(L) Fairy Tail Manga Discussion Thread

[immblueversion]

Originally Posted by MAX_COLA_POWER!

I'm happy if this turns out to be true. We dodged a Kishimoto bullet.

Would've appreciated it if you used the tag... I know what you mean by Kishimoto...

[Kafriel]

Spoiler for 429:

Feet licking just became a whole lot scarier...and going for a kill so fast, these guys mean srs business. I'd say it's rather out of place for FT where there's always a joke around he corner (especially when Lucy's involved) but it's not bad. Gray saves the day like a bawss

[Starway]

Spoiler for Spolier:

I wish erza didn't come back the manga was fine without her and again someone's new look is change back to normal right away if your just going to change it back way bother changeling it at all. also anyone else see those veins on natsu on page 13 can you even get veins that go from your face all the way down to your neck not sure how I feel with gray being good all along makes the last 5 odd chapters pointless and again I really didn't what to see erza.

[Ultragunner]

is goat tongue that sharp? I never knew

[immblueversion]

Well that happened.

Now the thing I want to know is, why would Gray kill Frosch? It has to be more than just some random lie Future Rogue made up because he was evil; Present Rogue and Gray have had virtually zero interaction with each other as far as I can tell, so there must be a reason. And I doubt that the future has changed to the point that Frosch survives, because Future Rogue came from a time when the Eclipse Gate was closed and the invasion of 10,000 dragons was successfully averted (only Acnologia alone managed to take over the world). So just what will happen?

[Ultragunner]

yay, I forgot that we have a double issue this week

Spoiler for chap 430:

I'm scared of what Juvia might do if she saw Gray and Lucy in this chapter

[G147]

Originally Posted by Ultragunner

yay, I forgot that we have a double issue this week

Spoiler for chap 430:

I'm scared of what Juvia might do if she saw Gray and Lucy in this chapter

Spoiler for 430:

Love rival and war breakout.

[Slayerx]

Originally Posted by immblueversion

Now the thing I want to know is, why would Gray kill Frosch?

Spoiler:

Ya that's the only little hitch in here. Gray not being evil and just putting on an act to infiltrate avatar? All that is fine. in fact i find it preferable than dealing with all the melodrama of Gray turning evil... but that one tidbit about Frosch feels like a minor plothole. Though i guess its plenty possible that Gray could have killed him by accident or something.

[Marcus H.]

And the "Dragon Force" resounds in the hearts of everyone!
Good to have to the core five fighting again, although I'm not expecting them to win.

That said, I have yet to read the Tartaros Arc. >_<

[DOmus]

Originally Posted by Slayerx

Spoiler:

Ya that's the only little hitch in here. Gray not being evil and just putting on an act to infiltrate avatar? All that is fine. in fact i find it preferable than dealing with all the melodrama of Gray turning evil... but that one tidbit about Frosch feels like a minor plothole. Though i guess its plenty possible that Gray could have killed him by accident or something.

Maybe Avatar manages to do its sacrifice and Gray tries to stop them, and then a twist happens and his power run amock, then while fighting, Frosch dies(Rogue still goes to fight Avatar).

[MAX_COLA_POWER!]

Accidental kill was probably the logical course, after all, we don't know if Future Rogue's timeline had the battle with Tartaros or not, so, instead of worrying about that little tidbit, let us all enjoy the thorough whoopin these Avatar dorks will receive, though I wouldn't be surprised that after this fight is over, the main branch leader of the group would be revealed to be a strong person.

[Blueknight78]

Originally Posted by immblueversion

Well that happened.

Now the thing I want to know is, why would Gray kill Frosch? It has to be more than just some random lie Future Rogue made up because he was evil; Present Rogue and Gray have had virtually zero interaction with each other as far as I can tell, so there must be a reason. And I doubt that the future has changed to the point that Frosch survives, because Future Rogue came from a time when the Eclipse Gate was closed and the invasion of 10,000 dragons was successfully averted (only Acnologia alone managed to take over the world). So just what will happen?

the future which f. rogue was a "alternative future, and the current timeline is another, in his timeline no dragons passed from the gate, the gate was closed before any dragon had chance to come, in this timeline only 7 dragons passed instead of 10000, the current timeline is a mix of both futures, f.lucy future and f.rogue future, in the moment f.rogue and f.lucy come they already changed the future and he speaking to natsu also change the future.

