2010-06-15, 14:09 | Link #11081 | |
Mystery buff
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Gone Fishin!
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2010-06-15, 16:47 | Link #11082 |
別にいいけど
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: forever lost inside a logic error
|
Still in the case that in the end we'll find out that the murderer is Nanjo I bet someone will say that: "Nanjo was hinted to be the murderer because he was the only one whose location wasn't shown!"
__________________
|
2010-06-15, 17:10 | Link #11083 | |
Back off, I'm a scientist
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: In a badly written story.
|
Quote:
Seriously though, with the way the story is structured, it's very hard to say which is a hint and which is a deliberate lie, and the amount of information to process is monstrous. Current English translation itself is twice the length of War and Peace. If you look hard enough, you can find hints to support almost any kind of theory, including the deliberately silly Orbital Particle Beam Shot. I'm afraid it's not hints we should be looking for.
__________________
|
|
2010-06-15, 18:49 | Link #11084 |
BUY MY BOOK!!!
Join Date: May 2009
|
The anime shows Nanjo asleep in a chair somewhere at midnight in ep1. Of course, people's locations in the midnight montage should not necessarily be taken as gospel, nor does it necessarily matter where everyone is at midnight. The murderer, especially in ep1, has lots of time to commit the crime.Whether a safe haven is needed or not, we're told Kuwadorian was safe and that Eva was found there by the police. I don't see any reason for the people who said that to lie, and it would be a perfectly plausible place to find someone as it would be the only remaining "safe" structure and it has a port, so the police would (on Kawabata's information) probably set there first to conduct their search.
__________________
|
2010-06-15, 19:53 | Link #11085 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2009
|
Regarding the 1998 world, I am rather interested in the status of the chapel. When Ange goes to Rokkenjima she doesn't mention anything about it, nor is it shown, nor does anyone else mention anything about it. While it could be unimportant as Kuwadorian wasn't shown either, or it simply is unimportant. I find myself curious since the chapel is likely going to be a big point in the endgame.
|
2010-06-15, 20:03 | Link #11086 | ||
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2009
|
Quote:
In any case, this just goes to show how Ryuukishi's tendancy to get really long-winded while writing creates an abundance of hints as well as a ridiculously long story. Twice the length of War and Piece? Wow. That kinda makes me proud for reading all through Umineko. Maybe I'll marathon the entire series once I've got all the English patches. On a side note, an at max fifty-episode anime series doesn't quite seem to give Umineko much credit to me, now that I have a idea of long it is. Quote:
I wouldn't put it past Kinzo. |
||
2010-06-15, 20:18 | Link #11087 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2009
|
Quote:
|
|
2010-06-15, 20:38 | Link #11088 | |
Purupurupiko-Man
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: My beloved hometown, the mackerel river running through it
|
Quote:
|
|
2010-06-15, 21:10 | Link #11089 | |||
別にいいけど
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: forever lost inside a logic error
|
Quote:
P.S: you weren't serious about "war and peace", right? I don't think umineko really reached that length... Quote:
From the game we only have confirmation that the port doesn't exist anymore and that the path to reach the mansion is interrupted by a landslide. Apparently Ange needs to climb down to proceed, but if she does then she can't go back. There is a sentence that always bugged me, and was the main reason I always thought that there is really no Mansion anymore: Quote:
And yet she only wants to go there, deliver something, and then go back quickly to see the "main goal" Kuwadorian (where she's never been before). Mansion apart, what about the guesthouse? Not any curiosity about the chapel? They don't even deserve a mention? I really can't see any logic explanation except that the explosion destroyed all of them. Think also about these facts: -When Kinzo's books were auctioned it was explained that they survived the accident because they were in Kuwadorian. Hinting that the general public expected that no book could have survived. -Eva was found in a far away place from the site of the incident. Even if an explosion occurred, why she didn't rush back afterward to look for survivors? At the very least she should have done that to look for George or George's body. -A lot of bodies (if not all of them) are totally missing. A total disintegration of a body is not what you would expect from a normal explosion. And yet bodies are missing and it doesn't appear as if the fact is seen as strange, hinting that the kind of accident that happened can well explain why nothing is left of the victims. If not, why such disappearances are accepted so easily? A single body missing, okay... two... three could still be understandable, but four and more? I'd be a lot suspicious if it were me. -Ryuukishi said in an interview that the incident affected the terrain. He also affirmed that the fact that Kawabata was unable to dock at the port should have hinted this. (despite the fact the port is quite far from the Mansion). -Ryuukishi confirmed that the Mansion's remains are missing.
