AnimeSuki Forums

ahelo · 2014-05-08, 12:29

Personally the 2006 F/SN anime was one of the most mediocre anime I've ever watched. It's not the worst, just really mediocre. It's like when watching it, you know there's a huge potential but it just gets bogged down with terrible animation and terrible character interactions (well mostly when Shirou is on screen). Especially after watching Fate/Zero does F/SN become such a weird series to watch.

I'm super glad we're getting a remake. Now no one has to be compelled to watch the 2006 version.

Lenneth4 · 2014-05-08, 12:33

The blue scared girl , You should check Sword art online or chaos head.

Archon_Wing · 2014-05-08, 12:51

While Fate/Approximation 2006 had some entertaining moments, they were beset by a jumbled script and a distinct lack of animation and art more suitable for a 90s anime. It's certainly no Kanon 0.1 or Unlimited Cash-in Works but yea...

Thus when I said, I wanted to see Fate/Stay Night animated, the 2006 thingy doesn't really qualify as it being animated, beyond mere technicalities. That would be calling a bum wealthy because he technically owns some manner of wealth.

Also, the trailer is cleared up at least.

Shyni · 2014-05-08, 13:06

I actually rewatched the 2006 version recently, and yeah, it's lacking in the "animation" aspect, or at least tries too hard to compensate for that with excessive "camera" movement. The earliest episodes kinda gave me a headache with all the panning shots.

Sansker · 2014-05-08, 18:24

The first anime wasn't a master piece in terms of writing and animation but I like it overall. At least is less confusing than the movie, even if that one is a bit easier to watch on some parts. I have no particular appreciation for the VN so the changes in the adaptation don’t bother me as much but I agree the anime loses its grasp while trying to put everything in a single plot line. But overall was not that painful to watch. At least the animation has to be better now.

XFire · 2014-05-08, 18:32

A friend marathoned the dubbed anime with me once. Aside from a few funny scenes with Rin and Saber ("Well bleeaah to you too") we both agreed the best part was during the end when Rin and Shiro are standing in the road, because my friend got up and pantomined them being run over by a car.

ahelo · 2014-05-08, 21:56

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lenneth4

The blue scared girl , You should check Sword art online or chaos head.

Haha I don't get what your pointing at (or if I'm the one your pointing but I am the only one with the blue scared girl which is Ika Musume btw!!!) but since I watched those two, I will say they have nearly identical problems with Fate/Stay Night in which either something went wrong with the execution of the anime or the source material is really just not for me (though I don't think these two need remakes). And I'm really hoping for the former with F/SN because of VN hype and Fate/Zero.

You can't even excuse F/SN by saying it's an old anime so the animation is like that because it aired in the same year with stuff like Haruhi and Ouran which for me had some of the best animation shown in TV.

In short of my take which is the same as a lot of people: Did not like F/SN 2006 but am still really excited for the Remake because of F/Z and ufotable.

LoveYouSaber · 2014-05-09, 01:42

Is it just me or did the PV convey some serious tones. Is this a possible sign that we're going for HF route, which I hear is darker compared to the other two, or is it just Ufotable trying to sustain the same atmosphere with Fate/Zero regardless of the choice of routes...

When I watched the 2006 version, the Fate route shown there didn't convey this level of serious atmosphere.

cyberdemon · 2014-05-09, 01:47

Quote:

Originally Posted by LoveYouSaber

Is it just me or did the PV convey some serious tones. Is this a possible sign that we're going for HF route, which I hear is darker compared to the other two, or is it just Ufotable trying to sustain the same atmosphere with Fate/Zero regardless of the choice of routes...

When I watched the 2006 version, the Fate route shown there didn't convey this level of serious atmosphere.

I didn't see any hf scenes or scenes from any specific route. The presence of THAT grail though, even as a flashback to the fire, means it could have some prominence which it only does in hf.

Brother Coa · 2014-05-09, 05:38

Right now I only want for Kawai Kenji to direct the music again.

chaos_alfa · 2014-05-09, 06:20

Quote:

Originally Posted by Brother Coa

Right now I only want for Kenji Kawai to direct the music again.

It would be awesome if that happens, but I expect we will get Yuki Kajiura again. Not that Kajiura would be a bad choice, but I miss Kawai distinctive music style and I feel it would be fitting to have him compose for Fate/stay night again after having done the original.

Brother Coa · 2014-05-09, 07:05

For sure, I cannot imagine F/SN without tracks as Unmei No Yoru, Kishi Ou No Hokori and La Sola.

Shyni · 2014-05-09, 07:46

Yeah, I'd say those are the most important tracks. And of course, they'll do yet another version of Emiya.

MCAL · 2014-05-09, 09:22

http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x1t...80p_shortfilms

Another PV.

Brother Coa · 2014-05-09, 09:55

Saber is bada** as usual. Nice effects and quality is amazing as always.
So far it seems that Unfotable will deliver.