[immblueversion]

Originally Posted by Blueknight78

the future which f. rogue was a "alternative future, and the current timeline is another, in his timeline no dragons passed from the gate, the gate was closed before any dragon had chance to come, in this timeline only 7 dragons passed instead of 10000, the current timeline is a mix of both futures, f.lucy future and f.rogue future, in the moment f.rogue and f.lucy come they already changed the future and he speaking to natsu also change the future.

Yes, but the crisis was averted either way and Acnologia is still out there, so Future Rogue's timeline is likely the closest to the current timeline. Future Rogue may have told Natsu, but he kept it to himself all this time until just a few chapters ago, so not even Gray knows he'll kill Frosch (assuming Natsu didn't already tell him off-screen). Natsu may have stopped Present Rogue now, but who's to say that would lead to the moment where Frosch is put in danger? Or maybe Frosch will end up being endangered by someone else.

[MAX_COLA_POWER!]

Originally Posted by immblueversion

Yes, but the crisis was averted either way and Acnologia is still out there, so Future Rogue's timeline is likely the closest to the current timeline. Future Rogue may have told Natsu, but he kept it to himself all this time until just a few chapters ago, so not even Gray knows he'll kill Frosch (assuming Natsu didn't already tell him off-screen). Natsu may have stopped Present Rogue now, but who's to say that would lead to the moment where Frosch is put in danger? Or maybe Frosch will end up being endangered by someone else.

Blue, as a friend, I tell you this with the utmost care and respect: drop this whole timeline thing before you hurt yourself. Hiro will come back to it if and when he comes back to it. Gray isn't evil, Frosch is saved for the time being, laughs and cheers all around. Now let's go back to the beatdown this branch of Avatar will bring shall we?

[Blueknight78]

Originally Posted by immblueversion

Yes, but the crisis was averted either way and Acnologia is still out there, so Future Rogue's timeline is likely the closest to the current timeline. Future Rogue may have told Natsu, but he kept it to himself all this time until just a few chapters ago, so not even Gray knows he'll kill Frosch (assuming Natsu didn't already tell him off-screen). Natsu may have stopped Present Rogue now, but who's to say that would lead to the moment where Frosch is put in danger? Or maybe Frosch will end up being endangered by someone else.

he keep only in secret how frosh died, but he warned rogue about f.rogue and avoid turn evil, this already another future change point unless f.rogue ploted this to really make natsu warn his future and that is could be what triggered rogue turn in evil, but, current rogue is aware of the bad future then is more hard for him to be corrupted on this point or will be a choice rater than a moment of despair.

[Trax]

Perhaps in that alternate timeline, Zeref did actually appear and Gray's curse went out of control or something?

I also can't help but wonder about his obsession with the Book of End, was that very good acting or was it genuine? It sure convinced the members of Avatar...

[~Yami~]

Spoiler for 429-430:

That goat torture... I can't believe that it is actually a real torture weapon

well, it is not like we didn't see it incoming
Gray as spy... but Erza's involvement is quite unexpected.. I really think she already joined Crime Sorciere
well.. the old gang is back.. now wait until Gajeel and Levy started to enter the scene.. and Juvia+Wendy rushed to destroy those Zeref's minions

[Kafriel]

About Frosch, it may be one of those figurative kills where Gray has to take certain actions that lead to Frosch dying, making it a "you might as well have killed him yourself" situation...Mashima is above such petty dodges, but when you have the power to conceive a character like Jellal, anything is possible!

[Blueknight78]

about the goat torture, actually looks like real, this is also mentioned in spice and wolf, in the second half of the first season or was on one ova, well nora speak about it to laurence or was to horo i don't recall now.

must be really painfull lol.

here the confirmation about 8 chapters in 5 weeks

Spoiler:

[Wandering Soul]

Feet licking now sounds a lot more scary than it usually does. I had no idea a goat's tongue could do that.