Rate That Signature!

[MikoKikyo]

Originally Posted by Thany's sig

Signature taken off because I noticed a major flaw. First to guess it get a cookie

She wasn't really a young girl but an old man in disguise? o_O

Originally Posted by Slade xTekno

PriestessKikyo: 9/10. I love that purple! [hint for guys: the current "in" color for guys is anything bright, like pink. The "hot" color for fall is.... PURPLE!]

Ohh is that so, I didn't even know what How fashionable am I
This looks like you took a wallpaper, cropped and added your name and a border. Well, there's nothing wrong with that except that you should've also made the image smaller (proportionately in l and w) because it would work out better. It's not so big that it's against the rules, it's just too big for what the image offers. But overall, simple and nice. 8.2/10

ventriloquist- the colors in the BG are too bright and the text a bit hard to read. Everything is pixelized. But aside from that, it's a nice, colorful composition. 8/10

[Ayame]

Slade xTekno: woohoo, Kawaii 8/10

o_o MidoriShinobi: can you make me a signature like yours, that one with Shika and Ino Onegai, since I have no idea how to make signatures, so in other words, I SUCK! >_<

[Kabuto Maniac]

Oneesama : I don't really get your sig... is there something special to it? for now, it looks like a 6/10 to me...

ayame: cute sig and they seem to have fun too ^^ I give it a 8/... oh wait! Kakashi-sensei! 8.5/10

[hobobaggins]

Originally Posted by Slade xTekno

What happened to hobo-kun?

got banned. havent changed it. thinking of putting a link in it to link to where keitaro rated it ... but i wouldnt do that.
Kabuto- i dont like the pixelation of your KM. but that is just me. 8/10

ehh~ SxT, i remember that signature from sonewhere... is it new?

[OutPhase]

Slade xTekno: It's simple, no extra crap getting in the way. Just straight forward with the image.

Overall: 94%

[sarcasteak]

ChibiDusk - You asshole. 10/10

Thany - I didn't get to see your sig before it was taken off...I demand to see it NOW so I can get a cookie!

[Shay]

Aahhsin: If you do only use MSPaint the that’s a definite 10/10

Sacr: Ha! Very funny indeed and very nice transparency. 9/10

Chibi: Well what can I say....

Kabuto Mainiac: Nice...Plain...Simple.....Animated. 9.5/10

Necro: I agree with Hobo It’s definitely missing something.

Thany: I also missed your sig....

Hobo: I would like to see what you got banned for, was it something dirty or just too big?

[ChibiDusk]

ChibiDusk - You asshole. 10/10: gah..wait...what?
Steaky: It's genious, I love the stalker-san XD Hehe, don't quite get the "the army' part, though. Overall it made me laugh, hehe, always makes me smile just imagining her saying that XP 9.1/10

[GustaveElazul]

Kabuto Maniac: 9/10 Nice and clean, animation would be better if it wasn't pixels

Ayame: 8/10 Clear, simple and cute. I like the two background colors and the border fits well with them.

Chibidusk: 10/10 Really nice quality, I like the transparency look. Great job!

[Thany]

Originally Posted by ChibiDusk

Steaky: It's genious, I love the stalker-san XD Hehe, don't quite get the "the army' part, though. Overall it made me laugh, hehe, always makes me smile just imagining her saying that XP 9.1/10

You just had to look at JOJO'S signature, it's hentai for him, rori for sarcasteak :P

Originally Posted by sarcasteak

Thany - I didn't get to see your sig before it was taken off...I demand to see it NOW so I can get a cookie!

Too late I don't have it anymore and don't feel like searching through all the possibilities in imagehost

ChibiDusk : your sig is really nice looking. Very nice art and interesting cutting 8.5/10.

Also got a new sig, not the same as the 2 previous one :P

[sarcasteak]

Originally Posted by ChibiDusk

gah..wait...what?

That was a compliment. And yes, like Thany said, mine is a parody of JOJO's sig.


