2012-01-11, 00:51 | Link #26942 |
Member
Join Date: Nov 2011
|
Spoiler for Unreliable narrators make everything work:
I don't think it's quite a serious theory to compete with, say, Shkanon. But it's not a joke interpretation, either. It's an attempt to see the story in a different way and try to square away a few plot points without invoking amnesia. |
2012-01-11, 01:56 | Link #26943 |
The True Culprit
|
But the problem is that the Toya that Ange meets remembers being on Rokkenjima those days. He just can't emotionally connect with them. It's not that he couldn't reunite with her, it's because he wouldn't.
Also, Battler didn't write the original message bottles; so why is he in Legend and Turn? And what about the Reds that address Battler by name? And what about Yasu going on her spiel about how if Battler didn't return that year, there wouldn't of been a tragedy?
__________________
|
2012-01-11, 03:00 | Link #26946 |
Member
Join Date: Nov 2011
|
I'm going to put this in spoiler-tags, so that people who aren't interested in this fringe theory can skip it. It's a stretch, but stretching keeps the muscles limber.
Spoiler for Battler Wasn't There:
Last edited by WitchOfDoubt; 2012-01-11 at 03:13. |
2012-01-11, 12:30 | Link #26947 |
Ordinary Magician
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Gensokyo
Age: 31
|
That's impossible. Where did he go during the conference? Why did he leave Ange alone? This was never hinted in the story as well. And also how does Battler know all that stuff if he never went to the conference?
How did he know about Beatrice falling off a cliff when Rosa met her? It was not mentioned in the first two message bottles. Or anything about Yasu's memories at all? Right. He must have been there. Also red truths denying your theory : When Jessica's corpse was discovered, only Battler, George, Maria, Rosa, Genji, Gohda, Shannon, Kumasawa, and Nanjo were in Jessica's room Beatrice died in October of 1986. Therefore, the Golden Land she created was completely destroyed. Your family, which was made to live in the Golden Land, was destroyed along with it. Your father, mother, and of course Battler...will never return to you again, and will never speak your name again. EDIT You also seem to have forgotten that Eva survived.
__________________
Last edited by Remon; 2012-01-11 at 12:41. |
2012-01-11, 15:00 | Link #26948 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2006
|
I never got the appeal in wondering about whose pespective the story is told from. Narrators are just narrators, they don't have to be personified in any way. That's why we can see things that are not known to the human characters of the story, for example the meta-worlds can be thought of as such things.
That's why I'm also unnerved when people start speculating about which character authored which episode, and what characters have access to what information. The contents of the message bottles and the forgeries in the story need not be equal to the episodes of Umineko. Actually they can't be, unless Yasu was producing visual novels in 1986 and packing them in bottles. :P Anyway, I would be careful when juxtaposing our perspective with that of some character in the story. Only the writer should be qualified to do that...we should take the story we're told at face value.
__________________
|
2012-01-11, 15:15 | Link #26949 |
BUY MY BOOK!!!
Join Date: May 2009
|
It should be noted that 100% of the narration is not, and has never been, Battler, even stripping out all fantasy elements and whatnot. The story periodically slips into a third-person narrator and at times goes directly into the thoughts of non-Battler characters or even what amounts to the first-person perspective of characters (notably Natsuhi in ep5 and kinda in ep1).
So those parts of the story... what do we say about their veracity and reliability? Sometimes it's very matter-of-fact narration, sometimes it's telling outright lies. And it can't really be ascribed to Battler in one sense or another, as it's not his point of view. The narrative features his POV, but it's definitely not exclusive. EDIT: I should also note there are sequences here and there in the story that not only can neither Battler nor Yasu have witnessed, but that basically no one could possibly even know anything about to begin with. Some of the Rosa/Maria stuff, for example, at least the parts that aren't explicitly stated to be part of her diary... which, if it exists, there's no guarantee the author even had access to. So the author is, if nothing else, conjuring scenes whole cloth out of nowhere based either on outright speculation or impossible knowledge.
