Rate That Signature!

[USB500]

redframe:
8.5/10 = what is that? o_o

Cyz
8.5/10 = nice pick of anigirl (and nice quote, on top of that ;O )

[RedFrame]

@USB500=bg too simple try making it fancy for SOS brigade 6/10
p/s= USB its an ermine.From Mahou Sensei negima . The name is ~ Kamo-kun~

[lavielove]

Kila That one is better than Haruhi =D 8/10

[Cyz]

lavielove: i forgot the title of that anime, anyway, the only prob is it's a little bright. other than that, it's cool. 8/10

[Vaines]

@Ichy : 9/10 I really love that sig, it has this kind of deep feeling to it, and my fav color is purple I have no idea if the image comes from a particular anime and if the background is normally used with the character, but I like it anyway

Hmm, makes me wonder if I should maybe try something more joyful for a signature, this is my first sig ever, and I'm starting to think it's kind of sad...

[KiNA]

@ LL .. Love the dropping v touch. Lack of border? Oh there is an invisible one silly me .. 80%

@ USB .. Empty BG calls for empty marks =x 70%

@ Vaines .. Another new one.. For a starter that sig is rather good. Lack of border.. and color choice could be improve... There is a "sad" tone in it.. But poor choice of placement and color on your name is visible. Dont worry, you'll improve greatly. ^^. At first look, I thought is was render cloud BG, but its brushed ^^ .. so 70%

[Shini_GamI]

Vaines hey, we are the same ^^, im also a starter, bonus bias points to you heh 9/10 :P since im a starter too lmao heh...

Rate this two i made.... i have no idea if i had improved or not.
http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a1...mPy/Eruruu.jpg
http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a1...imPy/Momo2.jpg

[Cyz]

lavielove: new sig? colors are a little sharp. i didn't know there was a face in the bg until i get close to it. maybe toning it down a little ne? anyway, it's nice but not as good as your others. 8/10

new sig: this is sakura from fate/stay night. the white spots your seeing are actually sunlight from the pic (she's under a tree). this was made by amaranthine. thanks!

[Vaines]

@Kira_Naruto Interesting signature you have there, but I don't like the way the end of the sig is on the left, a too agressive cut I think, and the sig looks like a try at machine looking material, but not quite that. Hmm just my two cents 75%

Oh, and I just noticed that I hadn't put the last version of the sig I had worked on when I posted in this forum. You were right, I also had problems with the colors ^^

[Amaranthine]

Shini_GamI: 8/10 for the first one. The image on the left is a little fuzzy, and I think it shows more than it might when compared with the nice clean image on the right. The clean image is good though, and the enlargement in the background works well. ^^ The placement of the vertical text isn't the greatest, but the horizontal is good. So... it's kinda just the left hand side letting it down. It gets bias points because I have a thing about simple sigs though. :x

6.5/10 for the second. I like it... except that it's very fuzzy/blurry. :/ Also I can see why you made the text on the bottom, "So I cry for them", smaller, but IMO it would look better if it was the same size. But the main reason it loses points is because of the unclean look.

[lavielove]

Cyz like the font design.Sakura, powerless girl among those spice-girls =D 8/10.

Vaines Too Red and typical =P 7/10

[Homeschooler_Jenni]

chuck norris approves to all ~__~

[Cyz]

lavielove: i think this one is much better than your last one. except the bg seems a little empty. 8/10

- okay another new one: since caster made an initial appearance on the fate/stay night anime, amaranthine made this for me. thanx amaranthine!

[kira_lacusXX]

Cyz-pretty caster...love the bg but i can see some of the old sky bg from the screen shot behind bits of her hair...9/10

Jenni-i have no clue who chuck norris is but yeh...i dont know how i should rate this...

LL-i love the idea of a front view and a back view 8/10

Ama-the style and the colour is awesome 10/10

mine is made by BlackCatXIII...simple, nothing flashy but i love it

edit:
changed my siggie...i made this one

[Ending]

@ lavielove: Otherwise OK except that the black... light-brown background is pretty awful. Annoys me eyes.

@ Homeschooler_Jenni: I'm sure you know it, but perhaps you should take it to the "/b" section of 4chan, no?

@ USB500: Although not that good artistically, that expression and text are rather fitting.

[Cyz]

kira_lacusxx: aaw! what happen to your cute sigs? well, this one is okay too. but not as good as your others 8/10

[Pellissier]

Amaranthine: Very clean and stylish. Definitely very likeable 9/10

KiLa: Without a real text (except your name, that's it), it results to be a bit plain, even if animated. 7/10

Cyz: heh, that Caster shot is awesome and so it remains if inserted in a signature. The background fits, the text maybe does less. But that's just my opinion. 8,5/10

Vaines: Doesn't matter if sad or happy. You should work on colour tones and contrasts. Definitely too much dark red which doesn't suit, even the text is red. And the quality of the main image is quite low. 6,5/10

lavielove: nice overall but feels a bit empty in the middle. 7,5/10

[Cyz]

kira_lacusxx: now that's better i like the img. and also, i like where your name placement is *points at the book* 10/10

- my sig is fix

[Akarix]

kira_lacusxx: Ahhh kawaii~!!! *jumping up and down* kawaii~!!! cuteness overwhelming me~!!! [ man i sound lame ] 10/10

Wordplay: o.O she looks like some bad girl lolx... 8.5/10

Cyz: Hmmm concept simple blending with the whole background and the scan is okii... The whole siggy is ok but the text is not.. it makes the whole siggy stand down.. 7.5/10

[celcius]

kira_lacusxx: I'm just dropping by to say the same thing Akarix said: soooo cutee~~!! 10/10

Cyz: Image-wise, I prefer your previous. This doesn't seem to make me stop to gaze at your sig that much ^^; Nice blending of colors, and fitting font 9/10