Rate That Signature!

[KiNA]

@ flo

I lolled everytime I see you post .. because of the unique sig .. and av =3... I rated your current sig as OVER9000/10

@ SnakeLegend .. Fails for having degreen1 >.<

[Spectacular_Insanity]

Kira_Naruto: 9/10. I really like it, with the animation and the general quality (not to mention that I'm a fan of Cowboy Bebop), but I have to dock a point for a name that's nearly unreadable. The only reason I could tell what it was was by the fact that it was obviously your name. Standing alone, I would not have been able to tell, most likely. I'd suggest either slowing down the textual animation, or widening the highlight.

[Cyz]

Originally Posted by Renvi

@Cyz : I don't see a sig. ><;

Well, you're not the first one to say that to me. Hm, for some reason, people can't see my sig. I guess your PC must be blocking it somehow.

Renvi: I like the bg but you could make the width a little smaller though. Still, it was a nice fiery sig. 7/10
SnakeLegend: Oh yeah, relive the Shuffle! memories now that the Shuffle! Memories is out now The quality of the pic is a little low and it's missing a border. 7/10

[llama]

Woah. Haven't been here in a looong time.

But Kira_Naruto, I just have to say I really love your signature! ^_^ I've never seen Cowboy Bebop, but I've always thought Faye (that's her name, right?) looks cool. The animated smoke gives a really nice touch, too. I'd give it a 10.

[x_Kotori_x]

^ awww, that's so cute ^_^

[Renvi]

@x_Kotori_x: Those are beautiful images that you used,but they seem scrunched up. >< 6/10

@llama: SO CUTE. 8/10

[KiNA]

@ Renvi .. I'm not too fond of the main image being under some sort of brushing thee.. kinda make it dirty =/

@ Llama .. Aww, my sig managed to ge llama to post in here ... I like your drawing =3 .. so very cute like you, they seems to inherit your big eyes too neh

[Cyz]

llama: cute no? 7/10

[Pellissier]

Cyz: Feels a bit empty on the middle. But nice subject. 7,5/10

llama: Funny and cute theme, though I'd say not as nearly cute as the owner - 8/10

KiNA: I need to say that this time your sign really oustands. Technically and artistically flawless. Probably the first time I rate you like this, but .. 10/10


.... these things aside, new sign as my final tribute to the recently finished Bokura ga Ita. The subject is Nana-chan, and the theme is "running" (meant as "moving ahead"). As usual I had my good troubles to fit under the limit. :x ... and I know, it reminds a lot of Riker's signs of Shana and Yuji running, but heh, it just turned out like this ^^

[Klashikari]

*gah* well... hard to not analize this XD
the tears disappear quite bluntly but it's okay, i'm just not too fond of the awkward position of the texts and the font.
still, the animation is way less choppy than the previous one, cheers !
8.5/10

[Riker]

@Pellissier:

I was waiting for you to post in here. 9/10
And yea, trying to make animated sigs under 50,000 bytes is hard. ;___;

p.s. I think you make KiNA very happy with your rating. :3

[Pellissier]

Originally Posted by Riker

@Pellissier:

I was waiting for you to post in here. 9/10

Yeah... sashiburi dane ? .. It was like 1 month since I last posted here, I wasn't really fond of my previous sign, I adored the subject, but that was all about it :x

Actually I've noticed your current sign by surfing around and I like it very much, it's smooth and clean.
9 frames heh? I guess you kept just one frame with the whole background and photoshopped the other ones. At least that's what I'd do with that kind of source.
The only things are those artifact signs on the wall behind Ohno. 9,5/10

p.s. I think you make KiNA very happy with your rating. :3

I think too ... but since for once he's deserved it , I like even to spoil him a bit

[KiNA]

Awww.. now how am I supposed to change my sig .. I managed to squeeze a 10 from you.. even managed to get Llama to post in here ;_;

Domo arigatou ^^

@ Pelli .. The tears on her right side kinda dissapears unnaturally.. Other then that.. since you have 6 frames .. why dont you add animated ... as well after forever .. helps emphasize the forever IMO. Oh, lose the we were there .. or move it somewhere bottom.

@ Rika .. 64 colors ouch =/

edit ..you know Pelli ..Her chest movements kinda make it like she got melons =x

[White Manju Bun]

Pelli- hmmm I liked your other one better 7/10
KiNa - Oh Faye nice and I like that the cigeratte is actually smoking 9.5/10

[Potatochobit]

that is very very nice kiranaruto.

i also like traziemykel;s sig, not sure if he posted in this thread.

riker and raeju's sig are also very good.

man, im going to have to come up with some new material soon. i feel the preassure.

[Spectacular_Insanity]

Riker: I find it amusing. 10/10 I'm easily amused. :P

[kyo miu]

she looks so sweet and inoccent, i love it!!!

Originally Posted by Yuiichi

Wewt. It's good to be back.

Anyways, I just want to point out Catgirls that the link in your post points to the Rate that Avatar thread. Might want to change that

On to ratings!

JoJo: It seems that you can post images again, and an ecchi one this is! True style of the Hentai Army. The actual composition of the signature is simple, but it most definitely gets points for being eye catching. 9.1/10

Shay: Wow, I remember that sig. It was animated though, wasn't it? Anyways, it's still nice 9.1/10

Drake: (rating the actual signature)No longer my nemesis Oh well... I tried. Anyways, I really like this one. I like the double border, but it's sort of ruined at the top right (the picture is coming through). The "Casshern" is also a little difficult to read. Nice job though 9.3/10

[Cyz]

Pellissier: aw! poor her running in tears Is she crying for happiness or sadness? 8/10

[Tenma-chan]

Cyz- 9/10 I like the image and color you used, they blend together nicely.

[Pellissier]

Originally Posted by Klashikari

the tears disappear quite bluntly but it's okay, i'm just not too fond of the awkward position of the texts and the font.

To steal KiNA's words, it was a 5 minutes job, since I'm really strict of time lately. Even when you see me here on Suki, I'm having a book in my hands
So yeah, I couldn't really pick up on details like I usually do ^^ .. I'm glad enough it came out smooth ^^

Originally Posted by KiNA

@ Pelli .. The tears on her right side kinda dissapears unnaturally.. Other then that.. since you have 6 frames .. why dont you add animated ... as well after forever .. helps emphasize the forever IMO. Oh, lose the we were there .. or move it somewhere bottom.

First part, see above, January is harsh. The "..." could be added, when I'll manage to sligthly move the left text, maybe next week Thanks for the suggestion though ^^
.. I'll leave the "we were there" since it's the translation of "Bokura ga Ita", and assuming that not all people could know the meaning of the japanese form.

Originally Posted by KiNA

edit ..you know Pelli ..Her chest movements kinda make it like she got melons =x

On my first sign, she was 15, now she's going for 18. Isn't it amazingly natural ?

Originally Posted by Cyz

Pellissier: aw! poor her running in tears Is she crying for happiness or sadness? 8/10

Ah.. that's sadness... I'd daresay desperation

Tenma-chan: Shiori is probably my favourite Kanon-girl , but the sign is too big for such an empty background. Also there's no border... little bias for Shiori 7/10