2012-08-15, 15:14 | Link #461 |
Banned
Join Date: Dec 2006
Age: 38
|
When Mutta headbutted his boss, it was his integrity that pulled through. Luck played a role when Hoshika decided to investigate that, but when it came to the exam, it was Mutta's qualities and ability that played the major role. I guess we could take his trip to the States as consequence of nepotism, but honestly it didn't work in his favor all that much. I'd even venture to say that his relationship with Hibito worked against him, as clearly demonstrated by Nitta's prejudice.
|
2012-08-15, 15:14 | Link #462 | ||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2007
|
Quote:
Part of the reason I love this series so much is I can identify with it. However I don't think being fired, unemployed living with your parents, or in general having bad luck are character flaws. They are unfortunate life situations which a lot of people are finding themselves in these days. Heck Mutta only get fired because he defended Hibito and his boss was a jerk. But let's not forget that these circumstances Mutta were in during the very early parts of the story. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
He is however a character the audience is definitely supposed to identify with. This is not necessarily a bad thing. As I said above many people are down on their luck these days and Mutta in an inspiring character. But as the story ultimately calls for Mutta to succeed this does make him come off a bit too perfect to me at times or at least better than the other characters in the story. Sorry that's just how I see it. edit: Also for the person who neg repped me. I am not even sure what you mean by "tv tropes terms" but I am very sorry my own vocabulary does not meet your requirements.
__________________
Last edited by Kirarakim; 2012-08-15 at 15:46. |
||||
2012-08-15, 15:56 | Link #463 | ||
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2006
|
Quote:
Quote:
And yeah, Mutta often comes up with the answers to the problems. But like Enzo said this is mostly due to luck. It was luck that he learned about the green card thing when he visited Hibito, and it was also luck that Sharon has shared so much of her wisdom with him. He has talent of course, like his attention to detail and concentration, but the series makes it a point that this alone wouldn't be enough to succeed.
__________________
|
||
2012-08-15, 17:54 | Link #464 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2007
|
Quote:
But I don't want my criticism to come off the wrong way. I love the series & Mutta. Even with these issues I still think Space Brothers is better than 99% of what is out there.
__________________
|
|
2012-08-15, 19:05 | Link #465 |
絶対領域に嵌り過ぎた。
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Trendy Backwater
Age: 38
|
I'm still not convinced that Mutta's low self-esteem really a flaw but I guess it is, since he is working in a competitive environment. However what sets his character apart from the other characters, I think he is the one of the few characters working against the social expectation. The reason he is fired from the job and living in his parents' house in his early 30 is something he brought on himself. He just did what most people wouldn't risk doing.
If the other characters were in Mutta's situation when the boss started badmouthing their own families, I think most characters would really think of the consequence and probably grin and bear it. What Mutta did would most likely be registered as a flaw but to me it's very rare and good quality. He would defend the honour of his loved ones even if it means he will definitely lose his job. Not many characters would not dare to headbutt his own boss though I guess Kenji would probably come back with some subtle jabs. And don't get me wrong, I like Mutta, too but I was thinking of all the anime I watched, there hasn't been a male character more charming and just naturally balanced than this guy, even Okabe Rintarou had a number of visible flaws. So far everything Mutta does, he was in a right place at the right time. It is also quite ironic that Kenji whom Mutta seemed to show some jealousy towards is having a hard time because of Misoguchi. Even though Kenji doesn't get much screen time as the main character does, he gets a supple development to know what his strength and flaws are. |
2012-08-16, 02:30 | Link #466 | |
Le fou, c'est moi
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Las Vegas, NV, USA
Age: 34
|
IMO you two are reacting this way because he's just too charming.
