2004-12-18, 00:19 | Link #61 | |
Member
Join Date: Aug 2004
|
Quote:
First point you made, you mentioned that there were no innovations with the chraracters and storylines. But if Shenon only published Naruto Gaiden first, you would probably thought Obito would be a "Naruto" type of people, but how did he end up? You were both generalizing and stereotyping. Then you pointed out how the series annoyed you with Naruto's goals and his incompetency. If you really think about it, he is only a kid! My guess is you are way past Naruto's age, so the cognitive levels are different. And also, you have to include the psychological difficulties, becuase sometimes they are the main factors that forced human to cause dramatical reactions. And from the third paragraph down............... are somewhat funny to me. You expect too much from a kid. Even Albert Einstein was treated as a learning disable when he was little, so what is wrong with Naruto being a little slow?(If you don't get what I mean, it's ok. What I mean is that there could be genius that are fools when they were little, and young geniuses may not be the best . Trees take time to grow, bulidings take time to construct.) Then towards to end, you were still complaining about the unrealistic of the story is, hell, if it's realistic, then it's not manga! And who should care what you think? They like Naruto, just as you like your opinions. |
|
2004-12-18, 01:06 | Link #62 |
ore wa kanpeki da
Join Date: Nov 2003
|
Let me respond to your post by agreeing with you that naruto is a lazy bum, but his character is consistent with his lazy ass. Naruto likes to power his way through everything including intelligence. The naruto way is not to give a shit and go all out.
He is like a car that can only operate in 5th gear, where as a good car like Neji knows how to perfect shift from 1st gear to 4th gear. But once naruto is in 5th gear no one can touch him. Everything you said is true. He was lazy in school, he sucked in the chuunin exams and so on but the essence of his character is to overcome his faults just by will alone and you shouldn't fault him for it. If he was perfect there wouldn't be anything to tell. |
2004-12-18, 01:57 | Link #63 | |
where you goin' bub?
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: lalaland
|
Quote:
But of course the agreement ends there. The fights Naruto gets in (however difficult or dauntless) aren't like the lottery. Sure there is money and unspeakable riches at stake, but how can you take something so vain and stack it up against the lives of your loved ones, and your integrity. In the Gaara vs Naruto debacle, Sakura was in serious danger. You can't expect the guy to just throw in the towel and walk away. Sure it's stupid to even try defeating a seemingly invincible opponent, but that's the concept of courage for you. It's knowing you're screwed over before you begin but doing it anyway because there are more important things at risk besides getting your arse to safety. Just one of the many themes Kishimoto-sensei is getting across. All this aside I say your building frustration for the character is quite justified. |
|
2004-12-19, 12:17 | Link #66 | |
Vandread
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: I LOVE NEW YORK cough* my ass cough*
Age: 37
|
Quote:
In reality however, no one gives a shit about what I think as long as I disagree with them. If I say Naruto is the bomb, I will get showered with congratulations, while if I say Naruto sux ass, they will either flame me or give me a page long "reasonable" arguements to counter me. What I'm really saying through all this is that there is no point in telling people why you don't like Naruto when the answer is obvious....at least thats my standing on this. P.S.- I don't think ebony was zealously bashing it because he actually gave a well supported/debatable arguement in stead of saying "Naruto suxors....." |
|
2004-12-19, 13:17 | Link #67 | |||
KAWAIII-III!!!! >^_^ >
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Magical land! (Magica-ru land!)
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
|||
2004-12-20, 02:43 | Link #68 | ||||||||||||||||||
Junior Member
Join Date: Dec 2004
|
It's probably harder to like this story when your real life has never had anything happen that compares to what happens to Naruto, making it a little harder to believe... Soooooooooo............. let's get this party started.