__________________
|
2012-01-11, 15:53 | Link #26950 | |
Ordinary Magician
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Gensokyo
Age: 31
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2012-01-11, 17:05 | Link #26951 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2011
|
I know you guys already know this, but it seems like some of you forgot:
Red Truths have no bearing on what happened on Rokkenjima Prime. That is, the real world. They only apply to the worlds of the game boards. The game boards are just stories that either Yasu or the Hachijos wrote. In fact, there is absolutely no need to try and argue that Battler wasn't on the game board, because even without that, you can easily claim that "Battler wasn't there on Prime." There is basically nothing you can say for certain about Prime other than "most people died" and "Eva and Battler (and possibly Yasu) survived" and "Ange wasn't there." There's also no reason for Yasu to have needed to know about Battler's coming in 1986, in order to write the first two message bottles. Her purpose in writing those message bottles is vague, but this much about it should be certain: She wrote these stories to convey a message to Battler. In those stories, Piece!Beatrice tried to invite Piece!Battler to the Golden Land. I personally assign these definitions to them: -Piece!Beatrice symbolizes Yasu's feelings for Battler, which she could never come to terms with, and which she wanted to finally put to rest. -The Golden Land symbolizes the dreams Yasu had for her future. With those definitions, the whole thing ends up becoming a perfectly suitable metaphor for the message she wanted to convey to him. Following this, she used the epitaph as a device to create a method for Piece!Beatrice to open the door to the Golden Land, and an outline for the murder mystery game she wants to play with Battler. Prime!Yasu probably never committed murder or anything like that. She just wrote stories, and hoped for Battler's return. I doubt the murder mystery game even happened in Prime, it was probably just the subject of the stories she wrote for him. I doubt Prime!Yasu was even in a romantic relationship with either Jessica or George. Putting that in the stories was probably just her way of portraying her intense emotional turmoil, and attempting to develop these characters she made up as people. George probably was jealous of Battler, but Yasu seems to be perfectly aware of that. And while I can't find any evidence that she dislikes him, I can't find any evidence that she loves him either. It's not too hard to see how superficial the ShannonxGeorge relationship is in the stories. She's always asking him whether he's serious, and when he speaks of their future, he only mentions his business, the money he'll make, the house they'll have, etc. And Jessica just seems to be Yasu's childhood friend. So really, I think Prime!Yasu only loves Battler. Furthermore, I doubt that there really are 900 tons of explosives on Prime. I simply cannot come up with a reason for why the government would say "oh, hey, we'll just let this old rich guy do whatever he wants with them." But unfortunately, while I can't justify the existence of this huge bomb, I also can't figure out a way to cover up the equally huge number of plot holes it would create if the bomb doesn't exist. Certainly, I could say that it only exists within the world of the game board, but that still doesn't explain why Eva needed to go all the way to Kuwadorian to survive on Prime, and why all the evidence disappeared, and why Ange didn't see the mansion when she went there in EP4, and more. And I do personally accept the Ikuko = Yasu theory, but if you want me to explain my reasons for that, I'll do so in another post. |
2012-01-11, 18:00 | Link #26952 | ||||
Goat
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Gnawing away at Rokkenjima
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
The government probably wasn't aware of them. I don't find it implausible that in the chaos of WWII and its aftermath that the Japanese bureaucracy lost track of those explosives, or perhaps Kinzo bribed someone. There was a lot of corruption in Japan during the years following the war. |
||||
2012-01-11, 18:39 | Link #26953 | ||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2011
|
Quote:
Quote:
I just don't see a reason to have the game on Prime. The purpose of the game in the stories and on Prime would be the same, right? To have a debate with Battler and hopefully manage to convey her feelings. On the other hand, one carries large risks and the other does not. The stories are already written. Of course, I'm now willing to believe that the bomb does exist in Prime and did go off. And, the bomb pretty much has to exist on the game board. I want to say it's not a coincidence, but... Isn't it a coincidence regardless, if you believe that Yasu wasn't planning for it to go off? If we need a reason for the bomb going off in Prime, most people seem to say something like this: "At least one person ended up solving the epitaph and... 1. thought they were turning the switch off 2. wanted to use the bomb to cover up whatever had already happened 3. simply wanted to use it to kill everyone without any significant risk" Of those, only #2 would tie in with the murder mystery game theory. And even with that, it's easy to use #2 without the game. After all, throughout the story, it's made very clear that tensions were very high among the adults, regardless of what Beatrice did or did not do. Though, there's also the matter of the stories she sent out in message bottles. I'm not sure what her motive for sending those out could have possibly been... Even if we assume that she was following her fantasies of And Then There Were None (which I plan to read soon but haven't yet), that would imply that she plans for the bomb to go off and create a cat box. Well, you certainly can argue that she planned for the bomb to go off... The only problem is that she has practically no motivation to do it, as far as I can see... |
||
2012-01-11, 19:07 | Link #26954 | |||||
The True Culprit
|
Quote:
Quote:
For that reason alone, I don't really see the value in speculating that Battler wasn't here. It largely invalidates almost everything about Yasu's big confession in EP7. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
|||||
2012-01-11, 19:09 | Link #26955 | |||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2011
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
My theory is that in the end either Battler solved the game before Yasu could kill someone and the incident happened anyway for other reasons or that Yasu, thought planning to commit murder, when faced with the real thing, didn't feel up to it (or her plan failed) but again, the incident happened anyway. Quote:
True, she's talking to the goats, but they represent the witch hunters who theorize that George never had a relation with Shannon so I think this is something that can be proved in Prime. It's also likely in Prime it could be proved if they went at the aquarium together since they slept in a hotel. Though I think Yasu had no plans of marrying George, regardless fo the fact that George were to come back or not. Quote:
Quote:
Okonogi also offered a theory which would explain how it was an incident how Eva was in Kuwadorian when half of the island blew up. Also, if Yasu effectively planned to commit murder and have the island destroyed as Our confession seems to imply and then changed her mind and this happened anyway, it can be viewed as 'coincidential'... sort of... (as it's likely her actions set in motion what lead to the incident but she hadn't planned for it to happen that way). Umineko is also filled with coincidential things that are harder to believe, like how a baby fell from a cliff but didn't die or how Kinzo and Beatrice were the only survivors in the military base, how Kinzo dies the same night Yasu solves the epitaph, how an Italian submarine decides to carry gold in Japan and how the Japanese government conveniently forgot the explosive (or couldn't care less that Kinzo had it). Witch hunters even found suspicious how Ange remained at home... So... it's possible it's coincidental. Many of the settings for Yasu's story could be guessed as Ange was often sick, weather was often bad when the conference took place and the conference always took place around that time. The only thing that's really hard to guess was that Battler was coming back... but that could have been Yasu's wishful thinking... maybe she had tales with Battler coming back even for year 1985... and they went destroyed in the explosion... Quote:
I think before handing it to Kinzo they should have at least checked it for residual weapons and explosive. |
|||||||
2012-01-11, 19:42 | Link #26956 |
Junior Member
Join Date: Jan 2012
|
Sorry if this is a bit off topic, but I'm confused about why a lot of people seem to dislike George and like to make him the bad guy. I've read a lot of "lol-arguments" or very week arguments about him being the culprit but I remember that there was some among you who had some good argument for a George-culprit theory (something about him being manipulative and having knowledge about magic-stuff). Anyone who could be kind and fill me in on the more serious arguments?
|
2012-01-11, 19:48 | Link #26957 |
The True Culprit
|
Well, for starters, he's EXTREMELY creepy. He was jealous of a 12 year old Battler having the attentions of a 10-year-old Shannon when HE was 17.
That, and he's straight up admitted he can totally kill his whole family if that's what it takes to be with Shannon.
__________________
|
2012-01-11, 19:51 | Link #26958 | ||
Artist
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Yesterday!