And that's a good thing! I'm serious. Mutta is an extremely lovable character; just about everybody in the audience identifies with him completely, including, I think, both of you. It is a possibility that, perhaps, you are mistaking his charm as a lack of flaws or struggle on his part. He's basically a living (?) testament to the "funny guys are popular" statement after all. I don't think he is completely balanced and/or perfect. A perfect character is a Mary Sue character, an archetype that is disliked nearly by instinct -- though he certainly has a Mary Sue's luck, he isn't one of them. He started this show down in the dumps with a massive inferiority complex, his self-esteem issue never really went away, and he's still the butt monkey of more than half the show's jokes. We also have to remember that at this point in the story, the remaining candidates are highly qualified, driven individuals, including Mutta, and luck is just about the only thing that distinguishes them. Naturally, the main character is going to have some luck coming his way; it's just karma compensating his previous bad lucks anyway (lol). Quote:
____________ Speaking of which, I think love this show, I think I do. Say you love it too~ P.S. I could totally see Group A steal their own Millenium Falcon and start a grand space adventure by themselves (+ maybe Kenji and Hibito and Apo in place of a robot). They already have Star Wars ringtones ready! Alas, they're living in 202X Earth, not a galaxy far, far away. |
|
2012-08-16, 02:44 | Link #467 |
Banned
Join Date: Dec 2006
Age: 38
|
Well, it's not like Mutta comes directly out of the mold of perfect characters, such as Tokuchi Toua from One Outs, where we get to enjoy in his empathic intellect without any explanation why it is so. Mutta has his childhood flashbacks to back him up. The flashbacks are important because they illustrate just what kind of a child he was (curious, different, and competitive by nature) and what kind of support he received (Sharon, visiting JAXA etc.). I mean, you look at his past and you can't really argue why he turned out the way he did. The show made Mutta's skill set believable. He has to succeed to a certain degree, that much the audience expects from him, but it's not like he wasn't an underdog compared to other candidates at the beginning. His odds just got better as he cleared exams, that's why maybe there's an illusion of him being too perfect now. As Irenicus says, the score between candidates is still pretty fucking close.
Last edited by cyth; 2012-08-16 at 17:20. Reason: english fail |
2012-08-16, 05:44 | Link #468 | ||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2007
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
I 100% don't think he is a Mary Sue and I hoped I clarified that in previous posts. I ultimately do think he is a great character. Quote:
And yeah Mutta definitely has quirks and is a bit neurotic. These things can be seen as flaws but I think they are also Mutta's strengths, making him more unique. It is the same with Mutta being the butt monkey of the jokes, the initial impression of him might not always be favorable but he always grows on people in the end. Although Cyth is correct too that the reason Mutta succeeds is always explained and I do appreciate that.
__________________
|
||||
2012-08-16, 12:15 | Link #469 |
Seishu's Ace
Author
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Kobe, Japan
|
Mutta basically has two remarkable things about him. First, he genuinely likes people - genuinely, which is a rare thing - and wants everyone to get along. And B, he has an incredible attention to detail - which is both his greatest strength and at times his greatest liability.
So for me, the two charges leveled against him - inevitability and perfection - just don't hold up. Yes, we know he's going to be an astronaut - because he's the MC and that's the premise. Do we hold it against Gorou that's he's going to make the major leagues? Do we hold it against Inuyasha that he's eventually going to defeat Naraku? And as to perfection, I think the evidence being used against Mutta is based on his one great strength, his attention to detail. It's not as if he's preternaturally strong or fast or attractive - he just has this one kernel of genius, which drives him crazy as often as it helps him. Yes, Mutta is definitely lovable - one of the most likable characters in ages (and Hirata-san's performance is no small factor). But he's just an insecure, really bright guy and a bit of a geek, that really likes people and wants everyone to be happy.
__________________
|
2012-08-16, 14:09 | Link #470 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2007
|
Quote:
However because he is our protagonist the story sets him up to be better than the other candidates so he can ultimately succeed. That might not actually be the case, but when in the end the person who pretty much solved all of Team A's issues is Mutta then this is how it comes off to me. Yes I understand Mutta was able to do all that because of being in the right place at the right time, his own childhood experiences, etc but it was still pretty much all Mutta that drove Team A's success. Hence why I said he comes off perfect at times, not that he is perfect (although maybe perfect was not the best word to use). It sounds to me like people keep defending Mutta of being a Mary Sue or a badly written character, neither of which I think.
