Rate That Signature!

[Aoie_Emesai]

Ice Climbers - I think you should have blurry the bottom edge so it would fit in better. 8/10

The Chaos - I just feel that the background doesn't seem to match the stock too well. It just look plain strange. 7/10

Cyz - Me likey ^^. The light color is amazing, and I like those little light streaks on the right side. 9/10

Setsilya~ - going through another touhou phase, Setsilya? ^^

#1 - The pose is quite nice and the dark isn't overwhelming. 8.5/10
#2 - It must be the sky and the soft colors that is tempting me to like it even more ^^. 9.5/10
#3 - I liked this the best. The moonlight shining down on her is quite nice. 9.5/10

konstargirl - Hehehe ^^ the first one is quite funny ^^ (the expression that is) Nice color selection for both of them. 8.5/10

KasumiGirl - it just simply look great. 9.5/10

[black monster]

kakashi-san 9.5\10

[KholdStare]

Icy: 9/10, Wow, nice.
KasumiGirl: 8/10, Hm, I'm not sure if I like the background very much, but I'm weird.
Aoie_Emesai: 9/10, I'm pretty sure I rated it before, but it's still good.
kakashi-san: 8/10, Surprisingly simple and good.
black monster: 7/10, The guy is too much "in the shadow," and I don't really know what he's holding. You should use some lighting or just increase overall brightness.

[Nemu]

KasumiGirl: Aww, 9/10. =P
KholdStare: 7/10

[BearShare]

KholdStare: 6/10
Popsicle: 7/10

[Nemu]

BearShare: 9/10
Aoie_Emesai: 10/10

[Ice Climbers]

@Popsicle- !!! Rena is a swimsuit!!! Hauu!! The two bright spots seem a bit weird tho 8/10

[Shana]

Well, mine is made by Miko Miko. It's Shana from Shakugan no Shana (wooow XD)

@ Icy: 10/10 getto!

@ mikoo: nice - 7.5/10

@Popsicle: Rena! I like it overall, but not the white spots. Nice. - 8/10

[black monster]

Shana 9.5\10

[konstargirl]

@Shana: 5/10 render cut looks bad and font looks weird. Sorry don't like it.

@black monster: 6/10 The quality of it looks very poor and he's all squash

@Popsicle: very colorful. Maybe a little blur on the right side might look better. 8/10

@Icy: 8/10

[KholdStare]

Well thanks, kakashi-san. I don't remember such award, but nonetheless.

Popsicle: 8/10, Yeah, bright spots are questionably placed, but cute!

mikoo: 8.5/10, Hinagiku.

konstargirl: 8/10, Hm, I think the background kinda blends in too much with the attire.

[The Chaos]

KholdStare...Look So Nice..8.7/10
Icy..Kawaii~ ..9.3/10
Popsicle...Rena-Chan Look Cute in Swimsuit ..8.6/10
mikoo...I Love Hina-Chan .. 10/10

[Cyz]

@ Ice Climbers: Whoa 8/10

@ The Chaos: I like the BG and the Yuki pic that was used 8/10

--> Current sig made by Vibeke. Yeah, I need some motivation and inspiration before I made another sig again . Yuki Cross (or if you guys are following the manga then you know who she really is) from Vampire Knight

[starry_sky45]

Cyz - aww yuki 9.5/10
Chaos - 9/10
kholdStare - 8/10
kakashi-san - 9/10

[The Chaos]

Cyz...Nice Animation Sig..9/10
starry_sky45..Nice Rena Sig..8/10

[BearShare]

Starry_sky: 7/10
The Chaos: 7.5/10

[Cyz]

@ starry_sky45: No border Oh and the font style seems a little out of place IMO. Other than that, it was a good Rena sig indeed 8/10

@ BearShare: You know, she reminds me of the "Tattooed Priestess" from Fatal Frame 3 . I like the feeling of mystery over it. 8/10

[Spectacular_Insanity]

Cyz: Well, shit. I have no words to describe how awesome it is to have a smooth and prettyful animation, plus within the AS limits. Cookies for you. 10/10

[Kyuuen]

Popsicle: 7/10 - it looks like someone shot her from the side, the white sparkling light represents the blood XD
Shana: 8/10 - left side of Shana's hair isn't cropped probably
konstargirl: rated before, but i noticed that the top-part of the second white border goes very near her eyes, which is not a good idea
kakashi-san: 7.5/10 - i just don't like the way Orihime was drawn, too tall and slender (improportion head)
KholdStare: 6 - tone, contract, resolution of picture and text don't match, i don't know how to explain
The_Chaos: 9
Cyz: 6 - low quality background, border too close to the name
starry_sky45: 2.5 - looks strange
BearShare: 9
Spectacular_Insanity: 4

[Cyz]

Originally Posted by Kyuuen

Cyz: 6 - low quality background, border too close to the name

Higher quality for BG means making the file size higher too and that's against AS rules. I'm guessing Vibeke had a hard time making it fit to AS limit especially with that snowing animation plus the hair movements.

@ Kyuuen: Like the BG color used 7/10