AnimeSuki Forums

kreo · 2004-04-23, 16:25

Since the Byakugan can be use to see chakra flow and see threw really fast speeds and illusions the it can see the nevres and if so i wonder if a highly skilled Byakugan user could predict an opponets move simply by looking at there nerves !!!! Is it possible ?! and do you guys think it might show up in the anime or manga ?

Muad'Dib · 2004-04-23, 16:28

The signals sent along the nerves move really quickly--so I doubt they'd be able to see something so fast. Maybe somebody with sharingan within the Byukugan...

Dark Epyon · 2004-04-23, 16:34

I think only a highly trained person could do it. Neji has fast reflexes so it might work with him but others such as Hinata would have a problem.

sarcasteak · 2004-04-23, 16:39

Quote:

Originally Posted by Muad'Dib

Maybe somebody with sharingan within the Byukugan...

Let's lock Hinata and Sasuke together in a room to find out!

Lexander · 2004-04-23, 16:39

Omg ... that'b be so insanely cool ... Definate + for the Byukugen. I already like it more than the sharingan and that would be yet another reason to :P

kakashilion · 2004-04-23, 16:42

well i spose we could use some bilogy here. Nerves would move to fast for the muscles in the eye to follow. Im pretty sure the byakugan does not allow the user to move their eye quicker than usual.

plus just seeing the nerves wouldnt tell you what their going to do because the nerves themselves contain messages telling muscles to contract and relax etc. SO not only would you have to follow the nerves you would have to see the info they contain.

im not sure about this since i aint great at biology.

EDIT : oh and i forgot that naruto is only an anime so none of what i said matters.

p.s. good question for a first post

Lexander · 2004-04-23, 16:45

The Byakugan can see 360 degrees all around he doesn't not need to follow it. Neji can see 7 birds at the same time. His eyes don't follow the birds around. So if his eyes could somehow become so developed that he would see this movement ... it's completely possible.

By completely possible ... I mean it'b be totally cool hahaha.
Kakashillion I did read you post though and I know it's not possible

Muad'Dib · 2004-04-23, 16:46

I think it would require the attention to detail characteristic of the sharingan and the byukugan seeing-throughness (for lack of a better word.) However, I don't think too much could be gained from seeing the nerves--unless you could figure out what the signals meant as soon as they originate in the brain. If you could do that, it could gain you a fraction of a second. However, you'd also need that fraction to react--but I don't really think the characters in Naruto really follow the rules of physiology concerning reaction times, so whatever.

And if you could figure out what the signals mean, why stop there? Why not just read the signals in the brain and figure out what your opponent is thinking?

Sethi · 2004-04-23, 16:49

Well if that's the case then wouldn't it be easier to just watch the muscles movement and the chakra used to determine what your enemy is going to perform??

Also isn't the nerve speed like superfast it becomes a little hard to see it no?

kreo · 2004-04-23, 16:54

thanks everyone you make a new member feel welcome i;m glad you guys enjoyed my post

kakashilion · 2004-04-23, 17:11

i find it so funny when i see how me especially and other people take little things so seriously and find theoorys from real life why they can and can not be true whilst all the time we have people making copies of themself and using bugs and shadows to attack enemies :d

anyway lexander i was wondering if you have read the naruto manga??

Lexander · 2004-04-23, 17:14

I have read the manga a few times. You're talking about the blindspot?

Well Naruto actually forces us to come up with these crazy theories, I mean it's all explained in a scientific manner in Naruto, the diagrams and everything.

kakashilion · 2004-04-23, 17:20

yeah i did mean the blindspot. (I spent about 5 minutes trying to figure out a way to ask you about the manga without revealing anything.

)

i understand what you mean by him seeing everything all at once anyway.

i think the most scientific diagram induced anime is evangelion if you've ever seen it. And we have seen quite a few chakra diagrams so that does help to make it more believeable.

Lexander · 2004-04-23, 17:46

Talk about the blindspot if you want.

Animewatchers should know about it also. Tenten counted 8 by following them with her eyes, while Neji counted 7 by standing there

, showing that his 360 vision has a blindspot.

rEkKaShInObI · 2004-04-23, 18:11

interesting theory, it MAY be possible, yet it may not.

kakashilion · 2004-04-23, 18:12

yep thats about it.

its funny though because that relates to real human eyesight where we have a blind spot because of the optic nerve. So i spose more things in naruto relate to real scientific stuff than i thought.

Lexander · 2004-04-23, 18:14

Can we get spoiler tags in the title please?

Joe Dalton · 2004-04-23, 18:22

*grins* you didnt have 2 say you didnt follow bio... your post made that clear enough

I liked the part where you said "Nerves would move to fast for the muscles in the eye to follow"
Although... 1 thing I dont get... you know that the info you give isnt actualy based on what you know yet you still try 2 pass it of as an argument on the subject...

Lexander · 2004-04-23, 18:29

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joe Dalton

*grins* you didnt have 2 say you didnt follow bio... your post made that clear enough

I liked the part where you said "Nerves would move to fast for the muscles in the eye to follow"
Although... 1 thing I dont get... you know that the info you give isnt actualy based on what you know yet you still try 2 pass it of as an argument on the subject...

I don't get it ... are you actually saying that if eyes could see the nerves they would be able to follow?

Joe Dalton · 2004-04-23, 18:33

no first thing I found funny was when he said "Nerves would move"
Then "for the muscles in the eye to follow" the second 1 would need some explaining but the first is pretty clear i take it

2004-04-23, 16:25	Link #1
kreo Junior Member Join Date: Apr 2004	Byakugan theory Since the Byakugan can be use to see chakra flow and see threw really fast speeds and illusions the it can see the nevres and if so i wonder if a highly skilled Byakugan user could predict an opponets move simply by looking at there nerves !!!! Is it possible ?! and do you guys think it might show up in the anime or manga ?