Quote:
[QUOTE=EbonySeraphim]Perhaps the biggest reason why Naruto annoys me is his drive to become stronger. He says he is gonna be a Hokage and is going to work really hard at it, but what work have we seen him put in thus far? He screwed around in school all the freggin time, and only trains when teachers have a new jutsu to teach him formally. What a lamer. He should really be trying to improve the jutsu he already knows because he almost never uses them correctly (the few he does), or he could be practicing general ninja arts like throwing weapons, taijutsu, and speed – traditional training like what Rock Lee does. Naruto’s shallow pursuit for power is to take the quickest way there through “uber 1337 jutsu” that he really shouldn’t be learning to become truly strong. If he can never use those jutsu properly, then he probably can fight people on his level with it, and is even further disadvantaged when using it against stronger people who exploit it in some way. You can also tell his impatience during the beginning of his trip with Jiraiya to get Tsunade when Naruto wanted him to hurry up and teach him and ultra-jutsu. In my opinion, Jiraiya teaching Naruto Rasengan was a mistake. He should still force Naruto to become better overall. Gamabunta summon was for Naruto’s protection – Rasengan was not. What sickens me about this is that they anime beefs up Naruto as if he really is strong, and really does work hard when clearly he puts average effort at the very best into what he does, has no talent, and still wins. At the same time, hard workers like Rock Lee lose, geniuses (and hard working too if you ask me) like Neji, and monsters like Gaara lose to him – All while Naruto is neither a genius nor hard worker. He’s just a “boy with a dream” with a “spirit that never dies.” That’s a very bad message to send to younger audiences as there are only two types of people that are successful in this world (maybe three or four). There are those that are geniuses, and those that word hard. One or the other will determine your success in life more than likely. It is also SLIGHTLY possible that luck will do it. The last possibility is inheriting success (wealth and status). As I said before, Naruto is not hard working and not a genius. He is possibly lucky, and perhaps you could call him an inheritor of success (Kyuubi). But luck and inheritance isn’t something people can strive to be/have. It just doesn’t work because luck is extremely rare, and inheritance is out of anyone’s control. Then who is Naruto inspiration for? Those with dreams with no talent to back it up, and not willing to put the real effort to work hard for it? No sympathies from me from that group. I don’t think there is anyone in the world that would support someone in such a group so when they is Naruto even a liked character?[quote] Well, you could call it luck, but to me it's more like unharnessed skill. It's like a warm-up before his real ability comes out, but in this case it's more like he can't control that real ability to full extent yet. If you do hate this luck/inheritance, then in a way, you hate most of the characters in this whole anime. All of the characters we know anything about have talents passed on from their family. Their inheritance. Only thing different is that everyone else has a much greater limit under full control, while Naruto only seems great when under pressure. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
It seems like what's being said in this anime, is to protect people whom are important to you and to protect your dreams. Strive to live for those you care about and for your dreams. It's not really a never give up thing... As for the empty promises you say Naruto makes, can't deny he had no way of being sure of what he was promising and they were quite empty. However, Naruto doesn't like to see others worried or distressed. Even if he couldn't possibly be hold those promises without a doubt, he made them to give courage and strength to others, and at the same time to give himself another reason to be strong. It's just the kind of person Naruto is. Perfect situation for Naruto to win again and again... well, I can sum that up in a few words. Welcome to the world of anime. The unbelievable; the unprobable; the impossible. They're all factors of most animes. Don't mistake me for someone that loves everything in Naruto. I've agreed with some of the points you've made and said that, and I even have a few small details I could add, but I've left out since I'm standing on the Pro-Naruto side in this discussion. It's just that I can't get nearly enough hate or dislike of Naruto to overpower my like of him, lose interest in the anime/manga/story/Naruto himself, or have this urge to kill Naruto(or at least see him killed)... |
||||||||||||||||||
2004-12-20, 12:37 | Link #69 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2004
|
Allrigty, I didn't bother reading this whole thread, but man; You are a looser. Who and why would you complain about an anime/manga so much? It's a fucking cartoon you moron. If you don't like it no ones forcing you to watch it, why would you waste your time posting it here. In the long run Kishimoto, and whatever animation studio is animating this won't give a shit. This whole thread was stupid. Why would you complain about Naruto, and how he does everything in a certain pattren when the series is NARUTO. Are you special abled?
Every freaking story has a pattern to events. I'm sure all the annoying brats who complain about the similarities between DBZ and Naruto had probabbly at one point started watching DBZ, thought "Oh holy crap what a sweet anime" then as the episodes moved on, like any free-loading asshole complained it wasnt up to standard. What standard!? You're watching free fansubs asshole! There is no standard! Your opinion on the topic doesn't matter at all because you don't pay for it! I know my post is harsh, and some type of punitive action will be taken against me/it, but, it had to be said. |
2004-12-20, 13:36 | Link #70 | |
日本語を食べません!
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: San Francisco
Age: 41
|
Quote:
People over-analyze this series all the time (myself included). IMHO, that's what makes this forum so enjoyable. Just look at the Neji/Rasengan thread involving atomic bonding, vaccum/pressure, and compression of energy. The Byakugan/Sharingan thread where we analyze dominant/recessive traits. I too am losing interest in the series, and I expect I'm not alone. Right now, in the episode thread, people are sh*tting all over the concept of super-pills and super-seals that exponentially increase strength. The new message is clear - power > skill. A far cry from the first major arc in which Zabuza (a character almost universally seen to be seen as inferior to Kakashi) manages to beat Kakashi by outsmarting him (Water trap bubble) and two Genins (VASTLY inferior) free their mentor by outsmarting the experienced Mist ninja. Shikamaru beats Temari by out-thinking her. What happened to that series? Now, we get a series of seals making you 5x stronger, a pill that makes you 10x stronger, a new seal that makes you 20x stronger... |
|
2004-12-20, 13:55 | Link #71 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2003
|
Quote:
|
|
2004-12-20, 13:56 | Link #72 |
Senior Member
|
grrrrrrrrr *tackles person that created thread* NARUTO IS ADORBILE SO DON'T INSULT HIM!!! hmph! meanie! *huggles Naruto plushy* He's the stupidest most immature most adorible character in the whole series! And one of the most kick ass when things get tough...
