2007-01-03, 12:21 | Link #201 |
My name? But my name is..
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Germany
|
Which ending would satisfy the crowd out there?
I wouldn't be satisfied if Yuuichi chose a girl whom he pities. Which reduces the chances of Shiori as well as Nayuki - even when he finds out what Nayuki feels for him he never felt the same for her so far, she was clearly less important to him than Ayu. I would rather want to see Yuuichi choose a girl whom he already liked but forgot - which would then have to be Ayu or Mai. I would be fine with the more mature Yuuichi in 2k6 choosing his senpai Mai instead of the childish Ayu, that's why the current arc of 2k6 might be the most interesting one for me. Then again, Mai's arc is indeed too early in the series, and I guess Mai is destined to stay with Sayuri if we see more of Sayuri's arc. Plus Ayu is so dominant in the OP that everything other than Ayu winning (possibly with the help of some Minase lady at the hospital; Ayu looking after Akiko during this woman's cold allowed the girl to grow in 2k2) would be a big surprise. Nayuki being the hyperactive variant in 2k2 gave her at least some chance that Yuuichi might fall for her; if she's giving up at this point (after asking Yuuichi whether he remembers his past now) then she's out of the game for sure, she doesn't earn the victory then. And with the "Ayu incident" causing the whole scenario of Kanon, how much additional emotional damage can Yuuichi take anyway? Not much, if we believe Akiko. So it's not too likely that we see a character die. If Shiori were dying, which effect would that have on the relationship between Kaori and Kitawaga? Kaori would be freed from watching her dying sister every day, and Kitagawa might offer her some reasonable support (interfering in the Mai arc upgraded his role significantly). Could he possible become more than a comic relief in the end? If Mai were committing suicide the effect on both Sayuri and Yuuichi would be devastating; if Sayuri were killed by the demons then how would Mai ever recover? I see no real alternative to the 2k2 version of her arc, with Mai actively supporting Sayuri against Kuze as a potential bonus of 2k6. Mai is a victim (taking collateral damage of the Ayu incident) and Sayuri is her saviour - it's as simple as that. Yuuichi alone can only save Mai if he chooses her, not just by apologizing - we saw that in 2k2 already. Mai needs one person who will never abandon her. If Nayuki would die then what effect would that have on Akiko who knows the whole story but chose to stay at the sideline? Ayu dying would actually be the most likely candidate as she can sacrifice herself by using her last wish for someone else. Would it be logical enough to let her make the decision to give up waiting when her "astral body" observes Yuuichi falling in love with another girl? Would she be fine with Yuuichi choosing Nayuki (whom Ayu admires) or Mai (whom Ayu at least respects now)? |
2007-01-03, 12:46 | Link #202 | |
Anime Snark
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Singapore
Age: 41
|
Quote:
What makes you think Nayuki may die? Akiko is the Death Factor in Nayuki's arc, not Nayuki herself. As for the ending of Kanon, I am okay with anything so long as Ayu croaks. I don't care who Yuuichi ends up with if she does. Heck, he could go gallivanting into the sunset with Mishio for all I care, if Ayu bites the dust. Cheers.
__________________
|
|
2007-01-03, 12:53 | Link #203 |
I desire Tomorrow!
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: As far away from reality as possible
Age: 41
|
Me too, but Ayu fans don't like that idea at all, even when it could make the series better And, unfortunately, judging from the OP/ED sequences, it's gonna be a replay of the 2k2 ending... Oh well... At least KyoAni makes the rest enjoyable. (Not that I didn't like Toei's version).
__________________
|
2007-01-03, 13:23 | Link #204 | |
Anime Snark
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Singapore
Age: 41
|
Quote:
2) Air(TV) "For the sake of the story, her life must forfeit!" "You meanies..." Narf.
__________________
|
|
2007-01-03, 13:24 | Link #205 |
Obey the Darkly Cute ...
Author
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: On the whole, I'd rather be in Kyoto ...
