Rate That Signature!

[grylsyjaeger]

TheZap: Interesting style. I quite like it. 8.5/10

ganburu: I probably say this every time you chance signatures but I think this one is your best yet. I like how you've gone for fading the characters into a single colour rather than "tearing" the background apart.

Still just too much text for me! 9.5/10

[Evil Rick]

The Zap: Very cool and original style 8.5/10
Tha Chaos: Ehmm... well, those kind of sigs are not of my like >.< 7/10
Hs Vi Germania: 8/10
Escimo: Cool style 9/10
Hey Boss!: It's a bit hard to diferenciate the render from the bg :? 7/10
Drake: Simple but cool 8/10
ganbaru: It's nothing against the style of your sigs but just putting the renders there with a long text in the middle is not very atracting to me 6/10
fallschirmjager: Looks really cool 8/10

[Hs Vi Germania]

fallschirmjager: 9/10
Evil Rick: drawn by urself? xD looks lite it - so u get a bonus 9/10

[Katocchi]

fallschirmjager - 8/10
Evil Rick - 8.3/10
Hs Vi Germania - 8/10

[Shoko]

Hs Vi Germania - 8.5/10
Katocchi - 9/10

[ganbaru]

fallschirmjager 9.3/10 beautiful one . You are back to that game
Evil Rick 9/10 You draw way better than I can even hope to do.
Shoko 8.3/10 very faded in the background.

@fallschirmjager, this quote is not the longuest than I used, and I still have others in stock ( the real problems is the texts, but surface and the renders ( don't have always the appropriate one)
@ Evil Rick I know the background is plain.

[OutSmart]

"Gambaru

you even got the lettering right this time.. its rly wonderful that new sig.. 10/10, you deserved it!" - quote from my self ^^ I'm that self -centered ^^

Its perfect, congratz ^^

[jigoku shoujo]

Haruyan - 7.5/10
fallschirmjager - 9.5/10
Hs Vi Germania - 9/10 k-kawaii

[ganbaru]

Jigoku shoujo 8.4/10 A loli with a machine gun, not bad.

[Sinfully Naomi]

Ganbaru~ 8/10 Yes, yes. For Annabel Lee. <333

[Katocchi]

Jigoku shoujo - 7.5/10
Sinfully Naomi - 7.8/10

[Hs Vi Germania]

Katocchi: 8/10

[Spectacular_Insanity]

Katocchi: Very nice. 8/10

Hs Vi Germania: Hey, I've seen that siggy before! 9/10

[ganbaru]

Sinfully Naomy 8.3/10 good one but ther face feel strange.
Katocchi 9.1/10 peaceful one. The ''heart may be superfluous, no

It's my first animated sig, C&C are welcome. ( I already know is small, the intended size, 300X160 was over 300kb )



Edit, the intended version wasy too heavy for Animesuki (304,7kb)

[Hs Vi Germania]

Originally Posted by Spectacular_Insanity

Katocchi: Very nice. 8/10

Hs Vi Germania: Hey, I've seen that siggy before! 9/10

really? hm not my problem


ganbaru for ur animated sig a 8/10

[Spectacular_Insanity]

Ganbaru: It's not bad, but I think your selection of source material is poor. The text is just too small to read easily, and the slides go kinda fast considering it's hard to read. Not to mention the series of images seems a bit blurry, a result of a scan, I suppose. I'll give you a 7/10 for a sincere effort.

[grylsyjaeger]

ganburu: I think you always try to accomplish too much with your signatures. You need to focus on one thing, not trying to tell a whole story or quoting half a text book. Sure they're interesting to read but they're dull to look at.

Your animated signature is the same. You should focus on only a couple of images with as little text as possible. Use the images to tell the story. 6/10 for your animated sig.

[Hs Vi Germania]

fallschirmjager: dunno whether i already rated ur sig 8/10

[Mon Cheri]

fallschirmjager: Looks nice, i like it a lot. Nice to see some colors 8.7/10

[Katocchi]

Malin - 8.5/10