Rate That Signature!

[Azrael_Azure]

Kira lacusXX - Nice contrast of black on white. Really pretty picture. 10/10

Kira Naruto- 8.5/10 The background looks a little busy, but I love the character images.

Cyz- Sexy, and interesting. 9.3/10

[Cyz]

Azrael_Azure: the pic is a little bright and I don't see the main theme for it. Plus, it doesn't seem to have an border around it. 6/10

--> New sig. This was cropped and edited by KiNa. I know blonde is Arceuid but I don't know who the blue-haired one is.

[leofish]

Cyz - the composition is very nice. The blue complements the orange tones creating a pleasing color selection. The eye movement from Arceuid to the text beneath the image really boosts the entire effect of the sig also. only negative is that to my eyes the rendering of the box doesn't quite match the style of the characters, thus theres a little tension between to two parts of the image. other than that, very cute and effective. 9/10

finnaly got around to making a touka sig after finishing uta 2-3 weeks ago :X

[Faeyice]

Cyz:A very cute signature. Igive it a 9.8.

[shinobiknight0]

7/10, it's a little too overcrowded and the image quality isn't so great. I'm not so crazy about Yu Gi Oh anything though.

[Cyz]

leofish: mmhmm, Touka looks really good in there. The bg designs are nice too. You could put the pic a little down so we can see her whole face 9/10
Ai Suzuki: Too crowded IMO and it's a little dark too. But points for having Dark Magician Girl on it 7/10
shinobiknight0: I think it's better if the img is a little close. The dark made the img even harder to see. 7/10

[KiNA]

@ Azrael .. Can I call you that? Anyway crop sig .. would be better if you include full eyes =/

@ leofish .. the eyes getting cut was your failure.. half eye is bad >.< .. lower her a bit please .. BG is lovely .. get a smaller border .. or at least a bit transparent =/

@ shinobiknight ... I post my analysis (sort of) in that other thread =/

@ Ai .. Too crowded @_@

@ Cyz .. finally, how do it feel to use your own creation .. btw, blue haired girl = ren ... I've put their name in the filename, didnt I ^^

Anyway .. >.< Promoting my sig analysis/discussion thread again >.<

Dont rate my sig =/ in the 1st incarnation .. better one (sort of) in my thread

[Cyz]

Originally Posted by Kira_Naruto

@ Cyz .. finally, how do it feel to use your own creation .. btw, blue haired girl = ren ... I've put their name in the filename, didnt I ^^

Well, I didn't create the pic and didn't do the transparency thingy (it was you btw - thanx btw). So, I basically didn't do anything at all except resizing it. Oh..and who's Ren? I know the blue-haired girl..but need a info link or just a small description will do because I don't remember seeing her in the Tsukihime anime.

Tsukuyomi: That's one scary sig. A little late for Halloween no? 7/10

[Phelddagrif]

Cyz - I want. It's indescribably cute. In fact, I think I'll save it. 8.7/10

[Klashikari]

*is refraining himself, avoiding some too deep comments ~~*
@Azrael_Azure : the signature lacks of some mood/subject, while the zoom isn't bad (though like kina said, full eyes would be a plus). 6/10

@Cyz : very cute, though it's too bad that the top hair is cut.
also, the arcueid right ear isn't really smooth : are there cut leftover? 8,5/10

@leofish : either way, you should shrink touka picture, or displace it a little bit to the bottom (like already said, it should be better if touka's face isn't cropped.)
also, i dunno, but i feel something wrong, despite the sig quality. probably the font. 8/10

@AI suzuki : No comment...

@shinobiknight0 : something... funny is left on the bottom of the sig. i will agree with cyz : the picture is a bit small, and with the dark, it is rather hard to determine what's happening etc.
the signature could be slightly cut at the edges, and the font isn't really suiting it. 7.5/10

@phelddagrif : the image quality is a bit low (aliasing and graininess around). also, the BG are a bit contradictory, and don't fits Ed :s. last note : edward elric is really hard to read, especially the "elric" 7.5/10

[Cyz]

Originally Posted by Klashikari

@Cyz : very cute, though it's too bad that the top hair is cut. also, the arcueid right ear isn't really smooth : are there cut leftover? 8,5/10

Her hair looks like that even in the original pic. So I don't think her top hair was cut. As for the right ear, that's not cut left over. Look closely at her left ear. See? it has hair too.

Phelddagrif: I agree with Klashikari. The bg doesn't seem to fit Ed. 7/10

[Klashikari]

Originally Posted by Cyz

Her hair looks like that even in the original pic. So I don't think her top hair was cut. As for the right ear, that's not cut left over. Look closely at her left ear. See? it has hair too.

i see... i guess the problem is the edge then : the black line became realy thin, so instead, it gives some impression that the top hair was cut.

as for the right ear, i wasn't talking about the hair between the ear and the top hair, but the very ear itself : just like the top ear, the ear wasn't really cut smoothly, so the line was slightly cropped. XD

but this is really minor, of course ^^

[Spectacular_Insanity]

Phelddagrif: Meh. I've seen better FMA sigs. 6/10

[Ending]

@ Cyz: That's pretty fun sig to watch and the transparency fits in too.

@ Klashikari: Slightly too big and slightly too messy to my taste. You could remove some of the text inside and outside the pic.

@ Azrael_Azure: You need to sharpen the pic, add borders, and use less compression. The artifacts are a bit too obvious.

[CXC]

Klashikari: nice... 8.5/10

Cyz: Hey... Their gonna eat my mouse! XD 8.9/10

Shinobiknight0: Looks kool... 8.6/10

This here is one of my newest but the file was too big to use so i'll post it.
What do you guys tink of it...

[Klashikari]

EDIT : hem, i can't see the signature ^^;

[shinobiknight0]

Originally Posted by Klashikari

@shinobiknight0 : something... funny is left on the bottom of the sig. i will agree with cyz : the picture is a bit small, and with the dark, it is rather hard to determine what's happening etc.
the signature could be slightly cut at the edges, and the font isn't really suiting it. 7.5/10

I think it had a problem uploading cuz at the bottom, I didn't have that part of the sig there.

[kira_lacusXX]

shinobiknight0 - yeah I can't really make out what's happening, but i guess thats just the way it is, with the dark theme, which is nice. Th bottom doesn't seem to fit =/ I like the font though =)

CXC - I can't see the one you posted so I'll just comment the one you have now. I like the left side, but the right side doesnt really blend and it's pretty bare. Again I do really like the left though, pink is cool =)

Cyz - quality is great! and can you say cute xD? love it (yay to KiNa)

[Cyz]

Wordplay: Nice sig. She looks like from MMORPG or something. 8/10

-> Sig edited by KiNa again. This time, he put my name on it Thanx KiNa

[KiNA]

@ Cyz .. If only I have the time to do a vector on the original >.<

@ Wordplay.. You and Manti never change sig Kudos ^^

@ KiNA .. Please refrain from long ass winded bashing in here *looks at Klashikari* ... save it for the other thread