Mahouka Koukou no Rettousei LN - Archived Discussion

[TonyC1994]

Originally Posted by anonfr

onii...chan? not Onii-Sama?! Blasphemer!

Oh shoot... How the heck did I make such a mistake?
I swear this has never happen to me before.

Though the image of Miyuki saying Oni-Chan....hehehe, so moe.

[anonfr]

Originally Posted by TonyC1994

Oh shoot... How the heck did I make such a mistake?
I swear this has never happen to me before.

Though the image of Miyuki saying Oni-Chan....hehehe, so moe.

You may not know it, but I'm judging you. My face has judgement alll over it.

[Hokoga]

Originally Posted by anonfr

It's safe friend *soothing voice* All is well now. It's safe to come out.



onii...chan? not Onii-Sama?! Blasphemer!

I see I'm not the only one who took note of TonyC1994's mistake.

[TonyC1994]

Originally Posted by anonfr

You may not know it, but I'm judging you. My face has judgement alll over it.

Hahaha ahhhh....

*attempts to delete last comment*

[HasNoLove]

Originally Posted by fujin of shadows

Please, not another RomeoXJuliet ending or another guilty crown or Code Geass Ending.....

altough in the end lelouch still alive and travelin around the world with C.C....

[TonyC1994]

Originally Posted by HasNoLove

altough in the end lelouch still alive and travelin around the world with C.C....

Actually that's up for debate but I'm definitely not doing it here.

[anonfr]

Originally Posted by Hokoga

I see I'm not the only one who took note of TonyC1994's mistake.

Aha!

Originally Posted by TonyC1994

Hahaha ahhhh....

*attempts to delete last comment*

You can't hide the shame.

Originally Posted by TonyC1994

Actually that's up for debate but I'm definitely not doing it here.

Whenever and where ever you do have that debate, let me spectate. I'm interested in "Lelouch lives" theories.

[TonyC1994]

Originally Posted by anonfr

Aha!



You can't hide the shame.



Whenever and where ever you do have that debate, let me spectate. I'm interested in "Lelouch lives" theories.

I usually tend to avoid these types of debates since they are way to open for interpretations. Any evidence that can be provided are generally just assumptions or are the subjective perception of the arguer.

[hakazee]

Originally Posted by Okashira

Hmmm... Not, it's not like that, I think? Tomitsuka "knight" attitude makes him more or less respected by some people, it has been hinted that Ami & Chiaki kinda like him (the second one seems to be unaware of that, though); the narration even hints that he might have even more fans Tomitsuka himself hasn't shown clear interest on anyone, but his easily embarrassed nature can send the wrong signal to a girl.

It's time for the shota bloom, I think?

Oh, and I feel that he can be Tatsuya's friend, but perhaps unilaterally (as him, Tomitsuka respecting him and Tatsuya been wry about it )

My mistake.
So Tomitsuka doesn't show love interest to anyone right now.

Let's see if there will be love triangle drama between Tomitsuka, Chiaki, and Ami in the next 9SC.

Originally Posted by fujin of shadows

Please, not another RomeoXJuliet ending or another guilty crown or Code Geass Ending.....

Or Valvrave ending.

Ehmm GC, CG, and Valvrave was written by the same person.

[anonfr]

Originally Posted by TonyC1994

I usually tend to avoid these types of debates since they are way to open for interpretations. Any evidence that can be provided are generally just assumptions or are the subjective perception of the arguer.

Even if it's all just supposition of ad hominem arguments, it can still be interesting from the vantage of a spectator. But yeah, that's one topic I will never join in on. I will discuss the viability of the theories to be used in credible fan fiction though.

[TonyC1994]

Originally Posted by anonfr

Even if it's all just supposition of ad hominem arguments, it can still be interesting from the vantage of a spectator. But yeah, that's one topic I will never join in on. I will discuss the viability of the theories to be used in credible fan fiction though.

Agreed, you should of seen the Phantom: Requiem for the Phantom ending debate I participated in, interesting but biggest waste of time ever.


Anyway, does anyone have any good Mahouka topic? Preferably, non-shipping ones please. Got to at least have a 3-5 day period in between shipping wars so we don't suffer to many casualties.

[anonfr]

Originally Posted by TonyC1994

Agreed, you should of seen the Phantom: Requiem for the Phantom ending debate I participated in, interesting but biggest waste of time ever.


