2010-12-24, 16:17 | Link #2303 | |
The True Culprit
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2010-12-24, 16:25 | Link #2304 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2010
|
Maybe not as individuals but a family that employs both of them at the same time over the span of 4 years would never wonder why they have never seen two of their most trusted servants together at the same time? I know the Ushiromiya's aren't the brightest family in japan but...really?
|
2010-12-24, 16:27 | Link #2305 |
Junior Member
Join Date: Jan 2010
|
My Problem is how implausible it is. Well Shkannon is more or less fact know but it is hard to believe so many people
(minus the older servants and Genji who knew the truth) would be so negligent not to notice the existence of a person acting as both man and woman, going to school with Jessica (did noone notice there?) and on dates with George. Natsuhi is so picky but allows such an act? The witch of miracles must have helped Yasu more than once to pull that act. *chuckle* This makes the mystery-factor kinda dull as no all murders can be explained with either fake deaths, Eva doing the killing (ep3) or Shannon doing it... |
2010-12-24, 18:45 | Link #2306 | |
Dribble.....SHOOTOH!
Join Date: Feb 2006
|
Quote:
I can buy frightened people not realizing that that's just Shannon in a Beatrice costume. I can buy Maria seeing Shannon as Beatrice just by the way she acts. I can even buy Battler and some of the other family members who were barely around Kanon not realizing that something is up. But I can't buy that anyone would be fooled by a costume changing Kanon for 3 years, especially someone like Jessica who has a close relationship with both of them. From what we saw of Yasu, actively dressing and pretending to be Kanon doesn't seem to fit into the way her personas work either. I can totally see Kanon being a character in her head, even though the reasons the game gave for Kanon showing up seemed lacking. But dressing up and pretending to be two different people also seems much crazier then she was, at least at that point. |
|
2010-12-24, 18:49 | Link #2307 | |||||
The True Culprit
|
Quote:
Quote:
Shannon's and George's relationship is a secret, so of course Natsuhi doesn't know about it. AND SHE TALKS TO IMAGINARY PEOPLE, so who cares about what Natsuhi does or doesn't notice? Quote:
I know that such a deception can be done because it HAS been done. When I was in middle school, I pulled this sort of trick at school on a dare. Because of my poor health I missed out on a lot of school, so the two personas never being seen at the same time never phased anyone, and no one thought we were the same person for a full year. It's doable. It's not likely, but it IS doable for the right circumstances, and it doesn't mean people are stupid for not picking up on it. The "Master of Disguise" trope wouldn't be so heavily used if there wasn't a grain of truth in it. These anti-Shkanon arguments, on some level, boil down to "I figured it out, so why not these assholes in the story? Idiots." Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
|||||
2010-12-24, 20:15 | Link #2308 | |
別にいいけど
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: forever lost inside a logic error
|
Quote:
The fact that I strongly defended the shkanon theory after EP6 and I was one of those that proposed it since EP4 doesn't make my view biased on this matter. I acknowledge it: in a realistic scenario it would be impossible for a person to fool several people for several years with a simple disguise. If you think otherwise you need to adjust your reality check. The question here is if Ryuukishi has a realistic explanation for this or if he's simply riding on an overused plot device. Because indeed there's a huge block of narrative where disguises are supernaturally effective. As a plot device it is so widespread that it could give to Ryuukishi enough leeway to claim shkanon is acceptable. That doesn't change the fact that this is a physical impossibility.
__________________
Last edited by Jan-Poo; 2010-12-24 at 20:34. |
|
2010-12-24, 20:23 | Link #2309 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2010
|
Thats exactly how I feel, I knew it was coming since early in the episodes. I like to over analyze mundane things like intros to see if there is any foreshadowing for later episodes and it was very clear that something was going on with Shannon and Kanon since the second one was out. The only way I could solve some of the problems by the end of EP4 was with a name/personality trick and felt horrible for it.
I want to be surprised and I really hope I am with EP8, I'll half accept it if Im not though. Its just a huge suspension of disbelief that I would just have to deal with and be content that there was a huge amount of evidence for it. |
2010-12-24, 23:28 | Link #2311 |
The True Culprit
|
I'd also like to throw out there that it's heavily implied that none of the characters look how Ryukishi draws them, and that we're basically seeing false appearances (save for Beatrice, paradoxically). This is confirmed for Lion and technically Jessica.
__________________
|
2010-12-25, 00:15 | Link #2318 |
別にいいけど
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: forever lost inside a logic error
|
Really, if Jessica and Krauss really had blonde hairs the fact that Beatrice is blonde wouldn't have been pointed our so many times as something exotic.
Plus the joke that Kinzo and Bice made about Japanese hairs only makes sense if Japanese have all black hairs. Get over it, the various hair color you see are merely for visual purposes. They aren't actually like that. Except for Erika's hairs maybe...
__________________
|
|
|