Thany - This time your name and border match very well with the picture. Her face is a tad too chubby for my taste, but gosh that smile and blush is absolutely adorable! 9/10

[Wavie]

Spoiler:

Priestesskikyo

I really like this sig because of its amazing colours and the writting along the bottom goes with the bottom border as well. 9/10



Ayame

Nice picture, good background. The picture suits the site well. i like it 7/10



GustaveElazul

that sig is cool as well i like the idea of an anime character sticking out the top of a signature. not sure if you put snow in from seperate pic or not but it stands out, i like it. 8/10



razor

yours is amusing 7/10



kabuto

Awsome, being able to make characters change to me is hard and i do not know how to do it yet, so i give u credit on that . The background picture and text are awsome the way they are used together. 7/10




sarcasteak

Heh i like yours the char does look like a stalker and the barcode with your name on it is cool. oh added bonus for making it specificly for this forum by copying the background colour. good stuff 7/10



Thany

I like that pic, cute looking, nice glow behind the character and a nice red coloured border to go with hair and the text. 7/10

please say what you think of mines

please note its my first time using photoshop and my first attemps at making a signature.

here they are:





Inverted image



And of course the sig i use below...

[MikoKikyo]

Wavie- I like the top one better but would need a border ^^ 8.5/10

For your current one, good colors, but it needs to follow the sig rules. I also recommend adding something to the center of the image, where there is just blackness 8.2/10

[hobbs]

Wavie like the top one best aswell! but yeah it needs a border but im guessing because your not using it, it may not be finished? ~7/10
I like your current but its too dark,..hehe ~7/10

i have made a new one based on the new eva game, hehe cant wait to play it ill have it soon woooo! lol. *Ahem* nehoo its a different style than the usuall eva style. hehe. but i made a sig with a few images. didnt really know where to put the text...and everyone there is not really any yaoi at all here OMG!!

[hobobaggins]

Thany - not quite daring, but enough on the right track to earn you a 9.7/10. the border is far too bland.

wavie i think that your signature ( this one: is far superior to the one you have. 9.9/10 for that one. 8.9/10 for your current. i dont particularly like the planetary bodies in the background as naruto is not set in space.

[ChibiDusk]

Ayame: I like the image but the pink BG looks a bit plain on the left side, and the text doesn't show up that well over the BG. Perhaps a black or purple instead? I like the border, nice and simple. 7.6/10

Kabuto Maniac: Hm, not a fan of that border style, but I like the clam blue color. Can't tell whats going on in it, and the text transition its a little distracting. 6.6/10

GustaveEkazul: I've been a fan of sigs like these, the style where part of it sticks out from the regular shape. The text could be better, and the colors seem a bit washed out. 7.1/10

Thany: I like it better then your previous one bigger. Though using the same pink colors all the time could get boring. Same simple and easy to read font, nice job. 8.2/10

Wavie: First one + a border would be great.

hobbsy: Hm, again, not your best IMO. I am not really a fan of the thick borders and the artwork sort of seems like cheapily done fanart ^^" Just not a fan of that style I guess. The font seems a bit, too much of a constrast from the rest of the sig. 6.1/10

hobo: best. message. ever. Unfourtunatly, it's just so good it deserves a rating of 0/10

[hobbs]

chibi: me like yours, its good, dunno what else to say.. i thought D.N.Angel came out ages ago...? ~9/10 [/I]

[Wavie]

cool ta for feedback guys... appreciate it

i like your sig chibi 10/10 mate... really smart. i really like the text, bordered and the characters looks. cant say much more it looks perfect to me.

heh hobbsy those anime pics are really funny i like how you arranged them must have took a bit of work to merge them all. 10/10 for effort and definatly for the quality in which you merged them.

[GustaveElazul]

hobbsy: 10/10 Clean, nice pictures used, and extra points for Asuka-chan
Thany: 9/10 Your new one is much better, clearer and overall better including the border with text. Good job.

[hobobaggins]

Originally Posted by Wavie

omg! what happened here???

quality dropped by a factor of 10~

6/10 for that. other than that, awesome...

sorry for lack of signature. getting one okayed as we speak... >< xris' box is full however.