(L) Fairy Tail Manga Discussion Thread

[Xellos-_^]

Originally Posted by konart

"she was only brought back because of fanbase and the Anime staff love her."

fixed for truth

I can't remember Mira & Elfman seeing her being sucked into the sky. Anyway - she is alive or some kind of iZen technic, or even Gerard(Jelal? How should I call him now?)

try page 8 of the current chapter

[konart]

Originally Posted by Xellos-_^

try page 8 of the current chapter

And? How can you judge from this? This is just Lisanna's version of what happed. She was unconscious, lol

[Kir]

Originally Posted by konart

And? How can you judge from this? This is just Lisanna's version of what happed. She was unconscious, lol

Your argument is bit silly, if it didn't happen, the artist shouldn't have inserted that scene.

[konart]

Originally Posted by Kir

Your argument is bit silly, if she was unconscious then the artist shouldn't have inserted that scene.

er?
Let me put a quote here:

2 Years ago, while I was on a job with Mira-nee and Elf-niichan I lost consciousness. I was sucked into anima at that point

Or maybe I'm reading some kind of a bad translation?

PS: lol, you edited your post while I was writting, sorry.

if it didn't happen, the artist shouldn't have inserted that scene.

I guess it'd be better if he didn't, but that's what we've got.

PPS: Whatever - I think it's better to end this talk. Lisanna(or whoever it is) is back. That's the fact.

[Slayerx]

Honestly i like Lisanna too, but that alone is NOT an excuse for THIS... it's just painful to read
It would have been a thousand times better if they just said she's been missing for the past 2 years. Yes, the reveal that edo-lisanna is really earthland Lisanna would come to very little surprise, but it would have atleast been acceptable writing.

I could really enjoy Lisanna's return, i mean i felt something at the end of the chapter.... but this asspull of writing is just making it really, really hard to enjoy it

[ShiroiRyu]

But ... I think we will have a better explanation in 200 ...
That which extinguiches life.
With a name like that ... We will know more of Anima ?

[cyberdemon]

Originally Posted by ShiroiRyu

But ... I think we will have a better explanation in 200 ...
That which extinguiches life.
With a name like that ... We will know more of Anima ?

I'm betting we'll finally get the full story of that day 2 years ago from Mira. Why she told everyone Lisanna was dead, why Elfman went on a rampage, and all that stuff.

[squaresphere]

I have to agree the story telling ball was dropped on this one. It's just her "dead" body being sucked up that was the biggest miss step.

If they had set it up that Elfman had hit her into a "deadly unstable energy/crystal/mystic hoodoo" ok sure this would have worked out fine. But even the anime just shows her getting smacked, crashing down to be "dead".

Even with that, FT gets a semi pass as it was never "serious" to begin with.

[cyberdemon]

Originally Posted by squaresphere

I have to agree the story telling ball was dropped on this one. It's just her "dead" body being sucked up that was the biggest miss step.

If they had set it up that Elfman had hit her into a "deadly unstable energy/crystal/mystic hoodoo" ok sure this would have worked out fine. But even the anime just shows her getting smacked, crashing down to be "dead".

Even with that, FT gets a semi pass as it was never "serious" to begin with.

anime isn't considered canon. even then the anime director said he actually left her fate open in case she turned out to be alive in the manga. In the manga Lisanna was still alive but unconscious when she was sucked into the anima. there was no resurrection going on.

[Sprite_Coke]

SICK TWIST: that smile on the last page is an evil smile.

No but seriously, I don't want it to be an evil smile... It's probably Mira's face anyways.
Oh and reverse foreshadowing: Back in ch 197 title page group picture, Lisanna wasn't in it.

[Bombo]

Fairy tail chapter 199: The Best chapter of fairy tail.

Spoiler for 199=My fav chapter!!!!!!:

THIS CHAPTER IS MY DAY

LISANNA earthland IS BACK and alive YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEES:kissk iss:
Bye bye lucy bye bye erza...go find someone else
NatsuX lisanna 100% . what a great hug.!!!
eye to eye geez
I'm just disappiont about meeting her sister and brother .
Its jsut like that? with mira smile..I don't think there's will be happy chapter next week ..I hope that not true.

One thing i'm happy for it

LISANNA,!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[aliasxn]

The dead should stay dead. Period.

[Ravenblitz]

<_< i'm not sure i'd be happy or not but i'm curious of what happened with lisanna in the past years when she "disappeared"

lookin' forward if lisanna's presence will affect natsu and lucy's friendly relationship

[cyberdemon]

Originally Posted by aliasxn

The dead should stay dead. Period.

she wasn't dead so that doesn't quite work.

i have a feeling that next chapter either someone is dying or we're going to see what happened 2 years ago.

[Von Himmel]

I can't believe that those speculation long time ago are actually true...

[cyberdemon]

i just had a theory concerning the title of the next chapter.

Luxus's father is looking to take down Fairy Tail. What if he took control of Lisanna's mind 2 years ago which was what caused the incident. Elfman in his rage transformed and lost control. In the ensuing chaos Lisanna was badly hurt. He altered Mira's and Elfman's memories of the events to say that Lisanna died since she instead disappeared which put a ratchet into his plans since she was a key part of his plans. Now that she is back though he might take control again and have her attack and possibly kill someone in FT.

That would create a lot of drama.

[pampz21]

Well in Mashima's work there really no such thing as death....its like there body may dissolve but his soul remain just like sieg in rave! and you notice at the garunda what island the first S class....Bobo has a grave but doesn't have its body! means for some reason or another the bobo guy was alive! If anyone of you is unsatisfied by Anima sucking up Lisanna while Mira was there....here a piece of info! they didn't even realise that the whole town was suck to edoras! Gray and Erza explain that they was just there and was save by Gajeel....

And wat the heck! maybe FT may have some little tiny romance in the middle!
it like rave when Haru and Elie was to shy to express his feelings and develope love!

And another good point of reviving Lisanna was to a kinder side in Natsu! cuz Natsu is all way badass always want to fight for a nakama! would it be nice to see him almost die saving a girl he loves!


PS: sorry if some of it doesn't makes sense...cuz im not completely proud of my english!

[Anh_Minh]

Originally Posted by amjzz

I doubt mirajane saw the body of her sister being sucked by a misterious hole in the sky and completely ignored it, never mentioned anything about it and even made a grave for her.

Don't make fanon for fill the holes on the plot.

That's rich, coming from the guy coming up with "soul sucking + new body" schtick.

Originally Posted by Xellos-_^

thats the point if they couldn't find the body while did they list her as KIA and why bother with a false grave.

No Body =/ death.

and Miria was holding on to Lisanna both in the pervious flashback and the lisanna flashback.

As was said, that's just what Lisanna imagined happened. Maybe Mirajane was unconscious for a bit of that battle and when they woke up, they figured Elfman ate her. Whole.

[cyberdemon]

Originally Posted by Anh_Minh

As was said, that's just what Lisanna imagined happened. Maybe Mirajane was unconscious for a bit of that battle and when they woke up, they figured Elfman ate her. Whole.

perhaps their memory of the events was tampered with. Maybe by the person that cause Elfman to transform and go wild.

[Xellos-_^]

Originally Posted by Anh_Minh

That's rich, coming from the guy coming up with "soul sucking + new body" schtick.




As was said, that's just what Lisanna imagined happened. Maybe Mirajane was unconscious for a bit of that battle and when they woke up, they figured Elfman ate her. Whole.

we also had mirajane's pervious flashback of holding Lisanna upto the point that lisanna went unconscious.