|
2004-12-20, 13:58 | Link #73 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2003
|
I dunno, sure, some battles boil down to using a new pill/seal level/demon level to get stronger. But some battles revolve around having a style that beats your opponent's style, or outsmarting them. It would be just as hackneyed if EVERY battle came down to outwitting an otherwise vastly superior opponent. The reminder that power is important too seems welcome to me.
Let's look at the last 6 battles: Chouji vs Jiroubu: Battle of the powerups. Neji vs. Kidoumaru: Neji beats a superior opponent by determination and exploitation of a weakness in his technique. Kiba vs. Sakon: Kiba stalls a vastly superior opponent by exploiting a weakness in his primary technique, and then outsmarting him as he ran away. He thus wears away enough of his chakra for Sakon to get his ass kicked when reinforcements arrived. Shikamaru vs. Tayuya: Shikamaru stays competitive with and stalls a vastly superior opponent by outsmarting her. She is then beaten by Temari, who is also probably vastly inferior, but wins because her style is a weakness for Tayuya's style. Gaara/Lee vs Iforgethisname: Victory by illness. Naruto vs Sasuke: battle of the powerups That's only 2 of six that are all about power levels....not too bad for a manga. |
2004-12-20, 14:02 | Link #74 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2003
|
Quote:
my fav match in the manga is definitely shikamaru.. although his skills sucks to the core |
|
2004-12-20, 23:12 | Link #75 |
Phat Poster/Thread Killer
|
Yare yare. Too much stuff to reply to, but I'll leave a general word for a lot of people that have been screaming this to me:
"Naruto is only 12 years old!!!" - I don't give a damn. He is also an anime character where expectations are just a bit higher than the real world. You could even compare him to his peers (Sasuke and Shikamaru) in his world who are also his age and are far more competent (and in Shika's case especially - mature). Just about everyone else except Naruto shows much more maturity and level-headedness. I also repeat - he is an anime character where expectations from him are a lot higher. If they feel this 12 year old can be out on the battlefield in life or death situations, then he better be damn mature enough to handle himself appropriately when a(and his) life and mission is on the line. Trying to defend him because of his age is completely baseless, so enough with it.
__________________
|
2004-12-21, 03:17 | Link #76 | |
Cool as a Cucumber
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Holland
|
Quote:
People like Kimmimaro and the CS2 completely disrupts the series Balance, a balance which was carefully introduced and was rather perfect I might add. Also the fact that these genins posses ludicrious powers doesn't help. It a shame really, and I can only hope that what little we have seen in the Gaiden, in which raw power plays a minor part and stealth and swift action does. Will continue in the main story when the gaiden ends.
__________________
|
|
2004-12-21, 03:32 | Link #77 | |
日本語を食べません!
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: San Francisco
Age: 41
|
Quote:
I can't possibly think of how Temari used a good amount of brainpower in defeating Tayuya, what with the Super-wind attack and the summon. Same with Kankurou - one quick capture and it was all over... Gaara most definitely did not favor brains over power in his battle with Kimimaro. |
|
2004-12-21, 14:09 | Link #78 |
cho~ kakkoii
Moderator
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: 3rd Planet
|
BOOO.. BOOO to the few folks who quoted Ebony's entire post unnecessarily so they could write couple of l33t sentences in response. Some of the replies are harsh indeed without any constructive counter argument. Then again, it is very difficult to make sensible counter argument in two to three sentences. Those few responses have provided the glimpse of evolution, yes I am talking about of the infamous "power-up", from extreme Naruto fanatics to Narutards. So I will conclude my post with another round of BOOOOOOOOOOOO BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!
P.S. Nice reply Chaoticabyss. + rep..
__________________
|
2004-12-21, 16:33 | Link #79 | |
Member of the Year 2004!
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: "And if thou doest not well, _Sin_ lieth at the door."- Genesis 4:7
Age: 39
|
Quote:
|
|
2004-12-21, 17:14 | Link #80 |
Eyebrows...
Join Date: May 2004
Age: 37
|
Lately it seems like Shikamaru alone embodies the intelligent ninja fights, and everybody else just takes their biggest powers and butts heads. I agree that it's getting a little tiresome. This gaiden does seem to be more on the right path, and I truly hope that Kishimoto has gotten it all out of his system after the Chase Sasuke arc.
|
|
|