Rate That Signature!

[Akarix]

Kimimaro Ninja: really like the feeling from the siggy nyaa.. the text izz ok but the font izz not ok.. 8/10 could try changing some things here okii?

[SweetSpring]

Originally Posted by Azami

version 1

version 2

it very nice!you must have put in lots of efford!!!10/10

[Cyz]

Akarix: I like the bg but not the img. 7/10

tea servant 1996: hmm, those swirly borders around it makes the img a little harder to see. the text is not that visible too. 6/10

[C.A.]

Kila - 8/10, Haruhi + ipod = cool lol

steelbound - 7.5/10, Beware your class president indeed lol

Cyz - 8.5/10, Gratz on your new sig lol, Mikuru-chan ftw!

[steelbound]

It did look fuzzy. I brightened Mion and sharpened everything.



@Cyz: 9/10 - A little to pink for me but otherwise very cute
@tea_servant_1996: 7.5/10 - text a bit hard to read but like the swirls
@kimimaro_ninja: 8/10 - Like the background
@Akarix: 8.5/10 - Nice monocromatic sig

[CXC]

Steelbound: don't know what to say... 9.1/10
C.A.: Nice way of puting things... 8.7/10
Akarix: I definetly liking all of that... 10.2/10

[Keios]

Akarix - 8 - Stylish, blue is an excellent colour.
tea_servant_1996 - 6.5 - The text is way too difficult to read.
Cyz - 9 - Cute.
C.A. - 8 - Like it. Quite different from everything else. ^^
steelbound - 8.5 - Thumbs up for crazy Mion/Shion/Bion/Dion. \o
CXC - 9.5 - This one's a beauty. Love the colours.

[SweetSpring]

CXC :awesome like the awesome amitsu~ 9.5 !!!!!namine in the sig is too cute!!!

steelbound : i've admired the opposite text.very nice 9.7/10

[Shiryuu]

• Shay: Probably make her stand out more. I can't really see anything special about it. The black and red borders kinda doesn't look right. B-
  
• Kira_Naruto: The wind is messed up, why is her hair going to the left when the leaves(or whatever those are) are going to the right? Title and name doesn't match up either. Probably try a different color border too. B-
  
• Steelbound: How about being more creative and not just mirroring everything? Needs a name too. C-
  
• kimimaro_ninja: Somehow, the jagged edges of the text doesn't seem to fit in at all with the image. C
  
• Azami: The image quality for the girl is bad. She might need to get those blue spots on her right arm looked at. Text needs better font and positioning too. D+
  
• Keios: Small. Needs a name. C
  
• tea_servant_1996: Blurry. Maybe try centering the character? Also, either extend the leaves outside the rectangle or put a border on it. D
  
• C.A.: ...why is Dizzy so small and May so big? What's the purpose of the H? D
  
• Akarix: Needs to be shrinked by 5 pixels if you want to include 2 lines of text. Kinda looks better sharpened. C+

__________________

[SweetSpring]

@ Number 48 :must have used lots of brush...10/10
done Shiryuu's tip a little X_X outcome in my sig X_X

[Amaranthine]

Shiryuu: Great idea, I love it. 9.5/10

[Akarix]

Amaranthine: Awww the siggy looks sad XD end of the text hard to read LOL 7/10

tea servant: To much swirly thingys could try as least a smaller border and make sure the stock izz good and the colours try using different ones.. ya always use these colours.. 6/10

Shiryuu: Different from everyone else soo... 9/10

[SweetSpring]

i tried using other colours but ended up editing them until like this.

@ Akarix :good sig...but a bit too much blue.7.8/10

[Diaboso]

Akarix (little to much blue but very good) 9/10
tea_servant_1996 )a little to much greenary (plants) can read well) 7/10
Number 48 (yup) 8/10

and one new one from me

[C.A.]

Well heres an explanation of my seemingly weird and random signature, its actually a Haruhi + Guilty Gear cross:

Spoiler:

In case you don't know, this is May's instant kill move, Kyon recieves the death penalty from Haruhi .
Everyone except Haruhi, Kyon, Imouto, Mori and Yuki have poses/actions from the characters in the game.

From left to right:

Haruhi - May
Imouto - March
Mori - Leap (Year)
Classmate A(Girl with 2 small ponytails) - Novel (November)
Classmate B(Meganekko with 2 long ponytails) - Sephy (September)
Kimidori - Octy (October)
Classmate C(Meganekko with 1 ponytail) - June
Tsuruya - Febe (February)
Ryoko - July
Yuki - April
Kyon - Destroyed! Johnny
Mikuru - Dizzy (December)
Shamisen - Janice (January)
Classmate D(Girl with short red hair) - Augus (August)

I wanted to use 12 girls but there were only 9 named female characters in the show so I had to get 4 classmates.
Janice the cat is supposed to be female, but there are no female cats so Shamisen has to take the place lol

All classmates can be found in episode 2.

Time for me to rate some non-Haruhi signatures:

Azami: 9/10, great contrast and nowadays I seem to have great interest in Itou Noiji's style.
Akarix: 9/10, nice combination of sig and avatar, I like the haze in both.
CXC: 9.5/10, not sure why, but it greatly appeals to me lol

[kira_lacusXX]

diaboso- [for the saber one] i really like the image and the bg is pretty cool. i dont really like the font and its abit pixely..but i still like!

amaranthine- love the image as well and the fading font is really cool! simple bg but so good!

C.A.- really cool drawing, mustve taken awhile, i read about you joing together the two peices of paper on the other forum! i like it a lot

#48- i cant really see the text but you probably wanted to have a camouflaged effect right? the image doesnt really match though, but the green bg is cool

teaser- i like the brush but, but i cant really see the text again and the purple corners seemed to stand out more than anything. again i still like the green colour
though

Aka- blue!! different change from all those greens ^_^ image matches, text and font matches, bgs awesome *thumbs up*

keios- red!! another change!! the black lining around the girl looks good iun some parts but not so good in the middle where the red orb is =/ the right is abit empty but i like how the "masane" stands out ^_^

i think i rated enough for today... and lol kina... yeh it does seem like haruhi doesnt enjoy the music D: but i guess its b/c its normal human music

[SweetSpring]

kila:hahahaha!!!haruhi!!!it's funny!!!9.4/10

[C.A.]

Originally Posted by Number 48

C.A. - yep, the one who drew that is probably a skilled artist and the sig is pretty cool looking too. 10/10 no doubt.

You're too generous , I'm the one who drew the pic lol, I prefer to literally hand make sigs and avatars. I'm lazy to colour them thats why they are black and white sketches lol

Your sig: 8.5/10, the background looks complex and cool.

Keios: 9/10, blood red definitely makes the sig stand out.

[Keios]

I'm glad my new avatar is better than the first one. I'm new to making them, this is actually my 3rd self-made avatar. :\

kira_lacusXX: Don't know what else to say than great job. ^^
Number 48: I got to agree with kira_lacusXX on this. Looks like the image doesn't really belong there. But the BG itself is quite kewl.
tea_servant_1996: A lot better than the first one, in my opinion. What you need now is a border! :]

[Shini_GamI]

Keios: nice red background, and outline on her.... =D