GreyZone · 2014-05-09, 09:57

lol... the background effects are missing.

chaos_alfa · 2014-05-09, 10:11

Quote:

Originally Posted by MCAL

http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x1t...80p_shortfilms

Another PV.

It feels like it goes too fast. I hope there are some more shots or frames added to that scene. It could also be the missing sound effect which make the scene feel weird.

Ougon · 2014-05-09, 10:35

Quote:

Originally Posted by Brother Coa

Saber is bada** as usual. Nice effects and quality is amazing as always.
So far it seems that Unfotable will deliver.

Definitely. I, for one, actually likes that speedy execution, because it really feels like the words from the VN are coming alive.

kakakka · 2014-05-09, 11:10

Quote:

Originally Posted by GreyZone

lol... the background effects are missing.

It says its a Demo Version.

Archon_Wing · 2014-05-09, 11:43

Quote:

Originally Posted by Brother Coa

Right now I only want for Kawai Kenji to direct the music again.

Yea really. Kaijura is good but if you hear enough of it, I just think "It's all the same shit!"

2014-05-08, 12:29	Link #501
ahelo Criminal Unrequitor Graphic Designer Join Date: Jul 2010	Personally the 2006 F/SN anime was one of the most mediocre anime I've ever watched. It's not the worst, just really mediocre. It's like when watching it, you know there's a huge potential but it just gets bogged down with terrible animation and terrible character interactions (well mostly when Shirou is on screen). Especially after watching Fate/Zero does F/SN become such a weird series to watch. I'm super glad we're getting a remake. Now no one has to be compelled to watch the 2006 version. __________________ Traveler on Revenge / Ahelo Sigs / Saimoe Report! Signature by ganbaru

2014-05-08, 12:33	Link #502
Lenneth4 Senior Member Join Date: Sep 2010 Location: Dakar Age: 39	The blue scared girl , You should check Sword art online or chaos head. __________________ http://lenneth4.deviantart.com/ http://hermannkayode.wix.com/star-and-light

2014-05-08, 18:24	Link #505
Sansker Manus ad Ferrum Join Date: Dec 2012 Location: Costa Rica Age: 33	The first anime wasn't a master piece in terms of writing and animation but I like it overall. At least is less confusing than the movie, even if that one is a bit easier to watch on some parts. I have no particular appreciation for the VN so the changes in the adaptation don’t bother me as much but I agree the anime loses its grasp while trying to put everything in a single plot line. But overall was not that painful to watch. At least the animation has to be better now. __________________

2014-05-08, 18:32	Link #506
XFire 150% done Join Date: Feb 2012	A friend marathoned the dubbed anime with me once. Aside from a few funny scenes with Rin and Saber ("Well bleeaah to you too") we both agreed the best part was during the end when Rin and Shiro are standing in the road, because my friend got up and pantomined them being run over by a car. __________________

2014-05-09, 09:57	Link #516
GreyZone "Senior" "Member" Join Date: Jan 2012	lol... the background effects are missing. __________________

2014-05-08, 13:06	Link #504
Shyni Senior Member Join Date: Jan 2013 Location: nowhere	I actually rewatched the 2006 version recently, and yeah, it's lacking in the "animation" aspect, or at least tries too hard to compensate for that with excessive "camera" movement. The earliest episodes kinda gave me a headache with all the panning shots.

2014-05-09, 01:42	Link #508
LoveYouSaber Senior Member Join Date: Aug 2008 Age: 36	Is it just me or did the PV convey some serious tones. Is this a possible sign that we're going for HF route, which I hear is darker compared to the other two, or is it just Ufotable trying to sustain the same atmosphere with Fate/Zero regardless of the choice of routes... When I watched the 2006 version, the Fate route shown there didn't convey this level of serious atmosphere.

2014-05-09, 05:38	Link #510
Brother Coa Banned Join Date: Aug 2013 Location: Holy Terra	Right now I only want for Kawai Kenji to direct the music again.

2014-05-09, 07:05	Link #512
Brother Coa Banned Join Date: Aug 2013 Location: Holy Terra	For sure, I cannot imagine F/SN without tracks as Unmei No Yoru, Kishi Ou No Hokori and La Sola.

2014-05-09, 07:46	Link #513
Shyni Senior Member Join Date: Jan 2013 Location: nowhere	Yeah, I'd say those are the most important tracks. And of course, they'll do yet another version of Emiya.

2014-05-09, 09:22	Link #514
MCAL Senior Member Join Date: Oct 2012	http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x1t...80p_shortfilms Another PV.

2014-05-09, 09:55	Link #515
Brother Coa Banned Join Date: Aug 2013 Location: Holy Terra	Saber is bada** as usual. Nice effects and quality is amazing as always. So far it seems that Unfotable will deliver.