Rate That Signature!

[Frailty]

ganbaru: 7/10 || the right side is overly blurred. If you've kept the level for the whole sig, it would've looked better IMO since it would have created depth. It lacks lighting too.

ReaperxKing: 8/10 || it looks pretty good. The black thing underneath the render (are those wings?) kinda stands out though.

Crassa 7/10 || too bright

[Auxilism]

ganbaru (on post) 8.6/10
Nice radiating effect though it looks weird with her hair at the bottom.
I'll try removing the border from the animation next time.

Crassa 8.8/10
Only the top right is a little too bright to me, and by a little I mean very little.

Frailty 8.1/10
Why border-less on the left and right if the top and bottom have a border? Two light sources out of nowhere make it look strange and the right is a little empty compared to the rest.

[ganbaru]

Frailty 8,5/10 the girl look interesting but is the background really it with her ?

[Frailty]

@darkhalo191
the light at the bottom of the render, I thought it'd look like some energy stuff flowing out of my render
as for the border, it's for a cinematic effect maybe?

anyway rating yours
9/10 || good animation, interesting border and good pop-out effect. It's just that the white around the render looks weird. I guess it's because of the gif format

@ganbaru
nope, it's a stock. The stock and the render are two separate images. I just looked for a stock that'd fit my render~

[Om Nerabdator]

@ReaperxKingx 9.5 love it, no other words are needed ;D

@darkhalo191 7/10 im not a fan on the white stroke or the animation(maybe a different scene)

@Krytonis 9/10 mate just awesome^^

[Krytonis]

Om Nerabdator: 9/10 good focus and angle of the image also, Highschool DxD? WIN

[ganbaru]

Om Nerabdator 8,4/10 not a bad picture

[Rennir]

Krytonis-8.6/10 More depth and a more fitting bg stock would be nice; I like the colors and good job blending c4ds in

[Traece]

Rennir, 9, I actually always liked that sig. It's a nice pose and the SAO text strangely sells it for me. It's a simple-looking signature so there's not really much to say, I suppose.

Though I'm certainly not anyone to render credible judgements just yet.

[ganbaru]

Traece 8,5/10 a interesting one.

[Akito Kinomoto]

ganbaru--Very nice triangle between Reimu, the text, and the flowers. 8.6/10
Traece--Unique. 8.2/10
Rennir--It could use a border. 7.9/10
Om Nerabdator--Good balance. 8.39/10
Frailty--Yup. It's a cinematic effect. 8.6/10
darkhalo191--Getting away with no borders, perfectly placed and stylized text, no out of place crop of the picture, and nice quality on the gif. 10/10 because you aimed high and scored big.
Crassa--Unique. 8.2/10

[ganbaru]

Akito Kinomoto 8,4/10 not a bad crop sig.

[Rikimtasu]

ganbaru for some reason it look..scary for me. 8/10

[ganbaru]

Rikimtasu 8,2/10 not bad for a crop.

[Assort Dis]

ganbaru 8.5/10 I like the quote.

Btw, I drew this one

[ganbaru]

Assort Dis 8,710 for you own artwork.

Originally Posted by Assort Dis

ganbaru 8.5/10 I like the quote.

The quote is from the ending of the play ''Cyrano de Bergerac''. Honestly there was one monologue than I would had preferred to use but getting the artwork for it would had been much harder.

[Krytonis]

Assort Dis: 8/10 cuteness overload
ganbaru: 8.3/10 well made

[ganbaru]

Krytonis 8,7/10 good background and nice girl. The text might had been better placed closer of the bottom right corner.

[hoshino_crimsonwings]

ganbaru 8.4/10 Would be more if I could tell if the person was a male or female! The pedals (I assumed they were pedals) look really nice.

[HasuMasu]

Assort Dis: You're really good. - 9/10