AnimeSuki Forums

Dreamhacker · 2004-08-21, 13:41

What is best of Full Metal Panic, the anime or manga? And what is the difference?

Ambience Blue · 2004-08-21, 14:32

Well, the two are a bit different. There are currently two seasons of FMP (FMP! s. 1 and FMP?F s. 2) The first season focused more on the action aspect, and second season was more based on the comedy aspect of the FMP series. The manga (the English one, there are several different onesl in Japan) combines the two in one flow. Personally, I felt the two had very similar feels, so I didn't pursue the manga after the first volume. This was, since I had already watched the anime before the manga. IMO, the anime's animation got a bit shoddy at times, but the manga illustrations aren't that great in terms of other manga (compared to stuff like Ichigo 100%, I"s, or NOW!). Whichever one you choose, you'll probably get the same effect. Essentially, the difference is that the manga has a few more side-stories that really don't make that huge of an impact.

kj1980 · 2004-08-25, 23:57

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dreamhacker

What is best of Full Metal Panic, the anime or manga? And what is the difference?

The original novel since that is what both the anime and manga FMP is based on....and there are lots of short stories that haven't been covered in either media.

refused! · 2004-08-27, 19:28

I'm gonna be totally lame and answer: neither :P The novels are the best!

2004-08-21, 13:41	Link #1
Dreamhacker Member Join Date: Aug 2004	Anime vs Manga What is best of Full Metal Panic, the anime or manga? And what is the difference?

2004-08-21, 14:32	Link #2
Ambience Blue Fate/Stay Delight Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Caster's Magic Ball ^^ Age: 38	Well, the two are a bit different. There are currently two seasons of FMP (FMP! s. 1 and FMP?F s. 2) The first season focused more on the action aspect, and second season was more based on the comedy aspect of the FMP series. The manga (the English one, there are several different onesl in Japan) combines the two in one flow. Personally, I felt the two had very similar feels, so I didn't pursue the manga after the first volume. This was, since I had already watched the anime before the manga. IMO, the anime's animation got a bit shoddy at times, but the manga illustrations aren't that great in terms of other manga (compared to stuff like Ichigo 100%, I"s, or NOW!). Whichever one you choose, you'll probably get the same effect. Essentially, the difference is that the manga has a few more side-stories that really don't make that huge of an impact.

2004-08-27, 19:28	Link #4
refused! Junior Member Join Date: Feb 2004	I'm gonna be totally lame and answer: neither :P The novels are the best!