Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood General Discussion

[duckroll]

There's a rumored full staff list going around on 2ch, based on a "leak" on the mixi blogs. It claims that the series will be a collaboration between BONES and Doga Kobo, but there's really nothing to substantiate the rumor.

[Ronin Aquila]

Oh boy.

Thanks to Full Metal Alchemist Season 1 (and the movie), the 30th of December for the last 5 years of Comiket has been devoted entirely to doujinshis of Ed and Al in "situations."

Thanks to this new TV series, it looks like the 30th of December will be the day of "Brotherly Love" for a few more years to come.

[golthin]

Originally Posted by Kaioshin Sama

Well will be confirmed in the upcoming 20th volume issue of the manga proper. Here's the details:



Should be good news for fans. Here's to the envitable reunion of Romi Paku and Rie Kugimiya in their legendary roles as Edward and Alphonse Elric.

it will be interesting to see what approach they use to bring the brothers back. I bet the winry will be hapy but they probably will have her married and with kids in the sequel!

[HayashiTakara]

Heres hoping for a reunion of Ed and Winry... the ending of the movie left a horrible taste in my mouth.

[Chanberry]

Oh, I'm really excited for this. I've been waiting so long for a remake! I personally am looking forward to seeing all the characters from Xing and Briggs Mt. appear.

[gabbytay]

Originally Posted by Chanberry

Oh, I'm really excited for this. I've been waiting so long for a remake! I personally am looking forward to seeing all the characters from Xing and Briggs Mt. appear.

what are you talking about remake?? Its a sequel

[kujoe]

Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't the series follow the manga up to a certain point before it diverges into something different entirely?

If so, when is this? And has there been any info if this new series will start from the very beginning once again?

[King Lycan]

YESSS
Im so happy

[bayoab]

Originally Posted by kujoe

Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't the series follow the manga up to a certain point before it diverges into something different entirely?

If so, when is this?

The series "follows" the manga with some minor changes up until around the fifth lab. At that point, it slightly diverges. (Approximately ep 19.) They still roughly followed the manga up until episode 25 or so. (There were a number of filler/non-manga story lines prior.)

And has there been any info if this new series will start from the very beginning once again?

The rumor is full reboot from scratch.

[ZODDGUTS]

Originally Posted by gabbytay

what are you talking about remake?? Its a sequel

Uh it hasn't been confirm that I'll be a sequel buddy unless you have a source to provide to us that says it will be. Though rumors for quite awhile now have been saying that there was going to be another FMA anime and guess what it turn out to be true, also part of that rumor was that it's going to be a remake, plus adding the fact that the manga is going to end soon it adds more fuel as to this possibly is going to be a remake that follows the manga to the very end.

[Mystique]

Originally Posted by HayashiTakara

Heres hoping for a reunion of Ed and Winry... the ending of the movie left a horrible taste in my mouth.

And yet i thought it was fitting.
*isn't a EDxWinry fangirl*
What i didn't like was hawkeye being abandoned on the ground, what was that about?!
We did't even see if Roy came back to her.

And yeah cause of the anmie catching up so fast to the manga originally back in 2004, was the reason the anime went tangent, but it was still awesome.

I've not read the manga and im sure many others haven't either. So if this is a remake based soley from the manga (like hellsing ultimate) - please to take care on what you all say (this is to manga readers)

That means, people like me are vunerable to spoilers and since there's an entire story plot i've yet to see, it'd be a shame to find things out before it gets animated.
I wanna susbcribe and keep close track of this thread, but am semi in fear of someone saying something related from the manga ><;;;
(It was so nice when anime went tangent, meant no one could predict anything)

As for latest news from Japan, 9th April 2009, there will be a Hagaren Spring Festival with the VA's appearing as guest as well as chances to grab all kinds of merchandise, etc.
They're currently taking pre orders for the Ultimate collection set (TV series, movie, OVA + all VA singles)...was tempted to buy it but then already got movie collectors edition and its £300 of my moolah ($600)

I've yet to translate the rest of the details, but for those who can read Japanese, this is a website you'd wanna bookmark.
http://www.aniplex.co.jp/hagaren/news/index.html

[tigerwoods]

Originally Posted by ZODDGUTS

Uh it hasn't been confirm that I'll be a sequel buddy unless you have a source to provide to us that says it will be. Though rumors for quite awhile now have been saying that there was going to be another FMA anime and guess what it turn out to be true, also part of that rumor was that it's going to be a remake, plus adding the fact that the manga is going to end soon it adds more fuel as to this possibly is going to be a remake that follows the manga to the very end.

Yeah, I think so too. And I think most people are hoping for a remake and not a sequel, or is it just me?

