Rate That Signature!

[Keios]

Thanks.

You've got a nice sig too. Yuki looks a bit over-sharpened though?

[Akarix]

Shini GamI: Hmm quite nice.. but yuki looks like she has been sharpened more *nods* 8/10

Keios: very red.. background try something to iprove on it.. 7/10

[SweetSpring]

shini_gami : nice yuki pic but no border and it's plain.6.5/10
keios : nice sig but too much red but it's still matching.8.6/10
C.A : very creative but theres no colour.9.4/10
Diaboso : it's nice but the text is not too visible to me.8.7/10
Amaranthine : speechless with the pic and the font fits well.10/10
Shiryuu : it's very creative.8.7/10

[Wandy]

C.A. Very interesting signature 8.5/10
Akarix 9.5/10 i like the text especially
tea_servant_1996 7.5/10 very interesting signature what anime is that from ? :O

i had time to mess around with photoshop yesterday again and made this weeeeee~

Version1


Version 2

[Cyz]

Azami: a nice primula sig. love the bg color and the lightness too 9/10 - of the two version you put, i like the second one better

[Xellos-_^]

Steelbound, 9/10 great job.

KiLa, 8/10 good work

[Wavie]

Well then since xellos and keios are browsing thread at moment... i will rate you guys.

xellos:
Lol altho its just an image capture its a nice one... altho im not sure if nun with her clothes off is appealing .

Anyway its nice so 7/10

Keios have yet to watch that series... is it any good?

Background suits character - text is nice - definatly better text than mine... the area around text that is different to rest feels somewhat mmm, like something else could go there possibly?

Anyway 8/10 for yours.

Nice job guys.

My first new sig I have made in almost 6 months... as some may or may not know ?

[Shini_GamI]

Azami - cuties.... i liked version 1 better and nice colour for it :P
Cyz - its Mikuru >< i liked it a lot, pinky background for her, suits her
Xellos- ^ - wooh.... s3xy ^^ nice animation for it =D
btw sry bout the exceeding size for my sig, now its 31kb :S

[Wandy]

Number 48- 8.5/10 i like your grunge aspect of your signature background :P

[SweetSpring]

Originally Posted by Azami

C.A. Very interesting signature 8.5/10
Akarix 9.5/10 i like the text especially
tea_servant_1996 7.5/10 very interesting signature what anime is that from ? :O

i had time to mess around with photoshop yesterday again and made this weeeeee~

Version1


Version 2

it's from an anime called jubei-chan the ninja girl secret of the lovely eyepatch.
i prefer the version 1.the image is cute!!!10/10

[SweetHoney]

C.A.: Nice drawing way better than what I can draw 10/10

Tea: Nice brushes you used your getting better 7/10

Cyz: Mikuru kawaii 8/10

Keios: Nice! 8/10

[KiNA]

o.o
So many new sig while I slack off ^.^

@ C.A .. Nice drawing altho did u try to test the sig limit rule and see if any body notice ? ^.^ ... I lol at the overrun poor guy there .. totally destroyed by the swarm of girls ^.^ .. 88%

@ Keious .. Nice simple BG .. good image.. is it vectored? .. the ribbon got quite thick border tho .. 89%

@ No. 48 .. the fella nearly go invisible there :'| but for some reason I like it ^.^ 92%

@ Shini_GamI .. Wooo, sharpened filter overdosed @_@ .. a crop sig.. 78%

@ Cyz.. Oh no, I should have not fell asleep . Not very sharp for both mikuru image tho .. steal some sharpen filter from shini_gamI ^.^ 82%

@ Xell .. Ohh nun theme now eeh? Biased for a fellow E guy ^.^ 89%

@ Wavie.. A ha.. a Haruhi not from Haruhi @_@ .. is she getting grounded or something ? the BG seems suggesting that she's in a closed room like a priosn =x bottom right leave much to my taste tho .. either go full curves .. or go for the sleek rectangular all ard ... 80%

@ Azami o.o... u changed your name o.o .. Nice BG tho like teaser and shini I prefer version 1 then your current 1 .. both still excellent ^.^ 92%

@ Tea_ser Ahh the little curious princess Still with her kyuuute Jubeichan ^.^ .. Like Shini_gamI u overload with your plants... learn to be more moderate with brushing.. dont go overboard .. its messy Still you are 10 year old kid .. so biased loli point =x 74% .. And no, Im not like npal

@ Honey .. .. AzuD style sig .. like it, also like the BG .. look like a beach from above ^.^ Also Kareha got a bonus biased rating for being 1 of 3 blond goddess to me 95%

@ KiNA .. Result of a slacker .. *Points to av .. point to girl in sig .. same girl .. Revy from Black Lagoon* Not an anime for Tea_ser I'm afraid ^.^

[Deathkillz]

Xellos- ^ ~ legend O.o i cnt rate it
Azami ~ too cute...10/10
tea servent ~ i think it too stressful for my eyes...8/10
sweethoney ~ woot nice plain simple 9/10