Anyway, does anyone have any good Mahouka topic? Preferably, non-shipping ones please. Got to at least have a 3-5 day period in between shipping wars so we don't suffer to many casualties.

Hmmm. How about a time table on when we'll interact with the rest of the 10 families?

Or if we'll get to see deeper into all the families and their infrastructure. OR if there will be any more flashbacks on the past of the Yotsuba clan. I'll take a whole volume of side stories if they star Yotsuba Genzou being awesome.

Btw I am fully convinced Yotsuba Genzou is the genetic source of Tatsuya's awesomeness. In the debate of whether or not Miyuki or Tatsuya was truly a yotsuba or some adopted/clone child, I said Miyuki was the fake yotsuba, because Tatsuya has to be related to Genzou.

[TonyC1994]

Originally Posted by anonfr

Hmmm. How about a time table on when we'll interact with the rest of the 10 families?

Or if we'll get to see deeper into all the families and their infrastructure. OR if there will be any more flashbacks on the past of the Yotsuba clan. I'll take a whole volume of side stories if they star Yotsuba Genzou being awesome.

Btw I am fully convinced Yotsuba Genzou is the genetic source of Tatsuya's awesomeness. In the debate of whether or not Miyuki or Tatsuya was truly a yotsuba or some adopted/clone child, I said Miyuki was the fake yotsuba, because Tatsuya has to be related to Genzou.

Oh nice!
Speaking of Yotsuba flashbacks, I desperately want to see one involving Tatsuya and Miya's interaction before the experiment. (I've actually repeated this many times before, sorry). I don't know why but it just seems so interesting to me. Like did she love her son at all? I remember Miyuki commenting on how Miya seemed to be sufferring for not being able to love her son.

And on Genzou, that's a pretty interesting theory.

[anonfr]

Originally Posted by TonyC1994

Oh nice!
Speaking of Yotsuba flashbacks, I desperately want to see one involving Tatsuya and Miya's interaction before the experiment. (I've actually repeated this many times before, sorry). I don't know why but it just seems so interesting to me. Like did she love her son at all? I remember Miyuki commenting on how Miya seemed to be sufferring for not being able to love her son.

And on Genzou, that's a pretty interesting theory.

I think she loved her son. I always got the impression that she did the experiment to save him. When it didn't work she probably just lost heart.

and thank you!

[hakazee]

Originally Posted by TonyC1994

Anyway, does anyone have any good Mahouka topic? Preferably, non-shipping ones please. Got to at least have a 3-5 day period in between shipping wars so we don't suffer to many casualties.

I'm waiting for Mizuki's family background.
We don't know anything about her background, whether she's unimportant chara or maybe there is something.

Since She's also the second person ( after Mayumi ) to greet Tatsuya in the first day.

[Echizen777]

Originally Posted by TonyC1994

Oh nice!
Speaking of Yotsuba flashbacks, I desperately want to see one involving Tatsuya and Miya's interaction before the experiment. (I've actually repeated this many times before, sorry). I don't know why but it just seems so interesting to me. Like did she love her son at all? I remember Miyuki commenting on how Miya seemed to be sufferring for not being able to love her son.

And on Genzou, that's a pretty interesting theory.

I think she loved him but only before learning that he was a BS magician. She got an arranged marriage with someone who was cheating on her, and after that she learns that his child can't use normal magic... Used him as a guinea pig and his only proud of his intelligence.

About Tatsuya and Miyuki I don't think they could not be siblings, Miyuki clearly has the genes of her mother, Tatsuya is the first son so, he is definitely a Yotsuba.

I doubt Tatsuya loved her either, he became emotionless by her fault but even in this state he somewhat cared about Honami, you would think he would care for his mother too but no, he was completely indifferent to her. She probably never gave him motherly love, I am sure it pained him but it was only before the operation.

[pampz21]

Originally Posted by fujin of shadows

The greatest thing that defines Tatsuya as a character is his magic...If he loses that, then has fallen from grace. How can he become a CEO of a CAD manufacturing company without magic at his disposal and how can he change society for the better if he himself is not capable of magic.

Also, the magic of the Yotsuba is different from the other.

Miyuki's outer-systematic magic is different from her mother. Miya's magic cannot be duplicated, even if it's her daughter.

How do you think Tatsuya have been creating new magic? His magic abilities sucks.

