2009-10-26, 17:15 | Link #281 |
Frandle & Nightbag
Join Date: Oct 2009
|
That's a common misconception. Taniguchi cares about personality, even if it's only on a rather superficial level. As we're given to understand, he sees female personalities as either 'troublesome' or not, which really boils down to 'requiring effort' and not. In the case of Haruhi, she's absolutely beautiful, but she'd also be quite the handful. He's looking for a beautiful girl with a placid personality and simple wants so that he doesn't have to try hard, she essentially would serve as a trophy.
__________________
|
2009-10-26, 21:16 | Link #284 | |
Frandle & Nightbag
Join Date: Oct 2009
|
Quote:
Kyon gets frustrated with Taniguchi because he reflects back to him the things he dislikes most about himself, while Kunikida seems to have a more mature, focused head on his shoulders...but has even less of a presence than Taniguchi.
__________________
|
|
2009-10-26, 23:39 | Link #286 |
Kneel Before Your King!
|
You're thinking of the wrong character type. Prior to her little attempted stabfest, Asakura was set up as a Yamato Nadeshiko.
__________________
|
2009-10-26, 23:45 | Link #288 | |
Senior Member
Author
|
Quote:
From watching a lot of anime, I get the distinct impression that the Yamato Nadeshiko type is someone who's perfect (as a girlfriend/wife) and beloved by everyone - at least that this is how many Japanese anime fans feel.
__________________
|
|
2009-10-27, 03:33 | Link #289 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2009
|
大和撫子 = [やまとなでしこ, yamatonadeshiko] (n) woman who displays the feminine virtues of old Japan, a pink (the flower)
Well, anyway, my point is, at the beginning of the story, she was portrayed as a high school girl, who is perfect in every way, good at everything and loved by everyone. |
2009-10-28, 02:57 | Link #295 | |
Love Conquers All!
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: The Suzumiya Haruhi Section of AnimeSuki, (I placed my main Otaku HQ box there)
Age: 29
|
Quote:
What the hell have you been watching dude?
__________________
|
|
2009-10-28, 02:59 | Link #296 | |||
Sav'aaq!
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Hyrule
Age: 51
|
Quote:
Spoiler for Volume 4:
The Haruhi franchise is unique in that it is able to not only get away with two Mary Sue-ish characters (Tsuruya and to a lesser extent Kyon, which tells you how broad a definition "Mary Sue" can cover), but they're possibly the two most universally loved characters. Now Ryoko in "Disappearance of Yuki Nagato" is a different story. While she still isn't quite a YN (but for different reasons) she is quite the Mary Sue (oddly without any author avatar feeling)... I now eagerly anticipate the flames of those who decry me for calling Tsuruya and Kyon Mary Sues (okay, a Mary Sue and a Marty Stu) before they think about it... ^_^
__________________
|
|||
2009-10-28, 03:14 | Link #297 |
Homo Ludens
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Canada
Age: 34
|
While Tsuruya qualifies in some ways, she has absolutely no plot relevance and, although she steals every scene she's in, she never seems to be intrusive. One of the traits of a Mary Sue is that they steal plot relevance from everyone else. Tsuruya is not a Mary Sue.
...And one of the other traits of a Mary Sue is that they are flawless. Kyon? Flawless? HAHAHAHAHAHAHA The only thing really Sue-like about him is that he's clearly an avatar for Tanigawa, except less self-deprecating. And that alone doesn't make him a Sue... You want a Mary Sue? Check out post-Disappearance Nagato. Hijacks the plot? Oh yes. Entirely too much. Flawless? Aside from her emo fallout... pretty much, yeah. Beloved by everyone? Haruhi should not be this overly protective of anyone. WHERE did that come from? Poorly-written and developed? Given that her only point seems to be to serve Tanigawa's Nagato-fetish, she's already really finished her development at that point, and she really doesn't DO anything other than serve as the center of Kyon's attention up until Vol. 7... yeah. Nagato after her own development novel is one of the biggest Mary Sues I've ever seen, and that's why I don't like her at all. |
2009-10-28, 05:44 | Link #298 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2009
|
Quote:
What I did mean was, the way the author lured the readers before he created a twist by using the event you mentioned. If you're familiar with Japanese high school romance anime/manga/game/drama/movie/novel/etc. , you should know what I'm trying to say here. Umm... you know how cliché it is when a girl sent a letter to a boy to meet after school. |
|
2009-10-28, 07:39 | Link #299 | |||
Senior Member
|
Quote:
Hmmm, to be fair, Haruhi never needed to be over protective to anyone before. I believe she would act similarly if Mikuru was in need. Also, if I am not mistaken, the protectiveness is as early as Vol.5. Ah, and Yuki don't hijacks the plot, this only occur in Wondering Shadow and Snow Mountain. Also, in Editor in Chief the story seemed to be focused on her at first, and the it was hijacked by everyone else... However, as she did receive way more atention then Mikuru, and even Haruhi, you point still. Quote:
I could agree she didn't need the attention she received at Vol. 8, but I like her so this don't bother me. Also, in Edito in Chief everyone receive a bit of development (exept for Mikuru), and the main focus of Wondering Shadow was Haruhi, Yuki importance being not bigger then in Boredom(story) and Mystérique Sign Quote:
PP: Oh, yeah, back to the topic. (sorry for that) I believe Ryouko is neither a Yamado Nadeshiko nor a Mary Sue. However, I believe this is not the point freakonboard and Kogetsu tryed to made at first. Sure, after the "trying to kill Kyon" thing she is neither, however, Taniguchi did, in my opinion, tryed to stabilish her as a Mary Sue for Kyon/us, portrating her as flawless. Sure, she never had some traids of a true MS, like being the most impornat character in the cast. However, she was, indeed, meant to appear flawless and loved by everyone in the class. |
|||
2009-10-28, 07:42 | Link #300 | |||
Senior Member
Author
|
Quote:
But yeah, Ryoko clearly never panned out as a Mary Sue. Tanigawa may have wanted the readers to take her that way prior to Ryoko's attempt to take Kyon's life (i.e. build Ryoko up as this seemingly perfect girl so that when she tries to kill Kyon, it become a great plot twist for the readers - it's really good writing on his part that adds a lot of drama ) Quote:
Copying and pasting, here are the six criteria that I came up with... 1. Unbelievably good won-lost record (for protagonists: Never Lose or never lose fairly; for antagonists: Rarely lose) ... Yes to Haruhi, yes to Tsuruya, yes to Kyon (except when he goes against Haruhi - i.e. Cicada hunting competition). This is where Haruhi, and the entire SOS Brigade, is the most Sue-ish. They never lose. Period. 2. Not a signal other character present is shown to be superior to the Sue in any discernible or significant area (for a protagonist: amongst all other protagonists; for an antagonist: amongst all other characters). Probably one of the worse offenders of this was Silver Age Superman, with his super-everything power (super-intelligence putting it over the top, I felt). Simply put, the Sue is the best at everything (with the possible exception of a villainous enemy). Note: A good guard against a Sue is to have somebody with her/him that is brainier than him/her that can provide intellectual solutions that the Sue doesn't think of. - Hhhmmm... Kind of hard for this to apply to three different characters from the same anime. I tend to feel that this is true for Haruhi, since she excels at almost everything she puts her hand to (movie making being the sole exception it seems ). She has the looks, the marks, the athleticism, etc... To some degree, I guess you could say that this could apply to both Haruhi and Tsuruya as they're not in the same class. Ok, I'll say yes to Haruhi, yes to Tsuruya, no to Kyon. 3. Is beloved by other characters beyond what his/her accomplishments and personality/natural appeal would call for - this is especially true if people even morally aligned against him or her feels this way (i.e. a main protagonist that has antagonists pining for him/her romantically). - No to Haruhi, no to Tsuruya, yes to Kyon arguably (when it comes to women at least, lol). 4. Is or has the solution to almost every problem (protagonists)... or is the mastermind behind almost every problem (antagonists)... or both. - Yes to Haruhi and to Kyon, each in their own way; no to Tsuruya 5. Simply has the perfect, or almost perfect, life. This alone can be a big factor... either way. For example, if a character has a life that s/he hates, then that certainly doesn't make the character feel like a pet character to me. - Yes to Tsuruya, for obvious reasons. As for Haruhi and Kyon... I don't know. Haruhi seems consistently pretty upbeat and cheerful post-Melancholy... Kyon's situation is an enviable one in many ways, but also has its drawbacks. I'll say yes to Tsuruya, no to Haruhi, and no to Kyon, though. 6. This last one is a bit more of my own personal intuitive sense after watching anime (so if people disagree, I understand) - a seemingly normal human character that either eventually achieves a Godhood of sorts, or already unknowingly has a Godhood of sorts. - Yes to Haruhi, no to Kyon, no to Tsuruya Final Scores: Haruhi - 4, Kyon - 3, Tsuruya - 3 3 out of 6 is enough to set off Mary Sue "red flags" for me - so yeah, Kyon and Tsuruya are arguably Mary Sues. I don't dispute that. Kyon also has a bit of the self-insertion thing going on, which arguably adds a point to him, perhaps moving him up to 4. Haruhi is a Mary Sue, imo. Three borderline Mary Sues all in the same anime as part of a fairly small cast... Tanigawa must be quite the idealist. Quote:
If we take a stricter approach where every Mary Sue characteristic has to be struck, then Kaisos is right. But if it's a case where a majority of the Mary Sue characteristics is enough...
__________________
|
|||
Tags |
characters |
|
|