Rate That Signature!

[KiNA]

Ehh? Didn't I just rate his Fate-chan sig?

@ Heikuro .. As stated by someone, There's too much empty space on either side >.<

[Klashikari]

Originally Posted by Kira_Naruto

Please rate a sig in each post please

Spoiler for long explnation and off topic. i will save you from some brainache:

err... in fact, it would be hard for me to follow this rule as... i always pack up my rates in 1 post

in fact, i'm commenting on the sig of the current last page. if i comment something earlier, i MUST to rate everything earlier, to be fair so... errr

but well, my developped comment for blackcatXIII sig isn't enough? ^^; dumb copy paste of number isn't really my cup of tea XD (though, yours won't be rating too then, that's what BCXIII meant earlier, meh... let's forget this ! )

anyway, i still consider rating is eligible with some constructive comment ^^"

so let's see... let's review a bit more the H-Army goody (you asked for this ! )

-BG : the overall style is really nice, and it does give some... appealing feeling (don't get me wrong ! ). there is some artifact around the middle left and the far right.
*try to avoid nose-bleeding* err... but, at the left, the breast curve (or is it a butt? XD) suffered of some kind of grainyness. this isn't disturbing... except with the word "love" wich shows that either of the word or the effect on the stock is not intended/doesn't fit.
maybe some blurr? this suggestion seems a bit off, but it could aso add some "sweet" impression but meh, not really important.

i will comment a bit more on your quote :

The right side Tamanee was on several filter to turned her to more painting like texture rather then just an anime character draw >.< the grainyness was the side effect .. Still need to perfect the skill I guess =/

-main stock : here lies the real issue : the blending is creating some nasty effects on the hair and especially the shades : as you can see, there is some "red" part of the hair are really too exposed and doesn't really merge well with the black parts (not really annoying). but with this, you can see the shades red... and it does spread a bit too much...
you can see this problem around : the edge of the bra, shades under hair at the left and right, on the arm under the "... *heart* "

nothing really major except maybe this weird "red spread shade" around, so well XD (in fact, it's not the "draw style" change that is the problem. rather, it's the unwanted spread colour)

The BG is well done.. Qualm with me would be the text Ready .. it look out of position .. I'm refering to its set specificcally .. I can tell that set up and stand by is part of the set but Ready is like pasted on, because its position doesnt look like its in the BG =/ Hard to type out my explaination >.<.. It would be different if ready text is animated but alas its not. 2ndly, Fate's back is black .. means she's supposed to be front or the main image .. but alas her hair blends in the BG. So its quite confusing.

in fact, the "stand by" seems to be a bit apart, because you can see the 3 dots. but i had the same impression : maybe the "ready" should be more at the left and being in bright or something? hu well XD (but i understood pretty well what you meant, or correct me if i'm wrong)
as for the hair, i could probably change that part, but i feel it would distrub the balance of the sig, also it would have some problem with the hard blakc behind... but meh

Originally Posted by BlackCatXIII

I luv white.. but there's just something not good about it.. 8/10..

probably because of some contrast/cloud blending and such? ^^;
this is not to be meant as a stunning so i understand the whole blending is a bit awkward

[Silver Dragon]

It is very pretty 9/10

[XSexySaphieX]

Heikuro's is nice, it blends well and the red anime eyes seem to give it a mysterious look, as does the slight mistiness...

[Cyz]

Heikuro: I think I rated this one before? Anyway, it was pretty nice. She looks like one of those collectible dolls 8/10

New sig! These two are from Simoun (in case you're not paying attention to the above text. Anyway, this was made by kkcrow.

[SweetHoney]

Cyz: Oh um a kiss lol 8/10

Heikuro: pretty neat! 10/10

Mine one I'm using now is just a crop of an image from a production we did "Treasure Island" so yeah I would rate this sig you can rate my sig I'm using now but it'll be low marks so yeah rate the Kareha one

[RedFrame]

Sweethoney: you which one you wated to be rated ??
I guess the kareha one -->Kareha pic is ok but unsuitable bg to match
with her. 5/10
Cyz: i never able to see your sig -->?/?

[Cyz]

SweetHoney: mmm, purple doesn't seem to match Kareha. And the bg is a little empty though. Still, I like Kareha 8/10

[Silver Dragon]

The text needs to sharpened a bit, or brightened, it seems kinda dull in contrast with the rest of the picture, 9/10

[Cyz]

Godaime Hokage: different Kabuto pics really nice. 8/10

[Spectacular_Insanity]

Godaime Hokage: I like the Kabuto "prism" thing you've got going. Very nice. 8/10

[Cyz]

Spectacular_Insanity: I already rated yours before but I have to rate it again so my post won't get deleted. 7/10

-> New sig made by kkcrow. This is Feena from Yoake Mae Yori Ruri Iro Na

[Silver Dragon]

10/10, lovely

[celcius]

Godaime Hokage: Color bar? I think it would have been better if the colors didn't spill into the other boxes. 8/10
Cyz: Oh yes I would. Now I'm curious *goes off to check said anime* 8/10
RedFrame: Adorable Eri~ 9/10
SweetHoney: [Kareha] A wee bit blank towards the right hm? 8/10

me: Temp sig. Text is barely readable, but I had to shrink it to fit with Asuki limit but I think the important text are quite clear. Anyway, as I said, temp sig so I didn't bother with increasing the font sizes.

[Pellissier]

Klashikari: I like it, albeith white-ish, it's dark and mysterious. Gives out the Higurashi feeling quite well. 8/10

Cyz: Looks like just a crop work .. not even much outstanding. 6,5/10

Spectacular_Insanity: a bit crowded, dark and confused. Also borderless. But all in all is not bad. 7/10

celcius: Actually the text is kinda hard to read. I have to put my eyes close to the screen (19 lcd) to get all of it. No rating since it's temp.

Mine: well, making animated signs fitting under 50,000 bytes is becoming everyday harder. I'd figured to make a sea effect, but instead of the 6 frames I would have needed, I had to do just with 4 >_> .
Anyway, she's Nana-chan from Bokura ga Ita

[Cyz]

Pellissier: the animation is a little choppy still, it's another animated sig from you and it was a nice capture 8/10

[Pellissier]

Originally Posted by Cyz

Pellissier: the animation is a little choppy still, it's another animated sig from you and it was a nice capture 8/10

I've changed the times of the frames, though I still wish I could have had 1 more of them :x ... does it look better?

Anyway it's a temporary sign, I was just inspired by the situation, but it's gonna be winter and I have to find something appropriate for it.

Godaime Hokage: Nice idea, it's really small though, but on the various colors, looks good. 7,5/10

[Deathkillz]

celcius ~ wee free manga *grabs magnifling glass*
Pellissier ~ well its nice but the back and forth shimmering effect is a bit "ugh"...yep it could use more frames but that will probably push it over the limit...good effort 9/10 ^_^
cyz ~ feena its really nice but a bit too bright...and the text could be less obstructive...still 9.5/10 ^_^

[Sinestra]

Iv had this SIG for a while now and i never asked to have it rated so i guess ill do that now

[Faeyice]

Godaime Hokage, I give you a 9.5 on your signature.