AnimeSuki Forums

e2- · 2004-03-22, 16:57

Is the samurai deepper kyo anime as good as the manga? well i cant say that i have read a lot of this manga 3 volumes or something but i liked it what did u think about it and is the anime as good ?

Bullsquat · 2004-03-22, 20:23

I haven't read the manga but the anime is a mess. It just lacks focus and they made the plot seem so convoluted. I do think the manga can be good though since they may explain things better.

ShinDragon · 2004-03-23, 06:34

If you read the manga first...... and haven't see the anime.
Then I say don't watch it, just stick with the manga.
Changed too many stuff in the anime.

e2- · 2004-03-23, 09:11

ok maby ill just delete the anime from my computer and stick to the manga

Aurora · 2004-03-26, 14:56

I have read the first volume and am halfway through the second and can't seem to get interested in the series. Is this a story that you liked immediately or did it take a while to grow on you? I may just give up on it.

Hotaru · 2004-03-26, 15:41

I only read manga, it's much faster. I'm at volume 23 now (not English translation).

e2- · 2004-03-27, 13:03

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aurora

I have read the first volume and am halfway through the second and can't seem to get interested in the series. Is this a story that you liked immediately or did it take a while to grow on you? I may just give up on it.

I kinda liked the story immedietely. maby its the samurais

Baka_Panda316 · 2004-04-02, 01:25

i liked it too maybe cuz i think it was funny..but i hate how the end always leaves you hanged of each one

niidel · 2004-04-02, 17:58

SDK manga >> SDK anime.

Having watched 15+ eps of anime before it got subbed, I can say it's... well, different - I can't explain how stupid it is. They have big monsters and all that. If you like, then you can like it.

After reading 5 (translated) volumes of the manga, I can say it is more realistic (if you can say "realistic" here :P). It also contains more ecchi material! Go manga! What's more, all the people slain are really people, not big monsters. :P

I stick with the manga.

2004-03-22, 16:57	Link #1
e2- Genius! Join Date: Dec 2003 Location: Finland Age: 38	Samurai deepper Kyo Is the samurai deepper kyo anime as good as the manga? well i cant say that i have read a lot of this manga 3 volumes or something but i liked it what did u think about it and is the anime as good ?

2004-03-22, 20:23	Link #2
Bullsquat Strange Love Join Date: Feb 2004	I haven't read the manga but the anime is a mess. It just lacks focus and they made the plot seem so convoluted. I do think the manga can be good though since they may explain things better.

2004-03-23, 06:34	Link #3
ShinDragon Senior Member Join Date: Jan 2003 Location: Richmond, BC	If you read the manga first...... and haven't see the anime. Then I say don't watch it, just stick with the manga. Changed too many stuff in the anime.

2004-03-23, 09:11	Link #4
e2- Genius! Join Date: Dec 2003 Location: Finland Age: 38	ok maby ill just delete the anime from my computer and stick to the manga

2004-03-26, 14:56	Link #5
Aurora Just visiting... Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: Kansas City Age: 51	I have read the first volume and am halfway through the second and can't seem to get interested in the series. Is this a story that you liked immediately or did it take a while to grow on you? I may just give up on it.

2004-03-26, 15:41	Link #6
Hotaru Miraioh Join Date: Mar 2004	I only read manga, it's much faster. I'm at volume 23 now (not English translation).

2004-04-02, 01:25	Link #8
Baka_Panda316 RoaR Join Date: Nov 2003 Location: Arizona Age: 34	i liked it too maybe cuz i think it was funny..but i hate how the end always leaves you hanged of each one

2004-04-02, 17:58	Link #9
niidel Junior Member Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: Hanko, Finland Age: 39	SDK manga >> SDK anime. Having watched 15+ eps of anime before it got subbed, I can say it's... well, different - I can't explain how stupid it is. They have big monsters and all that. If you like, then you can like it. After reading 5 (translated) volumes of the manga, I can say it is more realistic (if you can say "realistic" here :P). It also contains more ecchi material! Go manga! What's more, all the people slain are really people, not big monsters. :P I stick with the manga.