AnimeSuki Forums

trix · 2004-01-18, 09:11

is it just me or has the animation just went down the tube? i assume that 1-13 was season 1 and ep 14 started season 2?

well i am not looking forward to ep 15 if the animation is going to look like that.

Lord Raiden · 2004-01-18, 09:26

Don't feel bad. Animation seems to have gone in the pooper for a lot of animes lately. Not sure what the deal is, if it's a change in style or what's going on, but yeah, it's gone down. I agree with that.

SilverHeimdall · 2004-01-18, 12:01

Hmm, I didn't notice anything like that, I found it just as good as the other episodes o_o

What's so bad about 14 that would make you stop downloading the serie?

Lst2touchdasky · 2004-01-18, 12:08

I didnt see much change in the animation, may be you just dling from a different fan sub group and they didnt fix up as much as the last ones

trix · 2004-01-19, 13:25

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lst2touchdasky

I didnt see much change in the animation, may be you just dling from a different fan sub group and they didnt fix up as much as the last ones

the fan sub doesn't influence quality of animation. sorry but it just doesn't.

how can you not notice? the instant the ep started i noticed how shitty it is. i mean no its not like naruto where some ep look like my 5 yr old brother drew them. but its pretty severe.

a_nevels666 · 2004-01-19, 13:56

Quote:

Originally Posted by trix

the fan sub doesn't influence quality of animation. sorry but it just doesn't.

how can you not notice? the instant the ep started i noticed how shitty it is. i mean no its not like naruto where some ep look like my 5 yr old brother drew them. but its pretty severe.

Well, if you watch a lower quality encode, the animation will still be the same, but the overall visual experience won't be as good, obviously.

I wasn't really paying that much attention to the animation in Fullmetal Alchemist ep.14, but I didn't see anything wrong with the animation. It looked fine to me.

In Naruto I find the differences in animation level very obvious even when I'm not paying any special attention to it.

kj1980 · 2004-01-19, 15:04

You do realize many animes don't use the same genga studio each episode? While the production studio maybe the same, they usually give certain episodes to different genga studios. So while for one episode, a certain anime may use 12 different "good" genga studios, while the next episode may use 13 "obscure" different genga studios. Depending on production costs (and the importance of that episode), we may give a certain episode to a well experienced studio in Japan and Korea, or we may give a certain episode as a challenge to build up their own experience to some obscure start-up genga company in Japan and Taiwan.

For a more clear view on how current anime is made, I suggest you watch the anime "Animation Runner Kuromi-chan."

OrO · 2004-01-19, 17:22

I didn't notice ... I was enjoying the show so I think it can't be worst than some Naruto Episodes (Kiba vs Naruto)

Asakura_Y0h · 2004-01-19, 21:06

Wow, you ppl must have a good eye for spotting things... to me it didn't make any difference at all.... ok... maybe some parts were a little bit different like how they drew edward as compared to the other eps but the difference was too slight to overcome the plot...... I kinda agree that Naruto's was bad... even for me I could see it which means that it must've been really bad

2004-01-18, 09:11	Link #1
trix Junior Member Join Date: May 2003	fma 14? what happend? is it just me or has the animation just went down the tube? i assume that 1-13 was season 1 and ep 14 started season 2? well i am not looking forward to ep 15 if the animation is going to look like that.

2004-01-18, 09:26	Link #2
Lord Raiden Uber Coffee for da win! Join Date: May 2003 Location: Middle of insanity	Don't feel bad. Animation seems to have gone in the pooper for a lot of animes lately. Not sure what the deal is, if it's a change in style or what's going on, but yeah, it's gone down. I agree with that.

2004-01-18, 12:01	Link #3
SilverHeimdall Member Join Date: Jan 2004	Hmm, I didn't notice anything like that, I found it just as good as the other episodes o_o What's so bad about 14 that would make you stop downloading the serie?

2004-01-18, 12:08	Link #4
Lst2touchdasky Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2003 Location: Phoenix,AZ Age: 36	I didnt see much change in the animation, may be you just dling from a different fan sub group and they didnt fix up as much as the last ones

2004-01-19, 15:04	Link #7
kj1980 Gomen asobase desuwa! Join Date: Nov 2003 Age: 43	You do realize many animes don't use the same genga studio each episode? While the production studio maybe the same, they usually give certain episodes to different genga studios. So while for one episode, a certain anime may use 12 different "good" genga studios, while the next episode may use 13 "obscure" different genga studios. Depending on production costs (and the importance of that episode), we may give a certain episode to a well experienced studio in Japan and Korea, or we may give a certain episode as a challenge to build up their own experience to some obscure start-up genga company in Japan and Taiwan. For a more clear view on how current anime is made, I suggest you watch the anime "Animation Runner Kuromi-chan."

2004-01-19, 17:22	Link #8
OrO Vega Join Date: Apr 2003 Age: 40	I didn't notice ... I was enjoying the show so I think it can't be worst than some Naruto Episodes (Kiba vs Naruto)

2004-01-19, 21:06	Link #9
Asakura_Y0h little black butterfly Join Date: Nov 2003 Age: 42	Wow, you ppl must have a good eye for spotting things... to me it didn't make any difference at all.... ok... maybe some parts were a little bit different like how they drew edward as compared to the other eps but the difference was too slight to overcome the plot...... I kinda agree that Naruto's was bad... even for me I could see it which means that it must've been really bad