|
Quote:
Quote:
Yasu really loves Battler. The adults tend to treat Battler as an equal ("you two are like siblings more then father and son") while they treat George as still a kid ("He still has much to learn"). George is constantly said to be really good with kids, but even that much, Battler steals the show with Maria again, instantly becoming close friend with her. Battler is a fun person, he wants to drink for the heck of it, George is a boring person who'd only ever do it for work (again from arc 1). Again, Battler is a fun person, that he's back makes all the cousins says it's the most fun year (since Battler left) and that in between all they ever talked about was serious stuff like studies (George is again a boring person). There would have been more things too. If we follow the idea of "ideal passed down" like how Beatrice 1 was forced on Beatrice 2 and then on Beatrice 3, EVA or Eva Beatrice if you want could very well have been the incarnation of the expectations of Eva that got passed down to her child. At the time George was born, they were allowed to remain Ushiromiya family because Natsuhi couldn't get pregnant and as thus for the five first years of his life George was raised to be the heir. That position was "stolen" away from him by Jessica's birth, yet Eva seemingly continued to push all her life for the idea that if George was "better then Jessica enough" he'd be the heir. Now to talk about the love story. Six years ago, Yasu was 13, but Shannon was legally 10. So you had a 17 years old George who was jealous of a 12 years old Battler for getting all the attention from a 10 years old Yasu (yeah the whole thing sounds stupid to me... what kind of 12 years old have in depth discussions about mystery novels). According to arc 2, Shannon didn't notice George until soon before she solved the epitaph (the day she noticed him Kinzo was still alive as Eva went to see him with George, thus epitaph wasn't yet solved). That's around 2 years ago, but again it seems like they have barely ever seen each other outside of Rokkenjima. Atop of that it seems pretty clear that they never slept together, nor even did something much simpler like kissing. That relationship is now one where George is proposing to make her his bride. It seems a bit too fast to me. It looks more like "most 16 years old girls" who aren't too serious about love but simply enjoy a relationship, to end up with an older guy who's taking it more seriously then she is and is already thinking about how many children they will have and stuff like that. That sort of relationship, at least imo, is a total failure. It doesn't mean that Shannon doesn't like George at all btw, but there's a difference between a teen trying to date another guy to forget her previous love and planning to marry each other. So the general theory that was being raised by me is that George was a person who no one saw seriously while he was dead serious about a lot of things. I still think in many ways it's a relatively weak "why dunnit" but it was better IMO then any why dunnit ascribed to Yasu so far (outside of the "why did she write stories"). Nonetheless all this comes to basically no avail thanks to OC. Last edited by UsagiTenpura; 2012-01-11 at 20:10. |
||
2012-01-11, 19:58 | Link #26959 |
Reading your tale. :)
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Just out of sight, eating popcorn. >:D
|
Read Judoh's George culprit analysis. http://forums.animesuki.com/showpost...ostcount=14814
And I've been kinda ninja'ed by AT...
__________________
|
2012-01-11, 20:12 | Link #26960 | |||||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2011
|
Quote:
Quote:
But unfortunately, if I want to keep from invalidating that confession, I guess it's necessary to have Yasu do something in Prime due to his coming that would cause her a great deal of regret. Which means that my "Yasu didn't commit crimes in Prime" theory has yet another potential hole... And I have no idea how to resolve it. Quote:
But you're right, the fact that Ange wasn't there in EP1 or 2 really makes things weird. I hadn't even thought of that until now. It's possible for us to say that Ange, being a 6-year old girl, had no significant role in Yasu's mystery. And there's already many theories that the first two episodes of the sound novel are edited versions of the first two message bottles, so perhaps Ange was edited out after the fact. Quote:
Quote:
And to be honest, since they contained things that made a bunch of people believe "a witch did it" I don't really think that's the case... As for Yasu=Ikuko, there was a gap of about 1.5 years in Yasu's story after she solved the epitaph, and at that point she was very rich. It's possible that she could have used that time to setup a new identity. Maybe she just wanted to get away from Rokkenjima and try to start a new life for herself, but she still had hopes that she would be able to reach Battler, so she didn't actually choose to live there until after the 1986 conference. Quote:
Even if I tried to say something like "the 1998 we see is just the story Ange told us" which is actually probable given all the fantasy scenes, I wouldn't be able to come up with a reason for her to lie and say that Battler went to the conference... And if I say that she didn't know he stayed home, that's stretching it too far. I can't really argue against this. Quote:
And, as far as I remember, Our Confession only implied that Piece!Yasu had the intention to carry out the plan... Quote:
That's why I feel that I have reason to doubt what George and Shannon said there. But in the end, those letters are a devil's proof. Well, I'm not saying that Yasu wasn't friends with George in Prime. I think that she probably was. I just don't think they had a romantic, reciprocated relationship. Quote:
http://umineko.wikia.com/wiki/TIPS/A...Interview_Tape Well, either way, it's all just really weird. But I think it's still possible, so I'm alright with it. @George Culprit Theories: I haven't thought much about this, so I can't really say anything that hasn't already been said. |
|||||||||
|
|