2D Girls are better than 3D girls

[Crisis]

Discuss!

[risingstar3110]

They won't stab you several times to death, cut off your d***, throw it under the bed, throw the knife onto another room, and still manage to trick the polices into making the case "a suicide".


Mostly j/k, but you knows which incident i referred to...

[Dhomochevsky]

2D girls are all flat.

*badum* *dishhh*

[GN0010 Nosferatu]

Originally Posted by Dhomochevsky

2D girls are all flat.

*badum* *dishhh*

Debate now closed.

[HasuMasu]

Originally Posted by Dhomochevsky

2D girls are all flat.

*badum* *dishhh*

Dammit, I'm not allowed to give you rep for that.

Fabulous comment nonetheless.


As for the thread, the only solution is a girl 3D on the outside and 2D on the inside. :ccol:

[Urzu 7]

One thing I really like about anime femmes is how they usually have ideal beauty, and the simplicity of anime art conveys a very clean look for characters. Of course, this would be a problem if you would only settle for this ideal beauty typically found with many anime characters and felt disappointed with most real people not having ideal looks (such things definitely don't apply to me, in fact, I rather really like the girl next door type of women).

[Sides]

Originally Posted by Dhomochevsky

2D girls are all flat.

*badum* *dishhh*

I give you this
2D girls have no depth

[DonQuigleone]

Guys, how can you guys even argue about this? The answer is totally obvious, you'd have to be mentally disturbed, living an abnormal lifestyle to not get it.

Clearly 2D is better!

[Yui Is My Wife]

To be loved for who you are, without being forced to change into something you hate looking at in the mirror every morning just to "prove your love to her."

You'll be the luckiest fella alive to find a 3D girl who will do the above.

[SaintessHeart]

Actually 3D girls are better, IF you can find the kind that cares about you. 2D are adorable, but you can't start a family with a 2D girl.

3D > 2D (i ≈ R), in all other cases 3D = 2D (Where 3D != socialite bitch/slut).

[MeoTwister5]

Originally Posted by SaintessHeart

Actually 3D girls are better, IF you can find the kind that cares about you. 2D are adorable, but you can't start a family with a 2D girl.

Better reserve that Nobel Prize for Medicine for me then!

[bhl88]

2.5D is the best then (have the girl/boy cosplay).

2D is better: they don't get old unless told so, no need to spend money on them (except the Blu-Ray), no need for health insurance and stuff either.

[solomon]

I love how everyone can be so joking about this.

But for the guys who are all in.....

sorry but you ain't really getting anothing from that.....weither carnal or otherwise.

[Endless Soul]

Originally Posted by bhl88

2D is better: they don't get old unless told so, no need to spend money on them (except the Blu-Ray), no need for health insurance and stuff either.

~ knocks over chair while standing up quickly ~

OBJECTION!

You still need to actually buy the 2D girls.

Endless "The Litigator" Soul

[Paranoid Android]

3D! >: ( *gets set on fire*

They don't make me cringe and rip my eyeballs out when something really cheesy or cliche happens. I like to have eyes

Mentally 2 dimensional girls (IRL) are also awesome depending on what their attention is put towards. They make my life less stressful =P

2D gets REALLY awkward if you're the artist (Does that make you the father ?)

[Zakoo]

I couldn't even imagine my life without my daily touhou/loli.

2D is obviously better than 3D

[fanty]

I also have to add that 2D guys are definitely better than 3D ones.

[Gamer_2k4]

If you're talking about lusting after cartoons versus lusting after models, the two are no different. They're both shallow, image-first people who have been engineered to be nice to look at, and they're both equally unrealistic in terms of personality and attitude and so on.

Now, if you're comparing having an anime pillow girlfriend to having a real one, there's no question. Real is better for reasons I shouldn't even have to get into (and I'm not even just talking about physical ones).

Originally Posted by bhl88

2D is better: they don't get old unless told so, no need to spend money on them (except the Blu-Ray), no need for health insurance and stuff either.

"That's one thing I love about anime girls...I get older and they stay the same age!"

[Asuras]

Wh-what is this madness?

This like arguing which is better: A lightsaber or a wooden baton?
Clearly one is better, but who cares? We're never getting that lightsaber! D:

[Ledgem]

Originally Posted by Detective-san

As for the thread, the only solution is a girl 3D on the outside and 2D on the inside. :ccol:

I don't think so. The reason why anime girls are appealing is because they are fantasy, and in a fantasy medium. Their appearance and behavior is appealing within that context.

Try to imagine how it would be in reality. The excessively long hair would probably look quite a bit more messy, and it would not move around in the manner that it does in animation. It would probably look unkempt, in most cases (and I say that as someone who likes women with long hair). Many of the outfits that we think are the coolest thing ever would look weird or inappropriate.

The behaviors that the characters put on would also be very strange in reality. What are some of the endearing stereotypes of anime girls - the violent (but secretly caring) girl, the eccentric girl who only speaks randomly about things that sound intelligent (but nothing else), the eccentric girl who doesn't speak, the eccentric girl who talks about herself in the third person... there are many others, but take even one of those personality quirks and imagine it in real life. While some guys would truly like that (and I'm not judging anyone for it), I can say that I, personally, would find such behavior to be a turn-off and even annoying. I love seeing it on the shows because it tickles a "that's cute" type of reflex, but in reality? Nope.

Put it together, and while "2D girls" are great in the context of fantasy, their appeal doesn't extend beyond that.