__________________
|
|||
2010-06-16, 03:24 | Link #11090 | ||
Back off, I'm a scientist
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: In a badly written story.
|
Quote:
War and Peace is about 2 million characters long, give or take, including spaces. An average fantasy or science fiction novel is around 500-600 thousand. Most Harry Potter books exceed a single million each. The combined length of all translated English text in Umineko scripts, which is easy to compute because OnScripter requires it to be marked with backticks, is over 4 million characters. Quote:
Volcano eruption might do all these things, but it's a natural process that is extremely hard to deliberately cause. Various military explosive charges leave bits and pieces, lots of them, with the exception of fuel-air explosives which have more or less no way to end up on the island. Gas explosion works like fuel-air, but there's no way the island would have a stockpile of gas big enough to actually change the landscape - blow buildings to bits, sure, burn everything, sure, but actually moving this much earth, no. That explosion is actually extremely annoying. There's so little specific information on it's character, when it should be public knowledge in Ange's time. Official explanation of the incident absolutely can't be "something blew up, we don't know what it was except that it's an accident". They need to say at least what blew up and make a good guess why. Yet everybody is awkwardly avoiding the topic, including Ange and anyone else who should know, and it doesn't come off as obvious information they don't use because it's common knowledge, it sounds like someone censored Ange's memory and cut off chunks of conversation. I'm not even sure why this information needs to be kept away from the reader at such an expense. Is it because we would immediately guess who Beatrice is if we had the slightest idea on the true nature of the explosion? Gee, probably not. We have lots of theories that might fit (all not terribly satisfactorily) and the list of people who could have set them in motion and be 'Beatrice' is half the island for each of them. Unless they're all wrong, that is. There might be one explosion cause theory from which the identity of Beatrice inevitably follows and it would be the right one. But all the reasonable ones have been exhausted by now, which would normally mean one of them is correct. What's left is Hinamizawa syndrome-level nonsense.
__________________
|
||
2010-06-16, 04:10 | Link #11092 |
Back off, I'm a scientist
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: In a badly written story.
|
It is, but - why? To conceal the nature of endgame event.
Why conceal the nature of endgame event? To prevent us from discovering the nature of Beatrice, which would be naturally deducible if we knew the nature of endgame event. We now have a lot of theories on the nature of endgame event, and from none of them the identity of Beatrice follows cleanly. Therefore, none of them is the one that was actually concealed from us and they are all wrong. But we have tried all the ones that made sense. Therefore: The true endgame event theory is one that heretofore was not treated seriously because it does not make sense. And this is the conclusion I don't like.
__________________
|
2010-06-16, 04:50 | Link #11094 | |
07th Expansion&Touhou Fan
Join Date: Feb 2010
|
Quote:
As for that, IMO, we should start getting on more focused points, like "first we talk about the stuff in EP1", because I think that way, we can get a better idea. I dunno, it's just my opinion, but I think I'm not wrong at all.... Of course, I'm talking about discussing one thing, but using all the information we have, including TIPs, Novel and interviews. What do you guys think? |
|
2010-06-16, 04:57 | Link #11095 | ||
Back off, I'm a scientist
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: In a badly written story.
|
Quote:
Quote:
Since whichever theory fits the above-recited logic chain is not among the likely ones, none of which allow to pinpoint an identity of the perpetrator, it has to be among the unlikely and silly ones.
