AnimeSuki Forums

Flawfinder · 2011-11-20, 15:42

Whoa, wait a minute here. Are you kidding me? Are you really kidding me? Who the hell is going to be involved now that this knowledge has been imparted? A new girl? That soft-tough guy from earlier? Who? Who?!

Anyways, it was a nice chapter, but I just screamed "No!" over and over when I read the ending. I don't mind harem stuff, but doing it without the guy looking like a jackass is hard.

jzmagic · 2011-11-20, 15:43

Haha so basically he HAS to have a harem ending in order to get out. I'm sure we'll get some rule changes/updates when the time comes though, but for now he looks pretty screwed.

Newprimus · 2011-11-20, 15:48

The bane of all romance manga, which girl does the guy end up with?

Well this manga solved that issue by setting up the HAREM END!!!!!

felix · 2011-11-20, 15:52

I have to wonder what the reaction in the polls will be.

Shadow5YA · 2011-11-20, 15:56

Well, it's possible for Mao or Saki to fall out of love with Harisugawa. Then he wouldn't need to win both of them over.

blade82 · 2011-11-20, 16:07

funny that she owns different mirrors maybe she has one like the Evil queen of snow white

vansonbee · 2011-11-20, 16:16

Quote:

Originally Posted by blade82

funny that she owns different mirrors maybe she has one like the Evil queen of snow white

In chapter 19, the fortune teller lady cleaned the magic mirror, but hid a small pocket mirror in the cloth to absorb some of the magic mirror effects on her own mirror.

LeaD36 · 2011-11-20, 17:06

Haaareeeem EEEENNNDDIIIIING CONFIRMED!

Cyz · 2011-11-20, 17:26

So the more partners present the harder the "game" it would be then? So basically, Harisugawa will have to make both Saki and Mao to love him and him to love them to get out of the mirror? Hm, what a clever mirror indeed.

-> Seems like this manga is asking for more girls in his life

LeaD36 · 2011-11-20, 17:39

^This is actually a proper measure to give the manga a realistic ending anytime it could get the axe :O

Anh_Minh · 2011-11-20, 17:44

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cyz

So the more partners present the harder the "game" it would be then? So basically, Harisugawa will have to make both Saki and Mao to love him and him to love them to get out of the mirror? Hm, what a clever mirror indeed.

-> Seems like this manga is asking for more girls in his life

I don't know if it's just the translation or what, but didn't the woman say that partners are "people you share a mutual love with"?

That means the mirror's trial has never been about seduction. It's about getting the guts to confess. When you already know the other loves you. What the hell kind of trial is that?

Though I suppose part of it would also be "make sure the other doesn't freak out and reject you while in a blind panic"?

asbo · 2011-11-20, 17:46

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cyz

So the more partners present the harder the "game" it would be then? So basically, Harisugawa will have to make both Saki and Mao to love him and him to love them to get out of the mirror

Ahah the girl of the mirrors is tricking Harisugawa..in my opinion the "you have to love both girls and be loved from both girls" is exactly what will make Harisugawa disappear..that is a "love mirror", he can't sincerely confess his love to 2 different girls if he truly loves one of them..they're even best friends, by confessing to both he will just ruin Mao and Saki relationship and make them sad, that's not what is called "love".
The mangaka is tricking the readers, he just have to confess to his true love.

Tenchi Hou Take · 2011-11-20, 17:54

Quote:

Originally Posted by asbo

Ahah the girl of the mirrors is tricking Harisugawa..in my opinion the "you have to love both girls and be loved from both girls" is exactly what will make Harisugawa disappear..that is a "love mirror", he can't sincerely confess his love to 2 different girls if he truly loves one of them..they're even best friends, by confessing to both he will just ruin Mao and Saki relationship and make them sad, that's not what is called "love".
The mangaka is tricking the readers, he just have to confess to his true love.

Then there has to be something more to it than simply trying to make him dissapear, otherwise she could have lied from the start and told them to follow instructions that would have made him dissapear a long time ago. Either the instructions are correct or she gains something by having him confess to both of them.

Riltz · 2011-11-20, 17:56

I'm thinking....what if Mao get in the mirror and Suda *accidentaly* touch the mirror and get inside, but as the condition to lift the curse goes arround Harisugawa mutual feelings, will he need to confess/get confessed by Suda? If that happens, he's really screwed

...unless they put Suda in the mirror, paint it and throw it to a river and problem solved

asbo · 2011-11-20, 18:03

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tenchi Hou Take

Then there has to be something more to it than simply trying to make him dissapear, otherwise she could have lied from the start and told them to follow instructions that would have made him dissapear a long time ago. Either the instructions are correct or she gains something by having him confess to both of them.

