2008-12-21, 16:16 | Link #1121 | |
Banned
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: LA CA
|
Quote:
Last edited by Master Mold; 2008-12-21 at 16:32. |
|
2008-12-21, 17:08 | Link #1122 | ||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
||
2008-12-22, 21:42 | Link #1123 | ||||
Banned
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
NO. Last edited by Phenomenal; 2008-12-22 at 22:18. |
||||
2008-12-23, 00:14 | Link #1124 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
Mihawk affected Zoro in his own way, and Shanks effected Luffy in a different way... if Shanks and Mihawk never shared a connection in rivalry, that dynamic would not change at all Quote:
Words=something not to mention that "Words" means a good posssibility that Shanks will take "action" in the future Quote:
You need to review your classic Tropes This wouldn't be the first case where a character took a disability and trained themselves to not only compensate for it, but grow beyond what they would normally be capable of (Yomi from yuyu hakusho and Toph from avatar are the first two to come to mind) In shonen characters can not only grow stronger but they can overcome any disability... i mean, Zoro was nothing compared to Mihawk when they met, and he was barely able to handle a sword back when Mihawk first had the title (he might have been holding it longer than Zoro has been alive)... and yet this is the man that will rise up and take the title in no time at all... Same goes for Luffy... he only started his journey within the last year and already he accomplished and grown stronger than many others who spent their whole life time at sea... and soon he will surpass even the likes of Whitebeard who has been at the chase for one piece for that last 20 years great writing is not about making things "realistic" but just making them "believable" within the world of the story... What i'm saying is that we got weak little rookies rising up in less than a years time to defeat people who have been at this game for a decade... and your saying that Shanks with 1 arm can't possibly keep on training and eventually grow beyond Mihawk's level in 10 years? when you got no bodies rising up to the greatest heights in just one year, a seasoned and powerful swordsman with one arm rising up and becoming stronger than the next strongest guy in 10 years becomes quite believable... |
|||
2008-12-23, 00:31 | Link #1125 | ||||
Banned
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Shanks isn't making moves like Whitebeard or Blackbeard, period. Quote:
You automatically ASSUMING the guy Shanks couldn't beat with BOTH arms [Mihawk] stopped training?! Like I said, it ain't good or believable writing. |
||||
2008-12-23, 00:50 | Link #1126 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
i think from there you went on to talk about how each of them influenced someone in the story, and i have been pointing out that did not answer the question i orginal asked since their influences on people seems to be completely irrelevant to their own relationship Quote:
not to mention "talk" IS a kind of action... the whole "talk the talk, walk the walk" thing you quote refers to people who "talk like they can do something" but do not take "action that they said they could do"... like a person SAYING they can beat up guy A, but leaving the question as to whether or not he can pull it off... If the person can not beat up guy A, that means he could "talk the talk" but he could not "walk the walk"... this is much different than what Shanks is doing with Whitebeard as he was making an attempt at negotiation and diplomacy to convince Whitebeard to take on a different action that only he could do... through "words" he was attempting to influence the "actions" of whitebeard; ergo, if Whitebeard listened, Whitebeard's actions would have been Shank's actions (just because Shanks failed does not discount that fact that he tried to take action) Quote:
i mean, if Mihawk does 2000 pushups a day, and Shanks does 3000 one armed pushups a day, would it be surprising to say that Shanks more rigorous training would pay off and allow him to eventually surpass Mihawk? Last edited by Slayerx; 2008-12-23 at 01:09. |
|||
2008-12-23, 01:06 | Link #1127 | |||
Banned
|
Quote:
Quote:
Call me when Shanks is doing what Whitebeard is doing, taking action, actually doing something about it. Quote:
Shanks COULDN'T beat Mihakw with Both arms in the past he ain't beating him now with one arm. Hence the reason why Mihawk dismissed him and Shanks didn't challenge it at all. The facts are the facts and truth is truth Mihakw is the strongest swordsman. You know better Slayerx. You and I been at this one piece thing for years, |
|||
2008-12-23, 01:14 | Link #1128 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: East Cupcake
|
Quote:
edit: LOL, I just edited out that portion right before you posted . I mistook what you had written, but upon review, I edit out the portions dealing with Shanks v Mihawk. |
|
2008-12-23, 01:16 | Link #1129 | |
Banned
|
Quote:
You could be right about how Mihawk obtained his title but that is something the story will reveal, obviously. |
|
2008-12-23, 01:31 | Link #1130 | ||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
Quote:
"talk is cheap" is ANOTHER line just like "talk the talk and walk the walk"... people who say nothing can be accomplished through "talk" is speaking ignorance hell, people use "talking" everyday to influence the way of the world... and anytime you do something in a attempt to influence others you are taking an "action" really, "talk the talk" should be meant more towards those types that sit around at home complaining about how crappy things are and how things should be, but never get up off their asses to actually try and change what's wrong; and "talking" to the right kind of people CAN bring about change a single person can't make a new law for instance, but by talking to those that can make such laws he can take action, the action of talking, to the making new laws... hell entire wars can potentially be averted or ended through "talking"... heh, Oda knows that had shanks came in contact with Whitebeard sooner and Whitbeard listened to Shanks, Ace would not have been captured by Blackbeard Quote:
also you forget, we are talking about who is more important between Shanks and Mihawk, not Shanks and Whitbeard... and thus far, Shanks attempts at "talking" to influence the era, is better than anything Mihawk has done... and anything Mihawk has done that might have influence on the era will have been done out of personal selfishness, which is much lower than the actions and words from someone actually aiming to influence the era at hand Quote:
it could very well be that 10 years ago, Shanks and Mihawk each did 2000 push ups to maintain and grow their strength, but after Shanks lost his arm and had his power cut down along with it, he decided he was gonna train even harder to make up for it... hell that's what Zoro is doing, in one year after his encounter with Mihawk he has grown much faster than he did in the 10 years from when he first started his training; Zoro accelerated his training and Shanks could have done the same to overcome his weakness... what you are practically saying is that it is IMPOSSIBLE for Shanks to have trained harder Mihawk doesn't KNOW he can beat Shanks now... how could he, he hasn't fought Shanks in 10 years... He THINKS he can beat Shanks now that he has a handicap and that's why he has no interest in fighting Shanks. Essentially, his dismissal of Shanks is nothing more than pure arrogance. Is Mihawk right? maybe, but i'm saying its very well possible that he has allowed his arrogance to blind him to Shank's current potential |
||||
2008-12-23, 01:38 | Link #1131 | ||||
Banned
|
Quote:
Quote:
Spoiler:
Quote:
Quote:
I shall divine the difference in our strengths by eye. Does the bravery to stand up to me with blade in hand come from your heart...? Or from simple ignorance?" Last edited by Phenomenal; 2008-12-23 at 01:49. |
||||
2008-12-23, 03:31 | Link #1132 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
waht it does show is that Shanks is highly likely to take on furthar action in the future Quote:
Mihawk on the other hand, he does things for himself... he has a personal interest in Zoro as Zoro can be a potential new challanger to him... he doesn't give a damn about how Zoro might effect the era. Mihawk is arrogant and selfish in his actions... all in all, this gives Shanks more importance than Mihawk Quote:
that just ain't gonna cut it, unless you are trying to argue that Shanks is not just weaker but SIGNIFICANTLY weaker, which is unlikely due to his status in the world... not to mention the fact that Mihawk says he has no interest in fighting a one armed man... sounds more like he's not even using that glance of his and just looking with arrogance and saying that someone with a handicap his beneath him... |
|||
2008-12-23, 08:36 | Link #1133 | |
Junior Member
Join Date: Dec 2008
|
Quote:
mihawk cant be the strongest because it is obvious that one day zorro is gonna have to beat him. |
|
2008-12-23, 10:45 | Link #1134 | |
Best of both worlds
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: A land far, far away... or very, very close, depends on where you live
|
Quote:
Luffy is bound to surpass both Shanks and Whitebeard sooner or later.
__________________
|
|
2008-12-23, 17:52 | Link #1137 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2008
|
Whoa, this argument about Shanks and Mihawk has been for several days and still nothing concluded.
I wanna say something: 22 years after Roger execution, the New world has remained "peaceful" with the power balance between Marine, Shichibukai and Yonkou. They all hardly have anything to do. So Shanks kills time by drinking, and Mihawk kills time by traveling and chopping down small preys. Nothing we have seen would indicate they would gain more power than the past, though they should, as this is Shounen. We don't know anything about the duel between Mihawk and Shanks in the past. We don't know if it's really a tie, or one of them has the upper hand and just leave it like that (if you read Shounen enough, you can imagine the picture) We don't even know if they dueled each other only once or not. One's reason does not tell how importance one's action is. Blackbeard is pure evil and selfish, yet it's clear how influence his actions are. Mihawk, just sitting there as a Shichibukai, is influential enough to the whole world (may be he didn't even want to do it, but understood he must do it) We didn't see much of his action, but it does not mean he didn't do anything. He MAY has his own calculation, like Kuma. And i don't want to argue again, one-arm man and two-arm man, who is better. The only thing i see worth mentioning is Mihawk sentence: "i have given up thinking about fighting the one arm man like you for a long time." If Mihawk and Shanks power were truly equal before, there's no doubt after losing an arm, in a short time Shanks could not fill in the gap in the power, and lost in a rematch against Mihawk. Mihawks could even give Shanks several chance, but he still lost. Or as a fight between swordmen (Shanks also uses sword, so i assume so) Mihawk just finds it meaningless to fight a handicapped opponent, regardless of the outcome. Or Mihawk was just ignorance and looked down to others. Or he became a Shichibukai around the time Shanks came back from East Blue, or Shanks officially became an Yonkou at that time, or both, so they had to stop dueling. As it wasn't a personal matter anymore. Or their Friendship just "bloomed" after the duel, in a shounen way. Again, it comes down to how you see it, personal perspective, i guess. |
2009-07-20, 07:53 | Link #1140 | |
Master of The Sword
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
Oh yeah, good old topic. I remember all the old debates i had in this topic...that was fun. |
|
|
|