[OutPhase]

Keios: Good signature, but a litle lazy to make your avatar from it. 8/10

Xellos-_^: Another ecchi sig on this forum. HOW ORIGINAL. 4.5/10

Number_48: Very nice detail with the font, although a lttile hard to read. The slight strain is worth it to see that you put some work into your sig. 9.25/10

[CXC]

Originally Posted by Azami

C.A. Very interesting signature 8.5/10
Akarix 9.5/10 i like the text especially
tea_servant_1996 7.5/10 very interesting signature what anime is that from ? :O

i had time to mess around with photoshop yesterday again and made this weeeeee~

Version1


Version 2

Azami: Kawaii! I Like both but I perfer Ver. 1 12/10
SweetHoney: I like the stock and the text but the bg doesn't work IMO 7.5/10
Number 48: 9.8/10
Wavie: IMO I think it is overall too dark for me, lighten it up some more. 7.5/10

This is not orginally mine but a friend made it for me, it was a big file so I had to post it instead. Same goes my current sig.

[Pellissier]

C.A.: It's handmade, so it gets bias rating. Though I don't catch the former meaning, I appreciate it 8/10

Keios: Very clean and very simple. And nice to see ^^ , but why your avie turns on the other side ? ^^ 8/10

Shini_GamI: A borderless crop.. nice font used for your name, but that's it. 6/10

Akarix: Nice background, maybe the whole pic is a bit too wide, but you filled the space well. 8,25/10

tea_servant_1996: Heh, letting alone the lack of quality, the main character should literally "pop out" from the image. Instead, Jubei-chan is hidden. I mean, it's not, out of all the elements, the one firstly catching attention. And the greeen and the pink do not match with the background at all. Gomen ^^ 5,75/10

Azami: Look empty on the sides, while well coloured. Some text may fill the gap. I like version 1 more, because it's more faithful to Primula's former colours. Version 1 : 8,5/10 ; Version 2: 7,5/10

Number 48: That's a bit messy but I guess It will do, after all ^^ 6/10

Cyz: Kawaii Mikuru-chan ^^ .. a bit of blurriness on the pics, background a bit cheap, but it's still nice to watch. Nice font for the quote. 7,5/10

Xellos-_^: You took the specialization on nuns, isn't it? Just a crop, looks a bit empty, your name sticked somewhere may fill. ^^ 7/10

Wavie: Simple but not bad. Nice effects with the shadow and the rounded corner is a plus 7/10

SweetHoney: The picture is awesome, and the crop as well. Feeling of emptyness for all the remaining though :/ .. feels incomplete. 6,75/10

KiNa: While crowded, I like it a lot. There's a sort of hierarchy on the various elements and, even though you throw in it a lot of stuff, it doesn't generate confusion. And I have no bias rating since I'm not watching that series nor I am a fan of that genre either ^^ 9,25/10

Deathkillz: Very simple.. Prize for the text, which brings a meaningful message . 7/10

CXC: 4 signs to rate? o_O Let's see:

1)The Mikuru one, maybe not the best Mikuru source pic (does it come from doujin ^^), but the rest is amazing. I love that kind of background. 9/10

2)The Yuki one, not bad, but feels a bit empty in the middle, and the text, either for the font but especially for the colour, doesn't totally suit. 7/10

3)The Rena one, cute. All that flash in the middle make some of the squares to look each others. Other than that, a cute Higurashi sign. Though, that Rena pic with the axe is kind of abused. 7,5/10

As for your current sign. I love it. Maybe because I'm a sucker for black and blue, for the stars, for the darkness, for the coldness. But in that sign there's just everything capable of hitting my weak spots ^^ Omedetou to who made it 9,75/10

[SDM]

its animated! ^^ hooray for you

I,d give it a 6,5/10 (I like the text) I wont go any higher because honestly my standard for sigs is alot higher (no offense)

[kira_lacusXX]

SDM, gil!! that wouldnt be my favourite picture of gil but nevertheless...its shiny, and perrty >o< for some reason the bg seems just a tad too empty but i like the lines! *thumbs up*

[C.A.]

Originally Posted by Kira_Naruto

@ C.A .. Nice drawing altho did u try to test the sig limit rule and see if any body notice ? ^.^ ... I lol at the overrun poor guy there .. totally destroyed by the swarm of girls ^.^ .. 88%

lol! Yes, I couldn't reduce the sig any smaller, I'll not further evaluate on it

Keios: 9/10, not sure why but Al looks particularly cute and thats enough for a 9 lol

Pellissier: 8/10, Haruhi caught my attention instantly of course, and immediately I heard 'Tsk tsk tsk' in my mind. I shifted my focus away from Haruhi a little and discovered you included the text lol, nice!

[Nirvaphreak]

kira_lacusXX - It's Haruhi, how can it be low? 9/10

I thought I try coming back here once in a while with a new sig...here goes..

Well, I have two this time, so I thought I'd just show both o.o;