[duckroll]

Here's the rumored staff listing that's from mixi and 2ch. There is NOTHING to indicate this is real, but since there's no more "FMA rumors and speculation" thread and we're stuck with this one, I'll post it here. I've translated all the staff names and the text note at the end about how the production is progressing. Once again, this could very well be totally fake, so take it with huge grains of salt, it's just that we don't have anything else to discuss about for now, so...

Spoiler for Warning! Rumors! Could be FAKE!!:

Director: Yasuhiro Irie
Series Composition: Reiko Yoshida, Yasuhiro Irie
Script: Natsuko Takahashi, Satoru Nishizono, Kenichi Araki, Yuka Yamada, Megumi Shimizu, Takeshi Mori
Original Character Design: Yoshiyuki Ito
Character Design & Chief Animation Director (Second Half): Hideaki Maniwa
Key Animator: Kouichi Hashimoto, Hideaki Maniwa (1st Cour)
Prop Design: Koji Sugiura, Emi Kamiishi
Chimera Design: Junya Ishigaki
Art Design: Iho Narita
Art Director: Kazuyuki Hashimoto
Color Setting: Shihoko Nakayama
Sound Director: Toshihiko Nakajima
Music: Michiru Oshima
Chief Episode Director: Tarou Iwasaki
Production: BONES & Doga Kobo

Tensai Okamura and Tomoki Kyoda will be contributing to storyboards in the series, currently scripts have been completed up to episode 12.

(Source: mixi, 2ch)

duckroll's note: The original Mixi post said that Yoshiyuki Ito was the Character Designer, and the only Key Animator listed was Kouichi Hashimoto. Later when the list was posted on 2ch and discussed, someone on the BONES thread corrected it saying Hideaki Maniwa is the Character Designer and Chief Animation Director for the second half of the series when the new characters show up. He also said Hideaki Maniwa would be the second main Key Animator for the first cour (ep1-13).

[blewin]

for someone who hasn't read the manga, I wouldn't mind having a complete remake of FMA following the manga's plotline. After all, the real ending might be more surprising and pleasing than the anime ending. well, maybe.

[cereal_killerxx]

Please let this be true! I've been waiting and hoping for a long time!

[jonli]

I checked up on the Yasuhiro Irie director, this seems to be his first Anime Director role.

I'm a bit worried.

Why can't they just get Mizushima again?

[duckroll]

Originally Posted by jonli

I checked up on the Yasuhiro Irie director, this seems to be his first Anime Director role.

I'm a bit worried.

Why can't they just get Mizushima again?

Irie directed Kurau. He's far from being an industry newbie. He's been animating various things for a long time now. The entire Soul Eater opening sequence was directed, storyboarded and keyframed by him alone as well. It's pretty insulting to suggest he's inexperienced.

Mizushima wouldn't be interested in a new FMA anyway. He's stated before that he's told all he wanted to tell in the FMA world, and it would be hard to get all the staff together again. He's working on Gundam 00 now, so why would he be interested in going back and working on FMA from scratch again except with even less creative freedom since it's based on the manga?

[jonli]

Originally Posted by duckroll

Irie directed Kurau. He's far from being an industry newbie. He's been animating various things for a long time now. The entire Soul Eater opening sequence was directed, storyboarded and keyframed by him alone as well. It's pretty insulting to suggest he's inexperienced.

Mizushima wouldn't be interested in a new FMA anyway. He's stated before that he's told all he wanted to tell in the FMA world, and it would be hard to get all the staff together again. He's working on Gundam 00 now, so why would he be interested in going back and working on FMA from scratch again except with even less creative freedom since it's based on the manga?

Sorry buddy, I didn't mean harm to the new director.

I probably overlooked his profile, I didn't know he directed Kurau. So I thought it was his first Anime director role. And I didn't think directing and animating openings would give him much experience to supervise an entire project.

[BetoJR]

Great news, indeed. Here's one fan hoping that the tone of this doesn't stray too much from the original anime adaptation (as I kinda liked the different vibe, as opposed to the manga - wich I also love).
I'm hopeful.

[Icehawk]

I've got mixed feelings on the prospect of a complete remake. On one hand, yes it would be cool to see a more faithful manga adaptation that better follows the original creator story to its proper end. As well, would be nice if they do it in HD resolution as well. However, on the other hand it also seems like its a bit too early and not really necessary to go for a complete remake of the show at this point IMO.

More ideally for me they should just make an actual original second season that would override the shallow and rushed movie storyline with a more fleshed out and proper continuation from the ending of the first TV series.

The movie touched on a lot of cool idea's but due to its constrained length couldnt properly explore them such as the discovery and consequences of nuclear fission through alchemy and other things.