How can you be sure that Miyuki didnt inherite Miya's magic and how can you be sure that Tatsuya cant help develop the same or mostly the same as Miya?

If Tatsuya can remember the experiment;he might remember the activation/magic sequence.

Originally Posted by anonfr

I think she loved her son. I always got the impression that she did the experiment to save him. When it didn't work she probably just lost heart.

and thank you!

I doubt she loved her children from the bottom of her heart. She was already broken the moment she used magic on Maya; she was supposed to be the head afterall.

Originally Posted by hakazee

I'm waiting for Mizuki's family background.
We don't know anything about her background, whether she's unimportant chara or maybe there is something.

Since She's also the second person ( after Mayumi ) to greet Tatsuya in the first day.

Mizuki's family have been stated to be a normal family, shes the normal moe of the cast.

[Lucarion]

Originally Posted by TonyC1994

Oh we're discussing endings, sweet. Alright here's mine.

Tatsuya and Miyuki in a situation where they both die together holding hands. Before that, Tatsuya managed to completely change how Magicians are viewed, not as tools but as human beings.

Basically all my endings include Tatsuya sacrificing himself in one way or another. My reason is because characters that powerful usually die in stories. Though it's hard to imagine Miyuki without her precious Oni-chan, so I'd like to have them go together.

Though I'm all for a happy ending too

I pray it never goes there, but this is definitely a real possibility. Especially with how often Tatsuya says "No one can harm me"--that's usually a flag for someone destined to fall in an ironic manner.

If Tatsuya does fall in the end, I'm betting it will be by the hands of someone completely unremarkable. Adds an extra bite to the whole scene. The powerful Shiba Tatsuya brought down by a chump. Like Achilles being brought down by Paris, Balder by a twig of mistletoe, or like Xiang Yu being brought down by Liu Bang.

But I'd REALLY prefer he turn into the Supreme Lord of East Asia.

[Lucarion]

Originally Posted by anonfr

Hmmm. How about a time table on when we'll interact with the rest of the 10 families?

Or if we'll get to see deeper into all the families and their infrastructure. OR if there will be any more flashbacks on the past of the Yotsuba clan. I'll take a whole volume of side stories if they star Yotsuba Genzou being awesome.

Btw I am fully convinced Yotsuba Genzou is the genetic source of Tatsuya's awesomeness. In the debate of whether or not Miyuki or Tatsuya was truly a yotsuba or some adopted/clone child, I said Miyuki was the fake yotsuba, because Tatsuya has to be related to Genzou.

FINALLY! Someone as fascinated with Genzou as I am. Yeah, I agree, Genzou's probably the family member I've seen that is most similar to Tatsuya. Heck, I'm even going so far as to speculate that if we ever got a chance to see what the old man looked like we'd probably see more similarities between him and his monstrous grandson than with the boy and his father Tatsurou.

Also, I think the biggest irony in the whole Yotsuba household is that Tatsuya, as much he or anyone wants to deny it, definitely thinks and acts the most like a Yotsuba. More than Miyuki, he seems to embody all of their ideals.

[anonfr]

Originally Posted by pampz21

I doubt she loved her children from the bottom of her heart. She was already broken the moment she used magic on Maya; she was supposed to be the head afterall.

It's completely subjective and left open to interpretation though. We know how she ended up, we know the path that got her started, but everything in the middle is unknown. I think that experiment with Tatsuya is the straw that broke the camels back. I think she sincerely wanted to make him "better" but ended up figuratively murdering her own son the same way she "killed" her own sister. This is how I chose to think about it at least.

But this is my opinion on an unconfirmed issue. There's not really a right or wrong in this sort of thing.

Originally Posted by Lucarion

FINALLY! Someone as fascinated with Genzou as I am. Yeah, I agree, Genzou's probably the family member I've seen that is most similar to Tatsuya. Heck, I'm even going so far as to speculate that if we ever got a chance to see what the old man looked like we'd probably see more similarities between him and his monstrous grandson than with the boy and his father Tatsurou.

Also, I think the biggest irony in the whole Yotsuba household is that Tatsuya, as much he or anyone wants to deny it, definitely thinks and acts the most like a Yotsuba. More than Miyuki, he seems to embody all of their ideals.

Yes, Yes, and YES to all of that. We're in complete agreement.