__________________
|
||
2010-06-16, 07:53 | Link #11096 |
別にいいけど
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: forever lost inside a logic error
|
@Oliver
I think you need to see this with the right perspective. Umineko isn't just a mystery novel, it's a game. Or at least this is how Ryukishi sees it. In a game you need to create various challenges to entertain the players. Some of these challenges aren't strictly necessary to reach the end of the game their just there to give the players additional content to play with. So you don't need to think that anything that is mysterious is relevant for the main plot. It might be, but it might not. I think that it's absolutely clear that since EP1 Ryuukishi wanted everyone to believe that the police found some kind a slaughterhouse scenario which would clearly point to a murderer. Just read the ending scroll of EP1 it was cleverly constructed for that end. Hell, how many fell for that? Almost everyone I'd say. Even the generic term used to refer to "the site of the incident" is so much commonly used to refer to "crime scene" that the witch hunt opted for this translation, even 'though there is actually no reference at all about any crime. And the finishing blow was telling that this event later became known as "the rokkenjima murder mystery" although we know this is how wild speculators and "witch hunters" call it, and not the more serious media. Seeing through this kind of deceptions is what Ryuukishi consider "scoring" in his game. And he also stated that he doesn't want to give a readily available answer to those who didn't find the truth. He wants to extend the "winners" monopoly over certain truths as max as possible. Which is why he couldn't tell you right away that what happened in Rokkenjima was some kind of incident. He left tons of hints in EP4, and when he thought it was apparent enough he just dropped the bomb (quite fitting metaphor...). This kind of pattern can be seen everywhere in umineko. Ryuukishi doesn't reveal things out of the blue. He first slightly hints them, then he heavily hints them, and only after they have been speculated over and over again he confirms them. The lack of information about the incident in EP4 can be just a narrative expedient created for this end. But let's just suppose that it's as you say and there's a deeper reason for all this. How exactly knowing the kind of incident that happened can give us hints about Beatrice's nature? I can't even imagine a scenario where I could get some relevant information. Maybe you can help with that?
__________________
|
2010-06-16, 09:26 | Link #11097 |
Senior Member
|
Regarding Shkannon and their shifts:
There are two different parts to a shift: - what times a servant is supposed to be on duty at the mansion / guesthouse, and what times they are free - when on duty, what they are supposed to be doing at the mansion / guesthouse Most likely, the first is mostly fixed (Kanon is on duty Mondays, 5-7 PM, Renon Tuesdays 5-7 PM, etc.), while the second can be rearranged at any time. When Krauss and Natsuhi are mentioned as fiddling with the schedules, it's the second kind they're changing. IIRC, it's stated that there are usually only 2 or 3 servants on Rokkenjima at any time. With the Fukuins still being kids, they probably have very restricted schedules, while Genji and Gohda are probably full-timers. (Kumasawa is stated to be part-time, but she probably works longer shifts than the Fukuins.) In the absence of visitors, there probably isn't more than 1 Fukuin present at a time.
__________________
|
2010-06-16, 09:59 | Link #11098 | ||
Back off, I'm a scientist
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: In a badly written story.
|
Quote:
When I want to talk about subway bombings, I will say 'subway bombings', not 'incident' or 'accident'. When I want to talk about the time when my neighbour's house blew up because he left the gas open, I will say 'gas leak', not 'accident'. The usage of the unspecific 'accident' in such cases is restricted to fairly narrow cases:
What in particular Episode 4 does a lot is omitting any qualifiers as long as possible even when the result is a statement that makes no sense. Certain anime and manga series loved to play with this, defining some 'kono hito' early on and then using it as it it were the name of some completely undefined character which, supposedly, attracts mystique along the way in this manner. It has been many years since this stopped working and even jokes about this are going out of fashion -- people don't really talk that way. This is not narratively expedient, this looks silly, there have to be limits. It's like trying to write a book without using the letter "e" - possible, but gruesome. Which is why I feel that it may well be that Ryukishi really wanted to tell the story of Ange's pity party, but realised that giving us the police incident report in any serious detail would amount to giving the answer away, because with everything else we already know it's enough. That would really spoil the crowning final puzzle of Ep4! So he just concentrated on Maria's diary and censored over any other characters who would otherwise want to talk about the incident report. Quote:
Is it plausible? Not really. Would telling us that be a huge gamebreaking hint? Oh yes, I'd tell you where Kinzo got his gold then. Let us continue thinking backwards. If my guess is true, then the endgame event mechanism fits the following conditions:
This way any scenarios where anyone can cause an explosion are declared unfitting. Only those remain:
Any ideas, beside scrapping the whole chain of thought, ofcourse?
__________________
|
||
2010-06-16, 10:40 | Link #11099 | ||
別にいいけど
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: forever lost inside a logic error
|
Well I'm not sure if this linguistic expedient is as bad in japanese as it sounds in english. They tend to omit stuff a lot more than we do.