2004-04-23, 16:28	Link #2
Muad'Dib The Burninator Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: Arrakis	The signals sent along the nerves move really quickly--so I doubt they'd be able to see something so fast. Maybe somebody with sharingan within the Byukugan...

2004-04-23, 16:34	Link #3
Dark Epyon Useless Human Join Date: Apr 2004 Age: 35	I think only a highly trained person could do it. Neji has fast reflexes so it might work with him but others such as Hinata would have a problem.

2004-04-23, 16:39	Link #5
Lexander www.thefestlanders.com Join Date: Dec 2003	Omg ... that'b be so insanely cool ... Definate + for the Byukugen. I already like it more than the sharingan and that would be yet another reason to :P

2004-04-23, 16:42	Link #6
kakashilion has big feet Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: UK Age: 35	well i spose we could use some bilogy here. Nerves would move to fast for the muscles in the eye to follow. Im pretty sure the byakugan does not allow the user to move their eye quicker than usual. plus just seeing the nerves wouldnt tell you what their going to do because the nerves themselves contain messages telling muscles to contract and relax etc. SO not only would you have to follow the nerves you would have to see the info they contain. im not sure about this since i aint great at biology. EDIT : oh and i forgot that naruto is only an anime so none of what i said matters. p.s. good question for a first post

2004-04-23, 16:45	Link #7
Lexander www.thefestlanders.com Join Date: Dec 2003	The Byakugan can see 360 degrees all around he doesn't not need to follow it. Neji can see 7 birds at the same time. His eyes don't follow the birds around. So if his eyes could somehow become so developed that he would see this movement ... it's completely possible. By completely possible ... I mean it'b be totally cool hahaha. Kakashillion I did read you post though and I know it's not possible

2004-04-23, 16:46	Link #8
Muad'Dib The Burninator Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: Arrakis	I think it would require the attention to detail characteristic of the sharingan and the byukugan seeing-throughness (for lack of a better word.) However, I don't think too much could be gained from seeing the nerves--unless you could figure out what the signals meant as soon as they originate in the brain. If you could do that, it could gain you a fraction of a second. However, you'd also need that fraction to react--but I don't really think the characters in Naruto really follow the rules of physiology concerning reaction times, so whatever. And if you could figure out what the signals mean, why stop there? Why not just read the signals in the brain and figure out what your opponent is thinking?

2004-04-23, 16:49	Link #9
Sethi StormRider Join Date: Jun 2003 Location: Portugal	Well if that's the case then wouldn't it be easier to just watch the muscles movement and the chakra used to determine what your enemy is going to perform?? Also isn't the nerve speed like superfast it becomes a little hard to see it no?

2004-04-23, 16:54	Link #10
kreo Junior Member Join Date: Apr 2004	thanks everyone you make a new member feel welcome i;m glad you guys enjoyed my post

2004-04-23, 17:11	Link #11
kakashilion has big feet Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: UK Age: 35	i find it so funny when i see how me especially and other people take little things so seriously and find theoorys from real life why they can and can not be true whilst all the time we have people making copies of themself and using bugs and shadows to attack enemies :d anyway lexander i was wondering if you have read the naruto manga??

2004-04-23, 17:14	Link #12
Lexander www.thefestlanders.com Join Date: Dec 2003	I have read the manga a few times. You're talking about the blindspot? Well Naruto actually forces us to come up with these crazy theories, I mean it's all explained in a scientific manner in Naruto, the diagrams and everything.

2004-04-23, 17:20	Link #13
kakashilion has big feet Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: UK Age: 35	yeah i did mean the blindspot. (I spent about 5 minutes trying to figure out a way to ask you about the manga without revealing anything. ) i understand what you mean by him seeing everything all at once anyway. i think the most scientific diagram induced anime is evangelion if you've ever seen it. And we have seen quite a few chakra diagrams so that does help to make it more believeable.

2004-04-23, 17:46	Link #14
Lexander www.thefestlanders.com Join Date: Dec 2003	Talk about the blindspot if you want. Animewatchers should know about it also. Tenten counted 8 by following them with her eyes, while Neji counted 7 by standing there , showing that his 360 vision has a blindspot.

2004-04-23, 18:11	Link #15
rEkKaShInObI LiFe Of ReVeNgE Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: Vana'Diel Age: 36	interesting theory, it MAY be possible, yet it may not.

2004-04-23, 18:12	Link #16
kakashilion has big feet Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: UK Age: 35	yep thats about it. its funny though because that relates to real human eyesight where we have a blind spot because of the optic nerve. So i spose more things in naruto relate to real scientific stuff than i thought.

2004-04-23, 18:14	Link #17
Lexander www.thefestlanders.com Join Date: Dec 2003	Can we get spoiler tags in the title please?

2004-04-23, 18:22	Link #18
Joe Dalton Senior Member Join Date: Dec 2003	grins you didnt have 2 say you didnt follow bio... your post made that clear enough I liked the part where you said "Nerves would move to fast for the muscles in the eye to follow" Although... 1 thing I dont get... you know that the info you give isnt actualy based on what you know yet you still try 2 pass it of as an argument on the subject...

2004-04-23, 18:33	Link #20
Joe Dalton Senior Member Join Date: Dec 2003	no first thing I found funny was when he said "Nerves would move" Then "for the muscles in the eye to follow" the second 1 would need some explaining but the first is pretty clear i take it