Age: 66
|
@KenOhki'sRage
itemized remarks --- 1) The Kazehana appearance of Makoto was a copout (I even thought that on first viewing) --- at the least it should have been more abstract and surreal if presented at all. Hopefully KyoAni won't repeat that (or at least will present it in a way more as a daydream or ethereal experience). 2) Actually cousin marriage is acceptable in most of Europe and the US too... we just keep getting confused posters from the minor parts of both areas that think the extra-restrictive rules in their neighborhood are the norm rather than the exception. Discussed to death in any thread where people freak out because two people share the same roof for a period. 3) Mai gets to win or lose for herself, not dependent on being Yuuichi's "girl" (one of the reasons I *like* Kanon --- its not really about the date-sim, its about the resolution of each situation's mystery). Although Yuuichi is clearly impressed with her (I know I am ). Personally I find Yuuichi handing the baton to Sayuri for Mai to be a "save" from the suicide option. 4) Shiori really wants to have her sister back (acknowledging she exists) -- that's her resolution Despite the fact you can "play the paths" in the game to whatever, for an anime adaptation I have trouble seeing as much drama in any resolution other than either Ayu or Nayuki. Frankly, Ayu sacrificing herself for Nayuki or Nayuki sacrificing her chances for the sake of Ayu both strike me as being very powerful and I'd be good with either as I find them both noble ... though an Ayu sacrifice (being a complete sacrifice) would make me hurt as bad as I did at the end of AIR. Actually, I'd probably have to drink myself stupid if they took each "unchosen" arc to its worst possible end. eek...
__________________
|
2007-01-03, 14:51 | Link #207 |
I desire Tomorrow!
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: As far away from reality as possible
Age: 41
|
Well, have you seen 2k2 Kanon? Did you feel that the feeling you had that she's dead made the drama worse? I personally thought the way she was brought back was lame, but Ayu fans in particular think otherwise. I was ready for a no girl ending anyway, seemed pretty much the only true choice back then, even if Nayuki was effectively the only girl around. I thought that they couldn't have Yuuichi with Nayuki, because that ending was lacking both in drama and in the development section. But Ayu waking up... bleh... spoiled the whole series... And then appear those that preach the "story theme"...
__________________
|
2007-01-03, 15:06 | Link #208 |
Obey the Darkly Cute ...
Author
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: On the whole, I'd rather be in Kyoto ...
Age: 66
|
heh, I happened to like the Ayu ending at the time (back then I wasn't aware just how tragic some of these romances could get) but mostly because of Nayuki's sacrifice. Having done some research since then (and seeing other series)... an "all the girls die and Nayuki loses her mind when her mother dies" ending is not out of the realm of possiblity, but that enters the realm of serious masochism for my viewing tastes
__________________
|
2007-01-03, 15:06 | Link #209 | |
Member
Join Date: Oct 2006
|
Quote:
|
|
2007-01-03, 17:18 | Link #210 |
My name? But my name is..
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Germany
|
If Ayu hadn't awoken in 2k2 then Ayu's arc would have been identical to Makoto's arc, and Nayuki's role wouldn't have been as good as became due to her sacrifice. I'm not a fan of Ayu but by episode 12 we knew 2k2 was her show... there just had to be some reason for that to make the conclusion satisfying. The same applies to 2k6 so Ayu winning and Ayu sacrificing herself are the two plausible options IMHO.
Personally I would like 2k6 surprising me as I don't expect it to beat 2k2 if telling the same story again; so I'm fine with any number of additional casualties. |
2007-01-03, 18:14 | Link #211 |
うるとらぺど
Join Date: Oct 2004
Age: 44
|
Face it, this adapation is made for fans of the game in order to gain profit. (Abelit a good and high quality one that worth spending money on.)
It will go Ayu's route down right to the Epilogue no matter what, Japanese fan will cry sacrilege and it will be 2k2 Kanon again if they stray into anything else. |
2007-01-03, 18:39 | Link #215 |
I desire Tomorrow!