For example you mentioned "kono hito", but that definitely sounds a lot less strange than "that person" in english. Just think about Virgilia and how she never refers to Beatrice by her name. She always calls her "ano ko" (that child), that in western culture is simply silly but it's not really that strange in Japan. Plus most of the times the "unfortunate accident" is mentioned it's by some narrator. When it's people talking about that, my impression is that they don't want to mention what happened because it's painful to remember or because it's already clear what happened. Just think about the 9/11. I've just said two numbers but I guess you perfectly understood what I'm talking about. Nobody says "the terrorist attack at the world trade center", everyone is pretty much used to call it 9/11. And if this was a story you would say "why everyone is omitting to say what this "9/11" is?!" Because everyone already knows too well what it is, there's no need to repeat it every time. Quote:
But still this doesn't tell us much about Beatrice since it isn't clear if Beatrice has anything to do with the accident to begin with. Plus everyone could have come across this military base in a way or another. Quote:
If you believe in the author theory, then this incident only happened one time and it's a core rule of the fictional stories created afterward. If you believe in the many-world interpretation that might still be a core rule. The incident just has to happen at a precise time, and since it's definitely relevant, it's only natural that it cannot change. Anyway the fact it can never change fits more with a natural disaster scenario than with a human triggered one. However I have my doubts that this marks the end of each game. We know that the games end at midnight, but does that definitely means that incident happens at that precise time? It might be plausible, but I see no certain proof of this relation. The way I see it the unfortunate accident could have happened at any time in 6th October from 0:00 AM to 6:00 AM I'm also not certain about the last two, but you correctly used "probably". However the last, in particular, is not necessary because we know everyone can be saved simply by taking refuge in Kuwadorian.
__________________
|
||
2010-06-16, 10:48 | Link #11100 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2009
|
I have to both agree with you, Oliver, on some points, but on others, I agree with Jan-Poo.
First of all, where it is obviously intentional, like a subway bombing, people are not going to call it an accident. However, in a case where clues indicating an intentional explosion are not apparent, such as a gas leak or the Rokkenjima Explosion, people usually go with the assumption that it is an accident. "An absence of proof does not indicate a proof of absence," yes, but in such a situation as the Rokkenjima Explosion, I doubt it would be even difficult, let alone easy, to find clues indicating a premeditated explosion. It would near impossible, especially if the explosion did originate deep underground. But yes, it is very suspicious that in the entirety of Ange's back-story, we did not even get a definite confirmation of an explosion. All we got was a sob-story, an idea of how magic in Umineko works, and confusing hints like how Eva apparently died in a similar way to Kinzo. I have an idea to why Ange's memory feels incomplete, though I'm not sure how it might help. Think about it. Since Meta-Battler is the main narrator, it's reasonable to think that all narration, even the narration of characters which are not him (with the exception of a few Meta-Beatrice narrations) are just him narrating what Beato is narrating to him via the gameboard's story. But if this is true, how do we get Ange's narration, which doesn't take place on any gameboard? I think it's Battler, once again, narrating a narration which is give to him. As Ange was being turned into hamburger meat at the end of Episode 4, Battler says that all her memories, the struggles she went through after no one came back from the conference, flowed into him. So once again, he is receiving a narration, and all Ryuukishi is doing is having that narration shown to us at various moments throughout the Episode. However, like how Beato can modify the narration she gives Battler through the gameboard, isn't it possible for someone to modify Ange's narration that Battler receives. My immediate suspicions place this on Bern, but it seems out of character, at the time, for her. On the bomb, I've got a feeling that it's set up before the gameboard begins. Why? Because it always happens. In my opinion, things that are set up or happen before the gameboard begins are constants (such as Shannon breaking the island's mirror, or Kinzo's death), but things that happen during the game are variables, and are liable to change, as they do in each Episode. Note that the game is in play for forty-eight hours, from midnight on the fourth to midnight on the sixth. If I'm right, that means the culprit is either someone on the island, or has an accomplice who is regularly on the island. Which isn't much of a problem, since most people theorize that some number of the servants/Nanjo are accomplices to the mastermind. But yes, Beatrice must be the once who triggers the explosion. After all, in Episode 4, Beatrice is the one who kills Battler. So she must be the one who can trigger the bomb. However, both Jessica and Shannon, who seem to be the only characters left that can be Beatrice, rarely ever survive until endgame, which means if Beatrice is the one who triggers the explosion, it must be done at an earlier point. My reasoning indicates a timed explosion, set to detonate unless the Epitaph is solved, but this is incredibly clichéd, so I'm reluctant to decide on it. |
|
|