex" jutsu they introduce in the manga, do you suppose he will have an innate advantage against Kakashi's Sharingan since it was Obito's eyes originally.

tkdtiger · 2007-09-03, 22:42

Well IF it were to be Obito's body that Madara's using or somwthing along those lines the biggest advantage is clearly that unlike Kakashi Madara would be able to use the Sharingan without the strain that Kakashi has to go through when using it. Everything else I'm assuming is through training...

Quzor · 2007-09-04, 01:05

Have to agree here. I think the only difference is that Kakashi doesn't possess the Sharingan ability through bloodline, he inherited it from a friend through surgery. I doubt Kakashi's MS ability would be inherited from Obito if he learned to use MS...that's like saying a transplant patient's organ (say, liver) still receives information from the original body (how to process alcohol). Once the body part is transplanted, it becomes a part of that person's physical characteristics, and loses all relation it had to the original owner (if the original body can't process alcohol, that doesn't mean a transplant patient can't drink safely).

tatami · 2007-09-04, 02:49

just dont open new threads..you can discuss it on 4 different topics right now

sasuke2007 · 2007-09-04, 07:48

Toooooooooooo many Obito, Tobi threads.

Close it the F*** Down!!!

shadowyondaime · 2007-09-04, 08:26

wow ok lol let me add that we dont know that much about the mangekyou sharingan I think that ever1 has his own kind of mangekyou sharingan doesnt have to be like itachis

tkdtiger · 2007-09-04, 09:33

Quote:

Originally Posted by sasuke2007

Toooooooooooo many Obito, Tobi threads.

Close it the F*** Down!!!

although I wouldn't put it in that way I agree that there are many Tobi/Obitio threads and this could have been posted on one of them.

Frenchie · 2007-09-04, 10:26

Well, IF the statement above is true, then I suppose that, yes, the only difference would be in the amount of strain in the eyes.

What would be interesting I suppose, is whether the knowledge of eyes are interconnected or separate. As in, if you take one eye out, have it trained the MS, would there be some sort of link that makes the other eye get it ?

It could be interesting to see Kakashi didn't actually train his man.sharingan, but "discovered" it at some point, through someone else's training.

In the same way, it would be interesting to put an eye patch on one of your sharingans, and develop two different MS's in each eye. Did someone say broken?

I am fully expecting to hear more about how the Sharingan works and its origins when the brothers meet again, and I am keenly hoping for some background development on the "true purpose" of the Uchiha.

2007-09-03, 22:06	Link #1
epyon96 Senior Member Join Date: Feb 2004	Questions about Obito and Sharingan? (MANGA) This is one of those exploratory topics so any out-there explanation that can be rationalized by manga will be very welcome. Now this is a big IF. If Tobi does turn out to be Obito, whether it is via body sharing, or some other "voodoo deus ex" jutsu they introduce in the manga, do you suppose he will have an innate advantage against Kakashi's Sharingan since it was Obito's eyes originally. __________________ "Draw the line that defines being human through reason, not emotion," Envy Epyon Last edited by epyon96; 2007-09-03 at 23:31. Reason: changed the word "inherent" to "innate"

2007-09-04, 01:05	Link #3
Quzor It's the year 3030... Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: Spaceport Colony Sicilia Age: 39	Have to agree here. I think the only difference is that Kakashi doesn't possess the Sharingan ability through bloodline, he inherited it from a friend through surgery. I doubt Kakashi's MS ability would be inherited from Obito if he learned to use MS...that's like saying a transplant patient's organ (say, liver) still receives information from the original body (how to process alcohol). Once the body part is transplanted, it becomes a part of that person's physical characteristics, and loses all relation it had to the original owner (if the original body can't process alcohol, that doesn't mean a transplant patient can't drink safely). __________________

2007-09-04, 07:48	Link #5
sasuke2007 Missing-Nin Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: Area District 80, Rukongai	Toooooooooooo many Obito, Tobi threads. Close it the F* Down!!! __________________ ~Pain~** "Chibaku Tensei" It's Showtime

2007-09-03, 22:42	Link #2
tkdtiger Senior Member Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: In Florida	Well IF it were to be Obito's body that Madara's using or somwthing along those lines the biggest advantage is clearly that unlike Kakashi Madara would be able to use the Sharingan without the strain that Kakashi has to go through when using it. Everything else I'm assuming is through training...

2007-09-04, 02:49	Link #4
tatami back in black Join Date: Jul 2006 Location: Turkey Age: 41	just dont open new threads..you can discuss it on 4 different topics right now

2007-09-04, 08:26	Link #6
shadowyondaime Sponsor: Naughty Konoha! Join Date: Jan 2007 Location: Ladies bathroom Age: 33	wow ok lol let me add that we dont know that much about the mangekyou sharingan I think that ever1 has his own kind of mangekyou sharingan doesnt have to be like itachis

2007-09-04, 10:26	Link #8
Frenchie Shougi Génération Graphic Designer Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: Sydney, Australia Age: 37	Well, IF the statement above is true, then I suppose that, yes, the only difference would be in the amount of strain in the eyes. What would be interesting I suppose, is whether the knowledge of eyes are interconnected or separate. As in, if you take one eye out, have it trained the MS, would there be some sort of link that makes the other eye get it ? It could be interesting to see Kakashi didn't actually train his man.sharingan, but "discovered" it at some point, through someone else's training. In the same way, it would be interesting to put an eye patch on one of your sharingans, and develop two different MS's in each eye. Did someone say broken? I am fully expecting to hear more about how the Sharingan works and its origins when the brothers meet again, and I am keenly hoping for some background development on the "true purpose" of the Uchiha.