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: As far away from reality as possible
Age: 41
|
You mean 2k2 Kanon didn't do well?? Strange, cause I thought it was a perfectly good series (despite the bigger-than-necessary eyes) with a poor ending.
Oh well... I still hope KyoAni does something different with Ayu. I have the same reaction to the arcs as I had in 2k2, even with all the additions and nice KyoAni animation, so unless the ending changes, it'll be the same for me and everyone else that didn't like the 2k2 ending. Plus, I believe KyoAni has already secured DVD sales, judging from the quality of the series so far. I doubt making the ending better by altering the so-called source will harm production, but the producers know how to milk fans so they'll do whatever brings in more cash, no matter the level of quality.
__________________
|
2007-01-03, 18:47 | Link #216 | |
うるとらぺど
Join Date: Oct 2004
Age: 44
|
To quote from another thread :-
Quote:
KyoAni will not diviate into anything else if they do not want to cause harms for their video sales. And it's seems that way judging by how they are making Ayu out to be the central character that links everyone together. |
|
2007-01-03, 20:05 | Link #217 | |
Administrator
Join Date: Dec 2003
Age: 41
|
Quote:
In short, I'm giving 100:1 odds against Skane being "okay with the ending" (as per the definition here). Anyone want to take that bet?
__________________
|
|
2007-01-03, 21:10 | Link #218 | |
One PUNCH!
Administrator
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
|
|
2007-01-03, 21:13 | Link #219 | |||
I don't give a damn, dude
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: In Despair
Age: 37
|
Quote:
I may well be wrong, but here's just a thought. Quote:
Quote:
I believe the game did a far better job at explaining away Ayu's ending...and I believe KyoAni will do the same when the time comes. |
|||
2007-01-03, 22:16 | Link #220 |
Anime Snark
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Singapore
Age: 41
|
Too many posts to reply to. I'll just summarise all my replies and thoughts into this one post.
I used Air(TV) as an example because it sets precedence for KyoAni to not be afraid of upsetting the audience( both gamer and non-gamer) with the death of a lovable main character. As for 'hatred', a lot of successful series have a lot of hate as well, but went on to become profitable anyway. Neon Genesis Evangelion is a classic example, where the director ignored his detractors and made NGE accordingly to his own vision. So despite the brick-bracks of the vocal minority, Gainax went on to milk the series for more than 10 years, and it is still going strong... KGnE is another example where there were a lot of 'haters', because 'ZOMG!', Mitsuki won in the end? A lot of people hated Shuffle!'s ending, and hey, what do you know? It was still profitable enough to spawn another run. But hey... 'hate' is kinda of a strong word to use. I prefer to use the term, 'dislike'. It is perfectly fine to dislike something and still accept it in the end. I wasn't entirely satisfied with Canvas2's ending, but I still love the show very much, and if it ever made to R1, I would gladly buy it. Toei's Kanon is also not that unpopular, you know. A lot of the repeat viewers in this forum have stated their fondness for it, despite its' flaws( no anime is ever perfect anyway, or anything for that matter). Check out the Kanon(2002) thread sometime. ~~~~ ~~~~ Now... back to the main topic at hand. Why is it that a lot of people seem to enjoy the follow equation? Dead Ayu = Other Girls Win Whatever happened to the 'No Girls Win' option? Or the fact that Yuuichi may choose Ayu in the end? I am by no means an Ayu-hater. I LIKE Ayu as a character. It just doesn't stop me from wanting her to have a semi-tragic end. KyoAni will have to pull off a pretty inspired chain of events if they want me to accept Ayu's survival. If I... experience that 'cheapened' feeling again, then I am going to consider it a great loss for Kanon(2006), when it could have pulled off another epic bittersweet tragedy and perhaps... enter the pantheon of anime greats. Cheers.
__________________
|
|
|