__________________
|
|
2012-08-16, 17:37 | Link #471 |
Banned
Join Date: Dec 2006
Age: 38
|
That's a tough question whether Team A would be worse off without Mutta. Aside from Yasushi, everyone else kept their cool. It's just that the story was mostly narrated through Mutta's experiences, who knows what kind of mind schemes everyone else had on their mind? In the end, it became clear even Loud Mouth Yasushi was trying to deal with all the stress of picking two candidates on his own.
While I'm on this subject, I think one of my criticisms for this arc has to be that they significantly dumbed down Serika. Needlessly too. |
2012-08-16, 18:56 | Link #472 |
AS Oji-kun
Join Date: Nov 2006
Age: 74
|
That's bothered me, too. Sometimes it feels like she's more of a comic relief character (all that business about eating and her growling stomach in particular) which doesn't fit with what we know about her professional career.
__________________
|
2012-08-16, 21:56 | Link #475 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: France
|
Just found The Right Stuff on catch-up TV. (still available till the end of the week to the subscribers of Canalsat cinema channels if other frenchies are interested)
That was amazing, yet too long. (They could have done a movie for Yeager and one for the Mercury 7 I think. I understand both of those plotlines showcase men with the "Right Stuff", but the plotlines are not entwined enough) Anyways, to stay on topic, Space Brother's breathing test was taken litterally from the movie (reading that here renewed my interest in a movie that was in my "must watch" list for years) but was there other scenes / tributes ? |
2012-08-17, 08:08 | Link #476 |
AS Oji-kun
Join Date: Nov 2006
Age: 74
|
What did Serika contribute to the test? She put herself in charge of the food and didn't manage it very well. Her professional skills were never on display either. There could have been an episode where one of her fellow candidates had a medical problem that she could resolve. She was a much more compelling character in the first round of testing than she has been during this last sequence.
__________________
|
2012-08-17, 08:42 | Link #477 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2009
Age: 30
|
Quote:
|
|
2012-08-17, 17:17 | Link #478 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2006
|
Actually, I think we see a lot of various Team A members contributing; it's simply that--as everyone else has already said more eloquently--the story is told via first- and third-person sympathetic narration techniques, so naturally, we know Mutta better than everyone else.
Serika often has the exact same instincts that Mutta does, and she has the luxury of not having to put herself on the line because he's there. But that doesn't mean she isn't recognizing and assessing the same problems--and coming up with the same solutions--that he is. Furuya himself solved the problem with tension that arose after he accidentally broke the glasses. And he did it in a humble, self-effacing way. I don't think he's a character who either was likeably unlikeable or suddenly became sympathetic. I think he's been likeable and interesting all along. In fact, the latest stuff with his correspondence with the professor is (just personally speaking) the least interesting material we've gotten about him, despite giving ostensible background. Nitta remained an enigma, but in a good way. And his thawing toward the group from his very early near-paranoia (specifically regarding the bio-response bracelets) to someone who quickly agrees with what might seem like a crazy plan because it is, for their group, the rational choice, is subtle and nuanced. Fukuda didn't do so much, but his friendship with Furuya helped that character to grow, and his calm, dignified approach grounded the team and provided a useful counterpoint to Mutta's (or Furuya's, for that matter) semi-spastic leadership. So I don't think that we can really say it's just Mutta doing everything for his group. I think that he was (again) lucky to get a group that he could work with, but that he also went out of his way to help people bond because, as GE mentioned, he does like people. And it isn't that he wants them to get along out of a neurotic fear of conflict, but because I think he wants to have fun and as part of that, wants others to have fun along with him (represented by his early loneliness about his hobby). Last edited by Doria; 2012-08-17 at 17:21. Reason: typo-palooza |
2012-08-19, 00:21 | Link #480 |
User of the "Fast Draw"
|
Well they mostly did. Know that Furuya and Mutta didn't for sure. That just leaves one more person out of the three. Also a confirm on Kenji not making it out of his group.
Surprised though that the picking of the ones who passed had this level of effect on the result. I mean they could just add as many as they want after, but those guys at least get a chance to go further. Spoiler for Ep22 Preview:
__________________
|
Tags |
science fiction, seinen |
|
|