Her intention is not to make him disappear, but to test him.
That girl's past is somehow linked to the mirror (i have the feeling that the guy who disappeared from the mirror at the beginning of the manga is somehow is connected to her) and IMO now she's testing harisugawa...why? i have no idea!

Tenchi Hou Take · 2011-11-20, 18:35

Quote:

Originally Posted by asbo

Her intention is not to make him disappear, but to test him.
That girl's past is somehow linked to the mirror (i have the feeling that the guy who disappeared from the mirror at the beginning of the manga is somehow is connected to her) and IMO now she's testing harisugawa...why? i have no idea!

But what happens if he fails and it seems like a totally random test. I mean had Saki not touched the mirror/done the things she did then the supposed test wouldn't have occurred, so why punish him by testing him on something that had a very good chance of not happening at all. Just seems harsh and random.

blade82 · 2011-11-20, 19:08

the author had announce in a previous chapter "a new girl" no?

spikexp · 2011-11-20, 19:37

I say, one of the girl is going to die so that he just have 1 to confess too

(it's a joke, I really hope it's not that)

SoFarGone · 2011-11-20, 19:42

Quote:

Originally Posted by blade82

the author had announce in a previous chapter "a new girl" no?

yea at the end of chapter 10 it said that.

BladeEntity · 2011-11-20, 22:58

So basically, because Harisugawa is confused about his feelings Saki is more a partner. So as long as he falls out of love for one or the other and they can't enter the mirror, its a harem end. Still hoping for the true love end, it seems like its going to be a Saki end in my opinion. Honestly hope I am wrong...

2011-11-20, 15:42	Link #281
Flawfinder Loves the Experience Join Date: Aug 2011 Location: Earth...hopefully	Whoa, wait a minute here. Are you kidding me? Are you really kidding me? Who the hell is going to be involved now that this knowledge has been imparted? A new girl? That soft-tough guy from earlier? Who? Who?! Anyways, it was a nice chapter, but I just screamed "No!" over and over when I read the ending. I don't mind harem stuff, but doing it without the guy looking like a jackass is hard. __________________ My Awesome Anime Blog: Standing On My Neck

2011-11-20, 15:48	Link #283
Newprimus NO ESCAPE FROM NYAAA Artist Join Date: Jan 2004	The bane of all romance manga, which girl does the guy end up with? Well this manga solved that issue by setting up the HAREM END!!!!! __________________ NYAA-CEPTION

2011-11-20, 15:52	Link #284
felix sleepyhead Author Join Date: Dec 2005 Location: event horizon	I have to wonder what the reaction in the polls will be. __________________

2011-11-20, 22:58	Link #300
BladeEntity Anything's Possible Author Join Date: Jul 2009	So basically, because Harisugawa is confused about his feelings Saki is more a partner. So as long as he falls out of love for one or the other and they can't enter the mirror, its a harem end. Still hoping for the true love end, it seems like its going to be a Saki end in my opinion. Honestly hope I am wrong... __________________ Nothing is Impossible

2011-11-20, 15:43	Link #282
jzmagic flargansbog Join Date: Mar 2006	Haha so basically he HAS to have a harem ending in order to get out. I'm sure we'll get some rule changes/updates when the time comes though, but for now he looks pretty screwed.

2011-11-20, 15:56	Link #285
Shadow5YA Senior Member Join Date: Mar 2010	Well, it's possible for Mao or Saki to fall out of love with Harisugawa. Then he wouldn't need to win both of them over.

2011-11-20, 16:07	Link #286
blade82 Senior Member Join Date: May 2007 Location: you have to find out	funny that she owns different mirrors maybe she has one like the Evil queen of snow white

2011-11-20, 17:06	Link #288
LeaD36 LeaDfactor Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Hungary, Budapest Age: 33	Haaareeeem EEEENNNDDIIIIING CONFIRMED!

2011-11-20, 17:39	Link #290
LeaD36 LeaDfactor Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Hungary, Budapest Age: 33	^This is actually a proper measure to give the manga a realistic ending anytime it could get the axe :O

2011-11-20, 17:56	Link #294
Riltz ⌂ Vulcan 300 ⌂ Join Date: Aug 2007	I'm thinking....what if Mao get in the mirror and Suda accidentaly touch the mirror and get inside, but as the condition to lift the curse goes arround Harisugawa mutual feelings, will he need to confess/get confessed by Suda? If that happens, he's really screwed ...unless they put Suda in the mirror, paint it and throw it to a river and problem solved

2011-11-20, 19:08	Link #297
blade82 Senior Member Join Date: May 2007 Location: you have to find out	the author had announce in a previous chapter "a new girl" no?

2011-11-20, 19:37	Link #298
spikexp Senior Member Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: Quebec Age: 32	I say, one of the girl is going to die so that he just have 1 to confess too (it's a joke, I really hope it's not that)